3 ms·
The smart rod made me think. What is it about competitive hobbies and having the best kit. If you go fishing and have the best rod, bait, hooks, where's the up
by benj111 8y ago
The smart rod made me think.
What is it about competitive hobbies and having the best kit.
If you go fishing and have the best rod, bait, hooks, where's the upside? You cant be sure that massive fish you caught is your skill or just tech.
Everyone would expect you to catch a big fish because you have all the kit.
If on the other hand you just have a cheap rod etc, that big fish you catch, you caught because of your skill. The guy sitting next to you with all the kit, that's just caught a massive fish is ok, because he has all the kit.
I've noticed the same thing with cycling and golf.
I suppose you could say its to prove you're part of a group, but isn't being sat in the rain, next to a muddy pond proof enough?
- sz4kerto 8y agoYep, this is what eventually leads to back-to-the-nature movements (barefoot running, free climbing, expeditions without oxygen masks, etc.).
- Sendotsh 8y agoIt's everywhere though not just hobbies. Whether it's what clothes you wear, what phone you have, what car you drive. (Most) people want to have better stuff than those around them. "Beat the Joneses" etc. Consumerism is a drug, and it's incredibly addictive. It took me a long long time to stop caring about having the best stuff. New phone every year, new laptop every 2. As fancy a car as I could afford, high end fishing gear, etc. Thankfully, having kids let me "grow up" a lot in a very short timeframe, and I now have a 15yr old car, 4yr old phone, and generally just cheap but functional stuff around me, but it's still hard to shake that urge.
- claudius 8y agoEven though a hobby may be competitive, you don’t have to do it competitively. Maybe you just want to go fishing and catch fish and you’re happy if you caught one and want to catch more. As a hobbyist cyclist, I like having a decent bike simply because it’s more fun to cycle with less effort. Of course I could get an old crappy one to show off my skill and constitution, but that’s not the point for me. The point is to have some fun and while part of this fun is due to achieving goals, achieving a hard goal with a little help such as a good bike is still more fun than not achieving the hard goal, especially if it’s due to comparably-bad tech. Whether your threshold for bad tech is now a really old bike or a not-newest bike is merely a quantitative difference and in the end subject to personal preferences.
- benj111 8y agoWhere do ebikes fit into that picture?
- amelius 8y agoEbikes can be of assistance without spoiling the entire experience. For example, they may allow you to make more miles with the same human effort. One application is that they might allow you to bike to work, in cases where it would otherwise not be practically possible.
- jdietrich 8y agoThey fit a different niche. Some people cycle for fitness or sporting reasons; a motor might compromise the sense of achievement of going faster and further under your own power. A lot of people cycle just to enjoy the outdoors; the idea of going faster and further for the same effort might seem perfectly logical. Ebikes are a great solution if you're just using a bicycle as functional transport, serving as a convenient halfway house between a bicycle and motorcycle.
- scruple 8y agoPeople who go fishing for competitiveness are going fishing for the wrong reason, AFAIC. "Many men go fishing all of their lives without knowing that it is not fish that they are after." - Thoreau
- michaelt 8y agoWell, that's partly because you've specified "competitive hobbies". 98% of cyclists don't compete in time trials or races. If you single out the 2% of cyclists whose hobby is trying to go faster than the guy next to them, and ask why they buy equipment to make them go faster than the guy next to them, isn't the answer obvious?
- benj111 8y ago98% of cyclists may not compete, but a large % will shave their legs, don Lycra, and time themselves etc. Plus 98% of cyclists don't ride around on sit up and beg bikes, wearing normal clothes etc, outside of the Netherlands and a few other countries.
- michaelt 8y agoNo doubt it depends on your location. Cycle commuters in my locale look like [1] - you might see people with TT bars and shaved legs from time to time, but it's certainly not the norm. And if instead of cycle commuters you look at weekend cyclists on scenic bike paths, or the bikes locked to bike racks at major train stations, the vast majority won't be top-price high performance bikes. [1] https://www.123rf.com/photo_30847100_london-may-6th-unidentified-people-commute-to-work-on-may-the-6th-2014-in-london-england-uk-the-lond.html https://www.123rf.com/photo_30847100_london-may-6th-unidenti...
- benj111 8y ago"scenic bike paths" We obviously live in different UKs. It is more of a weekend rider thing, I note theres still only one sit up and beg, to the two drop handled bikes. Edit: Just to add, that picture is quite encouraging. People actually cycling in 'normal' clothes, a sign of an improving cycling culture. Hopefully it will spread to the rest of the UK.
- thisone 8y agowhy are Scandinavian style bikes, ridden by people in day clothes, seemingly the only acceptable bike commuter to you? what is it about the look of someone on, say a hybrid, who's wearing gear appropriate to their commute (which may be athletic gear) that induces so much tut-tutting?
