5 ms·
Strong and Weak Technologies
- philprx 8y agoOne could propose that weak technologies as described by Cdixon are just un-finished version of one technology. It's super hard to close the loop on a technology. It was often said that the companies who benefit the most from one type of technology are not the first to innovate but the last to innovate, e.g. Facebook not For etc. It's because what creates the finest working loop is hard to design into existence and tweak into motion.
- gomijacogeo 8y agoIf you rolled back the clock a decade or so, every 'weak' technology listed could have been presented as a 'strong' technology with another, earlier technology as the 'weak' one. E.g. Private intranets <- dedicated hardlines, Interactive TV <- broadcast TV, MP3 downloads <- physical objects (records, tapes, etc), Hybrid cars <- gasoline cars, ... I'd reframe it as: Technologists come in two flavors, the ones who think their current era is fundamentally distinct from earlier eras, and the ones who don't.
- Walkman 8y agoVery good point!
- suprfnk 8y agoI don't agree that "Augmented reality" is the weak form for "Virtual reality". They are two different concepts. Augmented reality is all about augmenting the real, physical world you live in. Virtual reality is about stepping into another world that (usually) has nothing to do with your real, physical surroundings.
- purplethinking 8y agoMaybe the real world is the weak reality? You can do anything in virtual reality, while the real world has tons of limitations. Thinking (very) long term, I don't see a reason for why we should prefer the physical reality made of atoms arranged in an arbitrary way and with laws we can't control or change, rather than the reality made of bits of information with limitless possibilities. It's sort of the difference between theatre and motion pictures. Theatre plays are great, but they are limited by what can be physically done on stage with real world objects and flesh and blood actors. Motion pictures with CGI has no such limitations.
- comex 8y agoIn the far future, maybe. But as long as we remain trapped in physical bodies that fundamentally need to spend a lot of time out and about in the real world, augmented reality will fill a niche that virtual reality cannot. It’s just that the technology isn’t ready yet. Once you can buy glasses that do things like, say, labeling people with their names, or giving walking directions by visually highlighting the path you need to take… then AR will really take off. (VR also has a long way to go before it reaches its potential; it’s just that for various reasons its current state is more “demoable”.)
- zapzupnz 8y ago> It's sort of the difference between theatre and motion pictures. Theatre plays are great, but they are limited by what can be physically done on stage with real world objects and flesh and blood actors. Motion pictures with CGI has no such limitations. By the same token, the experience of going to the theatre, seeing the actors live in person, being impressed by someone belting out a song (if it's a musical) for the umpteenth time that week and it still sounding amazing, feeling like a part of the action thanks to things like audience participation — things that you can't always get in CGI. Every time I watch a play, I always come away with a bizarre sense in my gut that I associate with disappointment that the experience is over; I don't feel the same thing with movies. Same thing with AR and VR. Yes, you might be able to do many more impressive things immersed in VR space — but there's a certain quality associated with the real world, what's directly in front of your eyes rather than a picture, that cannot and should not be ignored. There's nothing like a live performance and there's nothing like the real world (not even a simulation of it).
- Kinrany 8y agoTl;dr: the author proposes a scale where the strength of technology measures how much the world had to do to start using that technology. Another interpretation is that "weak" technology is designed to be immediately usable and useful, while "strong" technology expects the world to adapt and succeeds in this expectation. Perhaps using the word "compatible" or a synonym would be more appropriate.
- red_admiral 8y agoWhile the idea is sound, a lot of the examples are questionable to the point where I wonder if this is just another "blockchain is the future" shill article. Private clouds are extremely big business for FAANG and some governments, for example (I believe there's a particularly big one in Utah). iTunes is doing fine last time I checked. Pokemon Go is AR not VR and so on. The problem is that for every iPhone, there are 99 other technologies that are not adapted to the world, and fail as a consequence (3D TV where you have to wear polarising glasses at home or sit at exactly the right angle to the screen, anyone?). It's not a hard problem to look back at what has already happened and explain it with your pet theory, as long as your theory is sufficiently flexible. Using a theory to predict what's not happened yet, and getting it right - now that's where the real money is. The model as presented here doesn't seem very strong at identifying what upcoming technologies will be the strong ones, but really good at explaining things retroactively. As an investor at least, that's of limited use. On blockchains specifically, I can imagine a world where in 10 years' time bitcoin has completely collapsed. In fact, Satoshi has the possibility to create such a world if they still have the private key to their initial coins. I can also imagine a world where private/regulated chains are widely used and permissionless ones less so, or one where permissionless chains have taken off in a way they haven't yet. It's really too early to tell, although the Ethereum/DAO experiment makes me pessimistic.
- padobson 8y agoI completely agree with this. After reading some of the examples in the list (E-Sports vs. Traditional Sports, Hybrid Cars vs Electric Cars), it was clear the concept was not fully baked. This one needs to go back in the oven for a bit. In the case of hybrids vs. electrics, it's fine if you want to say hybrids are like the Blackberry - an initiating technology that prepares the market for a sweeping, fundamental change. But that's certainly different from Augmented Reality and Virtual Reality, two technologies that aim to accomplish different things, or streaming music vs MP3 downloads, which offer two different value propositions in the lease vs. own models. The idea needs to be more specific, like initiating technology vs. mature technology or evolutionary technology vs. revolutionary technology. One could say the Blackberry or the Palm Pilot was actually the revolution, where the iPhone was the right evolution of that technology to fully capture the market. But now I'm just trying to backfit a backfitted concept.
- mrob 8y ago>Strong technologies capture the imaginations of technology enthusiasts. By this definition, I disagree that music streaming is a strong technology. Streaming succeeded because it appealed to non-enthusiasts, who are a bigger market. Technology enthusiasts were early adopters of MP3 downloads, and I think they are still generally in favor of owning their own music.
- sidcool 8y agoThat's a good article and I agree with its essence, but some examples don't seem correct to me. Sometimes Weak Technologies are a necessary intermediate step to strong ones. Autopilot is a major stepping stone to full autonomy and Hybrid cars would pave the way (economically) for fully electric/hydrogen cars.
- evrydayhustling 8y agoWonder what the reasoning is on putting virtual and augmented reality on strong and weak sides respectively. I guess virtual reality inspired more new hardware in the 2016 boom, but maybe just because it was easier? VR feels more to me like 3D TV - something the industry would love to create a new generation of products, but doesn't actually improve experiences enough to motivate consumers and culture creators.
- shmerl 8y ago> Streaming music (Spotify) MP3 downloads (e.g. iTunes) Streaming (only) implies DRM. DRM-free downloads (Bandcamp) are always better. So it's a bad example, where some technology made things worse.
- thanatropism 8y agoWorse is better is worse is better is worse is...
- tacostakohashi 8y agoThis is more or less the idea from Antifragile: Things That Gain from Disorder (Nassim Nicholas Taleb), but in the form of a terse article with questionable examples. The "strong" technologies are those that benefit from technology improvements and competition / contributions from many parties ("volatility"), and the "weak" technologies are those that are dependent on a single company or ecosystem, and don't benefit from improvements in bandwidth.
- techpop10 8y agoThis is such an awful post. This is the equivalent of looking back at the last 50+ Super Bowls and proudly claiming the winner of each one. Very "Captain Obvious". Surprised he didn't have "automobiles" in the strong category and "horses" in the "weak" category. A few of these (cloud and blockchain) touch on current technologies but this is a really twisted (and cheap) way to demonstrate his key point that truly innovative technology means thinking outside of current norms. No kidding!