9 ms·
Why some Japanese pensioners want to go to jail
- devereaux 8y ago1) human contact 2) room and board When pensioners or just any adult prefers jail to freedom, it makes you think we failed something as a society.
- moltar 8y agoI kinda agree but it also depends on the jail. I imagine Japanese jails are nice, esp for small crimes. I’ve seen Nordik jails in a documentary and I’d totally pick that over many other places to live, if I was not able to afford living.
- devereaux 8y agoIt's not just about being able to afford basic living conditions. If these people can't get enough human contact, we failed them. There's no reason we shouldn't be able to create meaningful interactions for the elderly. There's no reason whatsoever they should be isolated.
- userulluipeste 8y ago"If these people can't get enough human contact, we failed them." These are adults, not children. Let's take responsibility for taking care of ourselves. There is no moral basis for blaming others if we individually fail at that (as long as others haven't done anything against us), as you imply. I also think we need more critique on gratuitous blaming/shaming. It does no good to allow abusive attitude like this, even when's addressed towards a diffuse target as the society at large.
- rfw 8y agoIt really doesn't depend on the jail, at all. Having to be incarcerated to have a good livelihood is unforgivably disgusting.
- dmos62 8y agoSome people seek a different kind of freedom, that that which is taken away by some jails, or maybe they don't seek freedom at all, rather comfort. Which is very sad and normal. I sometimes think that I'd find it therapeutic to stay in a fitting prison. Some maybe relevant characteristics of mine are that I often seek isolation, and my creative activities are fully isolated of any direct social contact.
- sosborn 8y agoThe prisons aren’t that nice: https://www.economist.com/asia/2015/12/03/silent-screams https://www.economist.com/asia/2015/12/03/silent-screams
- peteretep 8y ago> I imagine Japanese jails are nice, esp for small crimes I did some Googling of this around the time we were in Lanta, and they sounded terrible
- moltar 8y agoStalker ...
- gammateam 8y ago#notAllNordikJails
- userulluipeste 8y ago"When pensioners or just any adult prefers jail to freedom, it makes you think we failed something as a society." I don't see any reason to take people like myself accountable for the current state of society I inherited from the now pensioner generation, so let me rephrase the last part: "it makes you think they failed something as a society."
- Aeolun 8y agoWhy shouldn’t we hold ourselves responsible for the current state of society? What we inherited is done, we can’t change that any more. But we can certainly make tomorrow a little bit better than yesterday.
- userulluipeste 8y agoI consider that I'll be liable to this kind of judgement after most of my potential and actions are in past's domain. For now we may be responsible for where we're taking the current state further on but not so much for what we have. What we have now is for the most part inherited, so we should thank the past generations for it, especially so when it's about casting blame for something affecting the said past generations, obviously!
- calyth2018 8y agoYou'd think for the cost of actually jailing one of them for two years, they could give out a better pension and create programs for the elderly, and cover more for the same price.
- socalnate1 8y agoEverything about this story is heartbreaking.
- StillBored 8y agoThis sorta reminds me of the stories of homeless people committing minor crimes to get off the street during bad winter weather.
- whitepoplar 8y agoMy parents are set to turn 70 next year and I worry so much about their wellbeing when they get older. My dad, in particular, is a generally happy person, but doesn't have many friends. I worry that if my mom passes before him, he's going to have a rough time. I feel guilty because I'm one of those children described in the article who moved to another city to chase economic + social activity.
- Annatar 8y agoFrom the article it looks like a much better and cheaper solution is to build retirement homes for the elderly. Is it feasible to write to one's political representative in Japan?
- coldtea 8y ago>Is it feasible to write to one's political representative in Japan? Because that ever achieved anything in the US, except letting off steam?
- Annatar 8y agoJapan is decidedly not the United States. In some European countries like Germany writing to one's representative damn works, and works well; in Switzerland the situation is even better, the people decide directly and as the consequence the government is afraid of the people, which is as it should be. Looking at everything through the lens of how things are in the United States is dimwitted, to put it very considerately and politely.
