10 ms·
Napster: A New Killer Internet App (1999)
- forgotmypw2 8y agowritten by metafilter founder mathowie
- tclancy 8y agoAbout Napster and on evolt, the whole thing was a nostalgia bomb as soon as I clicked the link.
- napo 8y ago"if the recording industry knew about this, they'd probably shut it down."
- expertentipp 8y agoWell Lars must had read the article.
- FahadUddin92 8y ago'killer app.' I heard that was the term 'Bill Gates' was also asked about during his hearing in the Gates vs USA case.
- 0db532a0 8y agoCan anyone explain the T1, T2, T3 classification of internet speed? Back in the day, I don’t remember it being used where I lived.
- DanBC 8y agoI remember seeing them a bit, but not knowing what they meant. I've found this which explains it a bit. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/T-carrier https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/T-carrier > The most common legacy of this system is the line rate speeds. "T1" now means any data circuit that runs at the original 1.544 Mbit/s line rate. Originally the T1 format carried 24 pulse-code modulated, time-division multiplexed speech signals each encoded in 64 kbit/s streams, leaving 8 kbit/s of framing information which facilitates the synchronization and demultiplexing at the receiver. The T2 and T3 circuit channels carry multiple T1 channels multiplexed, resulting in transmission rates of 6.312 and 44.736 Mbit/s, respectively. A T3 line comprises 28 T1 lines, each operating at total signaling rate of 1.544 Mbit/s. It is possible to get a fractional T3 line, meaning a T3 line with some of the 28 lines turned off, resulting in a slower transfer rate but typically at reduced cost.
- SmellyGeekBoy 8y agoThe T1 users were like internet royalty to us dialup users back in the Napster days. I often pondered where they must be to get such an amazing connection (Universities, I assume). Now even in rural England I get a reliable connection that's over 50x faster. Even mobile is faster than that. How times change.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y agoUnfortunately in the parts of the rural US where my employer frequently operates we still have difficulty getting a connection on par with a T1.
- cpcallen 8y agoAHH, if only I lived in the countryside, rather than in a London suburb where my maximum ADSL speed has for at least the last decade been barely better than a T1 downstream, and hardly better than dialup upstream!
- thekid314 8y agoI'm stuck in Putney grrrr.
- porpoisely 8y agoI remember being on dial-up as a kid back then and being insanely jealous that kids in college got T1 connections in their dorms. One of the reasons why I wanted to go to college as a kid was the blazing fast internet speed. Downloads that took hours for me, took seconds for them. It sounded like heaven to me back then.
- function_seven 8y agoI went to a state school that hadn't completed networking their dorms. Even at school, I had to use dial-up to get my email (using Pine through a VMS). My girlfriend at a different school had high-speed access in the dorms. I remember making the 2 hour trip to visit her, and half of my excitement was all the music I could download once I got there. I show up, and find out she hadn't connected her computer yet! First priority of that day was going to the campus bookstore to buy an ISA network card and 10Base2 terminators and connectors.
- wslh 8y agoWikipedia is your friend: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/T-carrier https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/T-carrier
- degenerate 8y agoI learned what T1, T2, T3, OC-3, OC-12, and OC-48 meant back when counter-strike servers were adding it to their server names. However now that I think about it, most of the OC-3+ servers were straight up lying through their teeth. Still got me to join though.
- sizzzzlerz 8y agoOC-3/STM-1 155.52 Mb/s can carry 63 T1s OC-12/STM-4 622.04 Mb/s OC-48/STM-16 2488.16 Mb/s
- function_seven 8y agoOC-3/STM-1 155.52 Mb/s can carry 63 T1s OC-12/STM-4 622.04 Mb/s OC-48/STM-16 2488.16 Mb/s I think that's 63 E1s. An OC-3 can carry 84 T1s (3 x 28)
- sizzzzlerz 8y agod'oh. you are correct, sir.
- general8bitso 8y agoTake a look at ISDN, too. Family friend had that in their home.
- bluedino 8y ago'Only' 64k and 128k speeds. However, it was 'always on' compared to dialup over POTS lines. 4-5x faster for uploads and 2-4 times faster for downloads, so most dial-up users would have coveted it.
- general8bitso 8y agoand the monthly cost kept it out of greater adoption. I believe it was also used for high fidelity, low latency audio for interviews and music production.
- nickjj 8y agoDon't forget video games. In a game with good network code such as Quake 2 / 3, you could expect at best a 150ms ping time with a 56k modem in ideal scenarios but on ISDN you could get half that which made a world of a difference. I never had ISDN but I knew a few people with it. It was like you were playing a completely different game. Then cable came and it blew everything away with getting 20-30ms ping times even in the early 2000s.
