9 ms·
> It's technically illegal to have a wild animal as a pet in Brazil, as officials want to ensure vulnerable creatures don't get separated from their families an
by tzs 8y ago
> It's technically illegal to have a wild animal as a pet in Brazil, as officials want to ensure vulnerable creatures don't get separated from their families and that they can be reintroduced into the wild after injury.
Same where I am. I've wondered, though. What constitutes a pet?
For example, I give peanuts to the wild squirrels around my house. This is not illegal where I live. It is illegal, however, to keep a wild squirrel as a pet.
Several of the squirrels seem to recognize me, and run up to me when I go out, get up on their hind legs, and wave their front paws around in a gesture that looks like they are asking for peanuts.
I'm pretty sure some of them would come inside to get their peanuts if I opened the front door but did not go outside. From there I could probably train them to essentially be pets [1].
But would they legally be pets, and therefore illegal, if they were free to come and go at will? Or would they simply be wild animals coming into human space, which happens to be controlled by a human who isn't going to make them leave?
A co-worker had a similar situation with a raccoon. He was giving her food, and she got more and more comfortable with him, to the point she would come right up, and peacefully accept food and petting. She even brought her babies by apparently to show them to him.
Was he legally keeping a pet raccoon?
[1] I don't actually want squirrels in my house. In fact, I've done some looking into squirrel traps in case one does come in and I need to get it out. That almost happened a couple of times when I was tossing peanuts from the door, and one squirrel startled another from behind, causing the first squirrel to dash forward right toward my door.
- gerbilly 8y ago> I've wondered, though. What constitutes a pet? We don't need categories to be so rigid. I have some squirrels in the yard who recognise me and follow me around until I feed them. I call them 'yard pets'. Sometimes they come into the house when they are too excited, but I've never had trouble escorting them out. I don't particularly like the idea of laws getting in the way of my relationship with animals, even if they are wild.
- shliachtx 8y ago> We don't need categories to be so rigid. For the purposes of law we do. > I don't particularly like the idea of laws getting in the way of my relationship with animals, even if they are wild. And yet there is a case to be made for these laws to prevent animals from abuse, etc. These kinds of laws are usually well-served by having an attached definition of what constitutes a pet as it is used in the law. The more defined a law is, the less likely it is to get in the way where it isn't supposed to.
- circlefavshape 8y ago> For the purposes of law we do No we don't. That's why we have judges
- scarface74 8y agoAnd judges never give out different sentences based race or affluence....
- reaperducer 8y agoIs squirrel a race now?
- scarface74 8y agoNo but the person going in front of the judge is where the less clear the law is, the more of a chance for bias.
- ozzmotik 8y agosure if you mean it by the old sense of a species (cf. the human race)
- shliachtx 8y agoJudges are not lawmakers. They serve to interpret the laws accurately. Of course, often the laws are not codified very specifically, so it is left to judges to interpret it as straightforwardly as possible.
- gerbilly 8y agoMeh, I'm just talking about everyday interactions with squirrels in the yard. You're not telling me I'm going to need a lawyer to negotiate that, are you? :-) It's consensual, the squirrels enjoy the interaction and so do I. Either is free to defect anytime. Fun fact. Squirrels in most north american cities are not wild creatures, they were deliberately introduced into parks to create what was called 'communal pets'. The thinking was that the need to care for them would be a positive influence on people. There is a paper on it: The Urbanization of the Eastern Gray Squirrel in the United States Etienne Benson J Am Hist (2013) 100 (3): 691-710.
- vvanders 8y agoTo get a bit pedantic you're on the path to domesticating those squirrels, most wildlife professionals wouldn't consider them wild any more. My father worked for WI DNR for many years and it always irked him that people feeding the wildlife didn't think they were doing any harm when they were making the animals co-dependent on that food source.
- gerbilly 8y agoReposting from below. Eastern grey squirrels were deliberately introduced into city parks for the enjoyment of people.[1] Also wild animals are flexible enough in their behaviour to accommodate interactions with humans. If you observe them carefully, you can see them switch from 'normal' behaviour to the behaviour they use when interacting with people. It's kind of like when you speak two languages and can switch from one to the other in an instant. [1] The Urbanization of the Eastern Gray Squirrel in the United States Etienne Benson J Am Hist (2013) 100 (3): 691-710.
