9 ms·
This is legal. Any issues should be taken up with the political and tax system that allows it. If you blame the company for doing this then I expect that you a
by manigandham 8y ago
This is legal. Any issues should be taken up with the political and tax system that allows it.
If you blame the company for doing this then I expect that you also make 0 deductions on your personal taxes and pay as much as possible.
- sremani 8y agoYou cannot replace ethical with legal. We all understand its legal. But to post on a forum criticizing this is not a permissible action?, but some how supposed to bring the political class to change things...
- solarkraft 8y agoThe legal system should work to make ethical things legal and unethical things illegal. This is legal. I can't fault them ethically for taking advantage.
- sremani 8y agoRailroading people was legal too. So were many other heinous things. That should not stop people from expressing their distaste for certain "legal" practices. What are we doing here, other than sharing opinions and arguments?
- solarkraft 8y ago> Railroading people was legal too And it shouldn't have been.
- bzbarsky 8y ago> The legal system should work to make ethical things legal and unethical things illegal. As a blanket statement, not it should not. As a counterexample, consider that the whole purpose of the US First Amendment as regards speech is that it should not be illegal to speak, even if others don't like your speech (including because they think it's unethical). As another counterexample, the war on drugs and alcohol prohibition are examples, in the US, of people trying to make unethical things illegal. The latter is widely accepted as a failure. I'm pretty sure that eventually the former will be too. In general, trying to equate "I disapprove of X" and "X should be illegal" is a really dangerous tendency that comes and goes. It seem to be on the rise recently, unfortunately, at least in the US...
- solarkraft 8y agoIn my view drug prohibition is the attempt to make an ethical thing illegal. You can still defend somebody's right to speak (from an ethical pov) if you don't like what they say. These things don't have to be easy. I don't see what you're getting at. Laws are to govern things people should or shouldn't do - ethics are opinions on what people should or should not do. Am I missing something?
- bzbarsky 8y ago> Laws are to govern things people should or shouldn't do In RFC terms, laws are MUST and MUST NOT. Ethics are SHOULD and SHOULD NOT. There's a difference between those, even in RFCs. There is a similar difference in laws+ethics.
- cascom 8y agoCheating on your spouse is not ethical but it is legal, would you argue for it to become illegal? My point is that it is not a given that ethically dubious actions should be illegal. Furthermore, what is ethically wrong to some may not be so for others.
- sremani 8y agoBut if some one cheats in my family, I will use social shaming to put some heat on them. Our criticism on HN will not even have that effect, but its the closest thing to it. That's all. My only point is, "its legal" is not a pass from being socially judged by us plebs.
- mdorazio 8y agoNo it's not? In 20 states adultery is an actual crime, and in most others it is a significant factor in determining divorce outcomes.
- DannyBee 8y agoI agree with what you are trying to say, but i must point out: this example may not prove what you think "Cheating on your spouse is not ethical but it is legal, would you argue for it to become illegal?" It was and is in fact illegal for many years precisely because people found it not ethical enough. In english common law, it was even a felony. It is changing (and has changed in a lot of states) precisely because people are more okay with it than they were. In practice, the legality of things is generally decided by the societal consensus around "ethical dubiousness".
- hermitdev 8y agoIn some jurisdictions in the US, I think it is still illegal to cheat on your spouse, or to knowingly have relations with a person that is married. I think it's a civil penalty, usually not criminal. e.g. The cheated-on spouse would have to file a lawsuit. I don't have anything concrete to cite, just vague memories of a few news articles in the past decade.
- 8y ago
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- DannyBee 8y agoWell, criminal law is, for the most part, a representation of consensus around ethics. If everyone thought it was ethically cool to murder others, it would be legal to murder others. It's true you cannot replace legal with ethical, but the above should tell you the reason why: Your definition of what is ethical has not reached enough consensus to be legal/illegal. It's fine to say others should have your moral values and have arguments why. But expecting them to and scoffing at them for not doing so is silly - this is literally the stuff that makes legality not black and white.
- DannyBee 8y agoand to try to help , the distinction one would try to normally draw here is not about ethics. Legality almost always follows ethical consensus Really it's about legality vs social aberrance. Which is not the same as ethics.
