8 ms·
Napster is the future of the internet. It will come back. But the world has to evolve on a social level before this can happen. We saw the same with the printi
by toyg 8y ago
Napster is the future of the internet. It will come back. But the world has to evolve on a social level before this can happen.
We saw the same with the printing press: the Powers That Be first banned it, then tried to control it, and eventually had to relent. It will happen with data sharing too, eventually. It might take a century, but it will happen.
- rimliu 8y agoIf it solves problems nobody (for the little to moderate values of nobody) has it will not happen.
- bromuro 8y agoInternet Economy today is based on solving problems people do not have...
- orbifold 8y agoWhy wouldn't you want free access to all media ever produced at no cost except your internet subscription. The streaming video services are really terrible by comparison and the only reason that music piracy no longer exists to a large degree is due to the fact that youtube has a legal form of piracy build in. You can download any song you like and strip the irrelevant video.
- expertentipp 8y agoStreaming services make one to pay over and over, more and more for the same content while actively pursuing new ways to limit the accessibility to the content and to sneak in advertisements. It's a doomed industry.
- krapp 8y agoI use several streaming services and I've never had to pay over and over for the same content. Hell, more often than not, I don't have to pay anything for the content I actually want to see, as long as I'm willing to tolerate advertising, which is fine by me as long as it isn't too intrusive. I understand this is a Napster thread and as a result the most enthusiastically pro-piracy, anti-capitalist contingent of HN is going to show up and wave the black flag but at least try to be honest about the pros and cons for both. Streaming services do have their dark patterns and anti-consumer practices but they still offer something of value to the consumer, and despite what people want to believe, are more convenient than piracy for many people.
- vict00ms 8y agoI'm not who you replied to but I believe "over and over" was a reference to recurrent subscription fees.
- expertentipp 8y ago> I'm not who you replied to but I believe "over and over" was a reference to recurrent subscription fees. I mean that with subscription services one is unable to backup, or even "come back" repeatedly to the content. Let's say watching the same movie from time to time - it's not possible because service providers go out of business, copyright deals change, markets become more/less prioritized, different platforms are supported, the repertoire within the subscription changes over time. Thus watching the same movie requires buying it over and over again.
- ncphillips 8y ago1. $10/month is not an issue for me financially. 2. I want to support the artists who make my media financially, and doing that on an individual basis would be too inconvenient. 3. I know what I’m getting, P2P was always a gamble. 4. Current streaming services (movies and videos) have a significantly better UX that isnaccessible to anyone.
- quantummkv 8y agoJust wait for a year or two. All the content big creators(HBO, Disney, etc) have become jealous of Netflix and are preparing to silo their content to their exclusive streaming services for all that sweet cash. Once this process is compete and the silos are created Napster will rise again.
- SmellyGeekBoy 8y agoI know it's not the same from a technical standpoint but BitTorrent is still alive and well. Being peer-to-peer it could be considered a spiritual successor to Napster. I'm not ashamed to admit that I still use it to download movies or foreign TV shows that aren't legally available on the streaming services I use (at least in my region). In my case it's strictly a case of availability - I happily pay for Netflix, Amazon Prime and Spotify as well as whatever software I use. I wish the content creators would wise up to this - Steam solved this issue for gaming years ago.
- quantummkv 8y ago> Being peer-to-peer it could be considered a spiritual successor to Napster. Napster's popularity was not because of P2P or something else. The only reason Napster succeeded was convenience. Bittorrent cannot be the successor because it is not as convenient. > In my case it's strictly a case of availability - I happily pay for Netflix, Amazon Prime and Spotify as well as whatever software I use. Everyone pays now because it is convenient to pay at 2-3 places for all your needs. Once you have to start paying at a separate place for every different series/movie you want, you will stop paying. It is not only about availability. It is about availability AND convenience And Steam is facing the same issues as Netflix with Epic Store and Origin breaking away because EA and Tim wanted more money.
