9 ms·
2 things about Reddit's "use our app instead!" buttons: 1. They cycle through a couple of different messages, and the buttons get switched around 2. The wordi
by GordonS 8y ago
2 things about Reddit's "use our app instead!" buttons:
1. They cycle through a couple of different messages, and the buttons get switched around
2. The wording is such that you read it twice and still aren't sure which button will just take you to the damn website
I don't mind them promoting their app, but these dark patterns truely rile me
- eeeeeeeeeeeee 8y agoI've noticed this as well. Really annoying. Or any website that immediately pops up a "sign up for our email list!" and blocks you from seeing the content. Isn't there a ton of data that most people don't even use many apps anymore? Or they install them once and then uninstall them or ignore them? I hope we can move towards a web that stays in the web browser. Apps are becoming really annoying, especially for interactions you only have intermittently (I'm not a daily reddit user, but I go there every now and then, or it pops up on search).
- dsfyu404ed 8y ago>Isn't there a ton of data that most people don't even use many apps anymore? Or they install them once and then uninstall them or ignore them? That doesn't mean the app can't exfiltrate data (presumably data useful to advertisers) in the background.
- ethbro 8y agoThe browser is a client that works for the user (well, Google, Apple, and Microsoft muddy the waters). The mobile app is a program that works for the developer. The end result of browsers becoming more adtech-hostile and user-friendly is that more companies turn to mobile apps.
- eeeeeeeeeeeee 8y agoI can understand a developer/company wanting to do the app route to regain control (and not having to deal with the annoying inconsistencies/hacks in different browsers/versions), but is ad / tracker blocking really the major driver of going the app route?
- craftinator 8y agoYes. If data can be captured to apply targeted ads, each ad can be worth 2-5x as much to the company. Browser compatibility issues occur sometimes, but mobile device compatibility are always an issue for my apps. It's actually more work keeping an app working smoothly than a website, and the cost must be offset by the ad revenues
- ethbro 8y agoI'd say the worry is not just ad / tracker blocking, but loss of control. Apple decides to start notifying on cookies or make fingerprinting harder? Poof. There goes a chunk of your ad value per user. And who knows what any given browser vendor will do tomorrow? Some would say "So it's like the 90s, where everyone was continually adapting as web specs were negotiated." The difference is that now there are billion+ dollar businesses directly tied to that ad revenue.
- ndnxhs 8y agoYes, Firefox has been consistently blocking nasty advertiser tricks each release and it supports ad blockers on mobile. The latest Firefox release has a built in list of tracker domains to block and next release blocks auto playing video.
- rjf72 8y agoBrave is also making major progress here. It natively includes anti-fingerprinting, ad blocking, tracker blocking, HTTPS everywhere, and one-click in-session TOR windows on demand (similar to how incognito windows work for other browsers). It's also blazing fast. From a user perspective, now is probably the best time ever to be using the web.
- rjf72 8y agoYou can see indirect evidence for this by looking at the exponential rise in ad-blocker-blocking efforts from a wide array of sites. 'Hi, we see you're using an ad blocker. Please turn it off.' That literally did not exist several years ago, even though ad blocking has been around for decades. Companies in recent years are getting aggressively desperate as the web becomes increasingly user friendly. At the same time, mobile is still dominated by an OS developed by the the world's largest ad delivery corporation - and it behaves accordingly.
- gowld 8y agoI thought modern OSes now pop up notification icons when this happens, so you can detect and punish apps that do that. Doesn't stop them from getting a snapshot of your system on first run, though.
- rhinoceraptor 8y agoI do mind them promoting their app, it’s a horrible app and they’ve continually ruined their website. The only way I can stand to use reddit anymore is through Narwhal, at least until they kill their 3rd party apps API.
- IggleSniggle 8y agoIt’s funny, the web app used to be really good. Much better than the native app. Since then they have been making the web app increasingly worse over time, actively degrading its functionality and pleasantness to use.
- rjbwork 8y agoYou can just permanently set your account to use the old layout/view. I've noticed little to no changes other than user profiles, which are the "old new" ones. On my phone I use reddit is fun. I have no issues at all with reddit atm in terms of them fucking with my experience.
