9 ms·
Do I Offend?
- jseliger 8y agoThis is congruent with "What You Can't Say:" http://paulgraham.com/say.html http://paulgraham.com/say.html.
- neonate 8y agoAlso with John McWhorter's recent article (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18747429 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18747429).
- shawn 8y agoNo, they attribute to me the most extreme bad views imaginable Yes. It’s partly why I’m banned, and why people call my behavior monstrous even though all I’ve done is point out inconsistencies in HN’s moderation. I’ve built a 12 year reputation on this site, and it was destroyed overnight at the whims of a moderator. I haven’t broken any rules. Ultimately, no one cares about the fate of those who fall to authority. And why would they? If Dan is willing to utterly ruin a 12 year member of HN for merely asking “why was I penalized?” then imagine what he’ll do to you. As far as I can tell, he penalized me for some opinions I expressed (even though they were expressed thoughtfully and non inflammatorily). When I pressed the issue publicly, I was Game of Throne’d. He dressed it up as a “90 day probation,” but of course it morphed into a permanent ban. At this point it seems like my account has been marked unvouchable, meaning none of my comments even have a fair shot of being resurrected regardless of how many people vouch them. Pretty interesting to see all of this stem from me expressing a few opinions. But, I chose this life partly to highlight the absurdity.
- rangibaby 8y agoThis post is alive
- shawn 8y agoYes, a certain mod occasionally vouches comments I make. You can tell this is true because the comment is marked [flagged] immediately. If a comment is flagged by the community, it becomes [flagged][dead], not merely [flagged]. The consistent theme here is to do whatever it takes to make me seem unreasonable or mistaken. In this case, I say “none of my comments are able to be resurrected from the dead,” and presto! Almost instantly, that same comment is ressurected. Whereas my comments about bcrypt or tech related matters stay firmly dead. And before my account was (apparently) marked unvouchable, a mod manually killed a substantive comment I made that happened to be vouched: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18564850 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18564850 I don’t mind though. The hard part is the loneliness. I genuinely miss talking with you guys and discussing the news of the day. But again, I chose this life as public protest. This is my last comment for the next three hours, as I am limited to two comments every three. But I wish all the HN readers a Merry Christmas and a happy new year.
- nkurz 8y agoI vouched for it, and it came alive for a bit, although not immediately. I'm not sure if this was because it required multiple vouches to revivify, or whether there was manual intervention by administrators. It's dead again now, apparently by user flagging. I vouched for it not because I agree with it, but because I thought it was non-offensive, and because I thought that it was better for this dispute to occasionally be in the light rather than always in the shadow-text of the show-dead. As far as what's actually happening, I confess I don't understand. Shawn comes across as bright, polite, and occasionally oblivious to social norms. Which is to say, he doesn't seem that far out of place here. Dan has responded to him many times, including this meta-response linking to many other responses: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18454702 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18454702. I also confess that part of the reason I vouched for this comment was that it struck me as a real-life example of the loudly-humming child in the backseat, with the hands-over-ears seatmate writhing next to him. I'm not quite sure which is Dan, and which is Shawn, but either way, Merry Christmas to both of you, and best of luck in your respective quixotic quests.
- newer_guy 8y ago“When a politician says his opponent is mistaken, that's a straightforward criticism, but when he attacks a statement as "divisive" or "racially insensitive" instead of arguing that it's false, we should start paying attention.” At one point he reflects on the “high water mark of political correctness during the early 1990s.” Really funny to read that in 2018. Whether you are a liberal or not, everyone would agree that political correctness has grown tremendously since then. Wherher it was for good or bad depends on your politics. In any case, very interesting to consider. This essay was very good. Thanks.
- gweinberg 8y agoDon't you mean stop paying attention?
- imustbeevil 8y agoIt's a quote. I read this quote as "pay attention when someone stops making rational arguments because it means they don't have any rational arguments". If you aren't paying attention you'll miss the switch between what is reasonable and what is emotionally manipulative.
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoNo. The argument is that, when statements are labeled "divisive" rather than "wrong", that's telling you that there is something that, socially, you're not allowed to say (which was the topic of the essay that the quote came from).
- marcosdumay 8y ago> everyone would agree that political correctness has grown tremendously since then Yes, that's part of society stopping with it.
