9 ms·
This dark pattern seems to be spreading. Amazon recently pushed out an update to their (beta last I knew) web app that allows you to use their smile.amazon.com
by jerf 8y ago
This dark pattern seems to be spreading. Amazon recently pushed out an update to their (beta last I knew) web app that allows you to use their smile.amazon.com charity donation through the app. But in order to turn that on, you have to turn on all the notifications the app has, including their rather constant pushes of "deals I may be interested in". They're holding you hostage to their notifications because "it's for charity!"
Not that this is news, but clearly Silicon Valley has no intention of retraining itself in any manner. Every wheedling trick in the book will be used to track you, up to and including holding arbitrary charities emotionally hostage.
- mancerayder 8y agoI think the ad-tech industry has tapped into what can only be called -- and no offense to anyone here -- "virtue signalling." There's no doubt studies done on this, hence the new "controversial" sort of nature of some of the advertising. Who knew that Gillette and Nike were so interested in social issues, and not a bottom line PNL result. In the same way, perhaps, Amazon marketing teams found some research to suggest that same "heart-string tugging" mechanism can be combined as a "sweetener" to get you to do things you otherwise wouldn't do -- like subscribe to "buy this too" notifications.
- aljones 8y agoIt is not a very conspicuous signal. I don't know which one of my friends use Amazon Smile. I don't think the dark pattern would work well if Amazon Smile was only social signalling. Seems to me it relies much more upon the fact that actual money is given to charities. Pretty gross of Amazon to add unrelated self serving conditions to such giving.
- ErikVandeWater 8y agoI think the question is whether we would prefer Amazon Smile to exist as it is or not exist at all. Even if there is a forced advertising aspect, it makes the world better.
- jstarfish 8y agoThat line of thinking is what let Jimmy Savile run amok for decades.
- clairity 8y agowhat you’re pointing out is corporate social responsibility (CSR), which emerged decades ago. it’s an extension of branding, which advertising, among other marketing tools, supports. virtue signalling is on the consumer side, where consumption of the brand has the (positive) side effect of showing how with it and magnanimous you are. in any case, i also don’t see how it applies here (as sibling commenter points out).
- mancerayder 8y agoInteresting, it's always good to know what the technical lingo is in these things, it helps us understand how the marketing minds think.
- clairity 8y agoyes, it's interesting. the prius is a prime example of virtue signalling used in marketing classes: honda was puzzled at why its civic hybrid wasn't selling while the prius sold like hotcakes, until it realized that the prius, with it's unique body styling, signalled virtuous environmentalism, while the civic hybrid, with it's standard civic styling, had no (additional) virtue signal.
- mehrdadn 8y agoI hear it's (also?) called 'woke' capitalism.
- mulmen 8y agoHuh? Are you talking about adding a shortcut to smile.amazon.com to your homepage or do you mean the actual native app? I can add a shortcut (on iOS) to smile.amazon.com but I don’t see why that would ever send me a notification. The native iOS shopping app has no option I can find to default or even select smile. Am I missing something? Also what does Amazon have to do with SV?
- jerf 8y agoIt's the native app, albeit in beta, so you may not have it yet. You can turn on smile functionality in the app, but you must turn on all notifications. "Also what does Amazon have to do with SV?" Amazon is part of metaphorical Silicon Valley. So's Microsoft, for instance. Metaphorical Silicon Valley is too large to fit in literal Silicon Valley.
- mulmen 8y agoIs IBM included in metaphorical Silicon Valley? What about Expedia? Or Concur? Seems very arbitrary. Is metaphorical Silicon Valley only applicable to negative actions of tech companies or does it apply to all big tech companies? I searched for “metaphorical Silicon Valley” and didn’t see anything relevant. Also how did you get into this beta and where is the actual option? Is it under notifications? I’d prefer to use the native app and still use smile.
- jerf 8y agoI didn't do anything in particular to get the beta; the offer got pushed to me. As for SV, the inability to draw a rigid, precise line around a phenomenon doesn't mean it doesn't exist. Life's fuzzy.
- mulmen 8y agoSo when you say SV Company you mean high-growth technology leveraging company that puts profit first? I’m honestly struggling to understand how you apply SV to a company that is not physically from SV, or at least very nearby.
- blattimwind 8y agoOn the website I always found it quite interesting that the "if you shop on smile.amazon.com its for charity" pop-up does not contain any link to the current page on smile.amazon.com; even the domain is plain-text. You need to type it in manually in the address bar.
- rhizome 8y agoAnytime I see something like that I can automatically conclude that they are fundamentally unserious about the initiative.
- vorticalbox 8y agoNot just amazing Samsung is constantly bugging you to sign in with a Samsung account and that apps like galaxy store REQUIRE access to contacts and sms. Just to download an app..
- noisem4ker 8y agoI have never been bugged since I've set up my phone and disabled the bundled apps I didn't need. Galaxy S7 with Oreo.
- DennisAleynikov 8y agoSame here. Samsung does not impose anything on you especially if you don't want to use their services you are free to ignore or uninstall those apps. Theres no black UX and theres excessive notifications about transgressions like accessing mic or camera in bg. Besides all that the android permissions system is broken on a verbage level. contacts permission is often only needed for login, like authentication but also grants permission to scrape data. so you end up with little visibility into what data you are giving up. People end up rightfully fearing apps asking for contacts and calls and location services, when the apps just need access to some api that is bundled under vague unbrella terms like location services
- ranit 8y ago> Silicon Valley has no intention of retraining itself in any manner. Historically, no industry, once became major, intended to retrain itself to be more positive to the society. If any improvement happened, it was forced from outside.
