9 ms·
You don't need twins for this test. A single person can just sign up twice for these services and get different results, even if they make a single sample and
by jedberg 8y ago
You don't need twins for this test. A single person can just sign up twice for these services and get different results, even if they make a single sample and split it between the two vials.
I thought it was pretty well known that these services are estimates only to a large degree? These services only take samples, they don't sequence the entire genome. Of course there will be errors when you have to extrapolate from a sample.
Even for me personally, my results changed when my parents did it and linked up to me, because their results were able to flow into mine.
- BoiledCabbage 8y agoIf you sign up twice, won't they match your account and merge the results specifically to avoid this problem? I think part of why they used twins is to say its two different people so they'd have to treat it different. I'm actually curious how repeatable the results are. If they are using sampling of portions of the DNA (are they?) how much variability is there in a single dna sampling enun through the algorithm 10 times? Similarly for how much variability in 10 dna samples from the same person?
- dspillett 8y ago> If you sign up twice, won't they match your account and merge the results specifically to avoid this problem? Not if you sign-up with someone else's identity and pay with a different card. I very much doubt they go to any effort to verify the human the sample came from is the same human who paid and who the results are set to be sent to.
- mrits 8y ago"You have another 100% match!"
- darepublic 8y ago`Twins find each other through DNA service 23andme` read the hackernews post title
- sbr464 8y agoOr you could have a friend buy it then reimburse them. Or buy and swap a few times to see if it affects the results. Would be easier to test the theory if it wasn’t so expensive.
- benj111 8y agoI havent looked into getting a DNA test at all. But I would expect it to be accurate and repeatable.
- baddox 8y agoBut surely you wouldn’t expect it to be perfectly accurate and repeatable. It’s pretty well known that no medical test I can think of is perfect.
- CloudNetworking 8y agoPretty well known by who? The general population? I don't think so. And there's a difference between "not perfect" and "doesn't provide the same result twice".
- mtgx 8y agoYeah, I think most people would be surprised to learn that the same blood tests done by different labs can sometimes show 10% difference in values or even more. This could be the difference between a doctor declaring someone "within the normal range" or having a health problem.
- kingkawn 8y ago"Not perfect" is the hand-waving way of excusing the imperfections and proceeding as though it were nearly perfect "doesn't provide the same results twice" is the honest acknowledgement that the concept of perfection is itself what is flawed here because it creates false expectations of what science can give us in this arena
- semi-extrinsic 8y agoNo no no, "science" can definitely deliver repeatable and accurate DNA sequencing, this much is beyond question. But that's expensive, and these companies sacrifice accuracy/repeatability to make it cheap.
- mediocrejoker 8y agoCan you explain the difference between sampling and sequencing the entire genome? I had assumed they did the latter but I guess the particular markers for diseases they are interested in are at known location that they can "jump to" somehow?
- Obi_Juan_Kenobi 8y agoThere are basically 3 approaches: * Full DNA sequencing. This is a multi-million dollar effort taken on by large collaborations, usually to generate a reference genome sequence for a species or particular line. Typically a variety of methods are used, from 'shotgun' style illumina, 454 longer reads, and now some newer even-longer-read methods. Long reads are important for generating accurate assemblies. Generally, some tricky portions will need to be meticulously amplified and sequenced with traditional Sanger sequencing to clean up. This gives you a complete sequence, including all inter-gene sequences, repetitive portions, etc. * RNA sequencing. This method is the core of many molecular biology labs; you take expressed sequence (i.e. RNA that has been transcribed from DNA), reverse transcribe it to DNA, and then sequence the DNA. This gives you sequence information about the expressed part of genes (this is limited, though, because during the assembly process you'll reject many reads that don't map onto the reference sequence in standard analysis) but mostly gives you an idea of the relative expression of different genes. When people talk about gene expression going up or down in certain mutants, conditions, etc., they're usually talking about RNAseq (or qPCR if only a few loci are involved). * 'Sampling' in this case refers to chips with various DNA fragments on it. You pass the sample DNA over it, and compatible sequences hybridize together, which is then detected via florescence. These chips are designed to carry sequence fragments that vary in the population. Together, these variants form a DNA profile. The quality of this profile depends on the design of the chip. The sequences included are generally loci that are known to affect particular diseases or to be especially variable in the population for assessing ancestry. In cost magnitude, this goes from millions to thousands to tens.
- klmr 8y agoYour comment gives the impression that all DNA sequencing is a multi-million dollar effort. So, just to clarify: a modern, accurate (= 30x coverage) whole-genome DNA sequence costs less than 1000 USD. Adding long range information from single-molecule sequencing makes it only slightly more expensive.
- everdev 8y agoCan the errors extend to incorrect biological parents? I've heard stories of affairs being discovered through DNA testing. Curious if the denials might have validity.
- jedberg 8y agoI'm not a biologist so I'm basically making this up, but my guess is no. I think only false negative errors are possible because of the way they do their sampling. If two samples had enough similarity to say someone is a child of someone else, my guess is that's pretty accurate.
- JohnJamesRambo 8y agoIt would take so many errors adding up that I think it would be very impossible. Has anyone ever had a real sibling not come out as around 50% related?