- general8bitso 8y agoAh, I was only playing original Quake with a direct dial-up to a friend’s modem, for 1-on-1, but we did have it working in the computer lab on 10-baseT. If somebody went to turn their desktop slightly, the coax would pop out of the t-connector and those further down the chain would be at a severe disadvantage.
- obiefernandez 8y agoBack in 1995 my friend and I ordered a T1 with the intention of starting up a web hosting company. The startup didn't work, but we did end up with blazingly fast (for the time) internet access. I still remember downloading the first version of Netscape and it took just a few seconds. I almost fell out of my chair! Long story short, things must have been so crazy and disorganized at the vendor (I guess) that even though we never paid a single invoice for the T1, they took over a year to shut us off.
- c22 8y ago> I still remember downloading the first version of Netscape and it took just a few seconds. I almost fell out of my chair! This is still how I feel everytime I download a large file in seconds. I guess I spent so long accessing the internet over dialup this rapid (and relatively recent) explosion of speed at the edges is truly impressive. It's a little ironic that our most popular protocols and services these days reject p2p so thoroughly.
- toyg 8y agoNapster is the future of the internet. It will come back. But the world has to evolve on a social level before this can happen. We saw the same with the printing press: the Powers That Be first banned it, then tried to control it, and eventually had to relent. It will happen with data sharing too, eventually. It might take a century, but it will happen.
- rimliu 8y agoIf it solves problems nobody (for the little to moderate values of nobody) has it will not happen.
- bromuro 8y agoInternet Economy today is based on solving problems people do not have...
- orbifold 8y agoWhy wouldn't you want free access to all media ever produced at no cost except your internet subscription. The streaming video services are really terrible by comparison and the only reason that music piracy no longer exists to a large degree is due to the fact that youtube has a legal form of piracy build in. You can download any song you like and strip the irrelevant video.
- expertentipp 8y agoStreaming services make one to pay over and over, more and more for the same content while actively pursuing new ways to limit the accessibility to the content and to sneak in advertisements. It's a doomed industry.
- krapp 8y agoI use several streaming services and I've never had to pay over and over for the same content. Hell, more often than not, I don't have to pay anything for the content I actually want to see, as long as I'm willing to tolerate advertising, which is fine by me as long as it isn't too intrusive. I understand this is a Napster thread and as a result the most enthusiastically pro-piracy, anti-capitalist contingent of HN is going to show up and wave the black flag but at least try to be honest about the pros and cons for both. Streaming services do have their dark patterns and anti-consumer practices but they still offer something of value to the consumer, and despite what people want to believe, are more convenient than piracy for many people.
- eternalny1 8y agoI was the author of MP3 Fiend, which was doing really well back in 1999 (CNET 5-star Editor's Choice). Then Napster came along. While I appreciate that its 1999 interface was just as ugly as mine, what I didn't have was P2P. And obviously, that was the "killer technology".
- buboard 8y ago> killer technology Though technically nobody died from it
- lunchables 8y agoInterface looks great to me. I know what every single piece of the UI does immediately.
- wires 8y ago> It's a true community sharing all their music. That's the point. Sharing is caring. Also this is what culture is about... not about the pop shit we get shoved in our face all the time. If anything, mp3 sharing made me buy more records (12" vinyl), not less.
- moate 8y agoCounterpoint: I hate having to track files on a hard drive, love pop music, and could never be bothered to buy a physical piece of media ever again. Don't yuck my yum, I think that's a better point.
- adem666 8y agoWhat an application. I will download right away and try too.
- Tepix 8y agoI remember launching Napster for the first time. Millions of popular and obscure songs at your fingertips. It was exhilerating to experience the power of peer-to-peer. The genie was out of the bottle.
- gonesilent 8y agoTooth paste out of the tube is what Gene Kan tried to coin for it.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- buboard 8y agoGot to remember mp3. THAT was the killer tech that enabled everything.
- lunchables 8y agoBefore that we used real audio files. I remember downloading so much music via .ra files on IRC via XDCC. Back then it was a great choice because we were still using modems. The quality was basically AM radio level, but the files were tiny so the trade off was worth it.
- daveslash 8y agoOn my 28k modem with my Win 3.1 machine, I relied pretty heavily on MIDI files. I had a good collection Greenday, Nirvana, and movie theme songs (Ghost busters, Jaws, Jurrasic Park, Spaceballs, etc..) Oh, and I recently discovered that browsers no longer even support MIDI files.... yes, I _recently_ tried to create a webpage that would play music on load, don't ask me why...I'm just an awful person sometimes.
- lunchables 8y agoI'm hugely nostalgic for the early web, I don't blame you at all. If you've never seen it, this is worth scrolling through: https://www.cameronsworld.net/ https://www.cameronsworld.net/
- daveslash 8y agoThank you. That was amazing. The dancing girls especially made me reminisce (of my 13 y/o days). My parents never knew that I installed some secret dancing-girl thinger on the home-computer. I constantly wonder, and struggle with, how the internet impacts my 14 y/o stepdaughter in ways of which I'm unaware.... and how to approach it.
