9 ms·
I think your point about employees is especially true, particularly since the large tech companies pay disproportionately so much more. If you are a senior-leve
by hn_throwaway_99 8y ago
I think your point about employees is especially true, particularly since the large tech companies pay disproportionately so much more. If you are a senior-level software engineer, even if the startup is successful in the "unicorn" range, for most people that means an equity payout on the couple hundred K to the $1 million range for all but the very largest successes. Not bad at all, but when the FAANGS are already paying in the 250-500k range, going to a startup is you are not an exec or founder is almost always a poor financial decision. And remember, the vast majority of startups still fail outright.
- milquetoastaf 8y agoNot everyone can get a FAANG job nor do many FAANG jobs pay >300k
- hamandcheese 8y agoThis is assuming one can get hired by a FAANG, which is not true for many.
- billconan 8y agoI’m about to join a startup. I just want to do meaningful work and learn new things. I view it as a learning experience. I am so fed up with corporation life. I don’t see a way out other than joining a startup or starting my own. I don’t want to deal with project managers and fill their spreadsheets anymore. The most valuable thing I have is the remaining time I have in this life. Not the number in my bank account.
- jonathanyc 8y ago> I don’t want to deal with project managers and fill their spreadsheets anymore. Oh boy are you in for a surprise. Whether a company is a startup or not is almost entirely orthogonal to a culture of “filling out spreadsheets.”
- hsk0823 8y agoCareful what you wish for, startups have people who will wear as many different hats as required to make it work. Corporate life may have had a really well defined job role, that may not be true in any startup you join.
- billconan 8y agoI think I'm very entrepreneurial. "wear as many different hats as required to make it work", this is basically what I do for my side projects. I write both the web frontend (vue) and backend (in c++), do devops, content marketing, whereas my day job is device driver development.
- tiuPapa 8y ago> Backend in C++ Why? Is that simply because you are more familiar with the language or does the project actually require the raw power of Cpp?
- billconan 8y ago1. manage the cost. I fund my project out of my pocket. knowing how expensive AWS could be (through my day job), I'd keep my code efficient. 2. yes, familiarity.
- tiuPapa 8y agoCool to know. Do you use any framework for the backend? And if you don't mind what's the project? I am thinking about using Rust for one of my projects but I am still unsure if I should use it instead of something like NodeJs or Python.
- x220 8y ago>The most valuable thing I have is the remaining time I have in this life Then why work for a startup? Most will demand a huge amount of your time compared to other jobs. Why not pick a job which demands a sane amount of your time and spend your free time on relationships and hobbies?
- billconan 8y agothe startup is in robotics, highly aligned with my interests.
- x220 8y agoAll the startup employees I've talked to work 80 hours a week. Why is robots so important to you that you're willing to accomplish absolutely nothing in at least a few of the important areas of your life such as health and fitness, friendships, romantic relationships, extraneous interests, relaxation, or family?
- billconan 8y agothere are 2 kinds of engineers, one kind sent rockets and recollected them, made robots run and jump. The other kind, shrank blog posts to 140 characters, or added a timeout to short messages, removed the thumb down button, and called them a new feature. Today, we still remember the names of da Vinci, Tesla, Turing, not because they had a successful family ... I just want to keep the dream I had as a kid.
- dta5003 8y agoIt's not for everyone, but it sounds like you know what you want, and you are in the position to do it. Go for it!
- x220 8y ago>Today, we still remember the names of So you're living based on how you will be remembered by strangers? That sounds incredibly unfulfilling and doesn't sound like a good way to live. In a few hundred more years almost no one will remember the names of those people either. >da Vinci, Tesla, Turing It's incredibly safe to say that you are not going to be as successful as these people. Almost no one achieves this much success in the sciences. At most you will probably advance your field by a few useful steps and then be personally forgotten about except in research paper footnotes. >not because they had a successful family You know who cares about you and remembers you more significantly than as a research footnote? Your family. >I just want to keep the dream I had as a kid Man, don't we all.
- woolvalley 8y agoI work at a big tech co. I almost never fill out any spreadsheet, use JIRA, use a ticketing system that strongly, worry about 'user stories', have 'hurry up and wait' deadlines and so on. Maybe go to another big co?
- mi100hael 8y agoI wouldn't say all of those things are bad things. I'd hope even the smallest of startups is thinking about how users interact with their software and organizing those interactions into some sort of prioritized backlog for development.
- woolvalley 8y agoWe definitely have a planning process, I do write things down into design docs, and do keep track of things in some spreadsheets, docs and tickets. But I don't find it an excessive, oppressive or impractical process, which is probably what the parent post is hinting to.
- foobiekr 8y agoI would love to know about the list of "good" big companies (and good teams within them). In my direct experience, the big companies are soul crushing and monotonous and one is surrounded by mediocrity.
- woolvalley 8y agoThe best way to find out is to go interview at big cos, and ask them about all of your worries about process. One team can have a ton of process, the other can barely have any. It's really mostly a team and department basis thing. In my limited experience in talking with other people, FAANG tends to not have as much process as finance, IBM, insurance or other 'boring big companies'.
- eanzenberg 8y agoConversely, this assumes one can get hired at a startup with a high position and equity to match fang comp, which is not true for many.
- dunpeal 8y agoIt's not true for almost anyone. Conversely, if you can get hired to a unicorn in a position that's senior enough to have any hope of coming anywhere near top tech pay, then you are likely talented enough to work at top tech instead.
- eanzenberg 8y agoNot necessarily, as talents at that level which are valued in top tech may be different than talents at that level that are valued at growing startups. There a variety of companies that pay top dollar for talent, straddling early stage startups all the way through established companies. That doesn't mean it's easy to get those jobs. It does mean that you should apply your talents where it fits. BTW, you don't need to be at a unicorn to earn top EV. 1% of a 100M exit is 1M, which is more than the vast majority of equity grants I've heard of from FANG. Many people put 0 value on startup equity. Those people decrease their lifetime EV through misconceptions of statistics.
