5 ms·
At what price will the Bitcoin death spiral occur? (i.e. when it costs more to produce/handle Bitcoin than the revenue generated, so best move is to just exit t
by minimaxir 8y ago
At what price will the Bitcoin death spiral occur? (i.e. when it costs more to produce/handle Bitcoin than the revenue generated, so best move is to just exit the crypto industry).
- InGodsName 8y agoBitcoin will rise again. Bitcoin removes the need to trust a bookie/agent to move money offshore. Whenever flow of money is possible between a safe haven and a corrupt/socialist big country with high tax rate/more population burden. Money flows to the safe heaven. Bitcoin is one such way to move money from african nations/india/china to safe haven like Switzerland, Singapore, UK etc... I am talking about illict gains/unreported assets which can't be moved through official channels. Moving your unreported assets to a different country might not be illegal in that country if a deal is structured correctly. That's where lawyers/accounts/consultants come into play. Bitcoin will rise again once a need to move money to save heaven rises again. It's an efficient medium to move large sums of money without trusting a bookie. I can buy coffee loaded in container from an african country where inflation has killed the local currency and banks do not have infra for international settlement or take much bigger cut or simply aren't trusted by local people. For this i make simple bitcoin transfer from Hong Kong and get my coffee contain undocked in Hong Kong. Edit: it's haven not heaven.
- carlob 8y agoFirst of all the word you're looking for is haven (as in a harbor), not heaven. Secondly, are you saying that bitcoin exists solely for the purpose of money laundering and tax evasion?
- InGodsName 8y agoNo, but it certainly can be used for money laundering and tax evasion. It removes the need to trust a bookie or agent to move money offshore. There are lawyers/accountants in Switzerland and Hong Kong who will help you launder money from third world countries. Moving your assets offshore without local government knowing is not a crime in other country! Edit: why downvotes? What's wrong?
- carlob 8y agoMy point was that you are assuming some sort of libertarian viewpoint where nation-states trying to tax your money are fundamentally corrupt/socialist. I personally tend to think that in the vast majority of cases govt spending of tax money does more for the greater good than whatever a self-appointed authority would. There are many exception to this, but I still think this is largely true in democracies. But then again I tend to identify as a social-democrat.
- InGodsName 8y agoYeaa but if you go to some third world countries, you'll see high tax rate yet not enough benefits for your tax rate. Prime example is India where people still have power cuts yet business/salaried middle class pays north of 30% tax. People there will happily pay 60% tax if they get even Rome level of infrastructure access So, it's no brainer a lot of them move their money offshore. Edit: people who feel they are not getting fair share of their infra quality, with this line of thinking will move money aboard doesn't matter if it's ethical/legal thing to do or not.
- carlob 8y agoThis would require some discussion of international wealth and income distribution, but to me the injustice is not at the state level here, but rather in the fact itself that India is a third world country. The Indian upper-middle class should really be demanding reparation to the UK for the effects of colonization rather than moving money offshore damaging only their poorer countrymen.
- mmirate 8y ago> nation-states trying to tax your money are fundamentally corrupt/socialist That is a true statement; taxation is theft.
- perfmode 8y agoThe religiosity of this post is fitting.
- albertgoeswoof 8y agoDogmatic is the word you’re looking for
- perfmode 8y agoNah. > strong religious feeling or belief Religiosity
- mindfulplay 8y agoBasically a scam then?
- marcell 8y agoBitcoin was doing perfectly fine at $100, so I think these predictions are a bit premature and have some recency bias. The price drop does lower the amount of security in the network, so it becomes cheaper to attack it. However, it also means the payoff to attack is lower.
- minimaxir 8y agoThe cost of production (as a function of the hash rate) was much lower than $100/coin at that time.
- tinus_hn 8y agoThe cost adjusts to the resources people want to expend, so a block always takes approximately the same amount of time.
- duxup 8y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong, but I thought mining coins took power as time went on. Thus what it took to do the job in the past isn't what it would take today and thus past mining really wouldn't be comparable.
- barnabee 8y agoThe difficulty (amount/cost of power required) goes up over time when the price goes up because more miners join the network as it becomes more profitable, which means that on average new coins are produced more often. The network targets a certain rate of production and it does this by increasing the difficulty. If the price drops and miners leave this will happen in reverse and coins will not be produced fast enough, then the difficulty will reduce (meaning less power is required to mine a block). The network would be fine even back at $100.
- duxup 8y agoForgive me as I don't quite grok bitcoin. Does the math to calculate a coin change based on... price? For some reason I assumed the mathematical difficulty just naturally increased as part of what in my mind is "the mathematical problem" vs. number of coins.
- marcosdumay 8y agoDon't bitcoin costs adjust to a shrinking miner population as well as it adjusts for a growing one? If so, the answer is never. As people give-up, the costs for the remaining ones reduce so that at some point it's lucrative again. The interesting question is at what price people will stop speculating on its price and run to an exit? I don't think anybody can answer this one.
- hudon 8y agoThe difference is that even if the difficulty adjusts, there will be dormant ASICs waiting to be used. If the price lowers enough and enough ASICs are out on the bench, it’ll at one point becoming economically beneficial to turn them all on and attack the network rather than having them collect dust and depreciate.
- mikeyouse 8y agoIf they’re dormant, by definition they’re already unprofitable to operate. If the price decreases further, only the most efficient miners will remain, not the least efficient of them.