- fixermark 8y agoI don't think it's not permissible, but I think the burden of proof is on those who complain about a company's (or any person's, really) tax practices to clarify how it's unethical to read and follow the law.
- berbec 8y agoAbsolutely. Those who throw stones should be able to prove they take $0 in mortgage interest deductions, child deductions, medical deductions etc. If you have a problem with these legal loopholes, go after your congressman.
- yayana 8y agoIt's legal (and therefore ethical?) to shame a large company into getting less advantage from doing something at which point they should use their lobbyists to make it illegal to do to protect themselves from competition. I don't think I'm as skilled as a paid lobbyist.
- falcolas 8y agoMaking children work in sweatshops was legal... up until it wasn't. May I assume that every corporation and individual was obligated to work children in sweatshops up until it was made illegal?
- lotsofpulp 8y agoThat's what happened, manufacturers who didn't use sweatshops couldn't offer the same low prices, and consumers went for the cheapest option.
- manigandham 8y agoThis isn't the same thing. Also nothing is that simple. The government is the people and the laws tend to reflect what they feel is acceptable because otherwise it would already be made illegal. Corporations are also these very same people and so they'll follow the same standards. I believe your issue has nothing to do with corporations but more about different cultures and values, and perhaps the efficiency of a government that can keep pace with the population.
- PurpleBoxDragon 8y ago>This isn't the same thing. Where is the difference that would allow us to condemn the companies for maximizing profits by use labor laws but not condemn them for maximizing profits using tax laws? >Also nothing is that simple. Yet the previous statement seemed to have been made quite simply, an idea that if you take advantage of any law in your favor, you cannot condemn someone who takes advantage of any other law in their favor.
- fixermark 8y ago> Where is the difference that would allow us to condemn the companies for maximizing profits by use labor laws but not condemn them for maximizing profits using tax laws? Money isn't people.
- 8y ago
- kyrra 8y agoNote that the loophole has been closed (no one new can use it), and all companies that use it today will be done with it by 2020. It's not just Google, but many multinationals. A list of those that use it is on Wikipedia[0]. AirBnb being one of those that use it. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_Irish_arrangement#Multinationals_who_used_Irish_BEPS_tools https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_Irish_arrangement#Multi...
- EmilStenstrom 8y agoThe linked Wikipedia article clearly states that while the Double Irish is closed for new entrants, there are new loopholes available...
- jakelazaroff 8y agoAre we not allowed to criticize cheating significant others? Politicians who lie to their constituents? People who cut in line? Maybe we should just make all these things illegal, since that's the line we're apparently drawing. Just because something's legal doesn't mean it's ethical.
- csallen 8y agoYou're completely right, of course. But it's still incumbent upon you to make a convincing argument that paying <arbitrary>% tax is unethical. And I'd say you have your work cut out for you. It's much less black-and-white than cases like cheating on a spouse, misleading voters, cutting in line, etc.
- jjeaff 8y agoIf I deduct a portion of my rent as a home office deduction and you don't because you either can't or didn't know about it, does that make my actions unethical?
- jakelazaroff 8y agoYeah, those were all "logical extreme" examples. My issue here isn't determining an appropriate level of taxation so much as OP's "it's legal, so it's ethical" justification. I am open to the idea that Google is still paying an appropriate amount in taxes! Just not by that particular argument.
- manigandham 8y agoI didn't make that justification. Following laws is considered ethical though, because laws are the ethics of the society that they apply to. It's fine if you have personal ethics that are different, but that doesn't automatically apply to everyone.
- jakelazaroff 8y agoI don't understand. You're saying you didn't make that justification ("it's legal, so it's ethical") immediately followed by that statement, almost verbatim ("following laws is considered ethical"). Of course ethics are subjective. But voicing those ethics is how we arrive at a set of societal values in the first place! It's crazy to suggest that anyone complying with the law should be immune from criticism.
