8 ms·
We demand BuzzFeed pay out earned paid time off to its recent laid-off employees
- sct202 8y agoThere really needs to be more national level laws around PTO. Like my current employer has a policy to pay it out, but recently they've decided to cut our maximum rollovers from 6+ weeks (150% of accrual) to 1 week maximum from year to year. First world problems but this year I'm going to be taking a ton of days off. I mean sure they can do that, but why can't we just have a set rule and stick with it?
- zaroth 8y agoThere’s just one paragraph missing. If PTO isn’t paid out on termination, then PTO cannot be safely accrued. The undersigned should state that this behavior leaves them with no choice but to draw down their PTO balance, perhaps starting a specific day next week. But I wonder if the employees that weren’t in a state which requires paying out PTO balances had expected to be paid their PTO balance? Usually this is one of those things that’s addressed in the employment contract.
- hoaw 8y agoI am guessing they didn't expect to get laid off. Employment contracts can be tricky to negotiate, since at that point you usually want the job. It also isn't something most people do regularly or even know much about. Especially not if they are relatively young.
- adetrest 8y agoThe US is just nuts. Are you saying that your earned but unused PTO doesn't have to be paid out to you when you're laid off but is rather at the discretion of the employer? How is that justifiable in any way? Does the bank owe you accrued interest when you close your account or is it up to them to pay it? Why would it be different for PTO?
- coderintherye 8y agoIt's state by state. New York allows it based on the contract. California is explicit that earned PTO must be paid.
- golergka 8y ago> How is that justifiable in any way? My understanding is that it is stated in the contract.
- db48x 8y agoNon-salary benefits used to be extremely uncommon in the USA. During WW2, price and wage controls were enacted that made it illegal to increase prices for many types of goods, or salaries for many types of employees. This made it almost impossible for employers to find enough employees, so they started finding creative ways to sweeten the deal besides just increasing salary. Thus, virtually everyone now gets health insurance from an insurance company chosen by their employer rather than one they choose themselves, we tip workers that do certain jobs rather than paying them a normal wage, time off is negotiated ahead of time, etc.
- catacombs 8y ago> How is that justifiable in any way? Simply: Corporate greed. Or, executives trying to save any penny they can, so if the company is ever gobbled up by a large conglomerate, such as NBC or Combast, or merged with another media company, people like Jonah Peretti, Lenke Taylor and Ben Smith can laugh their way to the bank.
- rwz 8y agoAt my first job in US I had about a year and a half of unused PTO accumulated. I gave my two week notice like a good team player I was and then left on the agreed upon date. I obviously didn't get any of the PTO paid to me and in retrospect realize that I could have just taken my last two weeks off with the same outcome. I was so sure that there must be some law that would force employer to pay out unused PTO, that I haven't even thought about researching it in advance. This was a rude "welcome to United States, bitch" awakening for me.
- cperciva 8y agoThis seems like an excellent thing to ask for the next time they're negotiating a contract. But it seems a bit late to complain about the terms of a contract after said contract has ended.
- maxerickson 8y agoThat's pretty much the classic mistake individuals make when dealing with businesses though. There's no reason to restrict yourself to the legal system and terms of a contract if you think you have leverage enough to do better.
- maxerickson 8y agoSee: https://www.cnn.com/2019/01/28/media/buzzfeed-layoffs-pto/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2019/01/28/media/buzzfeed-layoffs-pto/in...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- loraa 8y agoGuess fake news isn't too profitable. Even HuffPo, Vice and others of that genre seem to be having financial issues.
- brokensegue 8y agoi thought this was the law? Edit: oh only in CA
- chuckgreenman 8y agoIt is, in California. Most states don't have that requirement though.
- minimaxir 8y agoIt’s worth noting many CA BuzzFeed employees (including myself) signed the petition.
- exogeny 8y agoMax, what is your take on what's going on? Would love an insider's perspective, to the extent that you're comfortable with giving it.
- minimaxir 8y agoOther BF employees on Twitter (and recently-laid off employees) attest to the current mood better than I can. https://twitter.com/search?q=https%3A%2F%2Fmedium.com%2F%40BuzzFeedNewsStaffCouncil%2Fletter-to-buzzfeed-pto-layoffs-f79d9c857a21&src=typed_query https://twitter.com/search?q=https%3A%2F%2Fmedium.com%2F%40B...