- hudon 8y agoUnprofitable to operate in friendly conditions* If you can flip a switch and 10x the hashrate of a network, all under your control, and you don’t care about killing the chain in your attack, it may be a perfect exit for you if you no longer want to play the mining game. There’s actually a mining pool doing something like this on smaller PoW bitcoins https://sharkpool.cash https://sharkpool.cash (not associated, just think it’s interesting)
- dbldogdareudang 8y agoGreat. Self-aggrandizing tech-cultists utilized collective effort for creating shit tons of already outdated hardware to increase ephemeral “value numbers” that only exists in a database (net worth). The tech world has jumped the shark. It’s now producing fart pipes and spinner rims to justify investment, rather than truly useful invention.
- arisAlexis 8y agothere can be no such a thing by design. Tulips didn't have it but Bitcoin does have a mechanism of self adjusting mining difficulty
- CydeWeys 8y agoAs others have pointed out, the difficulty adjusts both up and down depending on the total work being done by the network, so no death cycle is possible. Additionally, even when there are rapid drops in value (and thus mining), people still want to transact Bitcoin, so transaction fees go up and become a significant percentage of the overall value of a new block, thus compensating miners for the reduced value of the block reward. There is no death spiral; there's just regular increase/decrease in value over time.
- LowLevelHacker 8y agoWhy does hn love to hate Bitcoin so much?
- asfgjonuinio 8y agoThere are tons of interesting failure modes. The simplistic one won't happen, but that doesn't mean that it isn't teetering on the bring of a death spiral. What happens when the market is flooded with cheap miners? A 51% attack is suddenly affordable. What happens if the price drops off a cliff right after a difficulty adjustment? As hash rate falls, difficulty adjustments become farther apart than the two weeks they're supposed to be. What happens when smaller miners close up shop? Bitcoin mining is already very centralized. Falling profitability would move it even more into the hands of the biggest players with the most efficient hardware and the cheapest electricity. Read: China. A falling price is a huge problem for the security and stability of the network. Bitcoin is teetering on the brink of complete collapse. >people still want to transact Bitcoin No one uses Bitcoin. The transaction fees would have to go up by a factor of over 100 to equal the current block rewards. And, if people don't use Bitcoin now, why would they when transactions are 100x the current price?
- ivalm 8y agoIf transaction fees go up too much this discourages the use of bitcoin as a currency....
- way2983 8y ago>As others have pointed out, the difficulty adjusts both up and down depending on the total work being done by the network, so no death cycle is possible. It's true that the difficulty adjusts both up and down, however it does so over 2016 block intervals. If a sufficiently fast and large drop in value/hashrate occurs, the chain could well 'death spiral'. The drop simply has to occur within the adjustment interval (2016 blocks- or 14 days). That said, recovering from a death spiral is as simple as a new Bitcoin Core release that hard-forks the difficulty to a new, workable level, so the fatalistic view of death spirals is still wrong.
- LowLevelHacker 8y agoAt what price does oil enter a death spiral, where it is best to just never use oil for anything ever again?
- 21 8y agoThere was a time when the Bitcoin price was zero, yet people spent computer time mining it. So the answer to your question is never, a Bitcoin death spiral can not occur.
- onion2k 8y agoYou're right in the sense that there'll always be a few hundred interested people mining Bitcoin for fun, but that's not very useful information. "Actually dead" and "effectively dead" might as well be synonyms in this case.
- asfgjonuinio 8y agoAlready happened. The hash rate is falling and the market is flooded with cheap hardware. You'll hear some handwaving about difficulty adjustments. That doesn't change the fact that it is becoming increasingly unprofitable and miners are already shutting down en masse.
- gammateam 8y agoThis happened from 2014 to mid 2016, a good 18 months. Nothing happened. There have been bigger threats to the network, the revenue of miners isn't currently one. A threat to the usability of the network would be if 90% of mining power disappeared at the same time, this means it would take 900% longer to confirm a block until the next difficulty adjustment drops the network confirmation time back to 10 minutes. Difficulty adjustments happen every 2016 blocks, each block is supposed to come every 10 minutes. The worst case scenario would be hashrate disappearing right after a difficulty adjustment meaning 2015 blocks will be found very slowly, there could be a max of 4 months of a slower bitcoin network. Makes me wonder what you even mean by death spiral, like what user experience do you expect to happen? Users wouldn't immediately stop using bitcoin because it was slower, they wouldn't even know it would suck, so more likely the unconfirmed transactions would add up, and to ensure getting mined into a block, the users would increase their transaction fees to coax miners to include them first (instead of dropping their transaction completely when they run out of memory). With a higher fee market, this is an even greater incentive for miners to come back on the network, because now the block reward doesn't even matter, since the fees can potentially eclipse it totally. The price of bitcoin would even cease to matter, if there is a dollar figure of fees just there. Miners come back on the network would make the hashrate higher again, before the difficulty adjustment, making blocks confirm faster, instead of slower. This equilibrium is already in the minds of miners, which contributes to them staying on the network so that they don't miss out. This isn't theory, its all happened before.
- sbenitoj 8y agoWhen it costs miners (who lack the economies of scale and access to cheap electricity that major miners have) more to produce Bitcoin than the block rewards and transactions fees they receive from doing so, they simply shut off their miners until the price gets high enough to operate profitably again (of course they could also just continue to operate at a loss in the short-term, but financial resources are always limited so they would have to stop operating at some point if the price doesn’t increase). There will always be SOME miners who have access to cheap enough electricity and economies of scale for whom it continues to be profitable to mine.
- cageface 8y agoI think the problem is that BTC has been through a very public boom and bust cycle so the public at large is now very wary and a lot of new regulations are coming in. Blockchain needs to start solving some actual man in the street kind of problems soon if it's going to retain any mindshare.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ramontayag 8y agoI think it is solving some man-in-the-street problems for people who aren't in countries with good financial systems.