- fredgrott 8y agoahem no its called having higher moral standard than politicians supposedly Google boosted of this when their saying don't do evil has paramount Either they abandon higher morals or decided to be in the same moral mud as Marck Z and facebook
- throw2016 8y agoThis is simplistic. What if there was a loophole in the law that allowed one to not repay debt. Bankers will get that loophole fixed asap. In this case saying its 'legal' misses all the processes, politics, lobbying, accounting firms drafting laws, ideology, tax havens, that are all in play to leave little 'loopholes' like this for selective enrichment. Google and other corporate interests who benefit from these 'loopholes' saying 'this is legal' is understandable, but why should an individual say this? How about employees allowed to sell their services to a third parties incorporated in low tax regions competing for their membership, which in turn then license it to employers, leading to reduced tax in their home countries? Why is this not a thing? If everyone did that the whole tax base would dissipate and destroy our current system, hence its now allowed, why is the exact same thing ok for corporations?
- jmalicki 8y ago> What if there was a loophole in the law that allowed one to not repay debt. Bankers will get that loophole fixed asap. Uh, no. It's called bankruptcy. One view is that bankruptcy laws in the US created a powerful bankruptcy bar whose special interest in enriching themselves through consumer-friendly bankruptcy laws became more powerful and focused than the special interest of banks. https://legacy.voteview.com/pdf/Berglof_Rosenthal_Bankruptcy.pdf https://legacy.voteview.com/pdf/Berglof_Rosenthal_Bankruptcy...
- throw2016 8y agoA bankruptcy is not a 'loophole' or benefit you can avail as a matter of course every year, but this misses the point. That was just an example, it could be anything, any 'financial innovation' not available to individuals.
- manigandham 8y agoSeems like a failure of politics. Which is what I said.
- lordnacho 8y ago> Any issues should be taken up with the political and tax system that allows it. Isn't that what people are doing when they point out the problems with it?
- fixermark 8y agoNot precisely---most of the arguments I've personally seen on the topic (here included) boil down to "it's not fair they do that," with no clarification as to what framework of fairness the plaintiff is using. Because there are multiple non-overlapping frameworks of fairness in play. The money in question here, for example, is paid by foreign citizens in non-US countries. How much of that money is owed to the US government, and why? How much owed to the nations from which those citizens hail, and why?
- zelon88 8y agoThe perfect cop out if you're a multinational tax dodging company who has a veritable army of lobbyists ensuring the political and tax systems stay exactly the way you made them.
- snarf21 8y agoNot to mention that most of the people complaining about this are not complaining about the record profits fueling their 401K and IRA. This is the biggest personal dilemma I face. Does it make sense to pay double for services from companies that aren't the big 5? Does it make sense to divest my retirement holdings from companies and indexes that have investments in the big 5? Will this just add new companies that will behave just as poorly? Am I better off trying to lobby my elected officials for change? I really have no good answer for this complex issue despite the fact that it bugs me and I think about it frequently.
- GoodJokes 8y agoCompanies aren’t people.
- jahaja 8y agoThis attitude seems inconsistent with your other recent post: > some of the world's biggest companies which have absolutely failed at anything resembling civic duty. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18771628 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18771628
- manigandham 8y agoHow so? Civic duty does not mean paying more taxes than required.
- jahaja 8y agoBy whose standard? I reckon not actively avoiding taxes is quite high up in most peoples list. Proclaiming the virtues of civic duty while still championing corporate tax avoidance rings very superficial to me at least.
- manigandham 8y agoBy my standard because if you included my full quote you would see my blame included the government as well. Transferring more money from the corporation to the government doesn't magically solve anything. I find it interesting that you see it as "championing corporate tax avoidance" instead of pointing out the failure of government to correctly control taxes. Perhaps we can debate how the money is actually spent on civic issues as that is probably more productive than who spends it.
- jahaja 8y agoWell, "Civic Duty" should be assumed to have a collective definition rather than some individuals selective thoughts. I think it's pretty clear that the sum of your posts in this thread isn't in line with that and it gives corporations the usual endless benefit of the doubt that's not afforded to the average citizen.
