6 ms·
Who decides which sites have "real" news and which sites have "fake" news? A big thing missing from these discussions is the history of propaganda. I think a
by ilaksh 8y ago
Who decides which sites have "real" news and which sites have "fake" news?
A big thing missing from these discussions is the history of propaganda. I think a lot of people who are worried about "fake news" need to research that term.
Propaganda is still very prevalent especially as far as war goes. Do people really think that CNN tells them the real reasons for going to war? They will say whatever the Pentagon tells them. Why? Because no one is going to risk their lives and kill other people for some technical, strategic reason or just as part of a larger military campaign. People risk their lives to fight the "bad guys" who are "evil". They need to believe its a moral cause.
Don't let some giant company (or a small one) dictate what source your information comes from. If I used a Microsoft browser I would uninstall that plugin. Assuming that's an option.
- phjesusthatguy3 8y ago>Who decides which sites have "real" news and which sites have "fake" news? https://www.newsguardtech.com/about/team/ https://www.newsguardtech.com/about/team/
- m348e912 8y agoRT ran an interesting peice on NewsGuard. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZkY9fMK26dE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZkY9fMK26dE
- tptacek 8y agoWell, not that I love being this glib, but, I guess now I know what the Russian government wants me to think about NewsGuard. Also: because WaPo and NYT have issued corrections about Deripaska stories, they're "repeat offenders" who "publish lies" (their citation: Fox News). Also, according to the chyron, I should be really scared of Islam.
- Bartweiss 8y agoIt's a reasonable criticism of RT, but it's amusing how thoroughly it cuts both ways: we now know what the Russian government wants us to think about NewsGuard, and also what a team of former US government officials want us to think about RT. That's not to say RT is a usable source, I'm not particularly interested in their coverage here. But I'm also not very interested in hearing what news Michael Hayden wants me to listen to.
- tptacek 8y agoI don't as much need to care what the US government thinks, because the US government doesn't fund any of its best known media companies. As you can pretty clearly see, most of the US news media market works in opposition to the current US administration.
- dingaling 8y agoIt doesn't matter if us.gov funds media or not if third-parties are nudging people to only trust sources acting in the US interest. Sure they might oppose the sitting President but would they publish something which would undermine stated US diplomatic policy?
- acqq 8y ago> Also, according to the chyron, I should be really scared of Islam. Citation needed. It almost seems that you invented something just as an attempt to demotivate people from taking a look. Normally I don't watch videos, but this time I got curious, and I've seen only "Belgian Imam embroiled in the scandal" in the chyron. But while checking that, I've found out that the video has some real points: - Co-founder of the NewsGuard: former columnist of the Wall Street Journal, for which EFF wrote that he "repeatedly gets his facts wrong about the NSA surveillance." - In Advisory Board: Michael Hayden, former NSA and CIA director, Tom Ridge, former First secretary of Homeland Security, Richard Stengel, former Undersecretary of State for Public Diplomacy
- arijun 8y agoYou should also read the RT pieces on how Crimea liberated itself, and how Putin won every election fair and square
- amaccuish 8y ago> how Putin won every election fair and square Maybe there was some tampering here and there but I got the impression when I lived there that most people thought he was good and supported him.
- jqt 8y agoSome people in the west are shocked when they find out people can also be happy when they don't live in liberal democracies, like Russia, China or SK.
- pvg 8y agothere was some tampering here and there Systematically and violently suppressing any political opposition is a lot more than 'some tampering here and there'.
- Shivetya 8y agoa list of names provides not real context to "who" decides. For the most part people will dismiss them quickly when the outcome does not match their personal views. so both sides will simply find examples to further their beliefs. for the most part these services are both circle the wagon and circle jerk in nature. circle the wagon because journalist of the same beliefs want to protect each other and circle jerk because their choices will simply be beneficial to those they already agree with. the public as I mentioned before will just dismiss it as more of the same. the internet is good at holding them to account and they don't like it.
- avn2109 8y agoDoes this organization have a published definition of "Fake News?" I suspect not, because in general, nobody can agree on a definition of it.
- wonthegame 8y agoI think people tend to categorize obvious exaggerations as fake news but in reality fake news is much more subtle than that.
- kbenson 8y agoJust because the public can't come to a definition, doesn't mean that a small group can't come to consensus about what it is with regard to what they can police. It may not match your definition, but it could be well defined. That said, I have no idea if they have done so.
- macintux 8y agoIf you look at the criteria they’re using, “fake news” isn’t one of them.
- raxxorrax 8y agoSince they are a team, they are already destined to fail. A team tends to gravitate to a particular position. So they will fail not only because nobody uses Edge.
- matt4077 8y agoCheck the Daily Mail, which apparently runs afoul of this plugin, and compare it to the NYT, or Economist. If you can‘t immediately spot the difference, you may be a late victim of post-modern relativism. They also have transparent documentation of their ratings. Example: https://www.newsguardtech.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/07/rt.com_.pdf https://www.newsguardtech.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/07/rt....
- arethuza 8y agoThe problem with that approach is that even the Daily Mail occasionally publishes something decent - e.g. this article on Clement Attlee: https://www.dailymail.co.uk/debate/article-3174009/DOMINIC-SANDBROOK-Labour-s-greatest-leader-teach-squabbling-pygmies.html https://www.dailymail.co.uk/debate/article-3174009/DOMINIC-S...
- RankingMember 8y agoIf a clock's broken and thus is right only twice a day, is it a clock worth keeping? The Daily Mail made its bed and it should have to lie in it.
- nailer 8y agoSure, but every other major news source has also published something verifiably false. Pick your poison.
- isostatic 8y agoSo two sources One is 95% truth, 5% they get wrong and apologise One is 95% lies, and 5% they get it right Which do you read?
- nailer 8y agoIt depends on the impact of the lies. The Guardian's Mark Duggan headline was the subject of a PCC complaint awarded against them, see https://www.theguardian.com/media/2012/feb/23/pcc-guardian-mark-duggan-headline https://www.theguardian.com/media/2012/feb/23/pcc-guardian-m... This could have easily led to more violence. This week The Washington Post recently published the false narrative against a 16 year old boy approached by a native man at a protest (saying that he'd approached and threatened the man), resulting in thousands of violent threats against a child. 'Proper' journalism doesn't exist. Maybe it never did, it's just more obvious now. It's news entertainment.
- schnevets 8y agoIt's all so disappointing because there are straightforward, objective rules that could dismiss a lot of these sites. Inform readers if the site was registered in the last 3 months, or claims to be Colorado-based but has a Bulgarian IP address, or plagiarized a bunch of articles from a different source. It may not shut down all forms of manipulated information, but it can stymie the flow of procedurally-generated blogs that are triggering so much confusion.
- sametmax 8y agoGiven that microsoft has itself a long history of propaganda, I'm extra suspicious.
- mtgx 8y agoApparently, "former" NSA agents.
- ilaksh 8y agoWhy do you say that? Is there some evidence? Edit: I see. One of the advisory board is the former director of the NSA. They also have a political analyst for NBC on their board. So I'm sure they are objective about NBC. https://www.newsguardtech.com/our-advisory-board/ https://www.newsguardtech.com/our-advisory-board/