10 ms·
Toyota Finally Has the Power in Electric Cars
- syntaxing 8y agoI've been waiting for one of the big Japanese automaker to make a reputable electric car. I'm hopeful for 2020 especially after Toyota announced that they're joining NVIDIA's DRIVE. An electric car that has Level 2 self driving capabilities and 200 mile range under $30000 would be awesome.
- bulletsvshumans 8y agoThe Nissan Leaf is a fairly well regarded all-electric car. I've been very happy with mine.
- ajford 8y agoI loved mine for a while, but the range was a problem for me. I traded it in for a Chevy Volt (2017), and don't regret it. The Leaf is fantastic, and will qualify that I had a 2011 model, so my range was ~45 miles due to degradation. Sadly I didn't make it in the recall range, so no replacement for me. I've heard that people with the 2013+ have better range and reliability (and less or unnoticeable degradation). I wish more manufacturers would consider plug-in hybrids with more range. 40mi electric seems like a perfect compromise between electric range and reduced weight.
- throw0u1t 8y agoI don't understand why you're being downvoted, this sounds a like perfectly reasonable comment.
- ajford 8y agoI just assume it's people not agreeing. The Leaf gets a bad rap, and a lot of hate. Nissan put a lot of great work into that car, and it doesn't get much recognition thanks to other developments in the recent years. They've been steadily increasing range (I think they're in the ~70mi range now), and have a much higher charging rate than others (Volt included, sadly). If it wasn't for the guess-o-meter (range gauge) being so unreliable, and the degradation, I would have held on to my Leaf. But my range vehicle (an '08 Prius) was starting to need some more maintenance, and the Leaf became problematic if I needed to run any errands after work.
- bulletsvshumans 8y agoMy wife has a conventional car, so we use hers for anything requiring an especially long drive, which only really happens maybe four times a year. I never hit the ~72 mile range of my 2015 in the course of my normal day. I feel like having access to a gas vehicle for rare occasions is the missing ingredient that makes fully electric cars viable for a large portion of the population. Maybe there's a market opportunity there.
- ajford 8y agoAgreed! My average day left me with about 10mi range out of about 45mi, which caused some amount of stress if I had to deviate from my normal day to run an errand or something similar. If I had to stop for groceries on the way home, I'd end up limping home in turtle mode, which was nerve wracking. My wife was driving an 08 prius at the time, which served as our long range car, but her work commute was about 40mi round trip, so if she had to run AC/Heat, she wouldn't make the round trip on the Leaf if I had to swap cars for the day. Now she drives the Volt, and the 53mi range seems perfect. She usually gets home with 10-15mi range, and the ICE eliminates range anxiety. Rental is always an option, and was something we considered if we were to get another BEV, but we routinely take 300mi round trips, so it would't economical.
- cptskippy 8y agoYikes! Only 45 miles? I have a 2015 Leaf and it gets anywhere from 75-92 miles depending on who is driving.
- ajford 8y agoYeah, and 45 was the high side. It often seemed closer to 38-40. I live in a hot climate, so the car was an oven without AC, which meant the range was reduced. But yeah, the early models had much worse degradation, on top of their lower range (expected on an early model, since it was new tech).
- dougmany 8y agoMy 2014 with 41,000 miles is about 87% capacity according to leafspy. This puts it at around 73 miles which handles about 80% of our driving.
- throwaway12iii 8y agoThe biggest selling electric car is from Japan. The Nissan leaf. Yes, you used the weasel word "reputable" - but what better reputation is there than having the most sales? Nissan from Japan sells the most electric cars. Apart from sales, the Nissan Leaf scores 7-8/10 and 4/5 from the critics. Which is around the same as the Tesla model 3. If the critics think they are ok, and they sell the most of all electric cars... then they can be considered reputable.
- technofiend 8y agoHe also mentioned a 200 mile range, which the Leaf is still working towards; Nissan's website clearly states the latest Leaf has a 150 mile range [1]. I've been lusting after all electric cars for a while including the Leaf but range is definitely a concern. Kudos to Tesla for breaking open the market and creating all electric cars with 200+ mile range. But I'm with the original poster in that I want 200+ miles and a quality product with no fit and finish issues or supply-chain problems when there's a breakdown. Tesla has one of three right now and eventually the majors will catch up. [1] https://www.nissanusa.com/vehicles/electric-cars/leaf/range-charging.html https://www.nissanusa.com/vehicles/electric-cars/leaf/range-...
- andrewmunsell 8y agoFor anyone interetsed, the Leaf E-Plus is coming within the next couple months with a 200 mile range: https://insideevs.com/leaf-e-plus-nissan-joins-200-mile-club/ https://insideevs.com/leaf-e-plus-nissan-joins-200-mile-club... There's still no active battery cooling though, which is a disappointment.
