27 ms·
U.S. Cloud Act is raising concern about extraterritoriality
- tyfon 8y agoAs of today we have cloud offerings of for instance azure completely separate from the US companies due to this. Here in Norway we can get the complete azure offering from a company called Evry using azure stack [1] and there is a data centre like this in Germany too at least that I know of, probably many more. And sectors like government and banking are required to use them and not the parent companies offerings, especially if it contains PII. If this goes on I suspect a lot of the revenue US tech companies see today will disappear even if (for now) most run the licensed version of azure stack and the like. [1] https://www.evry.com/en/what-we-do/key-services/evry-cloud-services/the-cloud-is-now-local---evry-azure-stack/ https://www.evry.com/en/what-we-do/key-services/evry-cloud-s...
- entity345 8y ago> We can now finally announce that, together with Dell EMC, and as one of the first companies in the world, successfully deployed a customer-ready, production version of Azure Stack. If they're working with Dell EMC, an American company, then it's still the exact same issue.
- TomMarius 8y agoOne step at a time. Having physical control over data definitely is an improvement. Not everyone believes conspiracy theories about spy microchips in mainboards.
- Tsubasachan 8y agoMicrosoft Euro branch is still subject to US law. The US can still seize your data.
- tyfon 8y agoYes, that is why you use azure stack and not azure. It's a licensed version of the software that you can run completely independent of Microsoft.
- kkarakk 8y agolicenses usually include provisions for being disabled if the parent country requires it. see what happened to iran when US levied sanctions
- TomMarius 8y agoDisabled != data changes hands.
- zaphirplane 8y agoUsually you want that unless you don’t and you don’t here :)
- ionised 8y ago> believes conspiracy theories about spy microchips in mainboards. You mean not everyone believes the cold, hard truth? That's unfortunate, because most of us here saw the evidence of this taking place.
- fixermark 8y agoInteresting. Can you provide a source?
- chopin 8y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_Management_Engine#Claims_that_ME_is_a_backdoor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_Management_Engine#Claims...
- Dahoon 8y agoHow is that a chip in a mainboard? The mainboard story was a propaganda piece in Bloomberg aimed at China.
- chopin 8y agoAfaik the processor is a chip on the mainboard. I personally don't care which part of the mainboard carries the backdoor.
- fixermark 8y agoWith respect, what you linked to is a conspiracy theory that the ME is used in ways other than explicitly stated by Intel and unsupported by any evidence other than allegation.
- acct1771 8y ago"Can be used in ways other than explicitly stated" quickly turns into "is used": "https://hackaday.com/2017/12/07/another-defeat-of-the-intel-management-engine/ https://hackaday.com/2017/12/07/another-defeat-of-the-intel-... "The Intel Management Engine with its proprietary firmware has complete access to and control over the PC: it can power on or shut down the PC, read all open files, examine all running applications, track all keys pressed and mouse movements, and even capture or display images on the screen. And it has a network interface that is demonstrably insecure, which can allow an attacker on the network to inject rootkits that completely compromise the PC and can report to the attacker all activities performed on the PC. It is a threat to freedom, security, and privacy that can't be ignored." - Hackaday
- baybal2 8y agoThat cloud thing is overhyped. The "Cloud" will never swallow the budget and mid-tier hosting industry for purely economic reasons. Uncle Liu hosting Co. and AWS are the same things underneath, running mainstream x86 hardware, and both buying from mid-tier OEM server assemblers. The days of people buying $10k Dell servers are gone, and ones ability to capitalise on undercutting major hosters by buying directly from OEMs is gone too, because every large scale hosting co began doing the same.
- basejumping 8y agoCloud is not purely hosting, it's the services on top, the benefits of the company behind it. I don't know the statistics but probably bigger companies will pay a premium knowing that it's Amazon doing the hosting and not 10 different Uncle Lius.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- solarkraft 8y ago> the same things underneath, running mainstream x86 hardware Maybe not for long. Some providers (Amazon, Google) are working on their own processors.
- vegardx 8y agoOutside of the government sector it seems like these laws are to make sure that the data is within legal jurisdiction, and has nothing to do with privacy.
- tyfon 8y agoBanking data is at least considered to be "important" enough to keep within the borders too, but privacy is important too in regards to GDPR. How do you prevent unauthorized access to the data (i.e. the US government) with the cloud act. Do you report those requests as a breech? There is really no difference between that and having the servers hacked in other ways.
