12 ms·
Japan's Rail Workers Pointing at Things (2017)
- GauntletWizard 8y agoWhen I was at Google, my team and other SRE teams around us adopted a similar approach to sensitive operations - deploys and data migrations and the like. We'd have one of us on the keyboard operating, and another looking over our shoulder. The operator would type a command and they verbally confirm the action they were going to take. Their partner would look it over and give verbal acknowledgement. We certainly still had mistakes, but I found that environment very helpful - and it was an almost necessary part of zero-blame postmortems, because every action was not one person, but equally shared between two.
- walshemj 8y agoI used to use check lists for this sort of critical tasks obvisly much smaller systems back then a 16 machine cluster was a big deal
- gnom69 8y agoI do something similiar with my keys: "I'm putting my keys on the sideboard". Before that I occasionally "lost" my keys because the location was never safed to my long term memory. At least that's reproducably the error why I sometimes just couldn't remember.
- smcl 8y agoHaving been locked out at annoying, inconvenient times of day I started follow the same process a few years back. I feel like I'm going mad when I'm doing it though, stepping out of my flat stopping, staring at my keys and consciously placing them into my pocket. I'm so glad someone else does the same.
- gmueckl 8y agoI have sinilar ritual when leavong my flat: I pat down all my pockets to check that everything I need is there: keys, paper tissues, phone, wallet... I even used to do it with a foot deliberately positioned in the doorframe to prevent myself from closing the door with the key inside.
- endgame 8y agoI count to six: wallet, watch, keys, phone, work pass, pen.
- oska 8y agoI always lock my front door from the outside when I leave the house. This requires using my keys (unlike locking it from the inside). This means I never leave my keys behind. It does require remembering to lock the front door but I don't have any problem remembering to do that.
- Tor3 8y agoMy front door can only be locked with a key.. that effectively prevents me from forgetting my keys inside.
- netsharc 8y agoWow, I feel very organized, I've always had a spot for my keys and wallet near the front doors of the different places I've lived. But I also hooked a USB drive to my wallet, and one time I needed a file from it, so I plugged it into my PC with the rest of the wallet attached to it, placing the wallet on top of the tower, behind the monitor. 20 minutes later I was on the phone with the local supermarket because I couldn't find my wallet at its usual spot, and I knew I had it with me while paying at the supermarket.
- martinkus 8y agoI use a similar system when deploying builds to production. The deployment itself is a multi-step process where I have to pick out two artifacts, verify that their git commit hashes are correct, then pick out the correct jenkins jobs and run them in a specific order (providing artifact numbers as input). At every stage I point to my screen, read out the information and only click on things that I'm pointing at. This may be anecdotal but multiple times I have stopped myself from clicking on the wrong thing only after saying its name out loud.
- tantalor 8y agoEr isn't that what scripting is for?
- ColinWright 8y agoNot everything can be scripted, automation doesn't always repay the work expended in creating and maintaining it[0][1], and sometimes it's just worth having a human in the loop to know what's going on. So, no, it isn't. [0] https://xkcd.com/1205/ https://xkcd.com/1205/ [1] https://xkcd.com/1319/ https://xkcd.com/1319/
- russdill 8y agoThe process described is not only easily scriptable, but are things for which a human could very commonly make a mistake. You can add things in to include a human in the loop, maybe hitting return at each step, or hitting y, but deploying to production should never depend on a series of manual steps except when absolutely necessary
- ColinWright 8y agomartinkus> ... I have to pick out two artifacts ... pick out the correct jenkins jobs and run them in a specific order ... russdill> The process described is not only easily scriptable, ... From the description given you can't know that. russdill> ... deploying to production should never depend on a series of manual steps except when absolutely necessary. So you, without knowing exactly what this person is doing, are declaring that it's not absolutely necessary? That's very bold of you.
- zeeZ 8y agoWhy drop the "why" from the title? Without it I assumed this was about behavior they carried over from what is otherwise just another mandatory workplace policy.
- ColinWright 8y agoI used the marklet to submit this directly, so it got lost somewhere in the automated process - it wasn't deliberately omitted.
- sixhobbits 8y ago(2017). Previous discussion https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14011793 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14011793
- DoctorOetker 8y agoI am not sure I understand how it works, but if I had to take a guess it is because normally your thoughts and attention are invisible to others, but if policy mandates you to use body language to indicate your attention, then the employee realizes any lapse in attention will be visible from afar, so the employee who doesn't want to be seen losing attention it becomes mandatory to constantly show that yes you are in fact still paying attention...
