7 ms·
Key Values – Find Engineering Teams That Share Your Values
- mediocrejoker 8y agoThis is a cool idea but the utility really hinges on the quality and quantity of the data. How many companies are represented here, and how do they get on the list? Who decides whether they meet each of the criteria?
- ddebernardy 8y agohttps://www.keyvalues.com/submit https://www.keyvalues.com/submit It seems to be self-reported by the startup and curated by the Key:Values staff.
- lynnetye 8y agoKey Values' staff is just me, Lynne. (Hi there!) Companies self-select the 8 values that best describe their engineering culture, and then I work closely w/ them to qualify them. All of the content is curated, and it takes a lot of time, care, and thought to put together. To answer the original question (Who decides whether they meet each of the criteria?), the answer is you, the reader. "Work/life balance" can mean any number of things, and people often forget that there are countless ways to define a given term. The goal is for teams to describe what it means to them and let interested applicants decide whether it resonates w/ them.
- tysonzni 8y agoI think it makes sense to ask companies to explicitly list cultural values they prioritize the most as well as what they value the least. Evaluating/creating a company culture is in a way really about understanding what the tradeoffs and sacrifices are.
- ddebernardy 8y agoOut of curiosity, how do you deal with (the many) companies that say their values are A, B, C when they're actually X, Y, Z? (I don't want to name shame prior companies I've worked with but this mismatch struck me as a fairly common occurrence.)
- DyslexicAtheist 8y agomy guess is not at all. it depends on how he charges for the service. since it's not applicants or job seekers paying, the agenda is set by their clients. no matter what the marketing says the values and how it is optimized gets defined by those who pay.
- burfog 8y agoBesides not having everything ALL IN UPPERCASE SHOUTING UNREADABLE I'd like to see: dogs at work patriotic IQ > EQ asperger's tolerant stability > risk-taking no inclusion/diversity shaming not taking work home short work hours no wellness shaming open floor plan offices with doors life-critical (autopilot, pacemaker, etc.) uses waterfall methodologies uses proven technologies slow-paced environment long-term stable company size does timecards works for military hires felons
- ambicapter 8y ago> no wellness shaming What does this mean?
- amelius 8y agoAlso, it would be nice to be able to select a geographic region first.
- ddebernardy 8y agoOr "Remote" as a region.
- amelius 8y agoAny way to exclude companies that participate in user tracking networks? Or are they excluded by default?
- htfy96 8y agoTBH I'm more willing to see a negative filter on these claimed team-values. "Risk over stability" may sound attractive for me (as well as many new grads to polish their resumes) several years ago, until you realize it's just an analog to "move fast and break things" and we all witnessed its side-efferts.
- xirdstl 8y agoI came here to say the same thing. There are some attributes that would be red flags to me, and it would be helpful to filter out companies that select them.
- Melchizedek 8y agoExactly, such as "uses agile methodologies". Also, I would like to select for less subjective factors like "private offices", not "thoughtful office layout".
- foo_in_bar 8y agoMore granular filtering would be helpful. I bet from some companies point of view thoughtful layout equals open space.
- Radim 8y agoThat was my immediate reaction too. If a team promotes some of these values, I'd want nothing to do with them. Is there an explicit filter for negation? "Want / Don't want / Don't care", as opposed to just "Want / Don't care".
- high_derivative 8y agoI had a similar (although cynical reading): Flat hierarchies: Chaotic leadership / implicit and unwritten hierarchies with CEO's favorites. Values diversity: Politicised office focusing on SJW issues and quotas, not diversity. Fosters psychological safety: Empowers toxic characters to bring their drama into work. Empirically, from the limited placements I have seen, the more a workplace outwardly focuses on one of these aspects, the more they are ridden by toxic tribalism/outrage culture.
- golemiprague 8y agoWhy there is no option for diverse team but no option for very homogenous team? I find that homogenous teams perform much better and responsible for most of the products and innovations you see today, how come there is no option to choose something that proved itself so well in the past?