- manigandham 8y ago
- tossaccount123 8y agoThere's a world of difference between taking a tax deduction and actively setting up shell corporations to dodge taxes Google could not pay taxes by giving their employees raises or bonuses, invest in infrastructure, donate it to charity, etc.Instead they stash it in the Caribbean. I wouldn't care but their executives actively push a political agenda not inline with their actions which makes them rampaging hypocrites and thus open for criticism
- zacharytelschow 8y agoSo some means of legal tax reduction are fine and others are not? How do you arbitrarily determine which is which?
- tossaccount123 8y agowritten deductions in the tax code vs legal loophole that's being made illegal in many countries I never argued it was illegal, I'm saying it's not ethical
- notacoward 8y ago> How do you arbitrarily determine which is which? It's not arbitrary. If the primary purpose of an entity or transaction is to avoid tax, then its employment is likely to constitute illegal tax avoidance or evasion (the terms have distinct legal meanings but those are not very interesting here). Purpose is determined primarily by contemporaneous documentation. Is there some interpretation involved? Yes, because just about any legal decision involves some interpretation and these matters tend to be exceedingly complex. By their nature, they usually involve some sort of subterfuge or concealment. But it's not arbitrary. There are laws and precedents that attempt to define exactly where the line is. Here are some references that might help clarify further. http://taxexecutive.org/tax-avoidance-vs-tax-evasion/ http://taxexecutive.org/tax-avoidance-vs-tax-evasion/ https://www.lowtax.net/blogs/The-Basics-of-Tax-Evasion-Tax-Avoidance-and-Tax-Minimisation-572162.html https://www.lowtax.net/blogs/The-Basics-of-Tax-Evasion-Tax-A...
- Maarten88 8y ago> Google Netherlands Holdings BV paid 3.4 million euros in taxes in the Netherlands in 2017, the documents showed, on a gross profit of 13.6 million euros The Netherlands is an economy about the size of California, the reason Google only makes 13.6 million here is that they make the subsidiary pay a lot of royalties to a Bermuda Google entity, who probably bought these rights internally from the Google Corp for a price that was way too low. They can price these royalties anything they want, so it will always be an amount that leaves a maginal profit. > This is legal. Of course they say that, but it depends on many things, such as the fairness of their internal pricing. If those prices are not fair, the arrangement may not be legal.
- moate 8y agoThese are not mutually exclusive thoughts. "The political and tax system that allows it" is often the product of lobbying funded by huge corporations in order to create massive loopholes. This allows them to pay what many consider to be an unfairly low amount in taxes. It entirely allowed to both hate the tax system AND hate the corporate cronyism that created it. Also your "if you blame the company..." scenario is, at best, a weak comparison. It would be akin to living and working in New Jersey, a highly taxed state, and instead shifting your assets to be taxed as if you live in Florida where there is no personal income tax.
- pbalau 8y agoThen why is lobbying legal?
- moate 8y agoThis is a great question. My general thought is "because people value money, and this allows rich people a valuable way to spend theirs". I mean campaign finance reform is a topic people on both sides at least pay lip service to (or at least bemoan how the other side gets funded).
- pbalau 8y agoSorry for the late reply. Campaign financing is something that I agree with, if I can afford to help this candidate reach more voters, why not? There is nothing wrong in that. There is another, different discussion about what this money should be spent on, eg this candidate is great vs these other candidate is bad, but I don't see nothing wrong with giving money for a candidate campaign. Lobbying is different, in most countries in the world this is called bribing, hence a factor in corruption.
- gregable 8y agoAs a different example: A company dumps toxic chemicals into the air/water, and it results in horrible deaths and destruction to the environment which makes everyone's lives worse. However, they've managed to do this in a completely legal way. Maybe they moved the dumping to a region without strong regulation. Maybe they found some legal loophole. Maybe they funded a politician's campaign who then carved out a legal loophole for them. Would you still not blame the company or call their actions unethical in this case? I personally would blame the company. I would consider their decisions unethical. I would also want to fix the laws so that I could legally hold them accountable, but I wouldn't absolve the company of responsibility until those laws were fixed. How is tax avoidance all that different? Sure, it's not directly harming anyone. However, the lack of funding for the government means fewer social services and those services often are used to help people avoid horrible deaths (such as homeless freezing on the streets, veterans receiving medical care, or safety improvements to roads) and to improve the environment we live in (national parks, clean water initiatives, etc.).
