21 ms·
Saudi Arabia’s Great Run Seems Headed for Trouble
- diminoten 8y agoForgive the naivety, but after a certain point doesn't cash just make more cash, and didn't the Saudis hit that a long time ago? I figured they got rich on oil, but could now stay rich through investment.
- nkoren 8y agoThe tl;dr for you is that the Saudi people made more people faster than their cash could make more cash. And as an extraction-based economy they made more jobs even more slowly than that. So now they've got a glut of young people, not enough cash to keep them complacent, and not enough jobs to keep them occupied. What do you think will happen next?
- simonh 8y agoThe problem is much of that wealth has been appropriated as personal assets by members of the Royal Family. A lot of it has also been squandered on extravagant projects that will never have anything close to a real ROI. They _could_ have managed it better and ended up living off it indefinitely, but SA is no Norway.
- swarnie_ 8y agoYour thinking of Norway's approach where the state uses oil to reinvest and pay for future generations. Saudi is trying to do this by spinning off part of Aramco in to public ownership and by stealing wealth from top officials. realistically they should have started 30 years ago.
- gaius 8y agoOr their investment in SoftBank. It’s got to be pretty weird to work for or in a WeWork and know what sort of regime you are sustaining.
- rleigh 8y agoI'm no economist, but isn't one of the primary problems here that they don't have a well enough developed and diversified economy to invest in, and expand their economy and benefit their society in a virtuous cycle of investment and growth? They have the option to invest in western companies, but isn't that rather risky? And it's also ultimately just monetary gains; they haven't gained materially as a nation unless they also spend that money on products and services from other nations. Eventually, it's left their economy and been frittered away. Also, how much is invested versus being spent lavishly on their princes and populace to keep them happy?
- Kadin 8y agoThat would be the case if they were investing the "rent" from extractive industry (oil) in productive industries above-ground. Or even just putting it into the market so that somebody else puts it to productive use. If you do that, you're well-positioned for the day the oil runs out or becomes uneconomical to extract. But the Saudis have the same problem nearly every other petro-regime has, which is spending that money on unproductive personal property (palaces, fancy cars, private jets, etc.) as well as unproductive state property (defense, mostly). They have built some universities and other public goods, but I suspect it's a small fraction of the wealth that's been extracted. They have no comparative advantage over other nations in anything other than petroleum, and religious tourism. There's no particular reason why you'd want to build a factory or move your multinational company there. They could create reasons for people to want to do that, but it would probably be expensive (they'd need to have low wages, probably artificially depressed or subsidized, or a very lax regulatory environment, which has its own costs, or both). In the short term I'd look for them to start borrowing to keep their budget balanced, using the oil still in the ground as collateral, basically. (They're effectively borrowing against future income.) If they do enough of this and build productive, sustainable economic assets, they might do okay. But eventually the cost of borrowing might get high, because as demand for oil falls and extraction costs increase, there will come a point where it's no longer economical to extract anymore and they'll have a load of "stranded assets" on their national books. The day they finally have to write those down will be the real day of reckoning, financially. If the ruling class is smart, they'll make it seem as though it's all a big Western bankster conspiracy (when in doubt, blame the Jews), not their own long-running incompetence, because the immediate cause of the pain will probably be a debt crisis or default.
- onetimemanytime 8y agoFertility dropped from 3.8 kids to less than 2 in 10 years, or am I reading the chart wrong? Did they put a gov official in each bedroom to lower birthrate or what? Birthrate of 4-6 is unsustainable (unless, maybe, they're Canada with all that land and resources) but above 2 is needed. Someone needs to work in 25 years and pay social security so old people get theirs. Looks like stormy seas ahead. They can open the spigot for a while but unless the tank keeps refilling (oil prices might not cooperate) it will run dry.
- raverbashing 8y agoThe earlier we stop the crap about "we have to be above replacement rates" (because of outdated pension models) the better
- AvocadoPanic 8y agoYou could argue replacement rates are not just about pensions, but continuing your society and culture with people that look like you.
- timbit42 8y agoWhat a vain and outdated way of thinking.
- onetimemanytime 8y agoVain might be called wanting to have your own kids too, but I disagree
- gwbas1c 8y agoI'm disappointed you're downvoted. This is a good discussion to have. A lot of problems that we, the human species, face, can be simpler to solve if there are less people! We have some very clear problems to solve if we have a negative birthrate. Caring for elderly is very hard work, harder, IMO, than raising young children. When we have a negative birthrate, how do we care for the elderly without it becoming a significant drain on our economy? We can essentially run government programs, like American Social Security, like a Ponzi scheme, because as long as population is growing, there's always more people who pay in than take out. And, just "saving more" won't solve the problem, because then there will be a bunch of rich old people who can't hire help because there just isn't enough young labor! Leads to a good discussion!