- vvanders 8y agoSure, but that's not really relevant here. The parent still considers them 'wild' despite providing alternate food source which changes their behavioral patterns. Somewhat similar to photographers baiting animals for more dramatic photos: https://www.audubon.org/news/why-you-shouldnt-feed-or-bait-owls https://www.audubon.org/news/why-you-shouldnt-feed-or-bait-o... If you want to keep wildlife truly wild you should do your part to minimize the impact you have on their habitats and behaviors.
- gerbilly 8y ago> The parent still considers them 'wild' despite providing alternate food source which changes their behavioral patterns. Who says this is changing their behavioural patterns? Maybe native people in north america have been randomly feeding grey squirrels for thens of thousands of years. Maybe for longer in Eurasia? In fact if it weren't in the animals behavioural repertoire to recognise the opportunity of taking food from people, then we wouldn't even be able to get them to understand.
- mehrdadn 8y agoSeems there's a Quora question with some answers on this: https://www.quora.com/In-the-US-is-there-a-legal-definition-of-what-a-household-pet-is/answer/Bill-Stein https://www.quora.com/In-the-US-is-there-a-legal-definition-...
- xkcd-sucks 8y agoFor some reason I read the "she" as your coworker and the "he" as the raccoon
- clairity 8y agoi gradually tamed the ducks that graced our pond with bits of wonder bread when i was a kid. they let me pet them and hug them and squeeze them in exchange. =) i didn’t quite consider them my pets but they certainly weren’t wild any more.
- dbdjfjrjvebd 8y agoSadly feeding bread to ducks is not healthy for them.
- marcosdumay 8y agoIn Brazil, if you cage the animal you have clearly crossed the line. I don't think anybody was ever successfully persecuted by having a pet they didn't cage, but I do know there is no lack of attempts.
- giarc 8y agoMy dad did the same thing and knew he had to stop when he turned around in his kitchen and his friendly squirrel was standing there asking for a peanut. Be careful because squirrels can really do damage if they get into your attic or house.
- apendleton 8y agoLegal or no, your coworker should probably be careful. Raccoons are one of the main rabies carriers in the US. Of course, if it was actually a pet, presumably your coworker could have gotten the raccoon vaccinated.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- tapland 8y agoHere in Sweden someone had pigeons flying to their balcony all the time and they got reported for keeping them as a pet. The city dropped them off in another town but they flew back and were ordered to be put down because native species are not allowed to be kept as pets and they were unwilling to adapt to not living on the balcony.
- vageli 8y ago> Here in Sweden someone had pigeons flying to their balcony all the time and they got reported for keeping them as a pet. The city dropped them off in another town but they flew back and were ordered to be put down because native species are not allowed to be kept as pets and they were unwilling to adapt to not living on the balcony. If the motivation of these laws is to protect the animals, I can't think of a more backwards response.
- wallace_f 8y agoWait until you hear about all the ways government applies that same authority to "protecting" people
- dddddaviddddd 8y agoUnless the intention is to preserve wild behavior and prevent domestication, i.e. removing some individuals from the population to (in a way) preserve the species.
- tapland 8y agoProbably. Some cockatiels that proved very hard to catch this summer after they escaped were ordered to be put down by some hunters as well. They can survive our winters in urban areas and pose a risk to the native birds.
- VBprogrammer 8y agoIt's really weird around London to see flocks of parakeets. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feral_parakeets_in_Great_Britain https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feral_parakeets_in_Great_Brita...
- freedomben 8y agoI know you already know, but just posting in case it helps someone else. Be really careful about letting a squirrel get into a closed area with you, or even too close to your body. If they feel threatened (which they will once they realize they are trapped) they will f--k you up. This happened to an acquaintance of mine and he has permanent eye damage from it. They may not seem like it when they are gracefully and happily climbing trees and branches, but they are fast as hell with reflexes like lightning, and claws like knives.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Buttons840 8y agoOr they might just scratch you and run off, then you get to have rabies treatments. Either way, no fun.