- lostlogin 8y agoI agree, but it’s jarring going between devices (phone, iPad and computer) and the multiple interfaces. Then the repeated niggling to use the app. If I haven’t after several years, the chances are I don’t want to.
- rjbwork 8y agoI am never nagged. I use RES on desktop to modify a few things, among others a dark theme. I use the RIF dark theme. Works pretty similarly.
- TylerE 8y ago"permenantly", except for the bug where about 1 pageview in 10 it still redirects you to new reddit. I think it's something related to improperly configured (server-side) caching or something.
- mort96 8y agoTheir mobile website has also started literally animating the "get the app" button; every minute or so, the button pulses for a bit in a deliberate (and in my case, consistently successful) attempt to make your attention move to the button they want you to click instead of the content you want to read. The reddit community is great, but the company seems to not care about their users at all.
- gowld 8y agoReddit has been on a downward spiral for N years (depending on your perspective), yet the data is near-completely crawlable, and no user-friendly sustainable alternative has appeared. Why? The closest is lobste.rs, which is better in some ways and worse in others, and a few (names I forgot) were good but died from lack of content / user interest.
- saagarjha 8y agoReddit has been slowly ruining their API for the last couple of years.
- baroffoos 8y agoI started working on a read only script to grab stuff from reddit years ago and then they changed it so you need to go through the whole register for an api key even for read only requests which didn't work for me because I wanted users to download and run the script themselves
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoIt would be interesting to know how much more a user is worth to them when they install the app; it must be quite significant.
- TH3R3LL1K 8y agoIm wondering if they are able to get more information on user when they use reddit on the app then on the browser
- lftl 8y agoI'm really amazed they still let the old mobile interface work for the most part. Just add ".compact" to any URL and browse almost annoyance free (newer features like video don't work, but that's not too surprising).
- rwc 8y agoI've been switching the "www" in "www.reddit.com" to "old" with good results.
- idointernet 8y agogood call!
- gowld 8y agoFor the lazy, there are browser extensions that do this for you, or you can write a simple user-script in your user-script engine of choice (Greasemonkey, Tampermonkey, etc)
- ken 8y agoIt's the 21st century Clippy. "You look like you're trying to do X. Here, let me help you do Y instead."
- ethbro 8y agoI'll take issue with that. For all Clippy's interpretation problems (way ahead of their time), it was still trying to facilitate actions that were useful to you (not Microsoft). Dark patterns are defined by trying to willfully get you to do something that's counter to your own intent.
- ken 8y agoWhat's the difference, if the result is the same? Do you not think that the employees who write big "use the app!" banners believe they're doing what's best for the user? As for Clippy, it's not hard to design a straightforward auto-correction feature, which detects what you typed and suggests a useful addition or replacement. Google, Apple, etc., all have their own designs that work perfectly well. I have trouble seeing an animated 3D cartoon as anything other than "trying to willfully get me to do something counter to my own intent". That's a classic way to manipulate people.
- hopler 8y agoYou are ignoring the general population's and the industry's attitude toward computing metaphors and cartoons in the 1990s. What do you imagine is the exploitative profit motive of Clippy? Microsoft fido get more revenue when you formatted your document as a resume or whatever.
- WalterSear 8y ago"Here, help us pay our bills instead."
- zerocrates 8y agoWhen combined with an AMP result page you might get when coming from Google, it's sometimes just impossible to view the actual content of a post without getting kicked to the app, or out to another browsing context... Reddit on mobile is a purpose-built nightmare.
- vanadium 8y agoGoogle was also supposed to start penalizing sites that used their AMP pages as interstitials, but...I'm not sure whatever became of that.
- StringyBob 8y agoIt’s actually working well to curb my reddit addiction by making it harder to idly browse on the phone.
- jotm 8y agoNow all they need to do is remove the old design and I might be able to quit for good.
- tosser0001 8y agoI find it ironic that their tagline is "The front page of the internet" but they push you to use a proprietary app.
- nolok 8y agoFor the record, that tag line was an idea from their users, and chosen hey their users (through upvotes, of course). It wasn't how reddit the company sees itself, it was how its users saw it. I still remember the thread where it happened years ago.
- rpeden 8y agoFor now, https://i.reddit.com https://i.reddit.com seems not to have any of the dark patterns.
- socratesque 8y agoA good rule of thumb in these situations is to go for the hard-to-see button.