11 ms·
EU Cancels 'Final' Negotiations on EU Copyright Directive
- tyfon 8y agoSo what I get from this is that the system works. When enough people voice their concerns the people in charge actually listen. At least there seems to be no internet disaster as of now? I usually postpone my doomsday scenarios until they are fact . One just has to be vigilant in any new proposals that is made on this subject. And scream loudly if the lobbyists go at it again. Eventually I hope EU completely bans organised lobbying, nothing good ever comes from pandering to special interests.
- xoa 8y ago>So what I get from this is that the system works. This is definitely really worth repeating and something everyone should always keep in mind. It's very dangerous for educated people and experts in particular to allow apathy or over cynicism to obscure the fact that it is truly possible to lobby successfully for positive changes too. >I usually postpone my doomsday scenarios until they are fact. I'm not quite sure what you mean by this? You mean you postpone your contingency plan activation, or do you mean warning people around it? But if you think it really is a doomsday scenario and you don't warn people until after it's done how do you keep it from happening in the first place? >Eventually I hope EU completely bans organised lobbying, nothing good ever comes from pandering to special interests. How would that not affect organizations like the EFF or ACLU or whatever the EU equivalents are? I know that most of the population, even if they're massively effected by the destructive effects of IP maximalism, are not actually cognizant of it at all. That makes those of us opposed to it "special interests" too doesn't it? We're trying to lobby for technocratic policy changes that will benefit us personally even if it will also benefit others too. It would likely benefit many of us commercially too, which isn't an inherently bad thing. How do you create an objective set of rules around that?
- tyfon 8y ago> I'm not quite sure what you mean by this? You mean you postpone your contingency plan activation, or do you mean warning people around it? But if you think it really is a doomsday scenario and you don't warn people until after it's done how do you keep it from happening in the first place? What I mean is that I don't go screaming "the internet is doomed" for months before the actual vote like I've seen many forums posts and articles claim. However I have no issue in warning people that "if the proposal is accepted as is it would do great harm". >How would that not affect organizations like the EFF or ACLU or whatever the EU equivalents are? I know that most of the population, even if they're massively effected by the destructive effects of IP maximalism, are not actually cognizant of it at all. That makes those of us opposed to it "special interests" too doesn't it? We're trying to lobby for technocratic policy changes that will benefit us personally even if it will also benefit others too. It would likely benefit many of us commercially too, which isn't an inherently bad thing. How do you create an objective set of rules around that? They can still organise, spread information and argue their point. I might have been a bit broad in my strokes. There should be no organised "secret" lobbying, that is I wish all that the politicians do and talk about in their official capacities should be recorded and open. This includes internal party meetings, lobbyist meetings etc. It is very hard to create this objectively but the end-game for me is to get back-door politics out in the open. I once read a book by L.E. Modesitt Jr names "Haze" which has a system that I actually find very appealing. It's a bit much to recap it here but if one likes to explore different systems this is a good one imho.
- Mirioron 8y ago>What I mean is that I don't go screaming "the internet is doomed" for months before the actual vote like I've seen many forums posts and articles claim. The only reason this didn't pass is because people screamed at the tops of their lungs.
- tyfon 8y agoYes but the internet was not doomed as we now see. I could have been but it was not at the point in time (presents form vs conditional form). I have no issues with warning people what can happen.
- ajnin 8y agoIt seems like it worked this time (it's not over yet). But they can try again next time. And again if it also fails. Will the response in opposition be as loud ? They can try as many times as they want but they only have to succeed once, while we have to succeed 100% of the time. This fundamental imbalance is worrying.
- vezycash 8y agoOf course they'll try again. Next time, they'll probably claim copyright violations cause economic down turns and bankrupt firms Same way the three lettered guys capitalized on terrorism and child porn to disregard everyone's privacy.
- xoa 8y ago>It seems like it worked this time (it's not over yet). But they can try again next time. And again if it also fails. Will the response in opposition be as loud? It has to be in a democracy. Everyone is free to keep arguing for what they think are good ideas, and those who think they're not need to also keep at it. The struggle never ends, that's the civic duty of the people. Having said that, I think you might be missing one important strategy in this: >They can try as many times as they want but they only have to succeed once, while we have to succeed 100% of the time. This fundamental imbalance is worrying. Please correct me if I'm mistaken, but you seem to be implicitly assuming that opposition consists solely of attempting to maintain the status quo. In that scenario you're right that it's more difficult to keep the balance from shifting away from neutral over time. However, instead opposition can fight to actually actively move things farther in their preferred direction, and then even if they lose a certain amount of the time that still won't be disastrous. It's not necessary to win every battle if they're not purely defensive, just some of the time. I don't just oppose further efforts to maximalize IP, I want much (though not all) of the current bits reversed and brought back into more historical balance. I support efforts to reduce the terms back down towards 15-30 years (or alternatively to introduce dynamic pricing/terms), to completely eliminate math and business method patents, better fund examiners, etc. That's where the battle has to continue. Remember, you can flip your logic around there: we only need to get any given bit of overlong or incorrectly granted IP put back into the public domain once. Maximalists "have to succeed" at preventing it 100% of the time yes?