- kenha 8y agohomogenous in what way? i’m curious.
- golemiprague 8y agoWay of thinking and acting, but that usually derive from culture and correlated with race, so yes, I am aware of the implications. When people talk about diversity they usually refer to race and gender, so yes, exactly the opposite to that.
- creato 8y agoEven if any company wanted to advertise that, it probably would be incredibly unwise to do so for many reasons, but particularly because it's going to look really, really bad in court if they ever get sued for employment discrimination.
- MediumD 8y agoIt's certainly an interesting idea, but from my experience, most companies I worked for had values that were primarily all talk and weren't really substantial. Especially when things like 'Open Communication' and 'Fast-paced environment' mean completely different things to different people. Every company describes themselves as having 'impressive team members'. I'm not sure how this would help me actually find a company with the desired values when companies are able to say whatever they want about themselves.
- lynnetye 8y agoReplied to a comment below that touches on this, but the whole point is for teams to explain what things like “Open Communication” and “Fast-Paced Environment” mean to them. You can read how each team qualifies each of their value selections. Companies are limited to choosing 8 values and they’re also asked to rank them in order of importance. You’ll notice that many teams don’t select “Impressive Team Members.”
- jka 8y agoIs the Key:Values team (nice choice of name by the way!) familiar with Bryan Cantrill's talk on 'Principles of Technology Leadership'? https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=9QMGAtxUlAc https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=9QMGAtxUlAc It seems to resonate pretty closely with what you're building, so if it helps align or educate anyone (candidates, recruiters, or the team) that'd be neat. Edit: FWIW, the talk uses the term 'principle' to indicate what your site calls a 'value'; in practice I've seen tech companies talk about their 'core values' and so I think yours is very valid.
- jka 8y agoAh, I read that the team is you at the moment :) Either way, hope it might help!
- MediumD 8y agoMost of my skepticism is not tied to the ambiguity of certain values but the discrepancy of what people claim to be the values, versus what actually happens day-to-day. I don't mean to come off critical of your product. Your goals are admirable and you've made a lot of progress. I just don't think I could trust total strangers that their company truly is all about _____ or ____. I love the name though! It's clever
- azhenley 8y agoI want to see the employees' perceptions of these values so that I know if these are actually the values.
- lapnitnelav 8y agoSome kind of (anonymised) user rating of how each value is applied in the company would make a lot of sense. This would allow to assess the truthfulness of such claims
- morningmoon 8y agoIt’s nice to see unique approaches and improvements to the traditional job board. And from a bootstrapped solo founder as well! Kudos! Something I would like is a filter for industry or business model. A company’s values are largely driven by the company’s mission. For example, companies selling software to power weapons versus medical diagnostics speak to our values just as much as things like work-life balance, or nonviolent communication. One of the most difficult things for me when searching for new opportunities is having to figure out what each company actually does before I begin to evaluate whether there’s a culture fit.
- avip 8y agoName is brilliant. Well done.
- rch 8y agoGreat idea. When I started making selections[-] I expected filter-like behavior. I was surprised to see the results increasing with each selection. I'd rather configure my filters and provide contact info to be notified when an org satisfies my criteria. [-] Filters: Flat Organization; Supports Physical Wellness; Light Meetings; Open Source Contributor; Has Internship Program; Engineering Driven; Remote Ok.
- ounces 8y agoSounds like Mozilla.
- jrockway 8y agoAre any of these criteria specific to engineering? I was expecting things like "writing tests" or "code reviews mandatory". All of these things apply to anyone and everyone; you can have literally any specialty in an environment that's "good for parents" or has "open communication".
- lynnetye 8y agoSome of the values are specific to software engineering (i.e. pair programming, agile methodologies), but it’s more that the profiles are of the engineering team(s) within a given company. As you can imagine, there are subcultures within an organization and just because all of the parents on the marketing team take advantage of paid family leave doesn’t mean the parents on the engineering team do. If I were say a 30yo woman planning to have my first child in the near future, I’d like to know if there were any parents on the eng team I was about to join. Similarly, open communication on sales probably looks pretty different than it does for devs. The values are from the perspective of an engineer evaluating different employment opportunities. What would you or I want for our day-to-day and from our future teammates?
