11 ms·
This is why I try to avoid insurance policies wherever possible. It’s still hard to argue with people questioning why I don’t buy insurance for my $25k or so o
by Scoundreller 8y ago
This is why I try to avoid insurance policies wherever possible.
It’s still hard to argue with people questioning why I don’t buy insurance for my $25k or so of household contents in a relatively secure building.
I don’t care how cheap the policy is, I’m assuming they’re charging more than they payout on average, and I lock my doors consistently.
- sesutton 8y ago>I don’t care how cheap the policy is, I’m assuming they’re charging more than they payout on average. How would an insurance company stay in business if it were any other way?
- maxerickson 8y agoThey make money investing the float (the money they have received but not yet paid out).
- seanlinehan 8y agoInsurance companies make money by investing the premiums. It's possible for an insurance company to make a profit from investment even if they had unprofitable underwriting. From Warren Buffet: > Insurers receive premiums upfront and pay claims later. ... This collect-now, pay-later model leaves us holding large sums -- money we call "float" -- that will eventually go to others. Meanwhile, we get to invest this float for Berkshire's benefit. ... > If premiums exceed the total of expenses and eventual losses, we register an underwriting profit that adds to the investment income produced from the float. This combination allows us to enjoy the use of free money -- and, better yet, get paid for holding it. Alas, the hope of this happy result attracts intense competition, so vigorous in most years as to cause the P/C industry as a whole to operate at a significant underwriting loss. This loss, in effect, is what the industry pays to hold its float. Usually this cost is fairly low, but in some catastrophe-ridden years the cost from underwriting losses more than eats up the income derived from use of float. ...
- lotsofpulp 8y agoThat’s just saying the nominal premiums are less than what they pay out, but the real value of premiums including expected return on investment is more than the losses paid out (obviously since the insurance company is in business). This real value is available to everyone since nowadays everyone can invest like the insurance companies with index funds, so comparing the real value of the premiums paid by the policyholder when the insurance company has to pay out is an accurate comparison.
- maxerickson 8y agoThat's a fine point, but the question was probably asked in the context of the nominal values.
- lotsofpulp 8y agoIt doesn’t seem useful to me to talk about nominal values when discussing value of money over long periods of time. The original comment was that insurance charges more than they payout, which was disputed saying they make up for it in investment earnings. What I’m saying is that since the same investment earnings are available to the premium payer, it is true that the insurance company charges more than they pay out, hence the original poster is right in avoiding insurance whenever they can (i.e. they can afford to pay for a loss they might have been planning on purchasing insurance for). All they need to do is invest it in one of the many nearly free index funds, and they’re in the same boat as the insurance company, but without having to pay for the salaries of the insurance company’s employees.
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoThere's also a huge reinsurance market that insurers use to mitigate local risk, and arbitrage. It's how they can survive during the exceptional cases like a major flood where everyone is claiming.
- Waterluvian 8y agoI don't understand this for dental insurance in Canada. The premium I paid while a student was a fraction of a single visit. I visited twice a year and had additional work done some years.
- brewdad 8y agoMy best guess would be that it's cheaper to pay extra towards your routine appointments and catch problems early versus waiting until you need major work done down the road due to neglecting your dental health.
- Scoundreller 8y agoBut this is student coverage: the expensive problems tend to: 1) come along later 2) not be wel reimbursed (eg: 60%), so if it can wait, many will until they have employment and better coverage.
- wjnc 8y agoFrom an economic theory perspective if you have diminishing utility, pooling risks makes sense even if there are some profits for the insurer, since you have more certainty about the possible outcomes. With graphs [1] If the loss you are insuring is large enough, the acceptable profit is quite large for it still to be a worthwhile investment. [1] http://www.economicsdiscussion.net/articles/risk-aversion-and-insurance-explained-with-diagram/1419 http://www.economicsdiscussion.net/articles/risk-aversion-an...
