8 ms·
If San Francisco Is So Great, Why Is Everyone I Love Leaving?
- exabrial 8y agoI really hope the next wave of 'we should fix that'ers is a bunch of high salary earners convincing each other to donate to good causes rather than a bunch of disconnected high salary earners advocating for regressive high taxes and minimum wage increases.
- Lkjhmnbv 8y agoThey have armed guards. They did fix it. :)
- dsfyu404ed 8y ago>They have armed guards and nobody else is armed. FTFY
- Lkjhmnbv 8y agoGreat point. Just like Venezuela!
- paulcole 8y agoreminds me of the scorpion and the toad story
- the_clarence 8y agoYeah. Let’s continue to pay waiters 2$/hour and let’s reject the idea of free health care for people who can’t afford it. Murica!
- exabrial 8y agoAre you saying you know how to spend the money these people earn better than them? Or, to force you into a false dichotomy, are you saying that back when hotdogs cost $0.05, increasing the minimum wage from a few pennies an hour two $2.00 an hour made all the difference in the world?
- osdiab 8y agoPretty sure people need money in order to have them decide how to spend it, and that most people can't personally save their way into affording million-dollar cancer treatments. I don't particularly trust cutthroat employers, who have demonstrated their desire to do everything they can to undercut the salaries and benefits of their employees to expand a bottom line, to properly value and choose to provide the necessary income to give their employees humane standards of living. Though I do think that a fixed minimum wage where you have to have to have heated debates every time cost of living changes about what it should be set to, is silly. If it's supposed to reflect the ability to achieve a minimum standard of living, let's at least set it dynamically against the price of a typical basket of goods; or use a different mechanism than a minimum wage altogether to achieve that minimum standard of living.
- redisman 8y agoToo expensive
- chrisallick 8y agohaha. San Francisco is awful. That title is misleading and uninformed. Grew up there. Got a degree in math and comp sci and returned to work. Lasted a year before being so disgusted by the self quarantining of the rich. It’s a tech distopia. I’m not even talking about having to step over human feces 3 times per block. I’m talking about the utter lack of ethics and values of the people who have descended like rabid vultures to manipulate the tech utopian thinkers and then run with the money. The damage is done and we’re just now starting to see the impact it’s had on the people that haven’t been taken along for the ride to the top. That place is a lost cause. I guess it would have been cool to be there during the Alan Kay xerox parc days. Probably intoxicatingly inspiring environment. But now... I hope it burns. I’ll show up to repair and rebuild. I do enjoy the Marin headlands though. And I suppose I’ll take a Taqueria SF burrito most days of the week. And the punk scene in Berkeley was great, and growing up skating there was awesome, but... meh the bad outweighs the good.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- walrus01 8y ago> the utter lack of ethics and values of the people who have descended like rabid vultures to manipulate the tech utopian thinkers a lot of these people, having destroyed SF as a livable city, are now moving on to Seattle. Which is rapidly also turning into a city with feces laden sidewalks and a tech dystopia.
- chrisallick 8y agoSeattle has the 1/3rd largest homeless population and the city wanted a $500 per employee tax from amazon. Amazon said they’d move their business and also haulted construction on new building. 40k employees, that’s 20million a year. They then lobbied and got it repealed after city lowered to $250/employee. He than turns and donates millions/billions ONCE, but that’s specks of sand compared to what would be generated over time yearly and consistently. So... no faith in that city either and no faith in tech in general. Super sad.
- gnulinux 8y agoStudied in Berkeley, got bunch of 6 figure job offers in SF, instead left Bay Area for Boston. SF is a beautiful city, but it's not worth it. It has way too many problems. Maybe in the future I can come back, but I had to take a break.
- baddox 8y agoI don’t know how recently you’ve been here, or how closely you’ve looked, but it is very much not a beautiful city. It is literally gag-inducingly disgusting.
- nhf 8y agoI feel like this is a common sentiment: San Francisco is beautiful in the abstract, but disgusting in detail. I feel like this is a pretty common trope for most "grade A" cities—someone will always hate it, people who love it will always explain it away. - NYC is expensive and has failing transportation, but people love the unparalleled cultural diversity and gritty tenacity of the city - Paris is dirty and unfriendly, but the city's romance and character make it a great place to live - London is expensive and out of touch, but its job opportunities and multiculturalism make it a better place to live ...and so on and so forth. Someone's always going to dislike SF for a valid reason and someone's always going to hit you back with a valid reason why it's a good place. They're probably both correct.
