7 ms·
We ignored evidence linking cigarettes to cancer – Let's not do that with vaping
- siedes 8y agoI feel that the culture that builds up around things like vaping, marijauna, etc. are far more overreaching than the health effects itself on the individual. Because a culture has built up around it, easily influenced people, especially those who are younger, willingly take part in something that can/will worsen their health just because it is trending and 'everyone else' is doing it and it's 'safe'. Yes, marijuana and vaping are not as bad as cigarettes and other things. But I find using that as a justification is concerning since they can still bad right? Weed may have not ever killed anyone, but have you seen stoner culture? Let's say marijuana itself doesn't make you dumber or lazy, but stoner culture certainly will. You can justify anything if you have something worse to compare it to. Now it's weed or vaping, in the future it may be something else.
- kbrwn 8y agoYou should cite some actual evidence that "stoner culture" makes folks lazier and dumber or GTFO.
- siedes 8y agoSorry bro gotta smoke a bowl and eat some munchies. I don't have time to source things for ya :-) /s /s
- tlb 8y agoIt's not feasible to get scientific evidence for the effect of any culture on individual intelligence or laziness. This is true for all cultures including religious and ethnic. There's zero scientific evidence that any such culture is good or bad for you. You can't run a randomized controlled trial, and epidemiological techniques are unable to separate out all the confounding factors. There's also no scientific evidence that, say, Typescript is better than Javascript. Just anecdotes and opinion. Those are worthwhile, though. You have to choose somehow. So please don't reject sincere opinions for not having scientific evidence when none is available.
- lbj 8y agoIt doesn't seem like the effects, good/bad are being ignored. A little over a year ago, the british ministry of health conducted a very large study which concluded that vaping is not health, but its approximately 95% less harmful than cigarettes.
- skwb 8y agoCare to share a citation on the study?
- NeedMoreTea 8y agohttps://www.gov.uk/government/news/e-cigarettes-around-95-less-harmful-than-tobacco-estimates-landmark-review https://www.gov.uk/government/news/e-cigarettes-around-95-le...
- open-source-ux 8y agoThere's an update to the 2015 report from Public Health England (PHE) published in 2018: PHE publishes independent expert e-cigarettes evidence review https://www.gov.uk/government/news/phe-publishes-independent-expert-e-cigarettes-evidence-review https://www.gov.uk/government/news/phe-publishes-independent... This video demonstration from PHE provides a striking comparison between smoking and vaping. Perhaps unintentionally, the video might make people who vape to view it as a relatively safe practice (it's much safer than smoking, but still detrimental to health): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RisBe5sLGPc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RisBe5sLGPc
- DanBC 8y agoPHE are doing a pretty good job I think. They're telling smokers that vaping is much better than smoking. They're telling shops not to sell vaping supplies to people who were not previously smokers, and that self-regulation while inconsistant seems to be working okay at the moment.
- jessriedel 8y ago
- seibelj 8y agoI’m not a scientist but I simply can’t imagine that vaping a full JUUL cartridge and smoking a pack of cigarettes is even remotely the same.
- pmlnr 8y agoDoes the factor matter, if both are unhealthy enough to be a problem?
- slededit 8y agoOf course degree matters. Healthy and Unhealthy are not binary categories. Both alcohol and meth are harmful to health, but the degree makes one manageable and the other not.
- stefan_ 8y agoObviously? Dosage makes the poison.
- JamesBarney 8y agoYes, it matters because the government has an interest in improving the public health. When you reduce access to vaping that decreases the number of vapers and increases the number of smokers. So the relative risks of each are important in deciding how much you want to promote/restrict access to vaping. If vaping is just as bad as cigarettes than you probably want to make vaping really expensive and hard to get. If it's completely risk free you'd want to subsidize vaping and make sure it's available at every store. The best evidence looks like it's 5%-10% as deadly as smoking which means we probably don't want to restrict it too much.