- Broken_Hippo 8y agoBecause fire isn't going to affect you, obviously. The "security" of your house is only part of what folks buy such insurance for. Only the privileged can do such things and get away with it. You'd have to have enough money to have a nest egg large enough to replace the stuff you need and care about, money to replace documents and ID, money for a hotel and travel, and money leftover so that a second even in a short timeframe does not leave you horribly off. Poor people go without insurance all the time, but that is more the lack of ability to pay the premiums. And of course they are charging more than they are paying out - much like a retailer charges more for a product than it cost them to make. There are exceptions in both cases: A car accident can mean someone gets more benefits than they pay in and retailers take losses on some things - but it isn't the norm. The entire point, however, is that the risk is spread out so that most folks aren't hit with a life-destroying event when bad things happen. That's the real service you are paying a bit extra for. I find it weird that you'd judge teh company on making money. You can judge by how well they pay out claims - how much time it takes, what percentage they pay, and so on. Or how much money they make in total - and this should probably be something over a few years to balance out natural disasters.
- janekm 8y agoThat nest egg is much better insurance overall though, as it protects in many more scenarios... job loss, bad boss, loss of residence rights... The basic rule of insurance is "never insure that which you would be able to pay out yourself". There may be a few exceptions where you know that the risk/premium ratio is in your favour... I twice got my banks purchase protection "insurance" to replace bikes that a bike insurance wouldn't have even insured in that city. And that was with a free bank account.
- Nursie 8y ago> "never insure that which you would be able to pay out yourself". This is silly as a rule, IMHO. I could pay out for all new stuff if there was a fire, but it's a damn site cheaper to pay a few hundred a year for insurance. The point of insurance isn't that they pay out an individual less than they take in, but the group in aggregate.
- nightcracker 8y agoYou are an individual. You are not an average. The average is entirely irrelevant for you. The calculation you need to make is "how is MY life effected by this decision". If you choose to pay the small insurance amount you probably won't even miss the money in your day to day life. But when that unexpected event happens, one version of you can come back strong while the sucker can console himself with the thought that the average human is at least being happy.
- tspiteri 8y agoWith insurance, the expected worth for you has to be negative, otherwise how would insurance companies even survive? The value of insurance is not reducing the average loss, but reducing the risk. For example you lose $10 at a probability of 100% instead of $1000 at a probability of 0.5% (that is losing $5 on average). If you look at the probability distribution of your losses, you are not moving it to the left (lower average), you're just making the distribution narrower, that is you reduce the chance that you lose large amounts. In summary, if losing $25k is no big deal to you, you can on average save money by not buying insurance. If losing $25k is life changing, you should pay some money to reduce the risk.
- Retric 8y agoInsurance also has quite a bit more weight to toss around than you do. So, you’re comparing cost to them vs cost to you which can be very different numbers. Health insurance negotiators for example often save you more money than their profit margins. It’s dead weight to society but personally it’s a net gain.
- uasm 8y ago> "If losing $25k is life changing, you should pay some money to reduce the risk." What about the risk of your insurance company going bankrupt? Or the risk of your insurance company fighting tooth and nail to avoid paying you?
- tspiteri 8y agoI said reduce the risk, not eliminate it; or make the probability distribution narrower, not collapse it to one value.
- tzs 8y ago> What about the risk of your insurance company going bankrupt? For most insurance ordinary people would have, except possibly life insurance [1], coverage comes into effect fairly soon after you pay your premium. If your current insurance company is showing any signs of insolvency, you should be able to switch to someone else and get covered. If there were no warning signs that your insurance company is in trouble and they unexpectedly go bankrupt, but at a time when you don't need to make a claim, you can quickly switch to someone else. If they go bankrupt and you are making a claim, it should be covered by your state's guarantee fund. Insurance is a regulated industry, regulated by the states. Part of that regulation includes the state establishing a fund paid for by the insurance companies that is essentially insurance that the insurance companies can pay claims. If you pick a large, diverse insurance company, probably the only real risk that they might unexpectedly go bankrupt at a time when you need to make a claim, and the state guarantee fund might not be able to cover it, would be during some major widespread disaster that causes severe damage over a wide area. You might be screwed then, although there will probably be some kind of Federal disaster recovery aid available then. [1] I have never looked into details of life insurance so am not sure how that works.