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoWe've all done it, and often had to, which is the root of the problem. When I was under 10, both sets of grandparents and four of five aunts and uncles were within 10 miles, most under 3. Now we're all over the place and a visit isn't a regular frequent thing but a major, rarer, trip. As I'm in my mid fifties some of the future looks rather bleak. Add longer life expectancy after retirement and for most, better mental and physical health, and you end up with many more years to contemplate your loneliness. I saw one story a few years back of a retirement home that combined a nursery. Which turned out to be a huge boost for both the kid's development, parents, and the old folks. Every day they would have joint activities. Sounded a great idea that we need far more of, rather than occasional novelty worth reporting.
- labster 8y agoWe talked about this a bit last year with a different article: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16603343 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16603343
- expertentipp 8y agoJust wait to see Central European countries in 15-20 years. Prisons are quite rough though, it’l rather impact suicide rates.
- distances 8y agoCare to expand a bit for us not familiar with the situation there?
- ivanche 8y agoNot the OP, but maybe I can give opinion. A lot of young (and often well educated) people are leaving to USA, Canada, Germany etc, taking their families with them too. For example, there are about 30K immigrants from Serbia to Germany each year. From Croatia to Germany it's about 50K per year. Significant number of them are doctors and nurses. Average salary (and consequently, pension) in most of central and eastern European countries is quite low, making nursing homes unaffordable. This, combined with the fact that a lot of children/relatives now live 1000+km away and that the prisons are, say, not well known for friendliness there makes situation quite dire for current and future pensioners there.
- mschuster91 8y ago> Significant number of them are doctors and nurses. I'm half-German, half-Croat. Our excuse of a health minister (Spahn) actually thinks that the solution for the utter lack of staff in the German health system is to bleed the Balkan totally dry... as if that hasn't been going on for decades! All the people coming here to work in the health sector drop out after a couple of years due to horrible payment and labor conditions, thus leading to more recruiting in ever more remote countries, it's a vicious cycle. The obvious solution would be to massively increase pay to increase retention, but for unknown reasons no one wants to do this...
- Tyrannosaur 8y agoI've imagined a world where prisons and homeless shelters look almost identical, save the prisons don't allow you to leave.
- ljf 8y agoLook into prisons in Denmark - far closer to hostels or even universities halls of residence. So much so that they encourage you people to live in them too.
- beaconstudios 8y agothis seems more humanitarian, but doesn't it reduce the disincentive to commit another crime, especially for people from unstable or low-income backgrounds where the prison may be more pleasant than home? Most prisons around the world seem to be far too inhumane but I can't help but wonder if you can go too far in the other direction.
- Aeolun 8y agoI mean, if you want to go back to prison you likely aren’t going to commit a violent crime (even if you did for your initial visit), so that’s a win.
- Filligree 8y agoYou can't leave. That's the disincentive.
- Markoff 8y agoyou can leave minimum security prisons in many countries and basically go there just to do mandatory sleep
- pluma 8y agoPlease watch this video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AYj_FPT90cM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AYj_FPT90cM (it's about Norway, which has very humanitarian prisons) The short version is that a naive comparison shows that recidivism in Norway is much lower than in the US, a more thorough comparison shows that recidivism is actually not so different. But either way, making prisons worse doesn't actually help fighting crime. So the decision whether prisoners should be treated humanely or not is more about ideology than effectiveness. And personally I think humans should be treated humanely, no matter what they did.
- hurr_durr 8y agoWe are all going to get old some day. Better prepare well by saving up...don't expect to rely on anyone except yourself.
- innocentoldguy 8y agoWhen I lived in Japan back in the 80s, doctor visits were basically free. They took all day though, partially because the elderly would go to the doctor to interact with other people, rather than for a real medical need, thus clogging up the system.
- newnewpdro 8y agoThis seems so strange to me, do they not have cafes where strangers can socialize over a cheap cup of coffee or tea?
- konart 8y ago>do they not have cafes where strangers can socialize over a cheap cup of coffee or tea? Surely they have. But you have to order something and there is a good change you won't meet anyone of your age. If you come to a free clinic - you don't pay anything and you are immediately surrounded by people of your age (if we are talking about eldery as in this case).
