5 ms·
If efficient cars are a problem, tax efficient cars, not Uber. But given CA's environmental goals, this would be counterproductive.
by modeless 8y ago
If efficient cars are a problem, tax efficient cars, not Uber. But given CA's environmental goals, this would be counterproductive.
- bsder 8y agoEfficient cars aren't the problem. The problem is that Uber/Lyft drivers "cruise" when the demand is slack rather than park. So, for certain areas and times (generally about a hour before when that area is about to go from slack to busy), your street becomes a never-ending stream of ridesharing cars--generally doing stupid traffic maneuvers when they finally get summoned.
- manfredo 8y ago> The problem is that Uber/Lyft drivers "cruise" when the demand is slack rather than park Isn't the whole point that the apps limit cruising time? I recall a study that claimdd the average traditional taxi cruises for half an hour on average between each trip. Are there plans to tax traditional cabs by an amount commensurate with their cruising time? If not, this legislation seems more like protectionism for traditional cabs.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Are there plans to tax traditional cabs by an amount commensurate with their cruising time? Traditional taxis already pay a steep annual franchise fee to the city (even after it was cut down on recent years, probably in part because less-taxed rideshares reduced the level of franchise fee that was supportable).
- manfredo 8y agoFranchise fees also benefits the taxi companies. It constrains the supply to taxis, thus shielding the taxi companies from potential competition. They're paying for protection from competition.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Franchise fees also benefits the taxi companies. In the presence of a substitute service not subject to them, they do not. Actually, since there seems to be both a non-automatic approval process and a franchise fee, they don't really even without such competition; the approval process shields them from competition, the franchise fee is a pure cost. (Of course, there is a linkage between the two, but as long as the process is in place, incumbent taxi firms benefit from minimizing the fee.)
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoYes, I mentioned that is already beginning to happen. > But given CA's environmental goals, this would be counterproductive. That is irrelevant, we are reaching a point where taxation on road miles driven vs. fueled used becomes unavoidable. What will wind up happening is that efficient and clean energy vehicles will still need to be taxed to account for usage, while less efficient vehicles will be taxed even more (to discourage use).
- briandear 8y agoWhy should less efficient vehicles be taxed more? If they are already paying more for fuel, doesn’t that already “tax” them more? It seems like such a tax is regressive — rich people can buy new efficient cars more easily than poor people.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Why should less efficient vehicles be taxed more? Internalizing the environmental externalities of operating them. > If they are already paying more for fuel, doesn’t that already “tax” them more? Fuel taxes are a mechanism for the additional (that is, beyond road usage, in the context of the grandparent post) taxes on inefficient vehicles. > It seems like such a tax is regressive — rich people can buy new efficient cars more easily than poor people. That's actually a reason you might want a method other than exclusively fuel taxes to implement the additional taxation (which may be via, say, a means tested tax subsidy for purchase of more efficient cars, rather than directly another extra tax on inefficient ones), because fuel taxes are operations taxes but don't directly effect purchases (they may be taken into account, but the poor who feel they need a car will often buy what they can afford up front even if it is not fully rational because real people tend to fall short of rationality in some predictable ways, and discounting deferred costs is a big one.)
- seanmcdirmid 8y ago> Why should less efficient vehicles be taxed more? Taxation serves two purposes: (a) to fund roads, and (b) to discourage society damaging behavior. For (a), we need to tax all vehicles, for (b), we need to tax some vehicles more than others. > It seems like such a tax is regressive — rich people can buy new efficient cars more easily than poor people. True. Perhaps the efficiency tax can be built into the initial new car purchase while the use tax is ongoing (those old cars will eventually fall apart or fail an emissions test anyways and be taken off the road). Anyways, these things can be worked out.
- 2dollars27cents 8y agoAs others have mentioned, taxing efficient cars doesn't seem to make much sense. Maybe tax actual miles traveled instead? That would solve the problem of increasing efficiency and also decrease the value of loitering and cruising in-between pick-ups.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoThat is on the table in Europe with real-time tolling based on miles driven.
- ummonk 8y agoWait, how would taxing miles traveled decrease the value of loitering between pick-ups?
- beerlord 8y agoAnd unless we want to have ugly metal gantries everywhere, we are going to need to accept that the Government will need to be able to monitor our car's location at all times... via built-in transmitters also linked to the payment infrastructure. We will probably also need a way to communicate pricing. All of this will also need to be digital for autonomous vehicles. We should probably start working on some open standards for it all...
- jdhn 8y agoI'm real curious as to how taxing miles travelled would work, especially if you travel between states. Would you have to keep track of how many miles you drove in State A and State B, and how would you pay State B if you lived in State A? Since we'd need to replace the federal fuel tax as well, would the federal government require states to hold yearly odometer inspections, or would you have to fill out a form on your yearly taxes stating how far you drove? I supposed that these questions could be solved by utilizing GPS, but I'm not sure I like the idea of the government tracking the movements of my vehicle.
- reaperducer 8y agoI'm real curious as to how taxing miles travelled would work, especially if you travel between states. Trucks have been doing it for years with transponders in the cabs. That's how when a semi fills up with fuel in one state and ends its trip in another state the state in between still gets some fuel tax to pay for road maintenance.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> If efficient cars are a problem, tax efficient cars California already does that. (ZEVs pay a supplemental $100 annual fee.)