84 ms·
Hallelujah. It's not just enterprise apps, either. I've seen more than a few consumer app redesigns that just seemed to tack on the "clean", "minimalist", "whit
by hn_throwaway_99 8y ago
Hallelujah. It's not just enterprise apps, either. I've seen more than a few consumer app redesigns that just seemed to tack on the "clean", "minimalist", "whitespace" ethos, without really having a clue of an understanding of how users actually used the product.
I think this is a big factor in what killed slashdot. They did a big redesign years back that added a lot of whitespace but actually made it incredibly difficult to easily browse comment threads and see quality comments. Similarly, despite the old Reddit interface having a reputation as being "ugly", I hate the new interface and always browse on old.reddit.com, mainly because of the higher density of information that makes it easier for me to scan for posts I want to read.
- tenaciousDaniel 8y agoGod yes, the older reddit interface was so much better. I don't give a shit how pretty the UI is.
- duxup 8y agoI use ud.reddit.com Although anytime I mention this I fear they'll take it away...
- stronglikedan 8y agoJust out of curiosity, why "ud"? It seems like any two letter subdomain works in the same way.
- duxup 8y agoHonestly, I think that was just one I bookmarked at some point and there it is in my history ;)
- lessclue 8y agoIt's actually old.reddit.com but they probably have some sort of a wildcard rule.
- duxup 8y agoThanks!
- folkrav 8y agoThis is probably it : any two letter combination seems to work.
- godelski 8y agoTesting it out I found something interesting. You can put in subreddit.reddit.com and it redirects to reddit.com/r/subreddit. But any 2 char prefix works sends to old.reddit.com (a.reddit.com -> reddit.com/r/a) e.g. hackernews.reddit.com -> reddit.com/r/hackernews Why does this subreddit exist?
- thaumasiotes 8y ago> hackernews.reddit.com -> reddit.com/r/hackernews > Why does this subreddit exist? Considering the prevalence of the rebuke "HN is not reddit" on HN, probably for people who want to talk in a more reddit-like style.
- Nullabillity 8y agoIt was (originally) for localization: ja.reddit.com would (for example) give you a Japanese interface. Eventually they realized what a horrible idea l10n is for a community-oriented site, and dropped the translations, but kept the `lang` that it would apply attributes. Eventually subreddit moderators figured out that you could use this to provide multiple variants of the per-subreddit CSS, such as dark modes, custom filters, and other silliness[0]. [0]: For example, see /r/CrappyDesign with (https://old.reddit.com/r/CrappyDesign/ https://old.reddit.com/r/CrappyDesign/) and without (https://of.reddit.com/r/CrappyDesign https://of.reddit.com/r/CrappyDesign) Comic Sans.
- delecti 8y agoOther than "np", as in "np.reddit.com", which is used for "no-participation mode", I think the other two-letter sub-domains are used for language codes. I think at one point in reddit's history doing things like de.reddit.com could give a german site, and so on. I'm not sure what "ud" would refer to, but I assume it's similar.
- ehsankia 8y agoI have no idea what ud is, I use old.reddit.com
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- lelf 8y agoTry https://reddit.com/.compact https://reddit.com/.compact
- SlightRespect 8y agoCraigslist is _the_ case study on how an ugly UI can survive over a long timeline. There are many techies and UI designers that are just disgusted at the UI of craigslist. For some, aesthetic is more important than usability. Luckily, for most, it's not.
- tenaciousDaniel 8y agoYes exactly. CL is probably my favorite website on the internet, for the sheer reason that they have virtually not changed at all since they first launched over 10 years ago. It's fairly incredible. I can't think of another website that has done that.
- aidenn0 8y agohttp://rinkworks.com/ http://rinkworks.com/
- tenaciousDaniel 8y agoholy shit
- sevensor 8y agoThis still exists?! It's still being updated?!?! So much more content than when I last checked it, which would have been 2004 or so. My faith in the internet is restored.
- stingraycharles 8y agoCL is only ten years old? I always figured it was from the 90s — maybe a bias originating from the design.
- m741 8y agoIt's over 20 years old, it launched in 1996. Time flies.
- fiala__ 8y agoI tried the new interface, and even after a couple of minutes I still couldn't find where my saved posts were. Went straight back to `old.`
- thirdsun 8y agoThat’s the strange thing about reddit’s new design: It not only lacks functionality and performance, but also white space and clean aesthetics. It feels dated already.
- pantalaimon 8y agoThe thing is that the new interface can take seconds to load whereas the old one was instant. How is this an improvement?
- criddell 8y agoIt's better for them, not necessarily for you. Reddit wants lots of growth (they are taking new money now I think) and that means lots of new users that don't know the old UI. The new one is designed with those users in mind, not ones that know the site inside and out already.
- crowbahr 8y agoIt's sanding down a barrier to entry that was already fairly low, in my opinion. They haven't really made it much lower either. Integrating RES into the main site would've been most of what they needed to get going...
- criddell 8y agoThey aren't going to care about what anybody on HN has to say about it because we aren't the audience they are after. They need hundreds of millions of new users and those have to come from Facebook and probably on mobile.
- shakna 8y ago> and probably on mobile. The site isn't mobile-friendly though, is it? It's slow, bloated, and has repeated interstitials demanding you get their app if you deign to use mobile.