- benj111 8y agoIt talks about youth unemployment, but also says the birthrate has crashed from 6 children/woman to 2. Surely 1 would solve the other? Edit: So according to wikipedia, these are the age distributions: 0-14 years: 25.74% 15-24 years: 15.58% 25-54 years: 49.88% 55-64 years: 5.48% 65 years and over: 3.32% This suggests to me about the right amount of young adults, not too many, with potential issues in 10ish years time. Note that "upto 37%" of the population are immigrants, I assume they disproportionately fall into the 25-54 age range, and that that immigration could be controlled to some extent if needed. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_Saudi_Arabia https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_Saudi_Arabia
- petre 8y agoMaybe in 20 years. The youth from 2000 is now of employment age or just the right age for an uprising.
- benj111 8y agoPerhaps, but none if the other issues are particularly short term.
- xbmcuser 8y agoImigration has already been controlled millions of people have already been sent back to their own countries. And further restrictions are being put up on which jobs will be open to foriegners. They can't sent everyone back in one go but by adding restrictions each year they are doing it gradually.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> They can't sent everyone back in one go The KSA is a wealthy absolute monarchy. They absolutely can.
- immigrants 8y agoBut controlling immigration is evil. We’re just cool with that? No big deal? Kings make it okay?
- adventured 8y agoThis article gets a critical point wrong. The absolute worst thing that could happen to Saudi Arabia is that they continue to have a high birth and population expansion rate. The source of their biggest threat in regards to social unrest, is that they can't afford to placate their massive population expansion since ~1980. Their population has tripled since roughly 1982 and they have no traditional economy to support that what-so-ever, it's all oil dependent. The worst thing that could happen is that you double that population again rapidly, against a relatively static output of oil and while having still not developed a traditional economy to support the new population. It's a pretty simple equation. N oil production divided between Z population. Every year that goes by that their population increases and their oil production doesn't keep up, that oil money gets thinner per capita. Boosting the population doesn't boost their economy much (such that doing so enables them to better provide for an aging population), as they have practically no conventional economy. That's fundamentally why their budget requirement for the price of oil just keeps going up. It's at least ~$80 per barrel now that they need to balance the budget [1], so it's nearing a state of becoming permanently impossible to fulfill their budget demands. Soon it'll be $90, then $100. They've increased their population by 1/4 in roughly the past decade. That's far too fast of a population expansion rate based on the structure of their economy. What they actually need is population contraction, desperately. That oil economy is now trapped in hell with US shale production always acting as a price & supply counter that makes it impossible for Saudi to gain ground. The EIA output estimate for the US for 2018 as recently as three years ago was roughly two million barrels per day of production lower than what it actually turned out to be. In one form or another, that's largely coming out of the pocket of OPEC+ (OPEC + Russia). US shale supply will never stop pressing against the price & supply of oil and the US is rapidly ramping up its export capabilities. If the Saudis cut to firm prices, US supply takes it up and takes their price gains away (which may take months or years to fill out depending on the macro situation). Saudi will expand their population by another 12-15% in the next decade, against this disastrous economic scenario. The outcome is obvious, they won't be able to placate the burgeoning population and over time it'll rip the kingdom apart. If you cut their population in half right now, they'd struggle to build a traditional economy big enough to put under it in time before there's an oil crisis in the kingdom. As it is, they appear doomed to an inevitable civil war or revolt of some sort. [1] https://www.spglobal.com/platts/en/market-insights/latest-news/oil/121818-saudi-arabia-needs-84-b-oil-price-to-balance-2019-budget-analysts-warn https://www.spglobal.com/platts/en/market-insights/latest-ne...
- jillesvangurp 8y agoThe birthrate dropping is a good thing. This happens to countries that are seeing rising levels in education and security. The Saudi's are not poor or uneducated; great. It does create a big baby boom problem. They have a big generation that is going to grow old relatively healthy (unlike earlier generations) and wealthy. They are going to be dependent on a new generation that is much smaller and currently struggling with unemployment. So, the good news is that there should be plenty to do for these people when their parents retire. The bad news of course is that at point the saudi's will have some economic issues of having to produce more with less people, while facing issues with their oil revenue dropping. Other issues that are affecting them are the fact that their cities are becoming inhabitable due to rising temperatures. Regular temperatures above 50 degrees are not very sustainable. They are apparently already planning to create some new cities to address this. The political situation is of course the big topic. The royal family's power is rooted in oil money. As that dries up, the geo-political landscape in the region will start shifting. There's no shortage of countries in the region with similar issues and competing agendas to address their issues. E.g. Iran and Saudi Arabia is a war waiting to happen. The proxy wars have been going on for decades with the US and Europe having played no small role in the history of both countries. Weapon exports to the Saudi's and other countries in the region are substantial.