- karlakush 8y agoIf they wanted to get paid PTO after being fired, they should have signed a contract that paid them PTO upon termination. Sleazy company employs stupid people. I don't really care who wins this one.
- pointillistic 8y agoThe same people who wouldn't think twice about some PC expose that ruins a person's life forever, same people will fight for a couple days vacation time... Before you down-vote, what am I missing?
- ggm 8y agoYou missed that people are employed with rights to accrue leave, but only some have it bound in states rights laws and that BuzzFeed is trying to avoid honouring the spirit of employment conditions their staff worked under?
- mc32 8y agoI think they’re saying if they played loose with ethics in their management encouraging suspect reporting that one can expect the same ethics when it comes to their business end of things.
- ggm 8y agoYea.. that would make sense: be careful who you work for, lest the conditions of employment turn out to reflect a side of things you normally saw turned on others?
- beezischillin 8y agoSounds similar to Vice Media and their sexual harassment problem... I really wish these companies did a lot better because honestly now I just feel cynical about paying attention to what they’re publishing that I just try and avoid online media altogether.
- thebradbain 8y ago> BuzzFeed is trying to avoid honouring the spirit of employment conditions their staff worked under Which on its own could support the idea that if a corporation can't self-govern to be fair to its current and former employees without asterisks and gotchas, some greater (e.g. government) or counter (e.g. union) authority should hold the company accountable. I do believe that all BuzzFeed employees should be entitled to their PTO if they were misled to believe they would get it when they worked there. As for whether unionization or more regulation is necessary here, I do not know enough about the issue to form a strong opinion -- the above observation was just an observation.
- ggm 8y agoWhy, why do so many "trendy" companies shit on workers rights?
- catacombs 8y agoThey prey on the young. Look at BuzzFeed's staff demographic. A lot of them are younger than 35. Five years ago, BuzzFeed, at least in the journalism community, seemed like the place to be: the company was growing, their news team was just getting off the ground and the resources seemed endless. One would think the traffic brought in by Disney princess quizzes would pay the bills. Sadly, that is not the case. Video is still king over there. I'd be curious to know how many videographers and video editors lost their jobs compared to reporters.
- n-exploit 8y agoBecause it's a company with at-will employment. Businesses are operational functions that maximize value for a pool of shareholders. Unless you're in the pool, you're a cost and a liability.
- geofft 8y agoBecause just as individual contributors change employers a lot, managers also change employers often enough that the reputation of mistreating workers doesn't stick to anything. My own employer recently hired a handful of senior HR folks from Uber. They started after I joined. I hate it, but what can I do? I know they were present at Uber during Susan Fowler's very strange year; I don't know if they were actually the people making decisions. And if I preemptively quit, what is my guarantee that the next place will be any better?
- ykevinator 8y agoEven though buzz feed is awful and just contributes to cultural obesity, they should pay people accrued pto. This is a lowlife move.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- apl002 8y agoyep i fully agree with you
- gerbal 8y agoMaybe they BuzzFeed's remaining employees should unionize to keep this same shit from happening to them.
- hedora 8y agoIf they go that route, I hope they have the sense to create their own union instead of going with one of the giant established organizations.
- catacombs 8y agoEasier said than done.
- onetimemanytime 8y agoAnother company tried that: "News workers unionized. Days later, they were jobless. Was it payback?" https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2017/nov/04/dnainfo-gothamist-union-ricketts-shutdown https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2017/nov/04/dnainfo-goth...
- cribbles 8y agoSee also Mic,[1] which laid off its entire editorial staff in response to the formation of a union (but prior to a contract being signed). For counterexamples, see Vice,[2] which negotiated a nearly 30% pay hike in their first union contract, and Slate,[3] whose editorial union recently negotiated a $51,000 starting salary with annual pay increases. Note that a union is not a guarantee against layoffs. See [4]: the Huffington Post recently lost 15 of its unionized employees to a layoff. On the upside, they were contractually guaranteed severance pay - because they collectively bargained for it. [1] https://www.businessinsider.com/mic-layoff-bustle-union-labor https://www.businessinsider.com/mic-layoff-bustle-union-labo... [2] https://gawker.com/vice-writers-get-a-union-contract-with-a-big-raise-1771276669 https://gawker.com/vice-writers-get-a-union-contract-with-a-... [3] https://wwd.com/business-news/media/slate-media-editorial-staff-union-deal-1202965162/ https://wwd.com/business-news/media/slate-media-editorial-st... [4] https://twitter.com/HuffPostUnion/status/1088524725259628544 https://twitter.com/HuffPostUnion/status/1088524725259628544
- born_a_beetle 8y agoread your contract when you get hired, people. You shouldn't expect anything more than what's guaranteed right there in front of you.
