7 ms·
I'm sure I'm being naieve, but could we just get rid of billing altogether if we nationalize the health care system? I have to recount an anecdote. My mom was h
by analog31 8y ago
I'm sure I'm being naieve, but could we just get rid of billing altogether if we nationalize the health care system? I have to recount an anecdote. My mom was hiking in a foreign country, and got injured. She hobbled to the next town, and found a clinic. They treated her and were ready to let her go. She said:
Q: Okay, how do I pay?
A: You don't pay for health care.
Q: I'm American. I'm not part of your health care system.
A: That's all well and good, but we have no way of knowing how much to charge you, how to take your money, or where to send it. Have a nice vacation.
The clinic probably maintained some accounting records, but they simply had no billing system.
- ams6110 8y agoSomebody will be paying, and will want adequate and auditable documentation about what they are paying for. The potential for fraud is too great. Medicare and states all have to watch for fraud in their claim payments.
- bdamm 8y agoRight, but it’s probably done by auditing resources to treatment records. The actual patient needn’t be involved. And in countries like Canada you may end up with multiple operating agencies that are competing for efficiency, such as Coastal Health vs Providence, even though ultimately it’s the government footing the bill.
- Scoundreller 8y agoProvidence is under Vancouver Coastal health. The authorities aren’t competing with each other (well, not really) as they have their own geographic catchments.
- bdamm 8y agoRight, but they're able to be audited against each other, even though they have separate geographic catchments. Significant discrepancies can be then analyzed. Folks who view single-payer as a system without checks need to know how those checks do in fact occur.
- analog31 8y agoThat's true. But I think the system could be simpler if there were fewer, and possibly just one, entities. I work in a factory, so we live by SAP. And it's complex, typical "enterprise" software, but I don't think it's even within an order of magnitude as complex as Epic. We want an audit trail, but most of the transactions are made within a single business entity, e.g., from the stockroom to an assembly area. We've had process improvement projects that reduced the number of SAP transactions required to make something. So maybe the key isn't so much having a government run system, but simply reducing the number of entities. For instance a hospital doesn't have to make a claim to Medicare, if the hospital is Medicare. Also, the game of figuring out how much to bill the patient goes away. We don't even know how many entities there are in the medical system, or how much money is going to each one. Were I inclined towards cynicism, I'd suspect that this is by design.
- xenadu02 8y agoIf we had a national healthcare system the documentation would consist of proof of citizenship or permanent residency (or guardian's proof of same in the case of minors). That allows spot-checks to validate that fake or deceased people aren't being "treated" to generate fake charges. Right now even Medicare/Medicaid need lots of process to verify you are eligible and/or enrolled. That wouldn't be a problem if everyone were covered automatically.
- SolarNet 8y agoSure, but adequate and auditable documentation need not involve the patient nor money. Just a "here is the medical care we dispersed, on this date, to this person, it took these resources, these people administered the care." No following up every record for payments, no arguing with insurance companies over the price. And also, what abuse? If medical care is free and drugs are cheap, the only real abuse is drug abuse (by either seekers or medical personnel). With free access to proper care those drug abuse problems will sharply decrease, killing the market (the cause of the other half of drug abuse). The only reason there is medicare fraud to worry about right now is because not everyone is supposed to be on it, the "fraud" is attempting to get free health care. Which wouldn't exist if everyone had it.
- chii 8y ago> And also, what abuse? a clinic could mis-report (over-report?) how many patients they treated, and/or the procedure. They can then claim back more money than they actually spent, netting easy profit.
- emilfihlman 8y agoSolved by not allowing money to enter the circle. Results in you needing to sell the drugs/things you overcount on, which is rather easy to track and find out.
- jdminhbg 8y ago> Solved by not allowing money to enter the circle. This is not possible without socializing the entire economy. At some point, you have to pay doctors, nurses, staff, equipment manufacturers, etc.
- chobeat 8y agoIf they are public employees, they have sort of a standardized salary coming straight from the healthcare ministry/department/whatever where the specific hospital just administer the HR part. You still think in a for profit manner, where healthcare in most countries is not a for-profit endeavour. As long as it works, it's fine, even if it's a net negative. You try to limit the money you waste and inefficiencies, but not by pulling levers on the staff salaries.
- Escolte 8y agoFrom my Spanish Perspective. What fraud? Going to the doctor is literally useless unless you're ill. They will literally send you away home if they find you to be fine. The doctors and nurses and personnel and what have you will also get mad at you for wasting their time unjustifiably (and I've done this myself and oh boy they left an impression on me). If you mean Government fraud, from the ones planning the system yes, indeed, all documentation about how much a healthcare center "costs", how their location and capacity is decided, and etc... should be open and easily accessible to the public. Medication is partially subsidized and never given for free at a medical center or hospital unless it's an emergency, older than 65+, disabled, etc... Recently, the government ordered to make like 1200 common meds cheaper (link in Spanish) https://cadenaser.com/ser/2018/12/29/sociedad/1546084258_187663.html https://cadenaser.com/ser/2018/12/29/sociedad/1546084258_187...