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoSo who was forcing the many famous Victorian philanthropist industrialists to build their railway and model villages, with free schools, hospitals and more for workers? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Model_village https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Model_village
- lupire 8y agoI'm not seeing the philanthropy. They were trying to obtain effective workers without being destroyed by angry outside forces: > The Swing Riots of 1830 highlighted poor housing in the countryside, ill health and immorality and landowners had a responsibility to provide cottages with basic sanitation. The best landlords provided accommodation but many adopted a paternalistic attitude when they built model dwellings and imposed their own standards on the tenants charging low rents but paying low wages.[3] Also: Company Towns: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Company_town https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Company_town
- nathankunicki 8y agoThat was definitely for their benefit of their workers rather than the greater society, and on the whole doesn't seem much different than the larger Silicon Valley companies of today. Take Facebook for example. They have a large utopian-esque campus for the benefits of their workers. In this campus they have bikes for getting around, free bars and restaurants (and an ice cream shop), an on campus doctor, bicycle repair shop, and in fact have somehow managed to convince CBP and USCIS to visit their campus to conduct Global Entry and Visa interviews instead of the workers having to travel to an office. Couple this with the free employee shuttle buses for employees to travel from their homes to the campus, and it seems very much like the "Model village" you described. EDIT: Here is a link to an article (with photo tour) of their Menlo Park campus: https://www.businessinsider.com/facebooks-disneyland-inspired-campus-2013-10 https://www.businessinsider.com/facebooks-disneyland-inspire...
- ntaylor 8y agoSomewhat more sinister, I think, is that they added a TTL on the Amazon Smile opt-in. Now, you must re-opt-in every 90 (I think) days. Fair bet that this small change substantially hurts the effectiveness of this charity and drives a whole bunch of money back to Amazon.
- lupire 8y agoDoes Prime also require a re-opt-in every 90 days? oh....
- lenocinor 8y agoAmazon used to remind me when I wasn't on smile.amazon.com back when I used to go to www.amazon.com instead sometimes. Testing it right now, it doesn't seem like they do this anymore. :(
- vatueil 8y agoPrompts to use Amazon Smile do still appear. It's just that the reminders don't pop up every time you visit a non-smile domain. Haven't seen any 90-day time limit as the parent comment mentions.
- _jal 8y agoAmazon finally exceeded my tolerance for slimy behavior last year, and I let Prime lapse. The amount of time and energy they have put in to making it hard to compare prices in their own goddamn store was enough by itself; behavior like this is motor-oil icing on the garbage cake. I had to readjust a few common purchases, but I was far less habituated to them than I thought I was. Having to actually pay attention and look meant I found cheaper options. And I never cared about Video or their other goofy add-ons. Still handy for pricing data-points when buying elsewhere, though.
- JKCalhoun 8y agoYep, let Prime lapse a year or two ago as well. Moving my business to other companies now.
- malnourish 8y agoWhat competitors are you using?
- tspike 8y agoWalmart.com has stepped it up recently. Still a long way to go, and I doubt their intentions are any better, but competition is healthy.
- stevesearer 8y agoI also like to use boxed.com for quite a few bulk items that one might otherwise find at Costco. And compared to Amazon, I have found some competitive pricing at Smart & Final for other items I used to purchase online.
- all2 8y agoGlanced at boxed.com. Is there any way to see what they have without logging in?
- 8y ago
- duxup 8y agoThat and their notices "hey you look at this" are just a bunch of shit products that I have no interest in. Amazon's Prime Day and other efforts to sell me low quality garbage products are such a turn off. I don't typically think of Amazon like Wall-Mart but they sure as hell are trending that way.
- ncr100 8y agoComputer Science does not have the same heightened degree of Ethical Concern that exists in other sciences. E.g. genetic manipulation of human embryos is highly scrutinized, and action is taken when behavior that would corrupt future generations of humans is identified. Not so with CS. CS Ethics is muted, often conflated with Corporate Ethics whose "Greed is good" line seems to have won out above other ethical mantras.
- smt88 8y agoI wouldn't call these issues matters of computer science. They're just marketing and consumer psych, and they've existed as long as businesses have. The only difference now is that computers have enabled a level of efficient manipulation that wasn't possible before.
- matzf 8y agoThis is about corporate ethics. Just because these corporations happen to make use of computers doesn't make this a computer science issue.
- amelius 8y agoYet, computer scientists implement these systems, while being fully aware of the consequences. If hospitals order doctors to do $BAD_THING, they protest. If an advertisement company orders computer scientists to implement $BAD_SYSTEM, they just comply.
- eesmith 8y agoI believe the biological sciences have a higher degree of ethnics training than the other science fields, if only because most academic biological research requires oversight by an ethics board. Other fields of science do not have the same heightened degree of Ethical Concern as biology, and many have less ethics training than CS programs. For example, when I was at university, the CS program required that the students take a course in ethical topics related to computers. I believe that was due to ACS or IEEE accreditation requirements. The physics program had no similar requirement for their students.
- Plough_Jogger 8y agoAmazon is not based in Silicon Valley, do you mean consumer tech as an industry?