10 ms·
Cambridge University releases an app that improves concentration akin to Ritalin
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- jressey 8y agoThis whole thing has been scrutinized for years. A quick read shows that people that play the game, get better at... playing the game. Whoda thunk? Also, a private company gets to sop up profits from something created by public money. Boo.
- Bartweiss 8y agoIt's not exactly encouraging that the first author consults for Peak. The conflict of interest statement in the paper offers this deeply unpleasant comment: "BS consults for Cambridge Cognition and Peak. We have technology-transferred the App to Cambridge Enterprise who intends to technology-transfer the App to the games company Peak so that it can become widely available for use on mobile devices. This has not occurred yet." In short: we put up a free demo, but now we're giving all our code to the for-profit company our lead author happens to consult for. Also, they haven't bothered to actually release it outside their branded iOs-only app.
- systemBuilder 8y agoThis is pretty typical in the psychiatry and psychology field. The only way to make big money is to write a book or invent a test.
- BrockSamson 8y agoVery interesting to see how a particular style of game can have beneficial effects on attention. I wonder if the opposite is also true, although I'm sure there's some ethical issue with trying to find out.
- zeristor 8y agoWhomst? The article points to Decoder being embedded in an app, Peak Brain training: https://itunes.apple.com/gb/app/peak-brain-training/id806223188 https://itunes.apple.com/gb/app/peak-brain-training/id806223...
- zeristor 8y agoFrom the article it’s twice as effective as playing bingo, I take this is the FDA approved standard bingo, quite a strange comparison to make.
- Matticus_Rex 8y agoBingo has been studied for its effects in this regard: https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/153331750101600214 https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/153331750101600...
- blakesterz 8y ago"a month resulted in neurological improvements in healthy trial participants that were comparable to those taking stimulants such as methylphenidate (Ritalin) or nicotine." I was pretty excited to read this headline, but the details don't make sense to me. They only did this on people without ADD? I don't understand why they didn't test this on people who have ADHD. "Healthy trial participants" would never be taking stimulants such as methylphenidate (Ritalin), so how do they compare how a healthy person changes from Ritalin.
- dijit 8y ago> "Healthy trial participants" would never be taking stimulants such as methylphenidate (Ritalin), so how do they compare how a healthy person changes from Ritalin. Maybe in your circles. But I know a lot of people who abuse focus enhancing drugs (often touted as "nootropics") to keep up with their academic struggles.
- jeherr 8y agoI think the point is that there is little research on how healthy patients react to stimulants because they don't need them in the same way that those with ADHD do. This study says nothing about how this may help people with ADHD because you can't assume that they will have the same result.
- intuitionist 8y agoYeah, there’s a pretty thriving resale market for Ritalin and Adderall at any given college.
- Bartweiss 8y ago> I don't understand why they didn't test this on people who have ADHD. Ease of sample, probably, but also as a baseline proof. There's essentially no evidence of any brain-training game ever producing significant cognitive improvements in populations with roughly normal functioning (in which I'm including ADHD). So before pitching it as a Ritalin replacement, step one would be to demonstrate that it achieves anything at all. Unfortunately, they don't seem to have done that either, because the test was so close to the game that practice effects are the most likely explanation.
- lol768 8y agoIt's unfortunate that the app was licensed out to a commercial vendor ("Peak Brain Training") when the study received funding by the National Institute for Health Research (via the Department of Health and Social Care) which is taxpayer funded. Why wasn't the code open sourced and made available under a free license?
- andy_ppp 8y agoBecause capitalism?
- fuzz4lyfe 8y agoI'm not sure I understand could you go into more detail?
- andy_ppp 8y agoHaha, I’m just suggesting that where there is a profit to be made human beings tend to engineer opportunities to make cash, or in some cases, tenure. I would add that this happens everywhere from The Donald and construction of the wall (I’m sure the procurement process will be astonishingly transparent) to government building anything really. Clay Davis (shiiiiiiit) refers to this in The Wire as “the golden faucet”, a mythical place within government that you can make a seemingly infinite amount of money from. Alternatively for the UK read any edition of Private Eye.
- 0x262d 8y agowell, within capitalism, there is a massive amount of capital trying to find profitable investments of any kind. university research represents a promising source of such investments, so as long as private capital exists and is doing this, there will be all the socioeconomic pressure in the world for it to capture and exploit public research for private profits. sometimes this pressure results in useful things being made and sometimes it results in privatization of healthcare or research, public interest be damned. increasingly over time it is the latter.
- cptaj 8y ago
- arkades 8y agoInteresting that their press release claims the “public facing” version of the app is free ... but I can’t find anything except the peak brain trining app, which keeps decoder behind its pay wall.
- MartinMond 8y agoWonder how it compares to the dual n-back exercise. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/N-back https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/N-back
- ssfrr 8y agoThe game looks like a gamified version of the test they're using to measure concentration. It seems likely that the subjects are getting better at that specific task through practice, but I'd be skeptical that the results would generalize to other tasks requiring concentration.
