10 ms·
The card payment industry duopoly (in europe at least) is a really weird one that seems to go mostly unnoticed. I often wonder how much goes into the pockets o
by dijit 8y ago
The card payment industry duopoly (in europe at least) is a really weird one that seems to go mostly unnoticed.
I often wonder how much goes into the pockets of these companies who are essentially providing an easily replaceable service if it were not for the entrenched reality. (IE; to compete you'd need an entirely new card system that would be incompatible with the others, and thus your card would be unusable in most places)
That said, I can't complain too much about VISA; which (Apple Pay and Samsung Pay also uses on the backend, there is no escape in Europe) -- they seem to be processing things fairly well, even if I don't understand how much both parties paying for such a service.
- rfinney 8y ago"easily replaceable service" Yeah. It's called "cash" and "checks".
- seattle_spring 8y agoJust like Tesla would be easily replaceable with "horse" and "buggy".
- miluge 8y agoBut Tesla doesnt have a monopoly...
- FiveSquared 8y agoBut cars do over walking and biking!
- vvillena 8y agoYeah, in the same way that a washing machine can be replaced by a river and a piece of wood. As the parent comment explains, nearly every electronic money system in Europe uses Visa or Mastercard as a backend, creating a unhealthy duopoly. The free market needs some competition so it can thrive.
- blattimwind 8y agoAIUI the two largely act as a fallback and the relevant interbank network (e.g. Girocard) is used directly if possible.
- Someone 8y ago”nearly every electronic money system in Europe uses Visa or Mastercard as a backend” I think that’s nearly every credit card system. Many countries have debit card systems that, AFAIK 100% outside of Visa and MasterCard, traditionally work across most banks in the countries, and nowadays work across the Single European Payment Area (28 EU countries plus six others. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Single_Euro_Payments_Area https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Single_Euro_Payments_Area).
- bluejekyll 8y agoI’ve always found the difference between cash and credit to be a wash in terms of ease of use. For cash you need to always make sure you stop by an ATM. For credit you have to wait for a receipt after nearly every transaction, and sign (this is changing with chipped cards). But ApplePay is actually more pleasant than both. I can pay with my phone and my watch. It is a faster transaction than both cash and credit, and no need to pull my wallet out. With one big exception! There are a few places in the city that are starting to only accept credit/applepay/etc., but when their terminals go offline, they’re screwed. I saw this exact thing, for some reason they had no backup system to accept cash. I assume this is a rare issue, but still, I couldn’t believe they couldn’t resort to cash.
- rtkwe 8y ago> I saw this exact thing, for some reason they had no backup system to accept cash To accept cash as a back up you have to have all the items in place to accept it all the time basically. You need the register and to have enough cash on hand to cover giving change plus the accounting and tracking at the end of the day to make sure cash hasn't walked. So if a place has the ability to accept cash intermittently they might as well accept it always.
- dalore 8y agoFor those that don't handle cash, they could get some sort of insurance to make up for lost business (and any brand damage) if the machines go down.
- bluejekyll 8y agoYeah, I realized that something along those lines is the issue. It's still surprising when a business can't operate in a situation like this.
- e12e 8y agoAt least in Norway most visa debit (and/or credit) cards now come with nfc/"tap" payment up to a certain amount (10-15 usd I think) - with no need for chip&pin for "Small" transactions. Has some issues wrt theft (portable pay terminal with boosted nfc signal/antenna) - but certainly convenient.
- SketchySeaBeast 8y ago"checks" being a clearly inferior option. While they are convenient they are fraught with fraud / bank balance issues, and add risk to the merchant and to the customer. They also take longer than any of the other options to create as well.
- Fre_d 8y agoHere in Denmark, the story is a bit different. Many consumers here use a Dankort, which is a national debit card. The fees are low and regulated by the government. It is usually combined with a Visa so that it can be used abroad as well.
- notimetorelax 8y agoIt’s similar in Switzerland, almost every shop accepts PostCard
- kodablah 8y agoAre there any consumer benefits, ala rewards, for using this card?
- thefounder 8y agoWho pays for these "consumer benefits"? Something tells me the consumer.
- Forbo 8y agoYeah, that was my interpretation. It sounds like the "low fees" is the consumer benefit. I'd rather everyone have lower rates than a select few being able to "game the system".
- kodablah 8y agoSure. The consumers do (at the end of the day), hence the fees. We also pay for the costs borne by them to resolve disputes, handle those that don't pay back, etc. Also hence the fees.
- krn 8y agoIn Europe, most cards are debit cards, not credit cards. In some countries and places, credit cards are not even accepted because of the possibility of a chargeback and much higher processing fees. In essence, many people here treat Visa / MasterCard as just "electronic cash", and therefore spend only the money they actually have. In my own EU country, only about 1% of private bank customers own a credit card. These are usually the wealthiest people in the country, who have no problems paying the balance back on time. The credit cards themselves provide very few benefits apart from the international health insurance for the entire family, and 0% fee for up to 45 days. The reward programs are almost non-existent. Just like the general idea of spending the money one doesn't have. It might sound like a very conservative society, but people here are a way more relaxed about their personal finances than in the US. Instead of trying to earn reward points, they try to plan their expenses upfront, and focus on staying debt-free as much as they can. That's because most Europeans have stable jobs with stable salaries which can neither grow, nor decline by a lot. Therefore, almost nobody expects to become very rich or very poor, and lives accordingly.