- technofiend 8y agoParticularly in hot climates there's concern both around battery performance and actual range. Practically speaking you need to factor in climate control use when driving, which lowers range.
- athenot 8y ago
- johnatwork 8y agoFor City driving or as a second car. A used Nissan Leaf is an incredible value, I'm saving about 200~250 a month in what I would have used in gas.
- ed_balls 8y agoWhy wouldn't you buy plugin hybrid Prius then? It cost 30k, range is not an issue and I wouldn't be surprised if your total Co2 would be similar to Tesla model 3 (it varies by location and how much you drive, but creating the battery produces a lot of Co2)
- lukeschlather 8y agoPersonally, I don't commute by car, so really a majority of the miles I drive would probably be all-gasoline given the plug-in's meager 12 miles of electric range. So a used Prius is far cheaper and also more efficient for me.
- ed_balls 8y agoYou can do 30 miles all electric in a new Prius (with a solar panel on roof). If you drive very little renting a car could make more sense.
- timbit42 8y agoA Prius isn't very efficient for about the first 5 minutes of a trip. I believe this has to do with the engine warming up. I live in a small town so most of my trips are under 5 minutes. I get much better fuel economy on the highway.
- ajford 8y agoThe PHEV Prii have such a paltry range. Even the newest models have ~30mi IIRC. If you happen to have a very short commute, or very little traffic, they might be a good fit, but I feel like you really need to be in the 50-60mi electric range to make much sense.
- danw1979 8y agoI just bought a 2013 PiP and knew the EV range was < 10 miles. What I like about it is: - on my 65 mile round trip commute I get a +10mpg increase if I leave home with a full charge and without charging at work. - I get the lovely EV driving experience for the 4 miles in and out of the city I work in. - I'm not contributing to poor urban air quality. - Its fully charged with 10 miles in 90 minutes. At weekends I frequently find that I make more than 30 miles of all-EV journeys around my home town.
- dpflan 8y agoHow big of a deal is this? How will battery technology be impacted? What did Tesla's open-sharing of their patents do to the landscape?
- Neil44 8y agoStrange that Toyota were so early with the hybrid cars, the Prius came out over 20 years ago. But they are now behind with full BEV's. Hydrogen just hasn't got the momentum at the moment.
- rcMgD2BwE72F 8y ago>Strange that Toyota were so early with the hybrid cars, the Prius came out over 20 years ago. https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/compliance_car https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/compliance_car
- rcMgD2BwE72F 8y agoAFAIK, the Panasonic deal is only to Chinese Toyota subsidiaries. Toyota still does not intend to manufacture battery electric vehicles and still pretend the auto market will fully switch to hydrogen first (as crazy as it sounds).
- daddylonglegs 8y agoLast year there were reports that the Tesla/Panasonic batteries in the Tesla Model 3 contained much less cobalt and that this was a significant competitive advantage for Tesla. Does anyone know if the enabling technology is Tesla's (or exclusive to Tesla through their agreement with Panasonic)? If not, will this be available to Toyota for use in their cars?
- gamblor956 8y agoIt will not be a competitive advantage for Tesla and the low-cobalt cells will be available to Toyota. Panasonic makes and designs the cells (the part with the cobalt), Tesla just arranges those cells into a battery (adds control systems, cooling, framing etc.)
- rcMgD2BwE72F 8y ago> It will not be a competitive advantage for Tesla and the low-cobalt cells will be available to Toyota. source?
- sabujp 8y agorange isn't even a concern, make them charge in 10 mins please! I'd be fine having a car that can go ~100mi but can charge in a short time and have a battery that will hold those specs for at least 7 years
- athenot 8y agoIn practice, I found charge time to be irrelevant as long as I can get it fully charged overnight. I didn't even bother installing a fast charger in my garage since the trickle charge was good enough for my needs. A longer range means you can forget to plug it in one evening and be fine. Or you can go on a longer day trip. For some reason many of us think we absolutely need to handle driving across the country; I'm sure some do but most of us don't. As a suburbanite who only occasionally travels long distance, this has not been an issue.
- masklinn 8y ago> range isn't even a concern, make them charge in 10 mins please! Range absolutely is a concern. I've pretty much no use for a car which only goes 100mi but don't mind overnight charging in the slightest. I'm waiting for EVs to do 600 miles on a charge at highway speed, with heating and/or AC.
- cptskippy 8y agoYou're going to be waiting a long time. EVs do not perform well at highways speeds so your ask is ridiculous. A 600 mile range use-case is a boundary condition at best as there are few ICE vehicles that can even achieve that. EV aren't going to eliminate the need for ICE vehicles but they should easily be able to accommodate 90-95% of the market. The biggest barrier to EV adoption currently is people incorrectly thinking they need a 200-300 mile range since that's what their ICE vehicle currently gets. We're a two car family and when we got the Leaf it was initially my commuter car (~25 miles one way) but quickly became our primary vehicle. We still had an ICE vehicle that was also used as a commuter but we ceased using it almost entirely beyond that. Last fall we sold our ICE vehicle and bought another EV and our lives have been so much better for it. Our biggest concerns now are how to transport lumber home from the home center as we no longer have a junker.