- sam_goody 8y agoGoodhart's law: "When a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure." If it is just training to become better at the test to measure ADHD (I don't know enough about the game to be sure) than it would be a classic application of that "law".
- WhompingWindows 8y agoI don't know much about the product either, but there are not good quantitative tests to measure ADHD. ADHD is a multifactorial diagnosis that can present with myriad symptoms, and it's diagnosed by examining a list of symptoms and their effect on the patient's life. For instance, do you lose things you need, are you attentive to details, do you daydream or space out to your own detriment, do you fidget or move when it's inappropriate, etc. It'd be very lackluster for a single test, or a single person, to judge these symptoms. The gold standard ADHD diagnosis would involve examining the child (or adult) in multiple settings with multiple people's evidence, and then comparing symptoms against those for anxiety, depression, and other MH diagnoses. If they have enough symptoms from the official list, and they've been carefully examined, they may qualify. A simple game/test will never be able to replace that process.
- maceurt 8y agoFurthermore, many tests for adhd also work as IQ tests, meaning if you have a loq iq you are more likely to get a lower score, and bice versa. I remember one of the tests for adhd involved response time to visual stimuli and how fast a person responded. Response time has a direct correlation to IQ.
- paulie_a 8y ago
- talltimtom 8y agoThis seems borderline scientific fraud. They are showing that participants get better at a test when they practice the test. They use this to make outlandish claims about the test-training app which is sold by a company previously fined for making fraudulent claims around their braintraining apps.
- Bartweiss 8y agoPretty much every brain-training routine that's ever showed promise has turned out to be a practice effect specific to the task. "Does it generalize?" is the question for regimens like this. After so many promising failures, I think it's inappropriate to claim even preliminary success without looking at that question. (Worse, in fact: they ran the Trail Making Test too, saw no significant change, and declared success because scores hadn't gone down.) Unless this stands up to a far stronger test, I'm not just dismissing the result but considering it an embarrassment for Cambridge's Neuroscience Institute, Frontiers in Behavioural Neuroscience, and ABC. Turning the results so far into a news story promising to free people from stimulants is reckless at best and dishonest at worst.
- dublo7 8y agoIf you look at the study they don't actually test anyone with ADHD at all. Just talk about it. They should have a population with confirmed ADHD taje Ritalin or not and then play the game. The headline had nothing to do with the drug or ADHD. People who played more got better compared to playing bingo is all they could take claim.
- jimkri 8y agoThis is pretty cool. When I was younger I was hooked up to a game that was similar to EKGs with the connectors on my head and I would have to concentrate to play the game. It's great seeing its available for anyone with a phone. I think VR games would be great for improving concentration, but at short intervals at first. Similar to meditation where you focus on breathing and then move onto other areas of meditation.
- jpkeisala 8y agoAnd of course, I read it Cambridge Analytica... I cannot image what kind of damage that company gave to Cambridge University.
- pergadad 8y agoCambridge is a city. There are many organisations calling themselves Cambridge (or Oxford for that matter), either because they are genuinely based there or because they hope to benefit from the association. Can't really trademark a city name though.
- 1rs 8y agoThat site is not a news site... That's just paid advertising?
- barbs 8y agoABC News? Probably one of the most reputable news sources in Australia. It's also funded and owned by the government and has no ads so I doubt it's paid advertising.
- sandworm101 8y agoI always thought of Ritalin as a thing for kids. Then I went to law school on the east coast of the US. What totally changed my perspective was the large number of adult students (mid-20s/30s) still on Ritalin. I was no slouch, but many of them were getting better grades than me. At what point did Ritalin shift from being something to correct a legitimate deficiency into something meant to increase performance? If you are getting strait As in a graduate program, maybe you don't need it as much as you think.
- drngdds 8y agoIt's both. The latter isn't the intended use, of course.
- reitanqild 8y ago> I was no slouch, but many of them were getting better grades than me. ADHD doesn't mean stupid. Many people who suffer under ADHD are really bright, they just have problems with focusing in school. And AFAIK Ritalin doesn't increase intelligence, the best explanation I've come across is it just lowers the threshold for "interesting" in the ADHD brain until things like driving according to speed limits and listening to teachers isn't mind numbingly boring anymore.
- kolinko 8y agoADHD is a genetic issue related (in most cases) to dopamine pathways in the brain. You don't grow out of it, just like you don't grow out of diabetes.
- unomie 8y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jhcn1_qsYmg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jhcn1_qsYmg
- ChuckMcM 8y agoSo basically this is a counter study to the 'brain stimulating games' do nothing papers. Presumably the game is not that complex in its mechanic such that an open source version that ran on more platforms could be devised. That said, I'm waiting for the study where they take participants and structure their access to email, social media, and television in such a way as to limit it to a prescribed time and duration. One hypothesis is that trying to multi-task negatively affects the ability to single task (concentrate) effectively.
- arippberger 8y agoDoes the app block access to Hacker News
- stevewodil 8y agoand reddit and youtube? In all seriousness I downloaded a browser extension to lock me into my course work when I need it. It's pretty sad for me
- rchaud 8y ago> available on iPhone and iPad I understand if there's no web version, but no Android version in 2019 is ridiculous. That and the plus university research angle seems to indicate that this is a one-off app that is unlikely to be updated or maintained down the line.