- Meai 8y agoWe all know what will happen next, they will make a new proposal under a friendler title with better deceptive phrases with extra goodies thrown in to gain just enough of an edge to make it pass with the ambiguous text that they want to have passed.
- squarefoot 8y agoOr rather settle for less evil laws, which could well be what they had in mind from start. In the great old game of public opinion manipulation, one thing is making clear you aim at 10 and go straight in that direction from the beginning, and a very different thing is pretending you aim at 100, then faking acceptance of criticism and adjustments to the objectives until you get to that 10. In the first case you'll be remembered as the usual bastard in power, in the second you will get new mandates, love letters, books and street names for being someone who listens to common people.
- rjf72 8y agoDoes it? COICA -> PIPA -> SOPA -> CISPA -> CISA tells another tale. Sure it's the USA, but the problem is not unique to the USA. It's a part of all major political systems today. If a government is determined to get a law passed, often at the behest of special interests, they'll just keep reintroducing it and slightly changing it until they win a war of attrition. Like somebody else mentioned they have to win once, you have to win every single time. Perhaps a balancing of powers would be public referendums enabling laws to rolled back. x signatures triggers a referendum and if a supermajority (70% perhaps?) votes in favor of a rollback, a law is undone with an e.g. decade long prohibition on the reintroduction of any materially similar law. Would be quite a remarkably democratic system that could enable the citizens of a nation to remove unjust, inappropriate, or simply obsolete laws. And just to ensure that citizens and their representatives are on equal footing, so long as the signatures are repeatedly reached - these referendums could be called each and every year.
- toufiqbarhamov 8y agoSure it's the USA, but the problem is not unique to the USA. I’m listening, but it would help if you could make a list that isn’t exclusively American. It really does imply that yeah, it’s very much a problem with the form of crony capitalism found in the US.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- latexr 8y ago> I’m listening, but it would help if you could make a list that isn’t exclusively American. Not the parent commenter, but here you go: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18948465 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18948465
- toufiqbarhamov 8y agoThat’s certainly a start, but the obvious counterpoint is GDPR, which was EU-wide rather than the activity of one minor constituent nation. All told it does feel like the U.S. goes well beyond most other Western nations in terms of locally and globally imposing their IP framework through laws and treties.
- isostatic 8y ago> Eventually I hope EU completely bans organised lobbying, nothing good ever comes from pandering to special interests. Google have been lobbying hard against this for months
- rue 8y agoSure, but copyright vampires have been setting this up for years.
- latexr 8y ago> At least there seems to be no internet disaster as of now? Are you saying there’s no disaster in general? Haven’t EU Net Neutrality laws taken a huge hit recently? In Portugal, every major telecom now has zero-rating plans. It’s so prevalent, it’s the example image given on the Wikipedia page![1] Portugal is also one of the leaders in site blocking.[2] It requires no judicial order, which as expected leads to legitimate sites being blocked as well. So I wouldn’t agree there haven’t been any disasters, just that they haven’t been felt hard enough. Nobody cares about small Portugal, and citizens will take any bad rules (no net neutrality) if they get their “fix” in return (use facebook without worrying about going over the data plan, which by the way is inferior to other EU countries). [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zero-rating https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zero-rating [2]: https://torrentfreak.com/portugal-blocks-330-pirate-sites-in-just-six-months-160430/ https://torrentfreak.com/portugal-blocks-330-pirate-sites-in...
- offsetr 8y agoIt didn't seem to with the cookies
- pessimizer 8y ago> One just has to be vigilant in any new proposals that is made on this subject. And scream loudly if the lobbyists go at it again. They're being paid to do this full time; they're not going to "go at it again," they're going to continue going at it every day, from 9 to 5. And then they're going to win once. The amount of treasure to be gained by being successful can pay two lawyers for 100,000 years. There's no reason to stop even if they only see a small chance of success. That's why the system doesn't work.
- nkkollaw 8y agoYup. Then they rename it and/or break it up, and push it anyway. See EU constitutions, repeated referendums, and finally "treaty of Lisbon".
- dane-pgp 8y agoThere was one attempt at passing a constitution for the EU (the "Treaty establishing a Constitution for Europe"), which had to be ratified by all member states to take effect. Most states did in fact ratify it, but a single referendum held in France, and one in the Netherlands, rejected the idea of giving the EU a constitution. Later, most of the reforms that were part of the TCE were repackaged into a more modestly-scoped treaty, the Treaty of Lisbon, as you say. This time, though, all the "constitutional" language was removed, to make it clear that the EU is a collection of sovereign nations, as is still the case today. To give some examples of what was removed, the Lisbon Treaty does not give any official status to the EU flag or anthem, nor does it have an article that enforces the supremacy of EU law over national legislation. One might say that the EU was guilty of hubris, or even a cynical negotiating tactic of asking for more than they expected before settling for what they were prepared to accept, but the EU did at least reduce their demands after they failed to receive unanimous approval. I think that a lot of the fears about the Treaty of Lisbon have been proven wrong since then, and of course the irony is that it was the Treaty of Lisbon that first formally introduced a process for a state to leave the union, which the UK is now in the process of exercising. Whether that process is being managed well or not by the UK government is still a matter for local debate, though, it seems.