- Volscio 8y agoGiven so much discussion on this topic, the first thing I looked for was whether there was a reference to whether a company does timed code pair interviews and white boarding, or uses some other method (paid trial period, take home test, etc). Would that be worth adding?
- gamma3 8y agoThe more values I select, the more matches I get. This should be the other way around. It should be an AND filter on the values.
- lynnetye 8y agoTrust me, once I have enough teams to make using AND logic a good user experience, I will!
- coding123 8y agoI figured that was why it was an OR right now too.
- elgenie 8y agoIf you don't have enough teams for AND to be a good user experience, NOT might be a better user experience.
- burfog 8y agoCount matches, sort, and then put separators between different levels of matching. So the top of the list would be companies with 8 matches, then there is a separator, then there are companies with 7 matches, then there is a separator, and so on... all the way down to zero matches. The list is always everything, but the sort order changes.
- actionowl 8y agoVery interesting idea! It reminds me of this talk from Bryan Cantril "PLATFORM AS A REFLECTION OF VALUES: JOYENT, NODE.JS, AND BEYOND" https://vimeo.com/230142234 https://vimeo.com/230142234
- mrhappyunhappy 8y agoDoesn’t work on my phone iPhone. Hard to read labels. Overall nice effort but as others mentioned this needs to be AND filtered. Perhaps add some anonymous review capability so employees can actually reflect on whether those values are real or bs.
- badfrog 8y agoI'd love to be able to filter for more explicit versions of work/life balance. For example, if I could find a job with a 4-day work week and 6 weeks of PTO, I'd sign up in a heartbeat. Instead the companies on this site that value work/life balance say things like "there is a lot of interest in fitness, nutrition, biohacking, and meditation" which is kind of meaningless to me.
- Cyclone_ 8y agoI believe having the company explain the value is the idea, since values could mean something different to everyone.
- badfrog 8y agoYeah for sure. I just wish I could filter by fine-grained ideas instead of having to read 30 paragraphs to find what I'm looking for.
- lynnetye 8y agoSounds like that company’s definition doesn’t resonate with you. Perfect. Now you know not to even bother applying. You might find more of what you’re looking for here: https://www.keyvalues.com/finding-worklife-balance-in-tech https://www.keyvalues.com/finding-worklife-balance-in-tech
- ThePadawan 8y agoNot sure if this is helpful, but IMO this might be due to a US/Europe disconnect (?). 4-day work week, 6 weeks off is within negotiable distance in Switzerland (from personal experience - have worked 4day/5weeks before). The extra 1-2 weeks PTO (on top of the legally mandated 4) are typical for larger enterprises such as governmental work or the postal system.
- hackerpacker 8y agoYah none of those really do it for me. I mean sure they sound good, but I know it is just another form of "inclusivity" which is really there to exclude. I don't like imposing my values on people, least of all at work, nor having them imposed on me. But that isn't an option, so sort of a forced poll. Oh, and the number expands the more you click, so not very useful... edit, where is the checkbox that says "doesn't make bloated 3mb (compressed) cheezy websites"?
- sriram_malhar 8y agoLove the name.
- high_derivative 8y agoMissing the most important filter of all: No Leet-code style white-board interviewing.
- amriksohata 8y agoEven though there are international companies on there, anything similar like this for UK specific companies?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ThePadawan 8y agoI would love to be able to link to the selection I just made. Something simple like https://www.keyvalues.com/#123-456-522 https://www.keyvalues.com/#123-456-522 would be really great to share this with friends and colleagues.
- hiccuphippo 8y agoHow about stuff like caring for user's privacy and no ads in the products?
- fareesh 8y agoWouldn't it also be useful to include companies that have conservative leanings?