- mhd 8y agoShared suffering is also a good conversation starter for the elderly. Some waiting rooms turn into a kind of Four Yorkshiremen sketch quickly. And yes, that's not good. The whole world hasn't quite come to terms yet with situation that we've got a whole lot of old people, neither with the healthy ones, nor the infirm ones. Given the sheer amount of both, there should be way more opportunities and organizations for them (not just the church and political parties). But that's not a sexy topic for startup bros and the VCs that love them.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ekianjo 8y agoIts not in free clinics, its Day Care where old people go to in Japan to spend time with planned activities.
- ToFab123 8y agoIn other news. It is cheaper to stay on a cruise ship than in a nursing home. https://www.reshareworthy.com/old-lady-alone-on-a-cruise-ship/ https://www.reshareworthy.com/old-lady-alone-on-a-cruise-shi...
- chii 8y agoThe cruise liner probably loses money if every customer is like that!
- est31 8y agoShe seems self-sufficient enough to not need a nursing home in the first place. Nursing homes aren't hotels. Does the cruise ship crew help her to shower? Get dressed? Brush her teeth? Are they able to deal with Alzheimer patients? I doubt they do.
- _Nat_ 8y agoSeems like the lady in that story was telling a joke, as the services offered by a cruise ship wouldn't be comparable to an assisted-living facility, let alone a nursing home. Not to ruin the joke, just, if she merely needed food delivered and chores done with someone to take her to the doctor, she could live in a normal residence and hire that help for much less. Assisted-living facilities would provide a step up, then nursing homes provide support a level beyond that.
- newnewpdro 8y agoThat sounds like a wonderful environment for a person living with declining immunity. http://fortune.com/2019/01/12/500-sick-on-cruise-ship-oasis-of-the-seas/ http://fortune.com/2019/01/12/500-sick-on-cruise-ship-oasis-... https://www.cdc.gov/nceh/vsp/surv/GIlist.htm https://www.cdc.gov/nceh/vsp/surv/GIlist.htm
- ToFab123 8y agoIn the future it may become cheaper to live on an intergalactic cruiser than in a nursing home
- benj111 8y agoSo can anyone shed any light on why they're jailing people for such low value items?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- konart 8y agoBecause stealing a car and stealing a pen - is the same thing. A pen given to me by my father 20 years ago can be of a bigger value for me than a fucking Porsche.
- ndnxhs 8y agoI don't think personal value counts in the legal system otherwise people would claim everything was a priceless family item.
- konart 8y agoThat's not my point.
- benj111 8y agoBut the things discussed were from a shop, and have prices attached. And they aren't the same thing, you yourself admit that, to you the pen is more valuable than the car.
- konart 8y ago>And they aren't the same thing, you yourself admit that, to you the pen is more valuable than the car. My point is that theft should be followed by a fierce punishment. Regardless of the market price.
- onetimemanytime 8y agoMy guess is to send the "Just DON'T do it" message. If you get away with low value you might aim for the higher ones...
- onetimemanytime 8y agoRetirement planning on $1200 SS: Go to jail for half of the time, plead guilty so no lawyer expenses, and when out, live on $2400 :) Sad way, but it's a way of doing it. Can't blame the newer generation as they can barely manage for themselves. Add mental illness that starts in a lot of older people and professional care is needed.
- gruez 8y agothat doesn't work in the US because you'll get charged court/jail fees that will wipe away any money you saved.
- toomuchtodo 8y agoOnly in certain circumstances can Social Security benefits be garnished.
- ekianjo 8y ago> Japan is in the grip of an elderly crime wave - the proportion of crimes committed by people over the age of 65 has been steadily increasing for 20 years Journalist does not get stats. Its increasing in absolute numbers because the population over 65 is exploding as baby boomers come in that range. In relative proportion its not increasing at all.
- ezoe 8y agoActually, Japan crime rate is high in elderly population. It use to be relatively rare, but now it's relatively high.