- vegardx 8y agoBanking data is important because the police and tax authority wants to make sure they have access, privacy doesn't really come into play here. It's a nice side effect, though. It's the same with accounting data. When it comes to GDPR it only talks about where and by who data is processed, it doens't really put any restriction on storage, except for some pretty vague (on purpose) requirements about data protection (read: encryption).
- tyfon 8y agoBut if the US government access PII without authorization via the cloud act wouldn't it count as a data breech when it comes to GDPR?
- vegardx 8y agoThen they should be getting encrypted or pseudoanonymised data, if you are following the regulations. For services like AWS you can argue that they should be able to get ahold of these encryption keys, but most data protection authorities seems to think this is good enough.
- thefounder 8y ago
- tpush 8y agoThe German one at least was cancelled recently [0] (source in German). [0] https://www.heise.de/newsticker/meldung/Auslaufmodell-Microsoft-Cloud-Deutschland-4152650.html https://www.heise.de/newsticker/meldung/Auslaufmodell-Micros...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- mtgx 8y agoI hope this bites US cloud service providers hard. They need a strong blowback against their cowardly support for the Cloud Act in the US. Microsoft, for instance, was suing the US government over its abusive NSL-enabled secret data requests, which made up almost half of the data requests the gov was making to Microsoft. But then Microsoft decided to drop the lawsuit and support the Cloud Act, which may have taken the actions of the US government from the shadows and into the light (somewhat), but it didn't really change the outcome of those actions. I imagine Microsoft and other cloud providers supported it because it gave them more legal cover. Well hopefully they'll live to regret that mistake with the EU blowback now. I also think it's just a matter of time (a year?) until the Privacy Shield will be invalidated by the top EU court, and then a new much stricter agreement will have to be made that will make all but impossible data transfers to the US. The EC is also to blame in this whole thing, because for some reason they decided to once again compromise with the US government on the type of EU-US data exchange deals they were making (which somehow always seem to go one way, from the EU to the US), because they gave the US gov the benefit of the doubt and thought the US gov would act in "good faith." Hopefully by now they've realized their error in thinking that.
- stunt 8y agoIs there a good European cloud provider?
- Spiritus 8y agoI'm using https://www.tilaa.com/en https://www.tilaa.com/en which is based in the Netherlands.
- zaarn 8y agoHetzner and OVH do cloud offerings, though they are more experienced in real hardware and shared hosting than actual cloud. The prices are competitive with AWS IMO.
- arendtio 8y agoFor Hetzner: https://www.hetzner.com/cloud https://www.hetzner.com/cloud What I like most about their service is the intuitive user interface and API. However, the downside is probably that they offer little more than virtual machines and storage. But for my projects, those things are completely sufficient and I am very happy with their service. I worked with AWS too but always hated it, because it takes so long to learn how they are doing things. Not because I am unfamiliar with the concepts, but because they seem to do things unnecessarily complicate (UX wise). Sometimes I ended up using CLI tools for AWS because they were more accessible and haunted by fewer bugs than their GUI.
- zaarn 8y agoPersonally, I prefer to build my stuff on top of baremetal. It costs more in personal/sysadmin time but you own the end result and it's less easily shut down by an overzealous AI at AWS HQ deciding you're a risk or competitor. That plus OVH and Hetzner aren't US corporations, my money and trust stay in Europe where they belong.
- tormeh 8y agoScaleway and Hetzner come to mind, although I have no idea how good they are.
- loxs 8y agoOf course. Decades of highest taxes on the planet make you uncompetitive and weak. Now we can only be "frightened" instead of us frightening the others.
- dang 8y agoCould you please stop posting unsubstantive comments to Hacker News?
- loxs 8y agoNot before you vote me to reputation that will prevent me from posting. Before that, I have the same rights and privileges as you, with regards of posting.
- dang 8y agoI'm afraid that's not the case. HN moderators (of which I'm one—sorry if that wasn't clear) ban accounts that keep posting unsubstantive comments. It's just one of the things we have to do in the attempt to keep this site from degenerating too quickly. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- loxs 8y agoIs there a guide on what comment is "substantive"?