- dunpeal 8y ago> Not necessarily, as talents at that level which are valued in top tech may be different than talents at that level that are valued at growing startups. I worked at both. Talent overlap is quite high, far higher than is commonly assumed. > There a variety of companies that pay top dollar for talent, straddling early stage startups all the way through established companies. I worked in startups for many years, and most of my friends still in the field are either founders or C-level execs. They are fully aware of the top compensation for top engineers in startups presently. Startups don't match top tech comp currently. Unless you factor in the options as a sure thing, and the startup ends up exiting at unicorn levels. > Many people put 0 value on startup equity. Those people decrease their lifetime EV through misconceptions of statistics. This is a reflection of how many people have spent precious years of their career working for startups, and generally seeing 0 return on these options. It's also a reflection of the perceived lack of control over this sort of deferred compensation, and various nasty dynamics that often snatch value away from rank-and-file employees, even at the last minute or past it. See the LinkedIn exit and their infamous clawback policy. Startup options have earned this reputation for 0 value over a decade of overhype and underperformance. Far too many talented people were promised the sky and ended up with nothing after years of hard work.
- cdoxsey 8y agoThank you for saying this. The point about FAANG paying so much gets made a lot, and that employees of startups are fools for their decisions, as if everyone's handed a dozen offers and makes a choice. Most of us are lucky to get a single offer, sometimes after months of trying, so we take what we are given. The rosy picture portrayed on HN isn't at all accurate to my experience. Though to be fair my current salary, as far as it is from the unrealistic portrayal of salaries here, still feels far better than almost any other job I would remotely have the capacity to do, and certainly far more than I need to live and have a pretty easy life if I were honest. I'm payed a crazy amount of money to do something I love.
- adventured 8y agoThese two statements contrasted is pretty fascinating: > The rosy picture portrayed on HN isn't at all accurate to my experience. > I'm payed a crazy amount of money ["far more than I need to live and have a pretty easy life"] to do something I love. You're living the rosy picture portrayed on HN. You react to $400k the same way most people would react to what you're describing.
- cdoxsey 8y agoSorry if I wasn't clear. I don't make 400k per year and I've tried to work at high paying tech companies in the bay area in the past and was rejected many times. At one point I was close to giving up on being a developer entirely after months of failing to find work, though thankfully I had a friend from a former job who helped give me a legup to a startup he was working for. It was that painful experience which made me grateful for what I have, even if its looked down on so much by my peers. I realized how lucky I was to be working at all. The rosy picture I was referring too wasn't so much the salary as the ability of software engineers to get these jobs. In my experience it was a lot more like a professional sport (spend decades working and practicing in this field and you still don't have what it takes) than finding a store with a help-wanted sign and filling out an application. I guess there's something of a paradox there... its a weird industry.
- dawhizkid 8y agoBest bet is a growth co that offers RSUs over options and a few years away from IPO. They will generally offer you a premium over what you'd make at a similar level in a public co (to make up for the illiquidity of the stock), and if you believe in the growth story it can pay off big time.
- aliston 8y agoWhy RSUs over options? In CA, in particular, if you're at a rocketship, the tax benefits of early exercised options can be huge, whereas with RSUs you're paying 30-40% to the government.
- dawhizkid 8y agoif you have the funds to early exercise, chances are you're joining a company that isn't yet a rocketship. and of course at that stage you can't make the same comparison with what you'd get at FB because your strike price is probably in the pennies and you're getting some small % of the overall company. Real world example: low to mid level engineers at Uber joining in 2014/2015 at this point have stock worth over $2m over 4 years if Uber successfully IPOs at $100b+. By that time, Uber was already at "scale", offering RSUs (options strike price would be so expensive that it would be a huge risk to exercise), and that $2m is almost definitely more than what you'd otherwise have received in the same amount of time working at Google or FB.
- dunpeal 8y agoPrecisely. A senior engineer can certainly hope to make $400k or more per year for good performance. Not just in FAANG either - plenty of other profitable businesses are competing for the same grade of talent and thus pay in the same range. Only a handful of almost surefire unicorns can reasonably come anywhere near matching that, and that only in the eventuality that they don't pull a Zenefits and leave you hundreds of thousands of dollars to millions of dollars short and in need of a new job. Anecdotally, last year I was contacted by such a surefire unicorn for a role that was actually very interesting. We crunched the numbers together, and the best case scenario was them effectively matching my current comp. Which was actually a great proposition for startup comp, the best I've seen. Still, nowhere near compelling enough to upend my life for a higher risk position without any financial upside. I worked in startups for the early part of my career, including a fairly well known one that exited. Neither me, nor any of my colleagues in that startup, nor any of the many other startup employees in my network, ever made more than a few hundred thousands on our options. Many very talented engineers made nothing at all on large quantities of options granted by several promising startups. It's no wonder that none of the recent graduates I interview nowadays is at all interested in startups. When I ask where else they are interviewing, it's always FAANG and other high-flying profitable businesses. Even more so for senior engineers, whose opportunity cost is even higher, typically in the hundreds of thousands per year.
- megaman8 8y ago> "hope to make 400k" Even with 10-20 years of experience in the bay area at small, medium, large size software companies, I've never ever made anything close to that amount.
- dunpeal 8y agoFAANG and other large, profitable companies like Microsoft will pay you that.
- babaganoosh89 8y agoFAANG tends to pay ~300k for senior engineers. For 400k you usually need to get lucky with stock appreciation.
- ucosty 8y agoWe can't all be FAANG employees, and those salaries certainly are not realistic in the UK.