- hornbaker 8y agoSquirrels (and others rodents) virtually never get or transmit rabies, so that’s not really a concern. Source: am DVM.
- avip 8y agoRodents "virtually never" transmit a disease that virtually always kills you, and consequently doctors virtually always send you to rabies treatment when bitten by rodents (but it's not as bad nowdays, just standard shots). Source: was bitten by rodents.
- hornbaker 8y agoThat’s surprising, given the CDC’s view on the matter: “[Small rodents] are almost never found to be infected with rabies and have not been known to transmit rabies to humans. In all cases involving rodents, the state or local health department should be consulted before a decision is made to initiate postexposure prophylaxis.” https://www.cdc.gov/rabies/exposure/animals/other.html https://www.cdc.gov/rabies/exposure/animals/other.html
- gaius 8y agoFrom there I could probably train them to essentially be pets There is a comic book character with this power https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Squirrel_Girl https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Squirrel_Girl
- K2h 8y agogave a cookie to a squirrel outside my dorm room at university (3rd story, he came in off the roof) and the little dude showed up for a few days. It was really cute. Then one day I come home and find the room trashed and a hole in the screen. He couldn't find his cookie! I learned my lesson.
- TheBeardKing 8y agoJust regulate against purposefully feeding wild animals. Problem solved.
- flukus 8y ago> Same where I am. I've wondered, though. What constitutes a pet? I think placing medium/long term restrictions on their movement is probably the most useful demarcation line. Your squirrels are free to leave any time but a dog is typically kept in by a fence, a caged bird is a pet but one free to fly away is a wild animal. Naturally cats a somewhere in between.
- codezero 8y agoI'm going to say something that people probably won't want to hear, but I hope to justify it and convince others of it as well. Don't feed wild animals. The difference between a pet, and a wild animal is that a pet owner takes responsibility for the wellbeing and actions of a pet. Feeding wild animals is detrimental to their wellbeing. They become accustomed to people, and not all people are nice to animals. You won't always live there, and they may come to depend on your good will. Also, you very likely don't know what their necessary macronutrients are, and they may very well remove a large portion of their natural nutrients to just eat peanuts, or bread, or what ever you're feeding them. This is also probably not healthy for them. They also suppress their natural instinct, which can get them killed in a number of ways, whether it's by doing riskier things, like crossing a street more often to get to the source of free food, or by behaving in a way that makes it easier for predators to prey on them. If you've been to a national park in the US, you might have noticed how accustomed squirrels and some other animals are to people. This isn't because one person feeds them, but because a few people of the many feed them, and it's enough to change their behavior. Nobody takes responsibility for the consequences of this, so I think people should blanket avoid doing it. To be clear, feeding animals doesn't make you a bad person, I'm not trying to condemn anyone, if anything it shows a lot of empathy, but I also think it is short sighted. If an animal is in distress, there are tons of resources, at least in the US to help. I've saved a crow and a seagull, and taken them to wild animal rescue centers, and I encourage others to do the same. If you're in the Bay Area, I highly recommend both visiting Lindsay Wildlife Rehabilitation Hospital, and considering it if you find an animal in distress: https://lindsaywildlife.org/ https://lindsaywildlife.org/ You can also usually contact the Human Society, or search, there are a lot of independent operators, I took the seagull I found to Native Animal Rescue in Santa Cruz: https://www.nativeanimalrescue.org https://www.nativeanimalrescue.org
- joshschreuder 8y agoI thought it was quite common to see signs up telling people not to feed wild animals, particularly in very populated areas like city parks? I'm guessing it is fairly common knowledge already and not that unpopular of a statement for you to say. With that said, it is fun to feed animals, so I can understand the appeal. We used to take loaves of stale bread and feed the ducks down by the lake growing up.
- mark-r 8y agoI was walking down the sidewalk at a University once, and a squirrel stopped in front of me. I stopped and stared down at it. It moved a foot closer and stared back up at me. Before I knew what was happening it started scampering up my leg! I jumped and it went back down, but I still don't know why it did that.
- Johnny555 8y agoHe was probably looking for the food that other students feed him. Squirrels at my university were quite used to people feeding them by hand.