- retSava 8y agoA part of the puzzle is just that it feels better. It's a bit like taking a long walk - with nice shoes you'll enjoy the views and weather, with bad shoes you'll just think about the pain in your sore back and knees. Myself, I generally strive to find the stuff at the point of diminishing returns. Top stuff is often just expensive in comparison, bottom stuff you just have to fight all the time.
- benj111 8y agoGood point, I think it goes past that though? Racing cycles and saddles aren't comfortable. And as for the quality feel. Is a smart rod going the feel better than a traditional rod?
- jdietrich 8y ago>Racing cycles and saddles aren't comfortable. They aren't uncomfortable if you're fast. The harder you ride, the more force you're applying to your pedals and so more of your weight is borne by your feet and hands. The saddle on a racing bicycle is more of a perch than a seat; it's a very important link in the connection between rider and bicycle, but it doesn't need to be plushly padded. A wide and heavily padded saddle deforms and creates a large and unstable contact area with the rider, which increases friction and leads to nasty chafing on longer rides. It seems superficially insane to use a hard and narrow saddle and padded shorts, but it's actually a very comfortable solution for a fast rider who spends a lot of time in the saddle. It's also worth bearing in mind the relatively enormous forces that a fast rider can apply to their bicycle. Solutions that work fine when you're pootling along at 120w are hopelessly unstable if you're banging out 500w in a hard effort or 1500w in a bunch sprint. You need a very stiff frame, you need stiff shoes with a rigid attachment to the pedals, you need high pressure tyres with good lateral stiffness. That stiffness can be bone-rattling at times, but it can also be very satisfying. There's a directness and agility to a good road bike, a precise connection to the road that is essential for professionals and hugely enjoyable for a certain sort of amateur. You can't do this on a "comfortable" bike: https://youtu.be/QE97iUvSHk0 https://youtu.be/QE97iUvSHk0 https://youtu.be/RxXqQqAc2pA https://youtu.be/RxXqQqAc2pA
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoLike car buying. In the UK many people buy over powered cars as if they're going to be racing them, preferring speed over comfort/durability/economy. Then they commute in them sitting alone in super-accelerating, high-speed, family-sized vehicles in traffic jams going under 30mph.
- huffmsa 8y agoLike car buying everywhere. For as rapidly as Teslas can accelerate off the line, I don't think I've ever had one out pull me leaving a light, and I'm never flooring it either
- arethuza 8y agoIt seems to be a device that you attach to your rod and it records where and how you cast. I don't see why that's hugely different to recording running/walking/cycling activity - which loads of people already do (and I do for walking/cycling).
- lmm 8y agoWhy use proper technique - wouldn't it show more skill to catch a fish when using poor technique? If you're not trying to catch fish why are you fishing at all? There is joy in doing a hard thing well, in improving yourself. But the only way to actually improve is to have an objective-enough standard for the thing you're doing - weight of fish, speed on bike, number of strokes in golf. Without that it devolves into "I only caught a small fish? Oh well, I was using a cheap rod, and my left hand, and I wasn't really trying anyway". Whereas if you caught a bigger fish this time, there's no way to fake that.
- benj111 8y ago"There is joy in doing a hard thing well, in improving yourself" Yes, which is why I'm confused. I'm not asking why people cycle instead of motorcycle, or don't go to the fish shop instead of fishing. With fishing surely theres an upper bound on the size of the fish, the worst rod can still catch it, while showing superior skill.
- lmm 8y ago> Yes, which is why I'm confused. I'm not asking why people cycle instead of motorcycle, or don't go to the fish shop instead of fishing. Well, it's two sides of the same coin: why is "no motor" a restriction that makes for an interesting hobby but "crappy bike" isn't? My answer is that trying to be as fast as possible subject to x can be interesting provided there's a clear sharp line between x and not-x. E.g. plenty of people ride single-speed bicycles - but they'll still try to be as fast as possible within that restriction, and may well buy an expensive single-speed bicycle for doing so. Indeed the vast majority of cyclists follow UCI's decidedly arbitrary rules which are explicitly designed to make cycling a bit less pay-to-win (minimum bicycle weight so that bikes made with cheaper materials can still be competitive, arbitrary spoke/frame shape requirements to make wind-tunnel testing less effective and limit innovative designs). You could say that people stick to the UCI rules so that they can compare to other UCI cyclists and be part of the same community, and I'm sure that's a part of that, but IMO that's a minor factor. The really important thing is having a ruleset that you can't easily change yourself: the UCI rules are external and fixed, whereas if I tried to follow my own definition of what a "crappy bike" was and be as fast as possible within that, there would always be a question of why that particular definition, and whether I could/should change something. If I got a new bike and was faster on it, would that be "cheating" because the new bike wasn't "crappy enough"? What about things I hadn't thought of in my ruleset? (e.g. when I first started cycling I hadn't even heard of cleats, so would switching to cleats have been breaking my rules?)