- ekianjo 8y agoAgain this article shows absolutely no evidence of this. None of the graphs support this hypothesis (since they can be explained in other ways). See my other comments.
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoSeems like the article caters for it well enough. In relative proportion it's increasing: "In 1997 this age group accounted for about one in 20 convictions but 20 years later the figure had grown to more than one in five - a rate that far outstrips the growth of the over-65s as a proportion of the population"
- ekianjo 8y agoYou missed the next sentence: > nd like Toshio, many of these elderly lawbreakers are repeat offenders. Of the 2,500 over-65s convicted in 2016, more than a third had more than five previous convictions. Those are not unique offenders. Somebody who commits multiple infractions is counted several times.
- konschubert 8y agoYes, but this is an uncorrelated effect.
- Tsubasachan 8y agoAssisted suicide is a big trend in my country for old people who want to check out. But I know that in many countries that's not an option due to religious beliefs.
- ezoe 8y agoReligious belief? It's more like moral and constitutional basic human right issue.
- dmos62 8y agoAre you saying that it's a basic human right to choose whether or not to live, or that it's a right to not have a right to choose? The former would be a very weird statement.
- NikolaeVarius 8y agoI subscribe to former and I have no ides why you think its weird. The choice of continued concious existence is literally the only real natural right we have.
- dvfjsdhgfv 8y ago> The choice of continued concious existence is literally the only real natural right we have. We have several choices and we make them each second. A choice to respond to this comment or not, for example. And even in a tragic scenario where you can't make any choice about your body, you may still have many others - see Hawking for example.
- dmos62 8y agoThere's an issue of terminology here. What you describe is not a right, it's an obligation. If some action is a right, you can choose not to do it. So you're saying that a human is obligated to live for the maximum span of time possible. Does it still not sound weird? Rhetorics aside, the power to turn yourself off is very important. Taking away this power has been used throughout history as a means to intensify torture. For someone in suffering, the power to end your life can literaly be the difference between complete powerlessness and empowerment. I've been through a few bouts of depression and can confirm this first-hand.
- tsukikage 8y agoA relative who is a court interpreter assures me we have exactly the same problem in the UK. The popular approach with her clients here is to smash a car window, then turn themselves in. With temperatures below zero, right now is a particularly busy time.
- LeftTurnSignal 8y agoI've seen this happen in the midwest US too. Given the choice between jail, being outside, or maybe a shelter if you live around a bigger city, I know what i would pick for the winter.
- jshprentz 8y agoThe 1904 O. Henry short story "The Cop and the Anthem"[1][2] tells of a homeless New York City man who commits small crimes, preferring arest and jail to charity handouts. "But to one of Soapy's proud spirit the gifts of charity are encumbered. If not in coin you must pay in humiliation of spirit for every benefit received at the hands of philanthropy. As Caesar had his Brutus, every bed of charity must have its toll of a bath, every loaf of bread its compensation of a private and personal inquisition. Wherefore it is better to be a guest of the law, which though conducted by rules, does not meddle unduly with a gentleman's private affairs." Soapy's many attempts fail, but the story ends with a typical O. Henry twist. No spoiler here. The story was filmed in 1952, one of five stories in "O. Henry's Full House." Charles Laughton played the vagrant. He briefly meets Marilyn Monroe. Watch this segment on YouTube[3] or enjoy the entire film. [1] https://americanliterature.com/author/o-henry/short-story/the-cop-and-the-anthem https://americanliterature.com/author/o-henry/short-story/th... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Cop_and_the_Anthem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Cop_and_the_Anthem [3] https://youtu.be/temSJCZwUlU https://youtu.be/temSJCZwUlU
- close04 8y agoThis is a common theme especially in any country with cold winters. People will commit low level crimes that will ensure just enough prison time to survive the winter when they're either homeless or their home offers little o no guarantee they will survive a very cold night (no money for heating). Sometimes the prison system is bad enough that most people wouldn't resort to this unless it's a life and death situation. So probably nothing of principle (not wanting to take pity money) or not just as a method to save some more money for a few years.
- Fjolsvith 8y agoSaw this in Alaska when I lived there.