- extra88 8y ago> Paris is dirty and unfriendly I didn’t find the tourist-trafficked parts to be dirty. Unfriendliness has is just Parisians being “on-brand.”
- the_clarence 8y agoHaving lived in London, Paris and SF I would disagree. SF is freaking disgusting. Paris is messy and has some crazies. London is a nice city.
- siralonso 8y ago
- JohnJamesRambo 8y agoI enjoyed reading these comments.
- kbos87 8y agoSan Francisco has never appealed to me. When I’ve told people that in the past, they’ve looked at me like I have two heads. For anyone who doesn’t live or spend much time there, the romantic notion of SF is pretty great. It’s got a lot going for it - a unique geography, it’s full of landmarks and architecture and history - but the day to day reality of what it’s become is just sad. It’s a pretty unliveable place unless you are a true millionaire,and the character it once had is quickly evaporating.
- burfog 8y agoIf a city is nice, then crowds will arrive until it is not nice. There are two main kinds of "not nice", prices and the annoyances of your fellow human beings. The end result is that locations that are physically nice will be occupied by people who have a relatively high tolerance for those two not-nice attributes and a relatively high desire for the physical niceness. So if you like cool weather and pretty hills and the ocean, and you don't mind violent crime or hepatitis or $2,000,000 houses, then you'll be happy to wedge yourself in like a chicken in a factory farm. It takes a certain type of person to decide that this is the best choice.
- osdiab 8y agoThere are plenty of examples of nice places that remain nice even as people move in. It's up to the city to be dynamic enough to adapt to a changing environment. In concrete terms, that means: building sufficient housing and infrastructure to keep life affordable and smooth; designing (or shepherding emergent patterns of) functional, livable neighborhoods; and addressing social problems as they arise. You might be surprised to find that you can still get a studio in Tokyo within 45 minutes of the city center for ~$400/mo (bump up to ~$600 if you want to be 15 minutes away), that it's easy and efficient to get around to nice urban and natural amenities, and that there are endless quiet, peaceful, and utterly charming neighborhoods, parks, and temples right next to all the hotspots. You'll never see any feces on the street, you never see anybody shooting up needles, and nobody will ever beg you to spare a dollar. Part of that is cultural, but most of that is by concerted effort. But positive outcomes like that can only happen if a city successfully adapts to changes—which San Francisco (and virtually every American city to varying degrees) has abysmally failed at. As another commenter pointed out up the page, San Francisco's public policy has been very nativist, and the physical form of the city has remained more or less unchanged for decades, which spells disaster for one of the most coveted places to move to in the world.
- rdiddly 8y agoIt's great the same way the view of the bay from some of the cells on the top floor of Alcatraz was great. Some prisoners loved having a view; others said it was worse to be reminded of such beauty while you were in a prison cell.
- sxp62000 8y agoI feel like a lot of my friends who are about to start a family or get married have started moving away from big cities like NYC, SF and LA. You just end up wanting a bigger place, a quieter street, and proximity to a Trader Joe's.
- kylec 8y agoA big part of this is that San Francisco attracts people that don't actually want to live there, they're just there for the jobs. Once they've had enough, or find a more desirable opportunity elsewhere, they leave.
- seppin 8y agoAlso they only hire one type of person (engineer) which has created a monoculture of people not predisposed to being outwardly friendly. (I know this is a stereotype, but sometimes stereotypes are true).
- karmasimida 8y agoMost people don't live in SF, the rent is ridiculous. I doubt they contribute to much to the so called culture, nor the engineers have time to enjoy much of the existing culture anyway.
- adjkant 8y agoI think part of that lack of outward friendliness is both transplants generally as well as those people that don't actually want to be there. But yes, the monoculture is the key problem. I was considering moving to SF because I loved the SF of 10-20 years ago (not without its problems but had so many things still right) but all of the other cultures that made SF great have been suffocated by the tech industry moving in. No longer a top option anymore for that reason alone.* * I've spent a limited amount of time in SF so grain of salt.
- electricslpnsld 8y ago> But what this “native” Bay Area kid won’t do is start blaming the guy from North Carolina or Wisconsin or Boston—basically every other person in the bar—for propelling the rents into the sky and inadvertently forcing the “locals” to flee. The author hasn’t been to a Berkeley (or San Francisco, or a Penninsula town) city council meeting... there is a lot of very blatant resentment in the Bay Area directed (mostly unfairly) at transplants.