- everdev 8y agoThe situation would be a child finding out they share 1 parent with their sibling instead of 2. Curious if the errors can extend that far.
- rthomas6 8y agoCould I sign up 10 times and use statistical regression to get very accurate results?
- analog31 8y agoNot necessarily. The results may only be as good as the training set that was used to produce the calibration (probably butchering the terminology). And the results that the twins got for their tests may have been "equally good" in terms of the reliability of the test. The whole concept of geographic ancestry may have fundamental limitations at the level where people are quoting percentages.
- hirsin 8y agoMine also changed after I complained that the results were obviously wrong. It indicated that several of my chromosome pairs came entirely from my father. Since that's generally impossible, it put the rest of the results in doubt.
- DoctorOetker 8y agohow long have you been using an ad-blocker? perhaps the fine print says the expected accuracy is only guaranteed if they can source an adequate profile from data mining resellers?
- wenc 8y ago> A single person can just sign up twice for these services and get different results Do you have any personal experience with this? Or anything you can cite? I'd be interested.
- riantogo 8y agoI haven’t seen a sample report, but doesn’t this mean the outcome could be, “you may or may-not be predisposed to xxx disease”. We need to spend $99 to know that?
- debacle 8y agoNo, those are specific genes they test for.
- oarabbus_ 8y ago>I thought it was pretty well known that these services are estimates only to a large degree? These services only take samples, they don't sequence the entire genome. Of course there will be errors when you have to extrapolate from a sample. The credit given to the intelligence of society at large here falls somewhere between "cute" and "astounding". I would recommend flipping through a tabloid and then considering such content sells millions of copies each print. And then reconsidering your thought that it's "pretty well known that these services are estimates only to a large degree".
- Waterluvian 8y agoI thought it was pretty well known that many tabloid readers read them the way one reads The Onion. Sorry I couldn't help myself. :)
- cowpig 8y agoSomeone buying a tabloid doesn't necessitate that they believe what they're reading. You could easily make the point that many people won't understand something without coming across as judgmental and elitist, but failed to do so.
- oarabbus_ 8y agoI disagree. He didn't ask that "don't most people know you need to fill up your car with gas once the tank gets low?" He made it seem like the fact that there is a high degree of uncertainty/estimation in genetic testing is common knowledge. We're talking about a society where half the members do not believe in anthropogenic climate change (note that I do not state the _degree_ of the change) and sizeable numbers of people (millions) don't believe in vaccination. He said "Of course there will be errors when you have to extrapolate from a sample." The common man doesn't know what extrapolate from a sample even means! I'm sorry but suggesting society as a whole understands genetic testing methods and techniques is just so far absolutely removed from reality (you're perhaps justified if you work for Illumina or are a faculty member of a University) that the point needed to be made even if harshly. Maybe I just interact more with "non hacker news" types than the average poster here, but that post quite frankly seemed so absurdly out of touch as to remind me of the Lucille Bluth quote from Arrested Development - "I mean, it's one banana Michael. How much could it possibly cost? 10 dollars?"
- cwmma 8y agoOn top of that even if they were able to sequence things perfectly the thing they are actually measuring is a very fuzzy thing. Like it's no surprise that one of the test had one twin from England but the other from Scotland/Ireland because people having been moving between those 3 countries for millennia so there isn't really a platonic idea of 'English DNA' it's just markers that tend to show up in England, but also show up near England but somewhat less and may also randomly popup other places, but usually not all of them in one other place.
- tru3_power 8y agoAre there any services that sequence the entire genome/have a higher level of accuracy?
- klmr 8y agoDantelabs does. Note: I am not endorsing their service, I have no experience with them.
- gumby 8y agoIt always surprised me to see them reporting results to a 10th of a percent precision (e.g. "2.3%"). I'd assumed that the best they could do on an individual was a couple of orders of magnitude less precise (e.g. 10%, 20%)
- analog31 8y agoBy day, I work with scientific equipment. Most people understand significant digits. But they also have conditioned expectations related to the number of digits that they see, and the quality of the equipment or measurement. People just like to see a digit after the decimal.
- 2bitencryption 8y agoYeah, "You're 76% German" makes my monkey brain think, "Come on, you're making that number up." But "76.2%" makes me think, "Ah, the miracles of science, time for a weizen of pilsner!"
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- adrianmonk 8y agoI wonder if there may be two issues here, one related to consistency and one related to twins. That is, you may not need twins to get differing results, but being twins may still be one of the reasons for differing results. I'm not a biologist, but apparently it's not the case that twins have exactly identical DNA: "Identical Twins' Genes Are Not Identical" ( https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/identical-twins-genes-are-not-identical/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/identical-twins-g... )
- jasongill 8y agoI did exactly this back when 23andMe switched to a newer chip. I signed up for a second account and matched with myself as a full brother. The old chip account had less data points (health items, etc) but most of the data was about the same. My wife did the same with the same result, as did a friend who had purchased the original 23andMe kit and wanted to get the newer data from the new chip. So while I don't doubt the accuracy of the linked article, my anecdotal experience is that the 23andMe DNA tests have repeatability at least.