- adetrest 8y agoI... Don't get this mentality. Yes replacing 25k worth of contents isn't that big a deal (although it would suck), but in a fire there are other costs that dwarf your contents. Think about how much your building/unit is worth. If the fire started in your place, you could be responsible for all these damages (and especially your neighbour's). Can you afford to repay a whole new building for you and your neighbours + their contents? How about living out of a hotel for a few months while the place is being repaired (which repairs you'll have to cover too) and potentially paying your neighbours' bills for that as well? How does that compare to a 1000$ deductible and a 300$/year premium? To me it's a no brainer. If you really want a low premium, get a 2 or 5k deductible, 5k contents, and shop around. You'll also get added protection like third party liability which is usually minimum 1 million $ and covers any damage you'd do to other's property. Of course no-one wakes up thinking they'll set their house on fire or flood the unit under them. And yet that happens every day. I don't know anyone who didn't have insurance and who got struck by a fire/flood/other damages say that they regret nothing and wouldn't buy insurance if they could go back in time.
- adetrest 8y agoNot even mentioning the ridiculous costs (especially in the US) that come into play should the fire that started in your unit injure or kill anyone.
- celticninja 8y agoMy buildings and contents insurance cost me about $280 a year, I happily pay that for the peace of mind of being covered if shit happens.
- code_duck 8y agoIt’s great, if the insurance company actually pays when your circumstances merit compensation.
- mcguire 8y agoInsurance companies, to my knowledge, almost always pay out for "normal" claims on standard policies, with some reasonable exceptions. That's why when they don't, it's news. You may not get all that you think you deserve, or you may get more (after the 2011 tornadoes, our insurance paid for a new roof, although only about a third was damaged by the falling tree).
- ikeboy 8y agoHaving got paid about 100k recently on a business insurance policy that cost under $250/month, I don't share your sentiment. Besides, even if insurance is negative expected dollars, it's positive EV given loss aversion in most cases.
- code_duck 8y ago“Charging more than they pay out on average”... Perhaps they make a profit, but the point of insurance is that some people, on exception, receive more than they pay in.
- robocat 8y agoFor extra health insurance (beyond the "socialist" baseline) about 15% of New Zealanders use a private not-for-profit organisation that began in 1961 called Southern Cross Medical Care Society. https://www.southerncross.co.nz/Group/About-us https://www.southerncross.co.nz/Group/About-us Health care is a special case where you usually "win" if you always paid premiums but never have to make a claim (because claims often can't repay bad health). And if you are a socialist, you can be happy because your premiums go to the health losers (had to make claims but their life might be shorter or shitier).
- conanbatt 8y ago> I don’t care how cheap the policy is, I’m assuming they’re charging more than they payout on average, and I lock my doors consistently. Thats not the correct "math". The value insurance provides is that the cost of the risk is higher than the cost of the premium. The whole point of insurance is how much are you willing to pay to avoid catastrophic scenarios.
- jopsen 8y agoThe reason I have renters insurance in Denmark is that it also covers liability, if I damage someones property.. even on a bike or something. (If I recall correctly, I had liability coverage through renters insurance in the US, when I lived there) Cover liability in case you run someone over on a bike and they are severely disabled.
- jancsika 8y ago> This is why I try to avoid insurance policies wherever possible. You read a story about about a special case for a policy four orders of magnitude larger than your own common case. The results of your cost/benefit analysis are that you should generally avoid insurance policies. I hate to defend the insurance industry, but it sounds to me like you're exactly the type of person who needs to have insurance.
- daveFNbuck 8y agoYou're taking a very uncharitable reading of that comment. This is clearly not describing a change they made in response to this particular article.