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoMaybe because the author has an upcoming business trip to Austin, Denver, etc, and doesn't want burn the bridge until after he's crossed it.
- 101km 8y agoThe first time I went to work here a few months ago I got out of the Lyft around 9am and two meters away a homeless man was injecting something into his veins. My office is in the Mission. Some parts of San Francisco are very dirty and the homeless issue is not exaggerated. Everybody knows about the Tenderloin at night. With that being said, I drove across the US two years ago and if you keep your eyes open you realize it is all over - Portland and Seattle are no better, just less talked about. My rent is $1300, I live with one roommate on Russian Hill. I'm flexible and lucky so this is not representative. A girl I know who works at Google lives in inner Richmond (arguably a less desirable area) by herself and pays nearly triple for some reason. It is hard to find a proper gym for less than a Benjamin and food is above average for an American city but hilariously expensive. Good way to gauge is pick some fast food chain and compare, Dennys is x2 here than the rest of the country. All in all this place isn't the shiny happy city you'd imagine from watching Full House or or the counter culture epicenter of hippie times gone by. It doesn't suck, I'd definitely visit for a week or two if you have never been, and there's a lot of history here but in the end it is no longer a very remarkable place to live.
- friedman23 8y ago>With that being said, I drove across the US two years ago and if you keep your eyes open you realize it is all over - Portland and Seattle are no better, just less talked about. It's not that it's not talked about, it's that other cities manage to not have it right in the middle of the city.
- geoka9 8y agoI can vouch for Portland - smack in the middle.
- countzeroasl 8y agoSeattle is every bit as bad as California. Interestingly enough, when California started getting bad, Washington was where they moved. Now? Hellloooo TEXAS!
- Teknoman117 8y ago
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- karmasimida 8y agoBecause it is expensive, and because I don't feel the quality of living there justifies the expense to be paid. Bad traffic, and a city wide hygiene problem. My sample is limited, but not a lot people around me have good opinions about SF. Guess it is a mutual selection as well.
- sys_64738 8y agoIt’s very expensive today but in five years time when people look back they’ll say it’s cheap. I remember looking at expensive houses in San Jose back in 2010. Now that price (750k$) isn’t available any more.
- osdiab 8y agoI do wonder if there's a breaking point where people won't be willing to pay the premium. Current rents are already severely stretching the budgets of your average entry-level techie. EDIT: some early evidence to that speculation: https://sanfrancisco.cbslocal.com/2018/10/19/bay-area-rents-dip-slightly-zillow/ https://sanfrancisco.cbslocal.com/2018/10/19/bay-area-rents-...
- watertom 8y agoYogi Bera said it best. "Nobody goes there anymore, it's too crowded."
- hintymad 8y agoI'm curious on why people love to set up their companies in the city or live in the city. I mean, there are plenty of office space in Fremont, for example, and living in the Bay Area is much more pleasant than in the city. I was wondering what's so enticing about city life. Bars? But bars are so noisy and anti-social. I never get it.
- osdiab 8y agoTo color it in with an anecdote as a 27 year old who grew up in the suburbs and spent the last 7-ish years of my life in city centers: my personal preference is just that I like the presence of other people. I don’t feel bothered by lots of people walking around the streets, hearing their conversations, living in proximity to others; and I only feel marginally bothered by crowds and packed trains, definitely less than I enjoy the bustle. In fact even if I don’t talk to a single person or enter a single establishment it just makes me feel energized to be around it. Bars are antisocial and I don’t go often, but even when I’m just walking past one on the way home, the atmosphere around them makes me feel happy (and you can be social at a reasonable volume with all the smokers and loiterers outside if that’s what you like). There’s something deeply depressing to me about the American suburban life I grew up in: always deserted, copy-pasted strip malls; giant, humanless roads clogged with hurtling metal death traps; cul-de-sacs of strangers spending large fractions of their lives solitary in cars. (I do acknowledge it can be different to some extent—the ethnic suburbs in LA are vibrant in pockets, for example—but even in the best cases they’re still pretty desolate to me.) Where I came from in the Midwest, my life involved never talking to anybody within a 20 mile radius of my house except in business transactions, and only rarely even seeing my neighbors. As a child I didn’t mind, but after having lived differently there’s no way I’d choose to go back unless it’s prohibitively expensive to choose otherwise (which is, to my knowledge, a major driver of people moving out of cities into suburbs). Separately, I personally dislike driving and greatly prefer public transportation. It’s far more comfortable (not much acceleration and far more space than a tiny car unless it’s rush hour), I don’t have to pay attention to anything except where I’m getting off, it’s super cheap, no risk of accidents or headaches from other drivers incompetence, I don’t have to ever find nor pay for parking, I don’t have to worry about the safety of my personal property, I don’t have to worry about my car breaking down out of nowhere, I can drink and not personally endanger myself, the list or positives is basically endless to me but I’ll stop there. But that all said San Francisco isn’t that dense (in my opinion), has such glaring social issues, is ludicrously expensive and doesn’t have particularly good infrastructure/transit. Given that I can get all of those things automatically by living in pretty much any major east Asian or European city, that’s my preference, but the one and only thing drawing me back is the concentration of jobs and money. I weaned myself off San Francisco and lived in east Asia for a couple years, but I found myself back now for a job. Hopefully not too long from now I’ll be able to head back over, or at least work remote for a significant part of my time.