- yborg 8y agoThis is interesting, I remember watching "Carrier" and noticing that the 'shooters' at the catapult controls followed the same process of pointing at their board (and even out the window at the plane) as they went through their launch checklist.
- neurotech1 8y agoAll aircraft handlers use hand signals, such as the crew who direct the plane on deck after landing, the crew that directs the jets onto the catapult, the catapult deck crew, and the pilots.
- nullandvoid 8y agoThe book I'm reading currently 'modular habits' uses the Japanese train conductors usage of this finger pointing an example of how to reinforce habits - the accident reduction noted with this technique was quite significant. On another note - how strange is it when you learn something new of which you haven't known about your whole life only to several days later see it appear on hn.. is there a name for this sort of thing?
- GuiA 8y ago> how strange is it when you learn something new of which you haven't known about your whole life only to several days later see it appear on hn.. is there a name for this sort of thing? https://science.howstuffworks.com/life/inside-the-mind/human-brain/baader-meinhof-phenomenon.htm https://science.howstuffworks.com/life/inside-the-mind/human...
- xemoka 8y agoI just looked up the name of this phenomenon about 10 minutes ago for something entirely unrelated... How self-reinforcing!
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- gordo4 8y agosynchronicity
- pfooti 8y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baader%E2%80%93Meinhof_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baader%E2%80%93Meinhof_effect
- kevinmchugh 8y agoI just heard about this!
- JimboOmega 8y ago
- genericone 8y agoSimilarly for climbers: https://opp.uoregon.edu/climbing/topics/signals.html https://opp.uoregon.edu/climbing/topics/signals.html
- carlmr 8y agoTrue, didn't even think of it, I don't like climbing with people that don't do this.
- woodruffw 8y agoNYC's conductors do a similar thing when they pull into stations[1]. The urban myth that I grew up with was that they were pointing at a hidden camera to show the dispatcher that they're awake, but the article I linked below suggests that it was taken directly from the Japanese railway. [1]: https://www.nydailynews.com/new-york/mta-conductors-point-stopping-subway-station-article-1.3502286 https://www.nydailynews.com/new-york/mta-conductors-point-st...
- ColinWright 8y agoIndeed, from the submitted article: > ... New York City’s MTA subway system, whose conductors have used a modified point-only system since 1996 after then Chief Transportation Officer Nathaniel Ford was fascinated by the point-and-call system during a business trip to Japan. In the MTA’s case, conductors point to a fixed black-and-white “zebra board” to confirm a stopped train is correctly located along the platform. > According to MTA spokeswoman Amanda Kwan, conductors were quick to adapt to the new system, and within two years of implementation, incidents of incorrectly berthed subways fell 57 percent.
- tialaramex 8y agoI would be interested to understand two related things about this situation: 1. Does the NYC subway as a result have significantly lower incidence of alignment problems than London's Underground? London has had one person operation of all trains across the system for decades, so, if the conductor pointing at stuff matters, logically not having a conductor at all ought to result in significantly more errors... I haven't heard of such errors at all, but presumably they do happen at least sometimes. 2. What do the rates look like in Copenhagen, which is GoA4 and thus there isn't anybody aboard the train with responsibility for the system, there's a control centre with some broad over-all authority, but individual trains drive themselves. My instinct is that actually this is not a good solution, it's what you might do if all the good solutions are off the table and you have to pay these guys anyway. "Well, might as well try to slightly improve our lousy accuracy".
- Tsiklon 8y agoA good number of London Underground lines are automatic operation - however on manually operated London underground lines they have a board similar to the zebra board at each station - it's at the driver end of the platform and shows their alignment, there is no conductor on the underground, just a driver and occasional plain clothes ticket inspectors. However not all underground platforms on each line are of uniform length - for example Baker Street's subsurface lines have platforms shorter than the trains that run on them.
- Dangeranger 8y agoWhen I worked on a large historical sailing ship that required a dozen crew to perform tasks like raising sails, tacking, or reefing, we followed a call-and-response verbal command system for many of the same reasons. When the helmsman would yell out "Ready about!", we would check the surroundings and respond "Ready!", then we would listen for "Helms Alee!" and prepare to switch sides and trim the sails. This process made sure that all of the crew were synchronized as to the current step in the process.[0] [0] http://lrsailingcenter.com/posts/tacking/ http://lrsailingcenter.com/posts/tacking/
- greetings 8y agoCall backs! A really good practice. As having also worked on a historical ship the bit that always gets me is when working on helm when needing to communicate our heading we say "one five three" rather than "one hundred fifty three" and then that is repeated back. Makes it much more difficult to make mistakes this way.