- doubleunplussed 8y agoI mean, divisiveness for its own sake is bad - I wish more people felt like we were 'in this together' more of the time instead of engaging in identity politics about which group deserves what. So I see where the point is coming from, but it's not a totally content-free argument to make, to accuse someone of being divisive. It doesn't mean they're wrong, but calling someone divisive could be a valid criticism in its own right.
- hombre_fatal 8y ago> Long ago when I had two young kids, they would sometimes pick fights, for example on long car trips. One might start singing, to which the other would complain. We might agree that singing is too much for such a small space. Then the first might start to quietly hum, which we might decide is okay. Then first might hum more loudly and triumphantly, while the second might writhe, cover their ears, and make a dramatic display of suffering. I love this example of bad faith complaining. There's something grotesque about adults doing this in internet comments. Like watching a grown man wear a diaper.
- perfmode 8y agoThe offended child is really complaining about the subtle and escalating transgression of the humming child. > Then the first might start to quietly hum, which we might decide is okay. Then first might hum more loudly and triumphantly The humming child scores low on the scale of interpersonal justice. Framing the offended child’s suffering as bad faith is, in a Wittgensteinian sense, to misunderstand their use of language. They aren’t playing the language game of the observer passing judgement. The observer is failing to steel-man the position of the aggrieved and instead chooses to focus on an apparent and ostensible fault.
- will4274 8y ago> the subtle and escalating transgression of the humming child Is humming a "transgression"? Music is typically considered entertainment. Why can't the other child put on head phones, hum a different song, or look out the window? It's exactly this phenomenon that OP is addressing. A fairly common behavior (humming to oneself) is portrayed as a "transgression" and you go so far as to say it is unjust, just because somebody else happens to not like it. You've thrown the authors framing, that certain actions are inherently annoying and unacceptable (singing loudly in a small space) while others are generally acceptable (humming softly to oneself) out the window.
- perfmode 8y agoContext matters. In a library, humming is a violation of the conventions of the space. In a music practice room, it is perfectly fine. In a car, the convention is ambiguous and dependent on the passengers. This is precisely why it is necessary to come to agreement on what is okay to do in the space. Again: The humming child was initially singing. So, to view the humming in isolation is to dismiss the fact that this is an iterative negotiation.
- mattigames 8y agoI offend and I try to offend, I try to offend the anti-vaxers, the pedophile priests, the corrupt politicians, I try to offend anyone who hold ideas or behaviors that clearly shouldn't be part of society, specially I try to offend people that long ago decided they don't care for reasoning and not matter how much proof there is about them being wrong, to be clear I don't mean any kind of offending but offenses that show how ridiculous or inmoral their stance is on such matters.
- AlexB138 8y agoAnd how do you manage to identify which ideas shouldn't be part of society? I can't imagine having the level of self assurance necessary to consider myself the arbiter of acceptable ideas for all of society, let alone to actually intentionally agitate people over my chosen results. It's fascinating.
- mattigames 8y ago“The problem with the world is that the intelligent people are full of doubts, while the stupid ones are full of confidence.” - Charles Bukowski
- rosser 8y agoThat's a re-phrasing of Bertrand Russell's "The trouble with the world is that the stupid are cocksure and the intelligent are full of doubt."
- mattigames 8y agoSorry, its the first one google shows, I will make sure to quote this one next time, even more for being a tad more offensive.
- benjohnson 8y agoAs I understand it - W. B. Yeats beat Bertrand by a few years with "The best lack all conviction, while the worst are full of passionate intensity." I'm sure this lament is as old as time - someone probably has Yeats beat by a few millennia.
- perfmode 8y agoThe author isn’t illogical. They are just not aware or interested in the broader context of the global issues they are attempting to engage with. The author would benefit from some time spent investigating from a humanistic perspective.
- wycs 8y ago>The author would benefit from some time spent investigating from a humanistic perspective. They need to grovel in other words.
- perfmode 8y agoI had to look that up. > act obsequiously in order to obtain forgiveness or favour. > obsequious: exhibiting servile complaisance or deference No. That’s not what I’m saying. I’m saying that there is a broader context to consider.
- zepto 8y agoAre you talking about Hanson? It’s quite obvious, because he describes aspects of the broader context, that he is aware of it. In particular, his investigation of the responses to A Star is Born, seems to be helpful and informative towards the humanistic perspective.
