12 ms·
No, we don't. Bitcoin is one way to use energy. There are hundreds of thousands of other ways. When you say Bitcoin "hurts the environment", what, concretely
by SilasX 8y ago
No, we don't.
Bitcoin is one way to use energy. There are hundreds of thousands of other ways.
When you say Bitcoin "hurts the environment", what, concretely do you mean? Presumably, you mean it in a stronger sense than "using energy to produce food hurts the environment" or "using energy to run an ER hurts the environment".
That is, you think that relative to the benefit provided, the use of (harmful) energy to run bitcoin miners doesn't justify its environmental cost.
Which is great, but I could say the same thing of Ferraris for show-off producers in LA, or Hello Kitty backpacks.
What justifies focusing our attention on Bitcoin per se, and not those? Do you plan to publish a universal, agreed-upon list of things whose social value doesn't justify its environmental cost?
The real problem is energy users not bearing the full environmental costs of what they do.
The thing is, we have a well known solution to that: cap the total carbon emissions, or tax them in a way that reflects the harm.
Yes, Bitcoin creates an incentive to use energy. And it will be spent by miners who weigh the costs of the energy against the value of the Bitcoins produced. Like every other good on the market, it will respond to incentives created by laws.
If the damage of energy isn't priced in, then there will be too many resources spent on mining relative to the environmental cost. But this is true of every other good as well.
All Bitcoin does is amplify the problems of the existing failure to appropriately price energy. But this is true of literally every other energy-using good in existence!
There is no reason to single out Bitcoin. To blame it for environmental problems is special pleading or privileging a hypothesis.
"I don't want wiggins at my university. They cheat!"
'Well, a certain percentage of any demographic is going to ch--'
"Irrelevant! We're talking about wiggins!"
EDIT: Should probably add the disclaimer that I'm long Bitcoin.
- aidanlister 8y agoOh come on. Bitcoin uses the same amount of energy that the country of Iraq [1] uses, home to 38 million people. Bitcoin has about 500k active bitcoin addresses [2], most of which contain less than $100 [3]. So what are we actually getting for all this energy usage, and couldn't we get that same result for a fraction of the energy usage? [1] https://digiconomist.net/bitcoin-energy-consumption https://digiconomist.net/bitcoin-energy-consumption [2] https://bitinfocharts.com/top-100-richest-bitcoin-addresses.html https://bitinfocharts.com/top-100-richest-bitcoin-addresses.... [3] https://bitinfocharts.com/comparison/bitcoin-activeaddresses.html https://bitinfocharts.com/comparison/bitcoin-activeaddresses...
- c22 8y agoYou think bitcoin is bad? https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B1s8219SGDIjMnkzdFI2QjhwNm8/view https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B1s8219SGDIjMnkzdFI2QjhwNm8... My gut instinct is that the vast majority of all computing cycles used by humanity are completely wasted on irrelevant tasks and inefficiencies.
- root_axis 8y agoBitcoin is wasteful because of its energy profile not because of an arbitrary value judgement regarding how energy should be used. Rendering images is useful work. Processing transactions is useful work. With gaming computers, increasing energy costs means increasing detail and complexity in the images that can be processed. Bitcoin is wasteful because the increasing energy costs does not increase the total number of transactions that can be processed.
- c22 8y agoNo, it increases the trust of the system. Is it the best solution? Perhaps not, but it is not without utility.
- root_axis 8y ago"Increasing trust" doesn't add value if the system is already sufficiently trustworthy for the task of processing transactions. Based on that reasoning the cost should ('should' meaning: it is beneficial) increase forever because an infinite amount of energy burned is infinitely trustworthy.
- c22 8y agoIs bitcoin sufficiently trustworthy without proof of work? I'm not a bitcoin expert, but my understanding was that this is an integral part of the trust model. If so then we're just back to talking about inefficiencies. I can't imagine the processing being done by my computer right now is all strictly necessary to read and post these comments, and I'd wager this site is more efficient than most these days. Still I accept reality and pay these costs in order to talk with you on the internet because this is the world we live in. It looks like these nice people at MIT are working on some of the inefficiencies of cryptocurrencies, so let's rejoice.