- manfredo 8y agoI've lives a while in Seattle (childhood to 2010) and San Francisco 4 years ago to present. My take on it is that San Francisco isn't really significantly better or worse than comparable dynamic cities. It's got good cultural, social, and economic opportunities. But it's nothing super special, and it largely doesn't justify the cost unless you're getting paid a premium to live there (thus why it's dominated by higher paid workers mostly in tech). I'm not so sure whether it's fair to say that this is the wealthy people deliberately imposing exclusory policies. It's mostly long time residents that are anti-development and favor nativist policies like rent control. Most of the tech workers I know want the city to build more housing and remove nativist policies. But some, like proposition 13, are enacted by the state and our ability to remove them is very limited.
- the_clarence 8y agoYou’re the first person I’ve seen being against rent control. You want to rent a place where the landlord can double the rent the following week?
- mmirate3 8y agoIncrement your count. I'd say more about it, but I don't think I can write any more eloquently and exhaustively than these folks: https://www.econlib.org/library/Enc/RentControl.html https://www.econlib.org/library/Enc/RentControl.html
- manfredo 8y agoThe only people who benefit from rent control are long time residents that were fortunate enough to start ending a long time ago. Everyone else is subsidizing those people. This is why rent control is a nativist policy. Not to mention, rent control suppresses willingness to build more housing thus contributing to the chronic undersupply of housing in places like San Francisco that have extensive rent control. People would be a lot less eager to shoot down development proposals if they felt the impact of rising rents. But currently, only ~30-40% of the renter population is affected by rising rents.
- duaoebg 8y agoSan Francisco is awful. Recently a homeless person mindlessly threw their bucket of shit onto the hood of my Uber. This was in SoMa so not even Tenderloin where you might expect something like that.
- the_clarence 8y agoA month ago I took the bus in emeryville, bunch of kids started slapping passengers randomly. I thought I was going to have to fight against them. They ended up ignoring my gf and I. A week after I take a bus around 2pm. In the mission a guy just jumped on a girl and pulled on her phone for like 10s until she released it. Then got out of the bus and ran away. Frightening stuff. That and the weird homeless jumping at you randomly in the street to give you a scare. I don’t understand why any tourists would come here. It’s really unsafe, especially if you have children. PS: I also feel so bad for these homes with homeless people sleeping on their porches... or all these shops, restaurants, bars and cafes that end up being swarmed and surrounded by the crazies. Life suck for a lot of the people here. I’m happy I can afford to cab everywhere and avoid the craziness most of the time.
- latchkey 8y agoAfter 20 years in the Bay Area, I left just over two years ago. I moved across the world to Saigon, Vietnam. I had never lived outside of California before. I did not leave because I hated SF, I left because I wanted to do something else with my life. In a way, for the same reasons I stopped going to Burningman after the 5th time. There is other things to do in life than just experience one city. One thing about the bay area is that it definitely goes through cycles. I went through that many times. You can't take it personally that your friends want to do something else with their life. The expectation that we stay in the bay area until we die seems obtuse to me. I was back recently for a work trip (consulting) and I did not miss it at all. I realized that at the end of the day, I was doing it wrong for myself. I was leading a consumerist lifestyle of click buying things I did not really need on Amazon or paying $20 for lunch every day. Now that I have changed those patterns, I am much happier and more free.