- MikeCapone 8y agoToyota has squandered its huge lead in hybrids and is now quite late to EVs. I'm glad to see them make these moves, but this should've happened over 10 years ago. These things take time.
- megaman8 8y agothey didn't simply ignore it. they tried EVs before, there simply wasn't much demand for it at the time. Now that batteries are cheaper, things are starting to look different.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Toyota has squandered its huge lead in hybrids and is now quite late to EVs. Toyota is somewhat late to battery powered pure EVs (ignoring the limited RAV4 EV contemporary to the GM EV1 and Honda EV+), because they were heavily invested both hybrids, including PHEVs, and hydrogen fuel cell vehicles. OTOH, other than advanced battery tech, they aren't late to anything involved in battery-powered pure EVs (PHEVs have a superset of the needs of pure EVs, and fuel cell vehicles are pure EVs), but that's just a matter of making a deal with Panasonic, which they've done now, per the story—their competitors don't have exclusive special sauce here.
- rcMgD2BwE72F 8y agoThey made a deal with Panasonic for quite a small % of their production (Chinese brands only)
- gamblor956 8y agoEVs still make up only a fraction of a percent of the global or domestic auto markets. Toyota has plenty of time to catch up, especially given Tesla's inability to properly execute.
- rcMgD2BwE72F 8y ago>especially given Tesla's inability to properly execute. Why established manufacturer proved to be better at producing EV than Tesla? Tesla is producing more than 50% of all battery capacity in the world (China included) and this % keeps growing. It's been a decade since we started hearing "competition is coming", "these are the Tesla killer" and yet none made a dent in Tesla's sales (which are doubling every two years and should grow faster with Model Y).
- _bxg1 8y agoReally glad we're shedding our dependence on Tesla to shoulder the future of the electric car industry. This is probably the single most important anti-climate-change measure the world is taking right now, and it'd be a shame if it lost steam because of Elon's breakdown. But I think Tesla managed to get the snowball rolling just in time.
- advertising 8y agoBill's stat on how many gas powered cars would need to be taken off the road (exchanged for electric) to equal the emissions of a single coal plant blew my mind. https://mobile.twitter.com/billgates/status/1052914693042450432?lang=en https://mobile.twitter.com/billgates/status/1052914693042450...
- _bxg1 8y agoThat is eye-opening, although: > even if clean energy supplied all the power, over 1.5 million people would still have to switch So it does factor in the current state of electricity-generation, which makes a big difference. I guess the way I've always looked at it is, the energy industry has a big head start (and much more flexibility) in moving to clean sources than cars do. It's really hard to: 1) Create a cultural change for billions of individual people 2) Replace the infrastructure of fueling stations 3) Create the technologies to make electric motors and storage feasible on a moving platform, where space and weight are at a premium Each of those things has its own powerful network-effect holding it in place. While not easy per say, I think the energy sector has much more opportunity to branch out. If you want to try out clean nuclear energy, you just decide to make your next plant a nuclear one. I honestly think one of Tesla's greatest contributions to the world - on par with its battery innovations - was making electric cars "cool". I think this was the core genius behind Musk's business plan. Much as we'd like to think otherwise, car culture in America has always been one of the greatest barriers to adoption of non-fossil-fuel vehicles; in the past, hybrids and electrics have always been boxy nerd-wagons. Elon said, "let's start with an exotic sports car". He broke that most entrenched of barriers and I think that's what really got the ball rolling.
- Scoundreller 8y agoAssuming drivers have access to plug-in charging, I doubt the large-scale need for 150 mile+ ranges, or even 100. There will be a market for short-duration exchanges between ICE and short-range electric car owners for long trips. Or just rentals of long-range vehicles (or trunk-battery-packs) for those with short-range vehicles that meet 99% of their needs.
- WorldMaker 8y agoOr an increased demand for long-range travel systems such as airplanes, buses, railroads, and/or zeppelins. America has fetishized the long distance road trip for a long time, but it's not the only way to travel.
- deagle50 8y agoCall me when there's an affordable Tesla alternative with RWD/AWD. Torque steer is bad enough with ICEs.
- danw1979 8y agoI used to think the Hybrid Synergy Drive in the Prius and other Toyota hybrids was a fancy name for an electric motor bolted onto the gearbox of a regular ICE car. I’ve owned several Prii over many years. For those interested here’s a great video explaining how it really works. It blew my mind... https://youtu.be/E_xCssR8qQI https://youtu.be/E_xCssR8qQI