- gesman 8y agoMulti billion insurance Co is not going to argue with you on $25k petty theft. Junior clerk is going to check paperwork and process your claim. $100M claim is a different story.
- jon-wood 8y agoI feel like you’ve fundamentally misunderstood how insurance works here. Yes, on average, across the entire risk pool, claims paid out average below premiums paid in. As an individual though you only really need to make one non-tribal claim on a home insurance policy to end up making a profit on the deal. The pathological example is a fire gutting your entire home, destroying everything - in that case you’re going to see $25k paid out to you, on average in the UK home insurance costs about £130, which would be about $170. You’d have to pay into that policy for almost 150 years to end up making a loss on that deal. Even a fairly minor issue like a burglary requiring the replacement of $5,000 worth of possessions you only end up making a profit by self insuring after 30 years. The other misunderstanding you seem to have is a pretty common one: “I lock my doors consistently”. Burglary is the thing insurers pay out least frequently on. Everyone locks their door and takes basic precautions to avoid it, even if someone does break in you’re not going to lose much in most cases. The big risks are fire, which is infrequent, but expensive, and flood. Flood is much more frequent than most people realise, and can easily result in paying out hundreds of thousands of dollars to replace contents, rip out all your floor boards and replace them, redecorate the house, and if you’re in an upper level flat potentially to do the same for everyone below you. Flooding is what keeps insurance pricers awake at night, wondering if they’ve accidentally under priced an unknown flood plain.
- robocat 8y ago"an unknown flood plain" In Australia there was an exception in the "flood" policy (required for a mortgage I think) for rising river levels. The exception used a very unfamiliar word (that I can't remember at the moment!)
- smsm42 8y ago> I’m assuming they’re charging more than they payout on average You are approaching this wrong. Yet, they charge more than they pay out, on average. But they charge everybody, and they pay out only to small percentage of people. The point of insurance is not making profit for you, it's to cap your losses to predictable small upfront payment, instead of large ruinous random loss at random moment in the future. Yes, if you can easily afford the loss of everything in your household, then insurance makes no sense for you. But if losing significant part of it could be ruinous, by paying a small sum upfront you avoid the possibility of being ruined. The thing you are buying is limiting of the losses.
- brewdad 8y agoEven if losing everything you own wouldn't be financially ruinous, there is still value in limiting losses.
- AJ007 8y agoI know little about insurance from a professional context, but as an investor what I know is often insurance companies do not earn more than they pay out from premiums, they earn it from the float. This can persist for very long periods of time. The entire “cyber” insurance thing has seemed extremely questionable to me. Technology is changing too fast and software propagates far to quickly to meaningfully quantify risk based on anything which has happened in the past.
- vagab0nd 8y agoIt's basic risk v reward. When you buy insurance you always lose on average. But the point is when you "win", you "win big". Meaning when something bad happens, it doesn't wipe you out.
- Spooky23 8y agoIt’s an argument that doesn’t make any sense, I’d imagine having it gets tiring. My in-laws just went through an event like this. A sewer backed up and basically destroyed about 60% of everything they owned — everything from HVAC to clothes to kitchen. It’s not a hazard that is likely to happen at that scale, but for the ridiculously cheap cost of that insurance it’s certainly something worth careful consideration. Getting a boiler replaced on an emergency basis in January is an expensive proposition. Low probability, high impact risks are the best risks to insure. Home/renter insurance isn’t a scam.
- matwood 8y agoIt's hard to argue, because your argument does not make any sense. For ~$200/year you can offload the non-zero risk of a $25k loss onto someone else. IMO, that's a great deal.
- closeparen 8y agoYou don’t live an aggregate of many lives, you live one. Insurance is the way you keep your individual outcome close to the population average.
- ThrustVectoring 8y agoThe fundamental product that insurance offers is moving resources from scenarios where you have more than enough to ones where you don't. It's an amazing trade from a maximin perspective. Going purely on EV will convince you to do things that are like picking up nickles in front of a steamroller.