- kibalock 8y agoI made a video about San Francisco and why I left: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=li6nZefWZ5w https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=li6nZefWZ5w
- blhack 8y agoEvery time there is one of these threads about SF, the topic of human feces seems to be a big part of it. People defecating everywhere, people throwing feces at each other, just filth everywhere. WHY does the city not just install portapotties all over the place? I bet they could even plumb the portos into the actual sewer eventually, but it seems like just installing portos and having trucks pump them a few times a day is something that could happen tomorrow.
- ransom1538 8y ago"WHY does the city not just install portapotties all over the place?" I can clarify what is happening - this might help others too. There is a large drug scene around Edddy & Turk & Market in San Francisco. Mainly crack or heroin (currently). To earn money these addicts pan handle around market street. What happens is the addicted users often get belly sick (crack guys from eating food while high and heroin guys from being 'dope sick'). They don't have the physical capacity to move quick enough to a restroom. AND they occupy the most heavily trafficked areas for money (powell/market). So this is a perfect storm.
- the_clarence 8y agoIt’s not just for the homeless, others have to go when they’re out of their place as well. I never understood why people get mad at me for pissing in the street when I don’t have much choice.
- masonic 8y agoThere are modern, self-cleaning public toilets all over. Of course, most are commandeered into shooting galleries or places to turn tricks. Portapotties need a lot of maintenance and have odor issues.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- 0x445442 8y agoIt's not just San Francisco. The whole state has been on a steady decline since... wait for it... the state turned blue. It's very sad because the California I grew up in was the place to be, not just in the US but in the world. I lived in the state from 1967 until 2006 and I can tell you 1992 was pretty much the pivot point.
- the_clarence 8y agoWouldn’t free healthcare actually prevent most of these cases?
- masonic 8y agoHealth Care is mostly subsidized already: the average premium cost paid on Covered CA is less than $150/month as it is.
- hirundo 8y agoFor the rent of a small studio in SF, ten years ago I left the bay area and got a mortgage on a modest house on a few acres in rural New Mexico. Now the mortgage is paid and all that cash not going to a landlord or a bank makes a big difference in my lifestyle and peace of mind. For me living far from a city is a bonus, and without remote work I'd be hosed here, so it's sure not for everyone. But I'm not tempted to go back.
- countzeroasl 8y agoCost of Living. I was born in California. I lived there for two years again starting in 1998. Even 20 years ago, cost of living was stupid. And that was in rural northern California. It was worse in the city. And it hasn't gotten any better in the last 20 years. In fact, I've even excluded California from my last and any future job searches because as a plastics engineering manager, a company can't pay me enough for my family and I to live on there. It's crazy.
- the_clarence 8y agoI’ve lived in Chicago, currently in SF. Both cities are filled with homeless like I’ve never seen before. I’d say I felt less safe in Chicago, but in SF the homeless are more trashy: poops and seringes and crazy people everywhere. People get harassed or mugged all the time. It’s not pretty. Now, tech-wise, SF is freaking amazing and you HAVE to go there for a few years if you work in tech. It’s that magical. If you’re a tourist, I’d say avoid it. Now if you want my opinion, it’s the US that has a huge disparity problem. SF is just the symptom of something much deeper. People are unwilling to see what’s in front of them. When I talk to people in SF or Chicago they tell me that their city is safe and that it has as much homeless as Paris or London. When I hear about prop C which tries to throw more money at the problem, people seem to be against it.
- redisman 8y agoHomelessness is really a federal problem but it shows its symptoms in big cities since that's where the homeless migrate/are sent. Especially the most "liberal" big cities with good reputations. The state and country end up dumping their problems on a handful of cities and expect them to solve it somehow. SF, LA, NY, SEA can't fix 300M peoples shitty mental health care system and lack of safety net nationally.
- 60654 8y agoHuh, I lived in both as well (in the city itself, not the burbs, in both cases), and had a very different reaction. I haven't felt "unsafe" in either city, but Chicago feels so much nicer and cleaner in comparison. In SF, however, the trashiness you mention is very much right there, front and center. And I haven't seen people be harassed in CHI like I've seen in SF - there's no equivalent of mid-market, with its luxury condos getting built right next to the TL.
- salman123abid 8y agoNeed fiverr reviews https://bit.ly/2Q2csNz https://bit.ly/2Q2csNz