- Ntrails 8y agoMusic Piracy absolutely still exists although WhatCD going down hurt it a bunch. However, the real trick of music streaming sites is to build in all of the scrobbly/suggestion/organisation features in. Piracy grows when it is more convenient than legal consumption. I'd rather download a torrent of a DvD I own than go and fetch it, put it in a cd tray, play it with shitty un-skippable intro etc. However - I'd rather spin a film up on Netflix than go hunting through a shitty folder structure of my own idiotic devising. I'd rather watch a series on netflix, which remembers where I am in the series and auto-plays next than manually load up episodes on the odd evening when I've got time. Admittedly Netflix seems to be going out of its way to make the UI intolerably aggravating, but at some points it seemed pretty well done.
- general8bitso 8y agouPNP is pretty cool.
- mbrock 8y agoNetflix's selection of films is also so atrocious as to be dangerous for the Bildung of our youth.
- antisthenes 8y ago> However - I'd rather spin a film up on Netflix than go hunting through a shitty folder structure of my own idiotic devising. I'd rather watch a series on netflix, which remembers where I am in the series and auto-plays next than manually load up episodes on the odd evening when I've got time. There is desktop software that does all of this locally, including auto-play, intro skipping, remembering where you were in a media file, even auto-downloading subtitles and displaying them. Nor do you have to navigate through your own 'idiotic' folder structure as you put it, because software like Everything exists. Just because you never bothered to set it up doesn't mean this functionality doesn't exist.
- rimliu 8y agoI've never pirated music. I did torrent few movies and shows . when there was no easy legal way to get them. A couple of apps too. Never music though. And I had no bittorrent client for a few years now. Why… That's a good question. First of all I am not interested in hoarding all the media ever produced. Most of it would not even be interesting to me. Second, I want so show some appreciation to the artist I like even if they get only a small percentage of what I pay. I may be outlier in my relationship with the music though. I do not get the urge to have it in my ears for 24/7. It is something I listen to not just a background or the way to drone out my own thoughts. So the smaller collections of the stuff I really like is enough.
- buboard 8y agotechnically music doesnt solve any problems
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- a_tractor 8y agoIt solves the problem of how to enjoy the sensory experience of human existence, for one. It also solves the problem of how to express complex and abstract human emotion and intellectual ideas in ways that would be nearly impossible to relate to otherwise. It helps bring large disparate groups of people together and supports the formation of happy communities... Provides respite from other more mundane, unsolvable problems... It solves more problems than it creates, that is for sure.
- kristianc 8y ago> We saw the same with the printing press: the Powers That Be first banned it, then tried to control it, and eventually had to relent. All of those phases have already happened - banning (RIAA lawsuits), control (iTunes), relent (Spotify). We've reached the endgame - it's streaming. If you want to store and maintain a personal 128GB collection of MP3 files with incomplete titles and data, that's your prerogative, but you're going to be in a tiny minority.
- general8bitso 8y agoMust be nice to have a high bandwidth connection with 5 nines uptime, no risk of your account being revoked, or the content licenses abrogated or expired. It is of the utmost importance to inculcate the newest generation of media consumers that renting is preferred to ownership.
- TheRealDunkirk 8y agoI slogged through keeping a local archive of my carefully-ripped audio collection on a hardware RAID-5 storage server for decades. When I finally gave up in favor of Google Play (and subsequently Apple Music), it was liberating. At the end of the day, the "content" we're talking about here is purely entertainment. You can live without it. And even if the hammer falls, and the copyright holders go backwards, things like Napster and Limewire and eDonkey will rise again. At 10 years old, I never understood the line in SW EPIV, where Leia says, "The more you tighten your grip, the more star systems will slip through your fingers." (Seriously, the line haunted me for years.) But it's a perfect allegory for this situation. Of course, I'm still waiting for the blowback against Facebook, so...