- reasonablemann 8y agoThe funny thing is a lot of people think the company they work for cares about their wellbeing. When you realize they don't care about you, they will feel it. And your pay will go up. I guarantee.
- catacombs 8y agoYou mind elaborating on this? Are you saying the mentality is to just show up, do the job within the allotted day then head home, knowing the company doesn't owe you thing, no matter how many extra hours you put in?
- sundaeofshock 8y agoSeems like a good idea to me. Why go above and beyond when the company won’t do the same for you?
- el_dev_hell 8y agoThis x1000. If a benefit isn't spelled out in black and white, it should be considered non-existent. Example: I used to get a ham at Christmas time. This was a gift from the company (i.e not in my contact). We had a bad year in 2017 and there was no ham - that's fine.
- jobigoud 8y agoHow is paying what's due a "benefit"?
- moftz 8y agoPTO is a benefit since there is no law that it has to be given out. Paying out PTO after you leave is another thing that isn't mandated so therefore it's a benefit. PTO and the payout of the balance shouldn't be a benefit, it should be the law.
- andrew_ 8y agoI've worked for many companies that don't pay out accrued PTO - PTO at those companies was use-it-or-lose-it. But I also understood that going in, and I understood that when I read the employee handbooks and explanation of benefits. It seems folks might have overlooked that bit of their employment. California is obviously a large exception. However, if an employer doesn't state that you get a particular benefit, or fails to explain how a benefit is managed, the onus falls on the employee to understand what they're signing on for. To expect otherwise drips of entitlement.
- minimaxir 8y agoOne of the issues here is that PTO isn't always easy to use. > No one at BuzzFeed told me not to use PTO. I had a lot saved because I was busy and wanted to be there for my team. https://twitter.com/FranBerkman/status/1089675336407752704 https://twitter.com/FranBerkman/status/1089675336407752704 > I have worked more holidays than I can count, and have gone on tough reporting trips where I’ve worked 16-hour days for days in a row. > I have about a month’s worth of comp days as a result. If I’d been laid off Friday, I wouldn’t have gotten paid for it. https://twitter.com/juliareinstein/status/1089672068923314176 https://twitter.com/juliareinstein/status/108967206892331417...
- andrew_ 8y agoYes, that all boils down to accountability for one's own choices. They made poor choices, that's just what it is. Now they're clamoring for something that wasn't promised to them. There's a degree of responsibility that these folks are tossing out the window in favor of entitlement.
- andrew_ 8y agoAh, and here come the downvotes. Mention responsibility and entitlement, and get hammered here.
- fzeroracer 8y agoPlease read up on the guidelines of HN. I really hate to backseat mod but I've seen a sharp rise in people complaining about their posts being downvoted and it adds absolutely nothing to the conversation.
- solarkraft 8y agoA company does no more than what's required by the law. I'm not sure I can get upset about that.
- Joky 8y agoCan we get upset at the (lack of) law?
- solarkraft 8y agoYes.
- dagw 8y agoDo you extend this sentiment to people as well? Or do you sometimes get upset when people do evil or immoral thing that technically stays on the right side of the law?
- solarkraft 8y agoI do if I don't know or trust them. Of course I can dislike those people and stop my dealing with them, but I can't really be surprised they're doing something they're allowed to do.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- jaak 8y agoThe company I currently work at uses the term "awarded" instead of accrued for PTO. This is their way of justifying not paying out unused PTO at termination (ie. it was not "earned" therefor they don't have to pay it out).
- Overtonwindow 8y agoSuggested title: Laid off Buzzfeed reporters write Medium post. You’ll never guess what happens next!
- jorgec 8y agoThey are not mentioning that Buzzfeed is paying a minimum of 10 weeks of salary.