- Bartweiss 8y agoI think it's the opposite problem, actually: Decoder is made by Peak, a company that specializes in Lumosity-style brain training games. This is basically a corporate/academic partnership, where Peak just wanted to develop for the higher-margin platform. As for the university research angle... it's bad research, embarrassingly so. There's a reason companies like Lumosity keep getting warned about making unsupported claims, and this looks like an attempt to get academic backing for a product with all the same problems as prior ones.
- eranation 8y agoI didn't read the entire study and didn't play too much with the app, but this entire article reads like an advertisement to the peak app. The only relation I found on peak's about page to Cambridge is Barbara Sahakian, FMedSci DSc, Scientific Advisor. http://www.peak.net/about/ http://www.peak.net/about/ I'm not calling this a fraud but didn't numerous studies showed that any of the so called brain trainig apps don't show translation of skill to the real world? e.g. you do get better that the games the apps have, but not helping in actual real life scenarios? The test they used (Rapid Visual Information Processing test) is just another "game" in a way. You can train someone to be better at the test, but it doesn't make their ADHD go away magically. I wish it was that easy. It looks like the app includes games that are way too similar to the actual test that was used to determine progress in the test subjects. From the article: About the game: "To meet the objective, users have to identify different combinations of number strings in missions littered with distraction." About the test (used to prove the game does improve cognitive abilities): "Those tested were asked to detect digit sequences (such as 2-4 or 6-8), and then hit a button once detected as quickly as they could — and multiple sequences could appear at the same time" Am I missing something or this sounds like almost the same thing? One can train and learn all the answers to an IQ test, this doesn't make one a genius. This feels like a real great promoted article in the cover of scientific writing, but maybe I'm just and old cynic. Once a study shows actual translation, after years of observation, that ADHD subjects get improvements in other aspects of life (school, social, grades, self esteem etc) then I'll be the first to support it. Until then, it just looks like greed and bottom line. I guess it's better than playing candy crush at least.
- Bartweiss 8y ago> didn't numerous studies showed that any of the so called brain trainig apps don't show translation of skill to the real world? e.g. you do get better that the games the apps have, but not helping in actual real life scenarios? Yes, this is almost always the problem. For quite a while, we thought dual n-back tests had generalized results, and so brain-training apps were basically attempting to stumble on a gamified version of that task. Unfortunately, newer studies[1] suggest that dual n-back also doesn't produce fluid intelligence or working memory improvements, so there's no proof of concept here at all. As for this study, the game and metric were exceedingly similar, and practice effects on the metric are an obvious risk. The researchers did apply a second metric less similar to their task, a standard dot-connecting task called Trail Making Task. Unfortunately, their stated intent was to show that improved single-task attention didn't degrade focus-switching attention, so this was a substantially different task for which they hypothesized no change. Their abstract reports a statistically significant improvement on TMT, which could be quite interesting. However, the full paper shows that Decoder had p=0.03 improvement on TMT over the active control (people who played Bingo), but the passive control (no play) was not significantly different than Decoder or the active control. This isn't regarded as a failure because they expected no change, but it means the study failed to show clear improvement in any metric which didn't precisely replicate the game's task. You're absolutely right to be skeptical here. Practice effects are a constant problem with this sort of research, and the study seems to be confusingly short on attempts to test for that. The actual app focuses more on gamification than using any type of proven test, and the lead author's corporate connection to Peak is at best concerning. I don't think there's any sort of fraud here, but it's a field riddled with well-meaning projects that turn out to lack any general benefit, and this result has all the warning signs for another promising failure. [1] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0160289613001293 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S016028961...
- dura-ace88 8y agoLet’s not forget that it was Cambridge who first identified the political opportunities of knowing people’s psychological tendencies through survey collection on Facebook - before Cambridge Analytica was born. Can’t help but feel that this is slightly on the nose.
- dura-ace88 8y agoLet’s not forget that it was Cambridge who first identified the political opportunities of knowing people’s psychological tendencies through survey collection on Facebook - before Cambridge Analytica was born. Can’t help but feel that doing something similar with cognition is slightly on the nose.
- yters 8y agoAnecdotally, for awhile I was solving Soduku entirely in my head, and I had a noticeable improvement in memory. Once I stopped the improvement went away. So, there seems to be benefit to some sorts of brain training.
- Ice_cream_suit 8y agoSounds very much like the snake oil that accompanied Lumosity...
- anonytrary 8y agoI wonder if they did research into MOBA games like League of Legends before making this app. League of Legends and other MOBA games are fun, competitive and require a boatload of concentration and reflexes if you wanna get good. I would point people to play those games if they wanna improve their concentration, although I'm not sure how much research there is on it.
- golemiprague 8y agoThe reward mechanism in games is very different from real life. It is very immediate and accurate and that's why so many , especially men, enjoy doing it. It doesn't really help with anything else.
- lwindyb 8y agoAnyone see the difference is a couple percent