5 ms·
> My email list is broadcast-only but any replies go directly to me. This sort of mass-email is weirdly impersonal because it tells the recipient that you want
by gnicholas 8y ago
> My email list is broadcast-only but any replies go directly to me.
This sort of mass-email is weirdly impersonal because it tells the recipient that you want them to know what you're up to, but you don't want to write a message just to them. Also, it would be very awkward to opt-out ("hey dude, um please don't send me your mass-email updates anymore."), unlike company emails which there's no awkwardness around unsubscribing.
I'm not saying this isn't better than FB, but it still has some downsides (some of which the author may be overlooking because they don't bother him).
- bacon_waffle 8y agoI have a few friends who send out periodic group emails like these, though IIRC only one uses mailing list software to do it. I really enjoy the mailings, and keep meaning to start sending them out myself. Receiving one of the mailings feels much more personal to me than I guess seeing a fb post would (I've been off it for several years), and seems more likely to prompt a personal reply from me. Not sure I understand the worry about awkwardness with opting out - surely it's just as easy to ignore an email as a post on "social media"?
- sm4rk0 8y ago"Broadcast-only" means subscribers can't post to it. But they still can reply to the list owner. It could be mixed with a blog, if you wanted to make it possible for subscribers (and others) to publicly interact. Also, I don't see a problem if a person finds my emails uninteresting and unsubscribes.
- gnicholas 8y ago> Also, I don't see a problem if a person finds my emails uninteresting and unsubscribes. Sure, but do all of your recipients know that? The point is that some people would be very uncomfortable doing this, even if you wouldn't subjectively be offended by it. And as the author notes, doing an opt-in system makes things complicated and potential excludes less tech-savvy folks.
- sm4rk0 8y agoThere are ways to solve this: 1. It could be written in message footer that I won't take unsubscribes personally. 2. That person could just create a filter for that mailing list to avoid unsubscribing. Also, less tech-savy folks could just ask for help and I'd subscribe them manually.
- Gys 8y ago> weirdly impersonal because it tells the recipient that you want them to know what you're up to, but you don't want to write a message just to them. Also, it would be very awkward to opt-out ("hey dude, um please don't send me your mass-email updates anymore.") You mean, like a post on FB ? Or Tweeting ? Readable for all ‘friends’ or ‘followers’ ? Who very likely are not really interested in your message ?
- gnicholas 8y agoIf you follow someone on Twitter, that means you want to get their updates. And it's trivially easy to mute people on Twitter/FB so that you can stop seeing people's messages without risking offending them or hurting their feelings. Another reply mentions having people who don't want to read your email newsletter set up filters to get rid of them. This is possible, but more work than a two-click mute on social media platforms. Don't get me wrong — I'm not saying FB/Twitter are "better" — just that this solution occupies a middle ground that creates different privacy/relationship issues.
- NotAnEconomist 8y ago> This is possible, but more work than a two-click mute on social media platforms. It was four clicks for me to set up an email filter on Gmail in response to a message in my inbox. And there's considerably more filtering options, had I wanted something non-trivial, than there are on FB or Twitter, which are all or nothing -- after all, on email I have the option to more than mute, such as to classify the message based on various parameters.
- eeeeeeeeeeeee 8y agoI think it’s interesting this point that keeps coming up about “offending” people. If someone posts a heartfelt post on Facebook and not a single person likes or comments, isn’t there the same outcome?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- joe_the_user 8y ago
- eeeeeeeeeeeee 8y agoWhy not ask people to opt-in to your list? That’s how I would do it. I definitely have close friends and family that would be interested and it would eliminate 80% of the “friends” from Facebook I have no interest in conversing with at all.