- throwaway415415 8y agoIf 60 people get addicted to juul, and only 20 gets addicted to cigarrets, there is a problem. Cigarrets are so strong and disgusting that it is really hard to start. You really need to want to look cool as a teen to start smoking cigs. Juul is just so easy to smoke, and the flavors make it awesome. It's insane how different the two products are in term of awesomeness. So if juul is bad for health, the next generation is in deep deep trouble
- code_duck 8y agoInhaling nicotine is very harmful to your heart. Repeated doses of a stimulant can cause heart disease, and about as many smokers die from that as lung disease. With vaping, even more nicotine is delivered immediately to the system. It seems that this would have the same negative consequences on cardiac and vascular health. Why is that not more often discussed? It seems like this risk alone is enough to declare vaping to be unsafe.
- JamesBarney 8y agoBecause most of the cardiovascular risks of smoking aren't related to nicotine.
- Alex3917 8y agoHow do the CO risks compare with the nicotine risks? Because nicotine on its own does raise your blood pressure substantially.
- JamesBarney 8y agoThis article argues that nicotine barely increases blood pressure, and nicotine replacement therapy is therefore safe in hypertensive individuals. https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/j.1524-6175.2001.00483.x https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/j.1524-6175...
- code_duck 8y agoWhat would they be related to, then? Other chemicals, or degraded respiration?
- JamesBarney 8y agoThe chemicals produced from burning the tobacco and additives. Combustion in general produces a bunch of nasty chemicals.
- 8y ago
- jarym 8y agoI spoke to a number of researchers several years ago before vaping really became so mainstream. To be honest a number had a rather surprising view: if it has nicotine in it then it must be bad. I formed my own opinion back then: the researchers did not seem that inretested in the effects of vaping and preferred to instead just associate it with cigarettes. This article talks about us not knowing the long term effects (which is true) but then goes on to regulating vaping. Why not advocate for more research instead? I don’t think vaping is without side effects but it’s my personal view and I have no scientific basis for it. But we should be doing more research before we clamp down on it.
- throwaway415415 8y agoThis is dumb because I vape thc or cbd but never nicotine. I still want to know if it's harmful.
- MereInterest 8y agoGiven that nicotine has been known to have harmful effects since the first time it was isolated, nearly 200 years ago [1], that is not an unreasonable approach to take. Just because it is being delivered in a slightly different mechanism doesn't mean that the previous research in entirely inapplicable. If I know that banging my head against a brick wall hurts, it is reasonable to assume that banging my head against a wooden wall will also hurt. [1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4363846/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4363846/
- JamesBarney 8y agoArticles like this always ignore the other side of the issue. Assuming half of vapers would be non-smokers, then every time we eliminate two vapers through clamping down on vaping we generate a cigarettes smoker. And cigarette smoking is one of the worst public health hazards.
- JauntTrooper 8y agoNicotine itself is bad. Yes, it's probably much better for you to not inhale hot smoke particles in your lungs and all the other ancillary chemicals from cigarettes, but if vaping is undermining decades of hard-fought progress against the single largest preventable cause of death globally (responsible for ~30% of cancer deaths) by bringing in new smokers and reducing the urgency to quit among current smokers I can see how public health officials would be cautious about embracing it.
- crazygringo 8y agoI don't think anyone's ignoring evidence with vaping. Rather, vaping is (from what we know so far) legitimately a far, far healthier alternative to smoking cigarettes. The biggest health risk by far isn't the nicotine, it's the smoke, which vaping doesn't have. It's been framed as a public health question since the very beginning: do the population-wide large health benefits of smokers who can't quit then switching to vaping, outweigh the (as currently understood) much smaller potential health problems with vaping, but which may be taken up by many people who otherwise wouldn't smoke at all? It's a balance of harms. What I've heard about Juul addiction among college-age kids sounds a little scary. (But then in my generation it was scary binge drinking, and that's fallen significantly over the past 10 years.) But at the same time, I've seen friends finally be able to give up smoking for vaping, which can only be a good thing given what we know right now.