- AsyncAwait 8y ago> At the end of the day, the "content" we're talking about here is purely entertainment. You can live without it. You can live without a lot of things, including drinkable tap water and flushable toilets, however that is not necessarily a reasonable standard to judge things by. I use music not just to 'entertain' myself, but to focus as well. Besides, why is entertainment and relaxation always treated as somehow secondary/not necessary? I realize many people find purpose in being work bees, but some strive for a healthy work-life balance.
- sorenjan 8y agoWhere I live Direct Connect (mainly the open source client DC++) was the most popular P2P network after Napster. One big difference is that you can share any kind of file, not just music. It even had hashing, so you could find copies of files with different names, and download from multiple sources at once. It's still around, but I never hear about anyone using it even though it's more flexible than Napster. A major feature and downside, depending on who you are, is that you can browse all files a user is sharing. This is great for discovering new things, but also means that copyright holders could sue you for all shared files, not just one at a time like with Bittorrent. Thinking about it, Kazaa was also more flexible than Napster and maybe a stronger household name than DC++. http://dcplusplus.sourceforge.net/ http://dcplusplus.sourceforge.net/
- k__ 8y agoDirect Connect was very popular in the dorm networks of my university. Back in the days (around 2005) I mostly used Soul Seek and IRC.
- kalleboo 8y agoSame at my uni. The networks inside each student housing complex were fast, but each complex was only connected to the school through 100 MBit lines, so everyone would add the name of their complex to their username, and you'd avoid downloading from outside your local network unless strictly necessary. Eventually the school stopped providing internet to the student housing and we got put on the municipal power company open commercial fiber network and got to choose from an array of commercial ISPs; got massive speed upgrades but it removed the community.
- rchaud 8y agoI believe I used the same thing in college (also 2005); something that let you share and download files from other people's Itunes libraries. I was blown away by it the first time I used it; totally seamless. Thank the lord that Slsk is still running. There is simply soo much material out there Spotify and the like will never have because they were unofficial live bootlegs, weird studio outtakes and obscure EPs and singles. Case in point: anybody ever listened to "Towering over the Rest?" It's a 20+ track compilation of Radiohead's B-sides and live cuts from 1993-2000. Never officially released, since the tracks were always available inside of individual singles, EPs and 7"s. Listening to it gave me a completely different perspective on the band's output, which I mostly knew through full albums. Discoveries like that now have to happen via Spotify playlists, and even then you couldn't reproduce that entire compilation simply because Spotify wouldn't have the license for some of those releases, which came out 25 years ago and on labels that no longer exist.
- Viker 8y ago> " had to relent " You mean they totally embraced, rebranded and used it and it as a tool of mass control.
- y4mi 8y ago> Napster is the future of the internet. The "Napster" brand still exists. Its now a streaming service and competitor to spotify.
- c22 8y agoDid it ever really leave? What.cd only shutdown a couple years ago, I assumed something else replaced it and I'm just not hip enough anymore to get an invite.
- miki123211 8y agodeezloader and clones
- drzaiusx11 8y agoI often wonder how long the artificial scarcity facade can hold. We need to find better monetization schemes than DRM. I'd gladly pay artists directly for their work rather than on a per-disc/media or stream basis. Of course I'm sure thats exactly what the record industry doesn't want.
- nickjj 8y agoI think people are starting to realize that openness is the only way to really control your content. At least in today's world. If you put your music up on Youtube for free then you become the main source that everyone links to because it's available. You gain control back of your data, rather than having someone pirate it. There's a number of musicians I see on Youtube who release everything they put out for free, but then have optional links to buy it on various music platforms. A lot of them are happy with the set up because they can make a living doing what they love. The same strategy applies to writing apps and open source in general, and it's even more beneficial because unlike a personally developed music track, an application greatly benefits from having multiple people work on it.
- miki123211 8y agoWhen people realize how copyright actually came to be [1], it won't take that long. The question is, will they? [1] https://questioncopyright.org/promise https://questioncopyright.org/promise