- mcv 8y agoI think this CLOUD Act will basically force internationally operating US companies to split up into a US part and an EU part. This law makes it impossible for any company with access to personal data of EU citizens, to obey both US and EU law. The only solution seems to be to ensure that they are two different companies. The other option is to abandon the EU market. What still surprises me is that nearly all of the major cloud companies are based in the US. Microsoft, Amazon, Netflix, Google, Apple, all of them US companies. If ever a law is going to create some EU competitors, it's the Cloud Act. The other option is that either the US or the EU is going to water down their law. I'd be really sad if it's the EU, because that would legitimise and strengthen other countries' extraterritorial grasp over non-citizens' data. Like China with Huawei.
- nolok 8y agoOf course it will, they were already bordering on it before that (see specifically Microsoft USA arguing it could not access Microsoft Ireland data when the US court told them to, which directly leads to the new situation)
- guitarbill 8y ago> The only solution seems to be to ensure that they are two different companies. The other option is to abandon the EU market. > What still surprises me is that nearly all of the major cloud companies are based in the US. Microsoft, Amazon, Netflix, Google, Apple, all of them US companies. If ever a law is going to create some EU competitors, it's the Cloud Act. Given that e.g. AWS alone "owns"/operates two regions in China and several GovCloud regions, at worst it'll have a slight impact on these cloud provider's business via mainly legal and not technical changes. What it will do is show the Privacy Shield agreement is a farce, and the US cannot be trusted in these matters - well, hardly new insights, with things like ICANN et al, but these things were largely left unsaid. I suspect US foreign politics and their image will be harmed more than any of these cloud companies.
- 420codebro 8y agoAWS China is ran by a in-country 3rd party Chinese entity. Similar structure to what the above describes - a separate, but related entity.
- Proven 8y ago> lawmaker who co-heads a parliamentary cyber-security and sovereignty group, said in an interview. “This must be a wake up call for Europe to accelerate its own, sovereign offer in the data sector. Statist fool. The solution is to start respecting property rights by not allowing the State to violate it under any disguise (say, “law” enforcement). That, of course, can’t and won’t happen in the EU (or elsewhere for that matter) so we’ll see less choice, more protectionism and same privacy (ie property rights) violations as in China and the US. While GDPR adds some meaningless protection, it disproportionately increases the cost and still introduces new violatations of property rights (of data operators).
- Isinlor 8y agoIf complying with CLOUD act would infringe on EU citizens rights, is there any legal reason why EU regulator should not fine a company that is infringing EU laws? We, Europeans, should follow our laws to their full extend and fine infringing companies with full power. No matter on whose request they break our laws. Be it Russians, Chinese, Australian or Americans.
- Neil44 8y agoI agree. Companies need to find a way to operate within the law, or not operate. Throwing your hands up and saying it’s too hard is not an acceptable answer.
- j16sdiz 8y agoNo. They just stash the fine as operation cost. Every bank have been doing this for decades.
- mcv 8y agoI'm not sure how I feel about this argument in light of article 13 of the EU's new copyright directive. Legislators also have a responsibility to make laws that are reasonable and possible to obey. It is possible for companies to obey the Cloud Act, but as far as I can see, only by choosing between operating in the US and operating in the EU. If that's considered unreasonable, then it's a bad law.
- delinka 8y agoA company choosing to operate in multiple jurisdictions with competing/contradicting laws does not put a requirement on lawmakers to make the laws more amenable to the company trying to satisfy both jurisdictions. If you take that path, consumers end up with little protection under the law. Maybe the company should split up operations, or operate under licensing agreements with foreign companies rather than thwart the will of the people who they seek to fleece.
- 8y ago
- hevi_jos 8y agoJust look at the new HoloLens: It uses the cloud in order to analyze the objects in front of you at your office, your house or whatever on real time. Combine that with this with companies like Apple tracking your pulse in your clock(that gives them knowledge about your deep emotions an activities on real time). Add companies like Google that track your phone, your car(with the maps abilities) on real time. Add to this companies that track what your friends are doing on real time: https://www.apertus.org/facebook https://www.apertus.org/facebook This gives the US secret services more control over people than Stasi had. With the difference that they control all the people in the world. Too much power with so small oversight.
- judge2020 8y ago> Apple tracking your pulse in your phone(that gives them knowledge about your deep emotions an activities on real time). Health data is encrypted to a point where Apple can't read it: https://www.apple.com/business/site/docs/iOS_Security_Guide.pdf https://www.apple.com/business/site/docs/iOS_Security_Guide.... > Health data can be stored in iCloud. When configured for iCloud storage, Health data is synced between devices and secured by encryption that protects the data both in transit and at rest. H
- sangnoir 8y ago> Health data is encrypted to a point where Apple can't read it Apple controls the encryption keys and the underlying OS. If the user is not in control of the encryption, then it's nothing more than a pinky-promise that they won't peek at your data, for example, if a new management team takes over tomorrow.