- tantalor 8y agoVaping causes nicotine addiction which has the secondary risk using of tobacco products later in life. In other words ecigs is a gateway to smoking. Youth Who Use Vaping Products Are More Likely to Smoke Cigarettes, Increase Use of Both Over Time https://www.rand.org/news/press/2018/10/02.html https://www.rand.org/news/press/2018/10/02.html
- zeta0134 8y agoSpecifically, vaping with nicotine causes the nicotine addiction. But there's a really awesome alternative: you can vape nicotine free. Any decent vape shop will let you pick out the strength that you like, and 0% is an option. One of my roommates did just that, because he liked the social benefits: getting to pretend he was a dragon, hanging out with his other friends during their smoke breaks, etc. Of course this doesn't solve any potential other problems with the practice (the popcorn lung scare from a while back comes to mind) but in theory, if you simply must smoke, it's possible to do so without any nicotine at all.
- treebeard901 8y agoThe real long term danger here might be to get an entire generation hooked on vaping as a safer alternative, then remove vape devices from the market. That's a whole lot of potential new customers (nicotine addicts) for traditional cigarette companies.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- exogeny 8y agoIn my opinion, way too many people bend over backwards to defend the rise of vaping through the lens of "better than cigarettes" equating to "healthy". My view - just like my view with marijuana - we need to do a better job of quantifying the negative impacts of addiction. It is fundamentally a bad thing for your body to be addicted to something, and we normalize that view by engaging in whataboutism; oh, it's just coffee, it's just sugar, it's better than cigarettes and on and on. There hasn't been enough research on it, it's certainly more opaque for consumers to really know where the ingredients are being sourced and how much nicotine they're actually receiving. These are all bad things, even if it's "better" than combustibles. That's of course in addition to the extreme shittiness of these companies blatantly advertising to kids, but that's another argument altogether.
- tekromancr 8y agoWhat blatant advertising to kids, tho? The only time I ever see vape ads, it's in store promos for Juul and the only copy is along the lines of "Satisfying alternative for adult smokers"
- qwerty456127 8y agoPeople should just learn these 2 simple facts and stop focusing on just one of the pair: 1. vaping is not healthy. 2. vaping is much healthier than smoking (as long as you use a liquid that doesn't contain nasty chemicals that cause popcorn lung syndrome, e.g. diacetyl). Whoever smokes and doesn't consider quitting as an option should try switching to vaping, whoever vapes should consider quitting as whoever smokes should, whoever doesn't smoke and doesn't vape should better avoid starting either.
- haxus_the_great 8y ago> use a liquid that doesn't contain nasty chemicals that cause popcorn lung syndrome, e.g. diacetyl The levels of diacetyl found in (certain) vape liquids are probably not a concern. Cigarette smoke contains much higher concentrations of diacetyl and popcorn lung doesn't appear to be endemic in smokers. Indeed most of the cases in medical literature seem to involve factory workers who were exposed to high amounts of diacetyl, plus a handful of people who consumed massive amounts of microwave popcorn. Are there any observed cases of popcorn lung in smokers?
- qwerty456127 8y agoInteresting. Thanks. Perhaps the idea of particular vaping liquids causing popcorn lung is a myth too. Here's an article I've found that includes some references to research: https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/vaping-causes-popcorn-lung/ https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/vaping-causes-popcorn-lung...
- epmaybe 8y agoI think we are going to have much better evidence on e-cigarettes, and by association, vaping, soon. NIH recently established and started producing a standardized nicotine and placebo e-cigarette for researchers to use. A big barrier to studying health effects was not being able to compare studies. https://www.drugabuse.gov/funding/supplemental-information-nida-e-cig https://www.drugabuse.gov/funding/supplemental-information-n...
- nazgulnarsil 8y agoReminder that mainstream media pieces and non profits against vaping are being funded by tobacco companies.
- matchagaucho 8y agoI vaped for 6+ months as a "nootropics" stimulant to augment caffeine intake. Could I code/work one more hour per day? Yes, usually. But the trade-offs were insomnia, irritability, and anxiety. It wasn't until I quit cold turkey that the effects of nicotine withdrawal really kicked in. I felt like crap for days. Sure, e-Cigarettes are a far better alternative than their counterpart. But the addictive quality, and recurring financial investment are very real.
- guilhas 8y agoAlso GMO, 5G, advert effects of vaccination, misprescribing and overprescribing of drugs, bad diets, lack of exercise... lets not ignore.