- ganeshkrishnan 8y agoYou know why Somalia is messed up? No government to regulate dumping of toxic waste. Which means waste can be disposed off without it being illegal in Somali waters. However this resulted in killing off all the marine life and fishes. So what do the fishermen do? Take up piracy!
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- xgbi 8y agoCan I deduce 97,5% of my wage legally? Because that's what we are talking about there. 100 million gross and 3.5 million taxes is a drop in the sea compared to 22B gross.
- drinchev 8y agoIt's not like the companies are not in politics these days. I rarely see laws, which are not made by lobbies representing the richest people in the world. Here in EU Monsanto lobbied a controversial regulation about a weedkiller ( RoundUp ) not a long time ago [1]. If we can't have non-corrupted politicians. Who should we blame then? Maybe the people that get most benefits from that fact. Like the top management level of those corps. 1 : https://www.reuters.com/article/us-germany-politics-glyphosate/germany-moving-ahead-with-plans-to-restrict-weed-killer-glyphosate-idUSKBN1HO2IM https://www.reuters.com/article/us-germany-politics-glyphosa...
- eeeeeeeeeeeee 8y agoI agree that this needs to be fixed by our politicians, but the scale of the average person deducting their mortgage taxes is not in the same league as 23 BILLION dollars being sent to Bermuda.
- conanbatt 8y agoSaying something is legal is the lowest level of defense of something. Its saying "you literally can't be thrown in jail for doing it".
- pbalau 8y agoI'm sorry, but this is the most stupid thing you could have said. The entire human civilization is based on following some "clear" rules, commonly known as law. If you disagree with the law, you fight to change it and in this case it did happen.
- conanbatt 8y agoRe-read the sentence and try again.
- manigandham 8y agoSaying "it's just not fair or ethical" without any specifics or plan is a far worse argument in favor of something.
- dwild 8y ago> If you blame the company for doing this then I expect that you also make 0 deductions on your personal taxes and pay as much as possible. Yeah not the same thing. The same thing would be for us to open a shell company in Bermuda, ask our job to pay us through there and use that bank account to pay for our local purchase. The deductions we get are for a reason, as long as the reason apply, it's perfectly ethical to use theses deductions. Once you don't actually respect that reason, no it's not ethical to use theses deductions. I knew some independent workers that went to restaurant and put that as a business expense to get a deduction. It was clearly not an actual business expense, we could argue that it was (well how could you have a business without eating?), but it was certainly not related to any business being done. The deduction would still pass, it would still be "legal", but it wouldn't be ethical at all.
- pasbesoin 8y agoWhen companies lobby for this, and come to "own" the respective governing bodies, people not only have the right but are being eminently practical in taking their concerns directly to those companies. Society has already decided that "because I can" is not a universally acceptable reason or defense.
- drugme 8y agoThis is legal. The (far) bigger point is that it's royally fucked up. And that of course corporations are not even (remotely) comparable to individuals. When you and I are able to radically reduce our tax liabilities by shifting our assets to Bermuda (or anywhere else), then perhaps we can have a discussion based on appeals to individual responsibility. But of course we can't. And that's why the state of affairs is royally fucked up.
- notacoward 8y ago> This is legal. That has yet to be determined. Tax law does recognize acts whose sole or primary purpose is to avoid taxes (i.e. not as a side effect of other business purposes) as evasion, and evasion is illegal. Just because such cases are very hard to prosecute successfully, and are rarely prosecuted at all for that or other reasons, doesn't make an illegal act legal. > I expect that you also make 0 deduction That's an incredibly shallow argument. Those who identify a problem don't have to be martyrs. In particular, those who identify inequity are under no obligation to increase it at their own expense before it can be addressed. I'll be glad to give up my exemptions when the tax code is fixed for everybody, not while others are still benefiting from its flaws. Policy and decisions and personal benefit should be separate. We should respect those who will argue for a policy change out of principle, even when that means giving something up, and not demand that they give up more. The people we really shouldn't trust are those who never argue for a policy that doesn't benefit them. That's called corruption.
- wnevets 8y agoJust because something is legal doesn't mean it should be done.