- matthewheath 8y ago> an article that enforces the supremacy of EU law over national legislation. For those unfamiliar with EU law, the Treaty of Lisbon didn't /need/ to include this particular article, so I don't know why they chose to originally (as the parent commenter says, it has since been removed). The reason the article was superfluous is that EU law is always supreme to national law. This is a core legal concept developed by the European Court of Justice. I agree that fears over the Treaty of Lisbon were overblown, and grateful that it established an exit mechanism for Member States wanting to leave. That said, the whole "let's run another referendum until we get what we want" approach doesn't endear the EU Council of Ministers or the Commission to me.
- sonnyblarney 8y agoOr maybe an example of the system coming way too close to disaster and that a 'working system' would not have introduced such byzantine legislation in the first place? And that a 'working' system would involve the implementation of some fairly common sense things?
- null000 8y agoPandering to corporate special interests, especially when citizen and labor special interests don't have a seat at the table. One of those represents a fat narrower slice of humanity than the other two, and thus is much more likely to produce negative outcomes for a majority of people if paid too much attention
- BossingAround 8y agoIt seems to me that the EU has been surprisingly good in terms of internet literacy and laws (though this is probably not the end of the Article 11 or 13). In view of recent leaks, I have filed a number of request for account deletion, given to me by GDPR, and all of them have been completed. This is pretty amazing in my mind.
- mikkom 8y agoHigh enough penalties enforced by a global power are quite effective.
- luckylion 8y agoHave you ever tried having your accounts deleted before the GDPR roll-out? Because I have, and no company ever said no.
- Kudos 8y agoThere's a big difference between "delete my account" and "delete all information you have on me". From people I've spoken to, there have been a lot of companies implementing the latter in order to be compliant.
- padthai 8y agoI could not delete my Discord account, for example, even talking with them several times by mail.
- ElFitz 8y agoAlso, some companies merely "soft-deleted" user accounts. Simple flag on the user in the database
- Quekid5 8y agoA bit of weird one here, but thedailywtf.com. I wasn't able to find any sort of "delete my account" functionality. Not that anythings changed post-GDPR, but... (The only reason I was reminded that I actually had an ancient account is that my password from there was apparently leaked and spammers tried to convince me that they'd gained control of something important. They couldn't connect the password to the site, obviously. It was just a leaked password database.)
- lbj 8y agoIm glad to see now support was found for 11/13, but Im afraid they'll poke their nasty heads in the near future. Now if we could only get GDPR trimmed down to half its current size and remove all the ambiguities I'd be thrilled.
- Mirioron 8y agoAdd a minimum threshold of company size, revenue, and data amount to GDPR. This would get rid of the biggest problems with it. In practice it already works that way.
- efdee 8y ago... there is a minimum threshold on at least company size and revenue built into the GDPR.
- Matticus_Rex 8y agoNo, there isn't. There's a minimum threshold for some extra burdens, but the vast majority of the burden has no minimum threshold (other than the fact that entirely personal activities of individuals aren't included).
- GordonS 8y agoAs a small business owner who can see things from both sides of GDPR, I disagree - GDPR really isn't that difficult to comply with.
- kolinko 8y agoFor GDPR and for VAT. After the changes 2 years ago, you have to sign up for that system to track which country's citizens buy your stuff, and pay VAT on a per-country level, with no minimums. From a perspective of SAAS / digital products it's a huge pain in the ass now. If I want to sell my app or online service now I have a lot of paperwork to fill in from the get-go.
- icebraining 8y agoAnd then the big players will use Hollywood accounting but for data - make a bunch of small companies with little revenue that handle the actual data and "sell" those services to the mothership. The whole point of using revenue-based fines was to avoid such tricks, and you want to add them back in?
- slim 8y agoJulia Reda (Pirate Party MEP) did a great job protecting our freedoms. I hope she gets reelected.
- TomMarius 8y agoThis is what I hate about the European Union. Since I am from another (member) country, I can't vote for her. Makes zero sense, her voice represents me more (as in actual votes she can lobby - due to her country being bigger and thus her party obtaining more mandates for the same result) than any party from my country does.
- kolinko 8y agoHah, I think you're getting downvotes because people think by "other country" you mean US and so on, and assume you expect Americans to be able to vote on EU politicians :) Being from Poland, my first thought was "well, of course someone from outside EU cannot vote", and then realised you mean "from another EU country".
- chmod775 8y agoMost EU countries (if not all?) have their own Pirate Party. I'm hopeful - should they reach the required number of votes - that they will find someone just as qualified to send to the EU parliament.
- StavrosK 8y ago
- cronix 8y agoI am glad cooler heads were able to prevail, and I'm heartened at the long list of countries that voted NO.
- rue 8y agoSome of the comments here are a little too optimistic, although this is a victory. The fight is not over yet. The directive needs to be written, and ideally in a way that prevents this from being brought back to the table again.