- pantalaimon 8y agoThere is an old mobile interface which is very quick and also easy to use. https://i.reddit.com/ https://i.reddit.com/
- 8y ago
- yoodenvranx 8y agoThe old mobile reddit site [0] is _amazing_! No whitespace, no padding! [0] The one which you can still reach by adding '.compact' to any reddit url
- thefifthsetpin 8y agoGiven how aggressively reddit push their terrible no good very bad interface, I figure there has to be some advantage to them to my using it? I don't know what that could be, maybe users struggling to use the new interface looks like engagement to ads?
- paulddraper 8y ago> so much better In particular, faster. I need to have a supercomputer to scroll past the first few pages.
- osrec 8y agoThe new UI isn't all that pretty either...
- renjimen 8y agoSpotify. These days it's so hard to organise or browse your own music collection.
- folkrav 8y agoI keep hearing this but I find Google Play Music to be way, way worse.
- dagoat 8y agoSo because Google Play Music is worse at X, that means Spotify's X can't be bad? Or are you saying the bar is: "as long as there's something worse"
- alehul 8y ago> So because Google Play Music is worse at X, that means Spotify's X can't be bad? It could be that, in most cases, we only think of the options as ones that we've been introduced to. We're way too busy with daily life to really think in-depth about everything in hypothetical possibilities, such as "here's a way in which a music app that doesn't exist could do it better." Instead, (unless we're very passionate about music), we tend to only think about the options that have been presented to us.
- folkrav 8y agoYou're extrapolating here. Maybe I was not clear enough. I've never found Spotify's interface to be that bad, but have the same sentiment you hold for Spotify towards Google Play Music.
- mo1ok 8y agoOh man, glad I'm not the only one I noticed this. It used to take ~2 seconds to find my favorite playlist and play it. Now it takes upwards of 10-20 seconds. On the dedicated "select a playlist" page with the squares, it even freaking re-organizes the squares every time you view it! Imagine if your desktop icons re-organized themselves in some arbitrary way every time you needed to open a program, and you get the utter destruction of muscle memory that can make up for the gaps in efficient design.
- sodosopa 8y agoAlso another great example about why user and accessibility testing are very very important. It was downright ignored and when pressed the Admins admitted it. Leave your beliefs at the door and fucking watch how the user interacts with your site, then ask them why they make those choices. Buy them a beer or whatever gets them to talk.
- Mindwipe 8y agoAlso worth noting - consumer app or website designs that cram negative space everywhere are almost always slow as shit to use compared to their older "ugly" replacements. The way new Reddit renders content is an excellent case in point. An older example is the Guardian website - it's design about four or five years ago was despised by users (which was ignored) because it was slow and made using the site slower.
- c3534l 8y agoReddit also fails to load aporoximately 20% of the time, too. I figured it was growing pains, but they've not changed a thing. They designed it, they're done, and they're really not interested in what the users think.
- Shivetya 8y agoI have seen it in ill fated attempts to replace POS systems that were old green screen types to warehousing stocking tools using the same all with new pretty GUI or web page interfaces. Looking slick is great if customer facing but down in the trenches its all about familiarity, speed, and stability.
- anitil 8y agoOne pet peeve of mine is that these old systems are often trivially navigable with a (often custom) keyboard, then replaced with something that needs a mouse. So 'tap, tap, tap, tap, enter' becomes 'tap, <locate mouse> click, tap, tap <locate mouse>, click'.
- choward 8y agoThe new Reddit interface wasn't designed for users. It was designed for the customers (advertisers).
- Reelin 8y agoI think old Reddit, HN, and Craigslist are good examples of what I've seen referred to as Brutalist Web Design (https://brutalist-web.design/ https://brutalist-web.design/).
- ioddly 8y ago> I hate the new interface and always browse on old.reddit.com, mainly because of the higher density of information that makes it easier for me to scan for posts I want to read. I'm actually trying to "redesign" an app (I put design in quotes because I'm a dev and just trying to make a personal project look nice) and one of the struggles I have had is that high information density can look crappy at first but once you get used to it, is a better experience. So much nicer to have everything you care about in a single screen.
- Moru 8y agoMake an optional pro interface so noobs get lured in for the prettyness and when they know what they are doing, can swith?
- rangibaby 8y ago> high information density can look crappy at first but once you get used to it, is a better experience. TL;DR Your app should have the information density that it needs to be: 1. Useful and 2. Help the user avoid operating the app in a way that they don't intend to or is dangerous Looking fancy is a secondary concern to good function. Typography has an important function because it is how you convey information to your user. Poorly laid out or written text can cause your user to get tired or use your app wrong. Of course, making a useful interface is a difficult and long job. It is also thankless work, because if you do a good job your users will use your app without even noticing how well designed it is (good design is invisible!). It's much easier to slap a pretty facade on your poorly designed app and call it done. People will be impressed by it, but struggle to use it. I would recommend finding physical copies of Josef Mueller Brockmann's books, especially "Grid Systems in Graphic Design" and "The Graphic Artist and His Design Problems". They are both old (pre-DTP) but have great basic advice about how to design pages.
- lvs 8y agoObligatory anger for the Gmail and Calendar minimalist redesigns. This is not minimalism really. It's whitespace maximalism.
- clanrebornsx 8y agoI can argue more apps killed by grumpy unmotivated developers than whitespace leaving designers.
- nprateem 8y ago> I think this is a big factor in what killed slashdot For me it was the pedantic, toxic community. HN is a breath of fresh air by comparison.
- turok 8y agoI use "old.reddit.com" exclusively too, information density is king. Material design and minimalism probably have a lot of strong theory behind them, but the cargo culting around them often leads to worse UX. I think a lot of companies reach the "dedicated UX team/person" stage before the "careful A B testing of user flow" stage.