- chrismeller 8y agoOnly tangentially related, but it’s the same in the US. Sure Discover and Amex exist, but fees for merchants are usually high and adoption is lower. I’ve travelled quite a lot, but everywhere I’ve been there has been the same - Visa, MC, and a local alternative or two that might be popular within the country but don’t extend elsewhere. Is there actually any other network elsewhere in the world that is of a similar scale? I assume China must have something?
- BrunkBeard 8y agoChina mostly uses WeChat's payment system and Alibaba's Alipay on mobile devices.
- janekm 8y agoAnd for the direct equivalent of Visa/MC there's unionpay.
- yoz-y 8y agoMost merchants also prefer to take WeChat and AliPay because there are no fees.
- ceejayoz 8y agoNot sure why you're getting downvoted. NPR had a story on exactly this - China largely skipped credit cards and went straight for the mobile payments. https://www.npr.org/sections/alltechconsidered/2017/06/29/534846403/in-china-a-cashless-trend-is-taking-hold-with-mobile-payments https://www.npr.org/sections/alltechconsidered/2017/06/29/53...
- rfinney 8y agoIt's called "protectionism". China did the same thing by banning Google and supporting Baidu.
- ceejayoz 8y agoSort of. In Baidu's case, they're a locally grown replacement. Per the article, local credit systems didn't really take off; a researcher in the article states their belief it's due to different attitudes on debt in China.
- rb808 8y agofees are also much cheaper in Europe. Interchange fees are capped at 0.3%, compared to 2%+ in the US. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interchange_fee https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interchange_fee
- vmarsy 8y ago> The card payment industry duopoly (in europe at least) is a really weird one that seems to go mostly unnoticed. It goes unnoticed to the consumer because it didn't go unnoticed to the lawmakers. The EU caped the fees those companies can charge to merchants to 0.3% for credit card and 0.2% for debit card back in 2015 [1]. In the US it's less ignored because those fees to merchants are on average 10x bigger! (2% on average [2]) [1] http://europa.eu/rapid/press-release_IP-15-4585_en.htm http://europa.eu/rapid/press-release_IP-15-4585_en.htm [2] https://www.hostmerchantservices.com/current-us-interchange-rates/ https://www.hostmerchantservices.com/current-us-interchange-...
- tomjohnneill 8y agoThat's not quite true. The interchange fee is the portion of the fee that goes direct to the banks. The payment processing market is a bit more complicated: When you make a transaction: 1) Your bank charges Visa/Mastercard an interchange fee (this is the bit capped at 0.2%/0.3%) 2) Visa/Mastercard charge a payments acquirer a processing fee 3) The payments acquirer charges the merchant a fee - this final fee is likely to be a blend of percentage and fixed fee per transaction. There's no cap imposed here.
- AnssiH 8y agoIndeed. For example, here in Finland the VISA/MasterCard merchant rates for Nets, which I believe to be the largest provider: EU-domestic debit cards 0.31% (max 0.75€), EU-domestic consumer credit cards 0.90%, EU-domestic company credit cards 1.10%, foreign consumer debit cards 1.25%, foreign company credit cards 1.45%, foreign credit cards 1.65%. No per-transaction fees, but card readers have a monthly fee (39-53 EUR/mo). Finnish source: https://www.yrittajat.fi/uutiset/572780-maksupaatteet-hintavertailussa-izettle-nets-vai-verifone https://www.yrittajat.fi/uutiset/572780-maksupaatteet-hintav...
- CodeMage 8y agoCould you explain this a bit for those of us who don't know in depth how this works? For starters, what's a payments acquirer? Also, due to inherent ambiguity in English, I'm not sure whether your point #1 means that my bank imposes an interchange fee on Visa/Mastercard or whether they impose a Visa/Mastercard fee on someone else (and who it would be).
- spdionis 8y ago> easily replaceable service > to compete you'd need an entirely new card system that would be incompatible with the others, and thus your card would be unusable in most places That's basically the definition of hard to replace.
- MagnumOpus 8y agoTechnically easy to replace but a hard-to-displace monopoly (duopoly) solely due to network effects. Like Facebook, eBay or WhatsApp in the tech space.
- zaarn 8y agoIn germany we have Girocard (formerly EC Card) which has about 4 to 5 providers with 40% marketshare and less, to my knowledge atleast.
- njarboe 8y agoA lot goes into their pockets. VISA is the 20th largest company in the world by market cap and MasterCard is 43rd, and they are still growing quickly.
- hocuspocus 8y agoIn a lot of European countries, payment cards use the domestic payment scheme and are co-branded Visa/MasterCard (or V-pay/Maestro).
- agumonkey 8y agoAre they abusing the market ?
- microcolonel 8y ago> easily replaceable service For all my disagreements with major payment processors, I must say that there is a lot more than meets the eye in these networks. Having visited the fraud detection apparatus of a couple payment networks, I am thoroughly impressed. Most of them were doing machine learning at an industrial scale at least eight years ago.
- blattimwind 8y agoThat's probably got a lot to do with credit cards being vastly less popular in Europe. Paying with plastic/card usually means using a debit card (many names, largely the same). Additionally in most parts of Europe paying cash is far more common than in the US.
- porpoisely 8y agoI worry that Visa/Mastercard will use their duopolistic position in credit/debit/etc payment processing to gather more data and spy on consumers. I suspect Visa/Mastercard collects even more valuable data than google or facebook and they've already indicated they want to me more of a technology/ML/AI company. With data being ever more valuable and a small group near monopolistic companies in position to siphon most of it, it's going to be difficult to lead a private life.
- YjSe2GMQ 8y agoGoogle is already on top of that data: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-08-30/google-and-mastercard-cut-a-secret-ad-deal-to-track-retail-sales https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-08-30/google-an...