- VikingCoder 8y agoI wish Mesh Networks were a bigger thing. I wish that casual P2P over them was a thing. Music. Books. Pictures. News. All spread by just walking around, gathering content that matches tags you subscribe to.
- xj9 8y agothere are a lot of people working on various aspects of this. hopefully something usable will be available in the next couple of years. https://www.scuttlebutt.nz/ https://www.scuttlebutt.nz/ https://www.open-mesh.org/projects/batman-adv/wiki https://www.open-mesh.org/projects/batman-adv/wiki https://heropunch.io/Tracker https://heropunch.io/Tracker
- cmollis 8y agoNapster. Worked there in 2000 and 2001. It was surreal (at least for me) to work at a place that was always in the news at the time. I can understand how employees at Faang must feel at times. Not a total distraction but it’s there. Napster was an interesting place.
- jimothyhalpert7 8y agoHow good a job did Justin Timberlake do in portraying Sean Parker?
- cmollis 8y agoOnly saw Sean Parker in a meeting once (and I don’t believe I was ever introduced) so, difficult to comment on that. My sense is that he was more involved at the beginning of the service. I got involved around the time Bertelsmann made the investment in the company.
- cmollis 8y agoI guess technically it was a ‘convertible loan’. Whatever.
- glenneroo 8y agoDo you have any interesting stories about your time there?
- cmollis 8y agoWe were working on the new commercial services in both client and server components. So perhaps the most interesting aspect was the general tension between those who felt strongly about the original intent and purpose of the service, and those who felt that it needed a commercial function that would appease the music industry rights holders. That said, I met many great engineers there , many who have gone on to their own fame and fortune. From a technical perspective it was quite enlightening also. I had never even heard of non-blocking io before I worked on that stuff. The scale was nothing I had ever seen before. Largely taken for granted today. Most of what we understand and experience today about consumption of music was really determined by what happened there both from legal and technical perspectives.
- cecilpl2 8y ago> I've used it mostly for finding obscure or impossible-to-find music. I mean, where else are you going to get a copy of The Mr. Belvedere Show theme song? This is a nice reminder of just how much things have advanced in a short 20 years. In four mouse clicks and under 5 seconds, I was watching the video for it. Select -> Right click -> Search with Google -> Click.
- kristianp 8y agoYouTube solved the problem of piracy enablers getting sued out of existence.
- davio 8y agoI was always amazed by the old jazz recordings that were never released on CD but were on Napster. Somebody cared enough to convert vinyl to mp3.
- ds0 8y agoSince my genre of choice is dance music, I use Soulseek, which I think has done a great job of carrying Napster's torch. The trouble is that many of the tracks I'm into come from the personal collections of assorted DJs or diggers on Youtube, so obscure tracks are often in poor quality: I've had to resort to using Discogs to purchase the original vinyls and recording them through a sound card. I am not yet a pro at digitally cleaning up some of the minute crackling that occurs, and buying a brush to clean the records hasn't helped much...
- joe_fishfish 8y agoI love Soulseek. I love that it's basically identical to Napster and still works great.
- lostgame 8y ago>> I've had to resort to using Discogs to purchase the original vinyls and recording them through a sound card. I am not yet a pro at digitally cleaning up some of the minute crackling that occurs, and buying a brush to clean the records hasn't helped much... Source: vinyl junkie, vinyl DJ, professional audio engineer and girl who presses her own vinyl here in Toronto - You really have to acetate wash your records and only use the highest quality gear. There's little you can do beyond that. If a record is messed after you acetone it, unfortunately removing the crackle sounds is kinda going in and modifying the original sound itself. You don't really know what else you're getting rid of. I use a Pioneer PLX-500 which has a built-in USB. I generally get an extremely low level of noise especially off of new LP's.
- CharlesW 8y ago> There's little you can do beyond that. Depending on how much you want to spend, some flavor of iZotope RX will let you de-crackle and perform other types of audio restoration in a very transparent way.
- lostgame 8y agoThe nostalgia for this UI/UX is astounding. These were truly golden days of a sort.
- diminoten 8y agoReminds me a little bit of Battle.net...
- flukus 8y agoThis seems like something that would be held up as an example of why programmers shouldn't do the UI but I think I'd hold it up as an example of why they should. Those buttons along the top look like an early implementation of tabs or a stack switcher that are common today. The search interface doesn't infantalize the user. I bet if you changed the windows theme it would match as well.
- borski 8y ago“I could go on and on about how I feel mp3's promote the sales of CDs, but that's an argument for another day.” Yeah. That worked out. ;)