- dtech 8y agoYou're right that "patient"-doctor fraud is unlikely, but receiving unnecessary medication (addictive/fun/valuable drugs) or medical people overcharging or charging for unperformed or unnecessary procedures is a possibility for fraud.
- endless1234 8y agoBut the personnel are salaried, not paid per procedure.
- lostlogin 8y agoMost hospitals have on-call work, overtime, outsourced work, consumables that can be billed for etc. Pay cheques vary a huge amount depending on work done, and as a radiographer in a regional hospital my yearly wage was more than half made up by penal rates and overtime.
- criddell 8y agoThere's a balance though. A huge bureaucracy to stop all fraud is expensive and cumbersome. There's going to be an acceptable level of fraud in order to keep the administration costs of the system in check. Other countries have figured this out. The US could use the experience of our allies that already have systems that are working to design a system for us.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoI will see your anecdote and raise you one. :) When I was an American military wife, I mostly just flashed my military ID, made an appointment, picked up my meds, etc. I was diagnosed with atypical CF in my mid thirties and some of the things I was prescribed were not on the formulary of the military hospital. I went in town and had a co-pay of (IIRC) $13 per prescription. One day, I tripped across an old receipt: More than $1200 worth of pills with a $39 co-pay. Probably three months worth of digestive enzymes. I was also seeing a specialist at a clinic at UC Davis Medical Center in Sacramento. I had been a few times when I noticed a sign prominently displayed on the front desk announcing that they would not see you if you owed money. I asked the person at the desk if I owed anything as I had never paid them anything at all. Surely, I owed some co-pays. She checked my records. Nope, I didn't owe anything. I was all good. Well, that was weird. But I was fighting for my life, so I shrugged and moved on with my life. I didn't have the energy to figure out what had happened. Some years later, I was talking with folks on a CF email list and, silly me, I remarked that "I guess the CF Foundation picked up the co-pays or something." People vociferously informed me that, oh, no, that is not what happened. That's not something they do. No clue why I was never billed at all by UC Davis Medical Center. But I (apparently* ) wasn't. I don't know how the military handles it. But when I was a military wife, no, I generally did not see medical bills of any kind. * I was extremely sick. It's possible my husband paid the bills and I just didn't realize it. But I don't think that's what happened.
- dmix 8y agoSorry, how is this relevant to what the OP comment posted? I don't follow...
- DoreenMichele 8y agoWe already have a healthcare system within the US where billing seems to mostly not happen. So, presumably, it isn't completely alien and foreign and something America would need to steal from elsewhere.
- nightfly 8y ago
- hvindin 8y agoAs an Australian I always struggle with the idea that healthcare would cost money above a couple of dollars for things that aren't essential. But almost every American I've ever spoken to who hasn't experienced decent national healthcare seem to have a bizzare view that "if it's free then obviously it will be abused", not realising that it's just as open to abuse as a system where end customer are also involved because shockingly customers arent usually the ones committing the fraud. It genuinely feels like theres a view that some people might not "deserve" healthcare, and the way we determine who "deserves" healthcare is not the very humane "well they need it, therefore they deserve it" but rather "capitalism. Definitely the answer." Makes me a little sad, but I guess when you have nothing else to compare it to...
- sjwright 8y agoAlso Australian. The concept of abuse seems hilarious. What abuse? That people might visit their local doctor more frequently? That's a good thing! Many ailments get more expensive to treat the longer they are left untreated. Once you come to terms with the fact it's permanently cheap/free, the psychological incentive to be wasteful ("use it or lose it") disappears completely. By comparison the American capitalist health system continually reinforces the notion that healthcare has monetary value, which means failing to take advantage of it feels wasteful.
- gaius 8y agoThe concept of abuse seems hilarious. What abuse? That people might visit their local doctor more frequently? That's a good thing! In the UK A&E is flooded with people with minor ailments that could have been treated at home with a first aid kit, or people who are just drunk. The system is definitely taken for granted. People even call ambulances for a ride to an appointment, not even an emergency. Source: once spent 5 hours waiting to be seen in A&E, sitting on a plastic chair with a broken leg, while kids with grazed knees and people with minor colds were seen before me. If I needed the bathroom or a glass of water, I had to get up and hobble there on my broken leg. The NHS were great once I actually got seen, but they are swamped with idiots demanding unnecessary medical attention, because it's free.
- type-2 8y agowhich country?
- sonnyblarney 8y agoThis is very misleading. In single payer systems, doctors and hospitals bill someone for their service, it's just that the 'insurance company' is the government. Someone 'out of system' cannot provide the health/ID necessary, ergo, no way for them to bill. But otherwise they do bill.