- ForHackernews 8y agoBitcoin is a terrible way to use energy. It's deliberately inefficient, and it's a constant arms race to become even more inefficient. You're literally killing the planet to enable...what? Tax evasion? Selling drugs and child porn? It's a moral and ecological atrocity. I agree that capping and/or taxing carbon emissions is the right policy approach, but I would seriously question the values of any humans who then decided to spend our limited carbon budget on something like bitcoin.
- sjeohp 8y ago> You're literally killing the planet This kind of hyperbole suggests you didn’t read the person’s comment very closely. How is using X joules mining bitcoin worse than using it for anything else? Eg. mining gold? If the energy grid was 100% sustainable would bitcoin still be “literally killing the planet”? Surely not, so maybe the problem is actually the energy source, not this particular use case.
- claudiawerner 8y agoIndeed it might be still killing the planet, if all the renewable energy we can make at the moment were to be used for Bitcoin and so the other needs must use fossil fuels. At the very least, this argument leads to the conclusion that we ought to stop mining Bitcoin until all energy is renewable, but something tells me its advocates won't be happy with that.
- eeZah7Ux 8y ago> How is using X joules mining bitcoin worse than using it for anything else? Eg. mining gold? Or powering an MRI machine to detect cancer in a patient. Is it the same ethically?
- kmkemp 8y agoA correction - bitcoin is not anonymous enough to enable any of the use cases you mentioned. But that misses the points - tools can't be blamed for secondary use cases - do you blame physical dollars for enabling child porn? As far as our carbon budget, how we choose to create energy and how much energy something uses are unrelated concepts. If people pay a proper price for energy that reflects its scarcity and externalities, then there is no problem. In a world where we use 100% renewable energy sources, would you complain about bitcoin mining? In any case, one could argue that the amount of energy required to secure the bitcoin network is a drop in the bucket compared to the amount of energy that (for example) the USA uses to secure the value of the dollar. If we then factor in the pretty obvious benefits of a decentralized currency, it seems like a great idea if the downsides can be properly addressed.
- orthecreedence 8y agoAn enormous amount of energy used to support a tiny minority of people participating in a highly-manipulated wealth redistribution mechanism is, objectively, a complete fucking waste. You cannot look at bitcoin by any measure and say that it's a practical success for any of its goals. And given the amount of energy it uses to perpetuate its own failure, it's nearly sinful to keep it going. That said, I do support some form of decentralized currency. Not because people are ever going to be smart enough to be their own bank or because I think some currency will magically topple governments and financial structures, but mainly so people can transact without overly-censorious middle-men who take a cut while adding nearly no value. We have the internet, now. Payment networks should have died years ago. I'm glad this problem is being worked on. However, it's possible to solve without using a country's-worth of energy to support a pathetic ~10 transactions per second.
- sjeohp 8y ago> “However, it's possible to solve without using a country's-worth of energy to support a pathetic ~10 transactions per second.” Great! I look forward to seeing your solution in action.
- koonsolo 8y agoNano does it in action.
- sjeohp 8y agoNano claims to do it in action. So do others. Some of them might even be proven right, the vast majority will not, so acting like it's some kind of trivial solved problem is disingenuous. Ethereum's PoS has been in development for years and there is still no consensus that it will be a better mechanism than PoW.
- orthecreedence 8y ago> acting like it's some kind of trivial solved problem is highly disingenuous I said it's possible. I didn't say it was easy. That said, PoW on a small scale is an interesting experiment. On a large scale, it's a horrible way of allocating energy usage. So while the databases running on PoW are working, they are a stupid waste of energy. I welcome any alternative.