- TheAceOfHearts 8y agoFor many people this is a reasonable risk. If they pulled something like that it would start a huge legal battle, and it would seriously harm their reputation. I suspect that pushing out a change of this sort would also require a system update, which you could always delay until it's been carefully vetted by others. At least with Apple you can maintain a fairly small chain of trust, since they have greater control over their hardware. Being in control of the encryption keys is unlikely to protect you from hardware backdoors or state-sponsored attacks.
- la6470 8y agoWhy are nations assuming crime even before they are committed? There are already provisions in law to prosecute a company if it breaks any law. Imagine that tomorrow EU says no to Japanese car and China says no to Siemens telecom equipment. This is kind of anal thinking by the policy makers.
- KangLi 8y ago"It struck a deal with Google to safeguard client data" xD!
- Kankuro 8y agoOk, so there should be reciprocal European law: any company operating in the EU must provide access to the EU authorities (all countries) any data managed by it and stored in any country in the world (so including US data stored in the US), otherwise it would get big fines or interdiction to operate in the EU. (PS: I don't want that, it should work like extradition but with real reciprocity)
- segmondy 8y agoThis reminds me of the crypto wars, except this time around it's the privacy wars. We didn't win the crypto wars for nothing, all we have to do is make use of it and we can win this again.
- tzs 8y agoSuppose I, operating in the US, rent some physical storage space in Europe from a European storage company, and then ship a box of documents to them and tell them to put them in my rented storage space. I don't think there is any serious doubt that a US court or US law enforcement with a warrant would be able to order me to contact the storage company and tell them to ship the box back to me. The European country the storage unit is in would not see this as some attempt at exercising extraterritorial jurisdiction. To them, it is just a routine interaction between me and a service provider I am using in Europe. That my motive for asking for my box back was to satisfy a court order rather than because I actually wanted to use my documents is irrelevant. (This works both ways. A French court ordering a French company that had stored physical documents to retrieve those documents would not raise issues in the US if the French company was using a US document archiving service to hold them). I don't see why there should be any difference between my physical documents that I keep in a box in a Paris storage unit, and my electronic documents that I keep on an Amazon server in the Paris AWS region.
- cesarb 8y agoIn your example, the US court is ordering you to request the documents. There's no question that the US court has jurisdiction over you. What about this variation over your example: instead of contacting you, the US court bypasses you and asks directly the European storage company. This is much more questionable, since a US court shouldn't have jurisdiction over an European company.
- DuskStar 8y agoFunnily enough, in the GDPR equivalent (you, a EU resident, hire a company in the US to store a box for you) the EU bypasses you and requires the storage company to have an effective security guard and fire suppression system...
- ionised 8y agoThe difference is that in this case the US considers itself the owner of all data on US and Eu citizens alike. The EU merely says that you cannot store Eu citizens data without the necessary safeguards in place and permissions asked. This is a very different issue in my view. The US has an inflated sense of entitlement, whereas the EU is being protective and inhibiting of data collection on its citizens by foreign organisations.
- hopler 8y agoNationalism/Sovereignty vs Globalisn/OneWorldOrder. In the past we occasionally had rounds of "harmonization" where countries agree on one set of laws, as with copyright. We'll see what the future holds.
- KorematsuFred 8y agoWhat happens if say EU were to pass a law that no data stored in EU data centered be shared with non-EU countries ? In such case no company can obey both laws. How will this be handled ?
- jeroenhd 8y agoActually, the EU privacy laws already forbid loads of data being stored in countries where the privacy of that data might not be maintained. When the US was ruled as not trustworthy enough, the Privacy Shield agreement was quickly thrown together. That's currently why some sensitive information about European citizens is allowed to be stored on US soil. However, acts like these (Cloud act, PATRIOT act, etc.) make me, as a European, very uncomfortable. I hope the EU will take action against the US. Russia and China already have regulations that certain information can only be stored inside their own country's borders and MS Outlook still works fine; there's no need for the EU to just take crap like this without putting up a fight.
- TheTruestKyle0 8y agoHow about you stop being a little cunt? You ever think about that bitch?