- nhf 8y agoSame in aviation, the ICAO phonetic alphabet is meant to reduce uncertainty over historically poor radio communications. Plus readback to air traffic control and so on is relatively standardized to allow for a few chances to realize you got the wrong thing down.
- sandworm101 8y agoIt seems silly until you have to do it in a storm, with wing literally howling into your ears. Combinations of sounds, gestures and readbacks are used anywhere loud noises are to be expected. Pretty much everything in aviation and the military requires some such layering.
- endgame 8y agoOn the ships I've worked on, call-and-response gets used for important messages even between two people: "Steer zero nine zero" "Zero nine zero aye"
- johan_larson 8y ago"I'm reading an article on HN about Japanese rail workers pointing at things." "Done." "I'm composing a snarky comment about Japanese rail workers pointing at things." "Done." "I'm pressing 'add comment' to post a snarky comment about Japanese rail workers pointing at things." Wait, what? No. I know better than that. Abort.
- Netcob 8y agoI would be prepared to completely ignore (and definitely not laugh at) rail personnel performing a naked rain dance if it meant that the trains would arrive on time more often. Hell, I'd join in if that helped.
- crooked-v 8y agoThat sounds like a Shadowrun plot hook.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- interfixus 8y agoIf Japanese rail does x, x is probably worth looking into.
- achamayou 8y agoBest start wearing white gloves then!
- bmer 8y agoWouldn't be surprised if maintaining a crisp uniform is part of keeping up a sense of attention to detail, which again, would feed back into safety/efficiency.
- snvzz 8y agoI was at an arcade recently that had these "denshade" train driving simulators. The cabinet had an uniform to put on. It sure helped get into the role.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- autokad 8y agoI do this in every day life, it makes sure I don't forget things and gives me assurance that I did it. no more "did I turn off the oven?"
- JackFr 8y agoMany basketball players, after shooting a free throw for a technical or flagrant foul (where they are alone at the free throw line and no one else is lined up on the key) will reach out and slap the hands of their imaginary teammates like they would after a normal free throw. I always wondered if it was superstition, unconscious habit, or a developed habit.
- LeifCarrotson 8y agoMakes me wonder if they practice that way. They probably don't break form and high-five a teammate when they're practicing...
- stevenjohns 8y agoAny chance it could just be light RSI?
- Havoc 8y agoThis also works for stuff like switching off the stove or locking the front door. If you find yourself second guessing whether you did it...just narrate the activity as you do it. Sticks much better
- Thorrez 8y agoI came up with a new phishing avoidance scheme based on this, point at the url bar before typing your password.
- kartan 8y ago> While some workers point-and-call more enthusiastically than others Yes, I have seen this. Rail workers are great at it, but in other places, it can get worse. I saw a guy pointing to both sides of the sidewalk - to assure that it was free of people - before letting a truck get into a parking lot. His colleague will barely move the hands. It looked slightly awkward. > Japanese commentators have theorized that Western employees feel “silly” performing the requisite gestures and calls. I guess that this is what humans are bad at. We overvalue our awareness, and we put a lot of much weight on any act with social implications. While I was at Fuji, I saw what it seemed a guy training alongside the train driver. He laughed time to time at his own movements. They both had a great time. So, even for Japanese, seems that the situation is slightly awkward.
- newsbinator 8y agoI wonder why we evolved to feel silly. You'd think the safety aspect of looking silly would outweigh the social aspect of doing things that cause mocking in others.
- jplayer01 8y agoWe evolved to overvalue the opinion of our peers. Back when we lived in tribes of 20-50, it was incredibly important to fit in and be accepted. It's maladaptive when the same mechanism is at work when doing something modern that is silly on an individual social level but incredibly important/beneficial on a rational one.
- carlmr 8y agoThe people that did a lot of silly looking things probably had a harder time finding partners for reproduction. So for something like safety with silliness to reproduce it would need a significant impact on our chance to survive. Looking at it this way workplace safety barely mattered until very recently. Before the big killers were the lack of food and vaccinations. It's only since society became as safe as it is today, that these smaller safety goals even seem to matter.