- throwawaymath 8y ago> When you say Bitcoin "hurts the environment", what, concretely do you mean? We mean that mining Bitcoin is extremely energy-intensive by design. This is to say that the energy consumed by Bitcoin's economic activity is deliberately and gratuitously significant, not incidentally so. Moreover, the energy consumed by Bitcoin mining scales commensurate with how many Bitcoins have been mined thus far. So yes, that makes it categorically different from other energy-expensive activities like farming or hospital maintenance. We are actually economically incentivized to consume less energy over time in most energy-expensive activities. With most cryptocurrencies, energy consumption is a design imperative.
- kadendogthing 8y ago>No, we don't. I stopped reading.
- reaperducer 8y agoWhich is great, but I could say the same thing of Ferraris for show-off producers in LA, or Hello Kitty backpacks. Just because one thing is bad doesn't mean the other thing isn't also bad.
- blaze33 8y agoOh sure, buying fresh berries imported by plane from the other side of the world is no better than this bitcoin mining business! But it's not a competition to single out the worst offender. I feel the parent comment shares this common intuition that there must be some way to design and code any crytocurrency to offer the same features without having to consume so much energy in the process. I'm no expert on cryptocoins but we surely can agree that any hope to see them mainstream won't rely on countless power plants to brute force computational puzzles.
- MarkSummer 8y ago> When you say Bitcoin "hurts the environment", what, concretely do you mean? Presumably, you mean it in a stronger sense than "using energy to produce food hurts the environment" or "using energy to run an ER hurts the environment". Perhaps a more direct analogy is "literally miming gold hurts the environment (since I highly doubt renewable energy is significantly leveraged in the supply chain)". > That is, you think that relative to the benefit provided, the use of (harmful) energy to run bitcoin miners doesn't justify its environmental cost. It makes me wonder if you couldn't somehow tie a renewable energy certificate (1) to a mined coin. I suppose green coin (2) is a similar, albeit indirect concept (i.e. value is from a unit of carbon sequestration). 1.) https://www.epa.gov/greenpower/renewable-energy-tracking-systems https://www.epa.gov/greenpower/renewable-energy-tracking-sys... 2.) https://coincheckup.com/coins/greencoin/purpose https://coincheckup.com/coins/greencoin/purpose
- alkonaut 8y agoThis argument assumes that bitcoin provides some value and isn’t mainly used for speculation.
- geofft 8y ago> When you say Bitcoin "hurts the environment", what, concretely do you mean? Presumably, you mean it in a stronger sense than "using energy to produce food hurts the environment" or "using energy to run an ER hurts the environment". That is, you think that relative to the benefit provided, the use of (harmful) energy to run bitcoin miners doesn't justify its environmental cost. For myself, that is not what I mean when I use the phrase. Bitcoin hurts the environment because Bitcoin, by design, wants to use as much power as available to secure it - and conversely is vulnerable to anyone who has significant power available, and so it had to design itself so that the rational thing to do is to commit that power to Bitcoin itself. Bitcoin automatically adjusts its difficulty based on the computational speed of the network over the past few thousand blocks. There is a target mining speed of one block every ten minutes. If someone throws more computational power at Bitcoin, Bitcoin itself will adjust to the additional available power, so that nothing more gets done, it just uses up the power. This is not a claim that the benefit is too low relative to the additional energy; this is a claim that the benefit is zero, by design, relative to additional energy, and that this property is inherent to Bitcoin. There is a reason to single out Bitcoin and blame it for environmental problems. No other product, concept, or idea in human history (besides Bitcoin clones) has been designed in a way where it expands gas-like to all the energy available to it (... except perhaps capitalism itself, and funny enough, people are claiming that capitalism too must be stopped to avert irrecoverable climate change). I'm supportive of other forms of cryptocurrency without this property (weakly supportive, given that I haven't used any of them in detail, but they seem promising). There seems no particular reason to use Bitcoin if alternatives exist without the burn-all-the-available-energy property.