- duozerk 8y ago> They are apparently already planning to create some new cities to address this. Unless they plan to build them somewhere else, I doubt that'll help. Large swathes of the middle east will become completely uninhabitable, quite possibly during our lifetime.
- politician 8y agoThey're planning on building dome cities. https://www.popsci.com/united-arab-emirates-mars-city-pictures https://www.popsci.com/united-arab-emirates-mars-city-pictur...
- duozerk 8y ago
- rossdavidh 8y agoSo, if we take a look at Venezuela's situation, in which a system that worked well enough when oil was >$100/barrel becomes disastrous after the price drops, and we apply that scenario to Saudi Arabia, it looks pretty frightening. SA is far more central to world society (e.g. its role in the world religion of Islam, its role in OPEC) than Venezuela. Perhaps the world should have done more to help Venezuela, but we at least had the option of ignoring it (or worse). When (not if) SA goes the way of Venezuela, it will be a far messier situation for the rest of us, and I don't think we are even thinking about it, much less preparing.
- jeffreyrogers 8y agoMy understanding is that Venezula's problems are exacerbated by its political situation. So I don't know that I'd predict Saudi Arabia becoming like Venezula. Saudi Arabia also has the lowest cost of production of any country, if I recall correctly, and they've weathered low prices just fine in the past.
- Cyph0n 8y agoMany Muslims, particularly those outside the Gulf, are looking towards KSA less for religious guidance. Islamic scholars that are allowed to operate by KSA have been shown time and again to be hypocritical and have little to no dignity. Their judgements and positions change with the whims of the king and crown prince, which lends little to their credibility. The remaining scholars that decide to stick to their principles end up in prison. For me personally, the only unique thing that KSA has that you can’t find elsewhere is Mecca.
- breitling 8y agoThis is true. The general public the world over is realizing that the Saudi scholars are "regulated" by the Saudi government...ergo the foreign powers that keep the ruling family propped up. They have zero credibility. Mecca and Medina are an exception to this.
- rossdavidh 8y agoThanks for your perspective, it is much better informed than mine. Mecca/the Hajj was definitely the aspect I was thinking of.
- m23khan 8y agoIn last 10-15 years, I have seen countless such articles about Saudi Arabia's troubled horizon. The Country has very deep connection with rest of Muslim World - they can hold 'brotherly' Muslim countries such as Pakistan and Egypt hooked on to Oil and Petroleum and can rely on these 'brotherly' countries to get access to their agricultural lands and can create massive 'alliances' with rest of Muslim World at their whim (case in point: Saudi-created and Saudi-led grand military alliance with Muslim Countries). While I support Humanity's move away from fossil fuels, let's not kid ourselves -- Muslim World (which represents 2+ billion people) as well as China and India are in no rush to give up Fossil fuels. What we see now (drop in oil prices, oversupply) may get corrected over time as the poorer Muslim Nations like Pakistan and Central Africa region stabilizes and industrializes thus softening the blow from any dip in business with West. As for social development across Saudi Arabia -- this is nothing new. Back in 1960s/1970s, Saudi Government had a modernizing phase where they bought Television and media to the masses. Universities were opened and Education was encouraged. Ever since then, Saudi men AND women have been sent to West and other places for their studies. This modernizing phase is just part 2. You have to understand something about Saudis, Emiratis, Kuwaitis, Qataris, etc. Average citizen in these Countries may have good amounts of wealth and may get exposed to secular culture, however, at heart, their population is very much conservative and strong supports their Royal Family. Case in Point UAE: Flush with Wealth and relatively liberal -- but local population still appears conservative and prefers to live in their own social circles. This (GCC) region is part of World where up until the Grand/great-Grand parents of current generation lived in desperate poverty since beginning of time and the society still remembers those harsh times very, very clearly -- given those circumstances and where they are now (almost First world type of living standards), any population of Human beings would be, very, very satisfied by their leadership.
- chriselles 8y agoWouldn’t a meaningful study of Saudi Arabia include the house of Saud? Anecdotals suggest the House of Saud itself has exploded in size. Supposedly at a rate far greater that House of Saud’s revenue streams. Petrodollar recycling programs often in the form of western arms contracts are a way for the House of Saud and insiders to “clip the ticket” on big dollar contracts. The multidecade Al Yamamah contract worth tens of billions with UK defence industry saw a corruption investigation stopped as a “matter of nationa, security” due to Saudi pressure. In commerce, financial reporting often includes “same store sales” for retail and restaurants. I wonder if “average Saudi Prince kickback/revenue generated” would be a valid metric? I suspect kickback revenue per member of the House of Saud has been in the decline.
- thedudeabides5 8y agoDoes anyone know the fiscal breakeven here? Aka the price of oil at which the Saudi sovereign is cash flow positive?