5 ms·
Economically speaking, aren’t open offices a necessity for a startup in Silicon Valley? I can’t fathom the rent for an office with personal offices for each emp
by Apocryphon 8y ago
Economically speaking, aren’t open offices a necessity for a startup in Silicon Valley? I can’t fathom the rent for an office with personal offices for each employee.
The solution that should make everyone happy, of course, is to just make everything remote.
- Someone1234 8y agoIf that was legitimately a concern then why not just have everyone telecommute? Then you get an office for every employee and $0 in rent.
- Apocryphon 8y agoThat's... exactly what I was suggesting.
- Gibbon1 8y agoLast time I dealt with this, 20 years ago. The cost of an office for a tech worker appeared to be basically nil. Less than 5% of wages, benefits, insurance. Place I'm in is a 1500sqft warren. Costs $300/month per tech monkey. Gonna pay $12000/mo for a code monkey? Costs $300-500/mo for him to have an office? The extravagance! I'm back to an old observation by Scott Adams; Ask yourself why the secretaries chair doesn't have armrests. Cost isn't an issue, the price difference is $50. This is all about status and class not money.
- sevensor 8y agoSomeone should start a business renting shoulder-high partitions that you put between desks.
- dmitriid 8y agoHow would they help? I've been at companies whose answer to complaints about open space was exactly this: shoulder high partitions. Yay, the cubicles are back.
- Aeolun 8y agoThey’re still preferable to full openness.
- quantumhobbit 8y agoWe used to macgyver particians out of white boards and project posters.
- gowld 8y agoSmall team rooms for up to 8 people who work on the same project -- promotes collaboration, no pointless distractions, and cost-effective real estate. Add a library room for people who want complete silence, and enough conference rooms for meetings that don't fit in the team room for whatever reason.
- virgilp 8y agoThis is an amazingly effective setup; I've worked at a company that has this by accident, and nothing compared to it in terms of productivity
- xiphias2 8y agoAlso so much fun. Sometimes working alone is more productive than working in a team of 5 (8 is too much for me), but having 5 people in a room is the best way to learn from others and build something together while not slowing others down too much.
- RHSeeger 8y agoI would never leave the library room, except for meetings. I can't work when people are talking around me. Edit: What is it about this statement that earned it a downvote?
- matwood 8y agoNot trying to be snarky, but you can't or you won't? At some point do you wonder if it's a problem you should look at addressing? I'm all about optimizing the work environment, but saying you can't work with talking around you comes across as entitled.
- RHSeeger 8y agoIt's not entitled, I just have serious issues focusing when there's other noise around me. I also have trouble hearing when there's background noise (I can't understand what's being said on the tv when the dishwasher is running in the next room, but I can understand it fine without the background noise; same volume).
- manigandham 8y agoNot really, most office space is constantly renovated and reused as companies cycle and grow. Cubicles and rooms are easy to build once and amortize, and they can be very lightweight these days. Construction doesn't have to be heavy permanent walls either and many places have fully configurable wall construction that is more than good enough to offer privacy and sound insulation.
- Apocryphon 8y agoHow big would these rooms be? Because while I don't agree with the cold accounting calculations that lead to startup mgmt. preferring open office plans, I understand that it truly maximizes empty space. To guarantee an office for each employee- I'm not sure how it can be sustainable unless you're working in an office park with enough cheap space.
- manigandham 8y agoDoesn't need to be 1 per individual, can group together small groups. Most "open plans" tend to waste lots of space on excessively wide desks, meeting areas, decorations, etc.
- Johnny555 8y agoIt's not so much the cost of construction as the cost of real estate -- it's hard to build an office as small as single desks or (yuck) bench-style side by side seating. Offices have tighter constraints on egress/ingress than rows of desks so you can't use space as efficiently. Plus, offices/cubes are not flexible at all -- when you start to outgrow your building full of offices (or even cubes), you can't easily squeeze desks together to make room while you seek additional space. We have some small "phone rooms" that are about as small as you can build an office, and they are super cramped and uncomfortable, I wouldn't want to spend a full work-day in one.
- manigandham 8y agoIt doesn't have to be an office per person. Small groups up to 8 people can work well and very doable without a big loss in usable square feet. I suspect most companies that absolutely need every inch of continuous desk space have bigger problems. Organic growth isn't difficult to manage, it's the crazy VC fueled hiring sprees that create real estate issues.
- PhasmaFelis 8y agoAdding cubicle walls to a row of desks barely increases the footprint. And I'd rather have cubicles than open-plan. Give me at least a smidgen of privacy.
- james_s_tayler 8y ago> The solution that should make everyone happy, of course, is to just make everything remote. Except there exist a set of people who enjoy the camaraderie of talking shit with their colleagues in the office while they go about their worker bee lives. You will inevitably make those people unhappy with that move and then they will come here on HN and categorically declare how terrible working remote is (for them, but they will omit that detail).
- matwood 8y ago> Except there exist a set of people who enjoy the camaraderie of talking shit with their colleagues in the office while they go about their worker bee lives. We are working through this right now. Our current office lease is up and the new space is not done yet. We let people also be fully remote, so we decided to go fully remote until the other space is completed. Quite a few people are very unhappy about even this short couple months of being forced remote.
- ghaff 8y agoI'm pretty much fully remote these days. But looking back to the long-term job in the computer industry I first had after school, I would not have liked or probably particularly flourished in being stuck in my apartment all day. (To be sure, I'd probably have moved into the city and found different patterns but it's still a bit hard for me to imagine.) I'd also note that I've known lots of people who basically had jobs that didn't require a lot of in-person interactions but still preferred to come into the office. Of course, that can be largely solved by paying for rental office space for them.
- cma 8y ago>The solution that should make everyone happy, of course, is to just make everything remote. http://conferencecall.biz/ http://conferencecall.biz/