- SilasX 8y agoThank you, this is a very productive reply, and you are highlighting specific things that are unique to Bitcoin. You're right that a core part of its design is making sure real computational resources are spent on it. That means the (total, social) cost network as such will scale with the size of the economy, not the number of transactions. So, in a sense, there's (something that looks) like an arms race going on, where more resources spent on it don't mean more transactions. Point taken. But that doesn't mean there's zero net benefit. The benefit is a permissionless network that no one can control unless they produce more computation than the rest of the network. So, the benefit of each miner coming on is raising the attack threshold and increasing your confidence that it won't be attacked. At equilibrium, the cost will be some fraction of the economy, not all available growth or energy (like a gas). That amount of energy that this involves will decrease as energy is taxed. That's pretty much the dynamic of gold mining under a gold standard: the larger the economy, the more money being spent mining (literal) money. I agree that it's a high price to pay, but I don't think the benefits should count as zero. Being able to bypass financial choke points so you can donate to Wikileaks is definitely a positive.
- Pharmakon 8y agoEDIT: Should probably add the disclaimer that I'm long Bitcoin. No need, at this point it’s trivial to determine that from the industrial-strength denial of the downsides and naked proselytizing. Someone brings up a real and long term concern about environmental consequences from a truly wasteful process, and your response is the kind of equivocating about what “harm” means, and fantasies about markets which have become the hallmark of the terminal-stage cryptocurrency investor/ideologue. Trust me, long before the edit, people understood where you were coming from, and smelled the search for new bagholders.
- woodruffw 8y ago> There is no reason to single out Bitcoin. To blame it for environmental problems is special pleading or privileging a hypothesis. It's not special pleading if I'm equally annoyed by Ferraris and other environmentally disastrous forms of conspicuous consumption. I don't know enough about Hello Kitty backpacks to have a serious reason to be against them. It's perfectly consistent for me or anyone else to leave a negative comment about Bitcoin on an online forum and then as much or far more to tackle a different issue that I/they consider pressing. And this, largely, is how it seems to be playing out: nobody has been arrested for using wasteful PoW schemes yet, because we have bigger fish to fry.
- TomMckenny 8y agoBut apparently there is some point where a large enough majority converts an ethic from subjective into objective. For example "murder is wrong" is considered objectively true even though serial killers my disagree. And at least in broad strokes, it is possible to determine benefit to harm ratios. It is esntially uncontroversial to say "Coal Rollers"[1] do more harm relative to good than candy manufacturing or face lifts. And a cap/tax carbon emissions would be great. But that hasn't happened, effectively isn't going to anytime soon and is more complex than it seems. Consider that spikes in green energy use will drive its price such that petroleum becomes more attractive in spite of a tax. And there is no way to correctly price carbon emissions when the effect will be felt by hundreds of generations and the extent of the harm is still unknown. It is, after all, simpler to try to persuade a smaller interest just to stop mining (even though that too has almost no chance of happening). I have no idea whether Bitcoin is being unfairly singled out or not. But since the thread is about mining efficiency, it is the logical topic rather than say deforestation. So it's not a-priori impossible that it does more harm than good. And even if not a catastrophic problem, surely it would still be nice to reduce the harm if possible. [1]https://www.businessinsider.com/conservatives-purposely-making-cars-spew-black-smoke-2014-7 https://www.businessinsider.com/conservatives-purposely-maki...
- lvs 8y agoThis is a long-winded argument that says only that Bitcoin shouldn't be singled out as a waste of energy. Fine, many things are also wasteful and pointless, but that doesn't absolve Bitcoin of anything.
- jchw 8y agoNo offense but this is some pretty strong whataboutism. The amount of energy that would be used by a crypto currency that gains mainstream adoption would be pretty substantial, certainly much, much more substantial than traditional currency/credit cards/etc.
- Aeolun 8y agoThese tiny blobs of data with utterly fake scarcity consume more energy than whole countries. And you try to argue that they’re a good expenditure of energy? The only reason to single out bitcoin is that it’s a highly visible waste. But just because there’s multiple ways we waste a ton of energy, does not mean we shouldn’t fix any of them.
- dorgo 8y ago> you try to argue that they’re a good expenditure of energy? I think his argument is that it shouldn't matter whether it is a good expenditure of energy or not. Environmental costs should be priced in the energy costs. Then it wouldn't matter for the society and for the environment how much energy you use or waste.