- sangnoir 8y ago
- Medraut 8y agoIt's effective for more than just safety. I suffer from mild anxiety over whether I have taken certain actions in a variety of every day scenarios. This behavior (pointing and verbally acknowledging) helps me cope with that sense of unease.
- themodelplumber 8y agoThat makes sense to me. Logging and measurement are also used for this purpose--increasing productive control over a (human in this case) system.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- they_live 8y agoIt’s kind of strange to see a country as dilligent as it is, and obsessed with flawless execution as one finds its citizenry to be (Japan really does make some of the best stuff) that there’s some sort of emotional toll that leads to a high suicide rate and low birth rate. Which is really a bummer, because on some level you tend to think, to buy into a stereotype, that the Japanese have their shit together, and you admire that, but the negative space of these qualities is that they never step out of line, and when they do, it’s the end of the world.
- Tor3 8y agoIt's.. not really that. The step-out-of-line thing, I mean. But the pressure on young people is extremely hard, it's literally passing an exam to enter every step of your education (exam when finishing a step, a new one to enter) from kindergarden and up (and even earlier, for really obsessed/concerned parents). Extremely long hours (and a lot of that comes from culture, so yes that's also a part) for students and workers alike. The moment you feel unable to handle the pressure things will fall apart quickly.
- amyjess 8y agoI've learned that the best way to make sure I don't forget to put my phone charger in my purse when I go to work in the morning is to point at the outlet and say "Charger, set!". I got the idea after the last time an article about this phenomenon was posted, and it's worked beautifully since.
- Animats 8y agoHand signals are common for many blue-collar team jobs. Cranes, aircraft ramp operations, marine work, military - where getting it wrong is deadly or at least expensive. It's only rare to white-collar types. It's the opposite of "move fast and break things". Heavy-lift companies and marine salvage companies (there's overlap) are in the business of "move slowly and don't break things". Mammoet, Titan, and Smit all have videos on line of some of their jobs. They are way into overpreparing. They have more gear on site than you'd think was needed, they prepare for as much as a year for some operations, there are detailed, written plans and backup plans which have been rehearsed and talked through by the people involved, and then on the big day, everything goes so smoothly it's dull. Watch some of those videos and you'll see some explicit hand signals.
- jacquesm 8y agoLong ago I spent a good bit of time in Rotterdam Harbor. What I distinctly remember is that when I first got there it was all a huge mystery to me, some kind of machine that moved by itself without any indication of what was going on and what would happen next. Then, over time I started to learn how to 'read' the dockside, and a good part of that was learning how to interpret the handsignals of the various crews to know when it was ok to pass and when it definitely wasn't.
- bitwize 8y agoI think it's neat. It visually and auditorily confirms to others that you are checking what needs to be checked, and reinforces the check in your own mind, letting you think about whether you are doing it properly. Similarly, Japanese sysadmins must write down -- and get approval for -- every single shell command they intend to execute on prod before actually issuing the command, specifically to reduce the number of 'rm -rf /' oopses (and other breaking changes). It may look unusual, but I wouldn't call such a thing silly. I've noticed that Japanese workers do just about everything so patently deliberately that there must always be a reason for it being that way.
- hondish 8y ago'Shooters' in a US aircraift carrier doing 'point and call', showing you can have fun and be safe at the same time: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GFqlwAWuMTg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GFqlwAWuMTg It's a choreographed checklist, which is great because others can notice if you miss anything.
- benbristow 8y agoOne of the most interesting things I saw on the rails when I was in Japan this year was on the Shinkansen (Bullet train) from Kyoto to Tokyo (and back again). Every time the train guard went through, when he got to the front of the door he'd turn around, do a 180 spin to face the passengers and give them a salute before 180 spinning back and going to the next carriage in front. I know it's a cultural thing but it's a nice touch.
- Tor3 8y agoYes, it is nice, isn't it? I remember the first time I came to Japan. From the airplane I could see three of the baggage crew -- white gloves, and all three of them did a bow to the airplane before they started working.
- matthewfelgate 8y agoIf I point at my code will I make fewer mistakes. :-)
- linkmotif 8y agoI see this all the time on the New York Subway too when conductors lean out and point. Must be the same thing?
- ColinWright 8y agoYes, and it's been mentioned both here in this thread[0] and in the article itself[1]. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18955029 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18955029 [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18955102 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18955102