- hjek 8y agoI didn't get the context, so I had to look it up: > What fraction of women assaulted by a nominee for Supreme Court in high school would wait to publicly accuse him not just 30 yrs, but after Congress hearings & just before Congress vote?[0] And then the author claims that the poll is "neutral"? However, there are biased ways of asking questions.[1] A poll about the Kavanaugh hearing could also ask "What fraction of rapists are convicted?" and that would carry a different political meaning. [0]: https://twitter.com/robinhanson/status/1041743505507405824?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw https://twitter.com/robinhanson/status/1041743505507405824?r... [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anschluss#/media/File:Stimmzettel-Anschluss.jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anschluss#/media/File:Stimmzet...
- ryanmonroe 8y agoAsking that question and then implying in the comments that the wording doesn't lead people to a specific conclusion is exactly the type of "bad faith" action this post purports to be against. Well, either that or the author is just very biased and very oblivious. Either way, it gives some insight into what he means by "infer indirectly from my neutral analytical text that I promote the most extreme views imaginable"
- whymauri 8y agoThis is a prime example of someone claiming to be neutral or centrist to push their agenda while holding a falsified high ground. You see it all the time on Reddit.
- zepto 8y agoYou may be right, but it’s also possible that you are projecting your own bias onto what the author is doing. If you read his pieces, it’s clear that his focus is on Bayesian probability and reasoning in general. That question is interesting, because you can certainly read it as a leading question. But you can also just take it at face value. One answer might be that the fraction is likely to be close to 100%, since there is a good chance that the population is just one, and we know that she actually did. What fraction of people can tell the difference between a Bayesian economist asking a question with an uninituitive answer, and someone with a ‘falsified’ agenda to push?
- DenisM 8y agoI wonder what would happen if the blog author stopped reading twitter? He would never know that someone is real angry someplace out there, nor would he care very much.
- JBReefer 8y agoIsn’t that the only point of twitter? It seems like the 24 hour version of the 2 minutes of hate.
- Zuider 8y agoIf only Twitter were merely an insubstantial epiphenomenon lacking influence on the real world, but unfortunately, people can use Twitter as a tool to destroy those who offend them.
- DenisM 8y agoIn what way? By telling other twitter users to boycott a twitter non-user? The only thing I can imagine that will have any effect if some potential employer misguidedly taking twitter rumors for facts. Is that a thing?
- btrask 8y agoHow one tweet can ruin your life | Jon Ronson https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wAIP6fI0NAI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wAIP6fI0NAI
- DenisM 8y agoWhen you work in PR, a PR gaffe can get you fired, that comes with the territory. If she wasn’t in PR and didn’t log in to Twitter she wouldn’t have any problems. So my question is whether you can get serious problem from twitter if you’re not in PR?
- otikik 8y agoQuick reminder: you'll surely offend some people when telling the truth. But offending people doesn't prove that what you are saying is true.
- zacherates 8y agoObligatory SMBC: https://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/the-offensive-truth https://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/the-offensive-truth
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- hkon 8y ago"Did he just" <insert newspeak here>
- sudofail 8y agoI think most people would agree that having rational, emotionally detached conversations about complex and sensitive subjects would be beneficial to society, so in that, I agree with the author. And from his writing, it does seem his effort to talk about these subjects is done in earnest. But I think there are a few reasons why this mindset fails in real world application. Firstly, the various social justice movements we see in western societies are all groups that aren’t straight white men. And while one might say that shouldn’t matter in a logical discussion, the fact is that the life experiences of these maligned groups are outside the realm of experience of the author, and of other straight white men. Rational debate depends on high quality data, and that data is not immediately available unless you live it. So unless you actively inquire and try to get a deep understanding of what these groups go through, you’re going to be debating or discussing something you don’t know a lot about, relatively. The other issue is that these discussions inherently aren’t rational and detached from emotion. To the maligned group, this topic is something they live with every day, and often times have had to endure extreme emotional trauma. When someone says to them, “let’s just discuss this rationally”, they rightly often feel very frustrated. If we want to have honest, good faith discussions on the topic of social equality, the only solution is for people to earnestly and honestly inform themselves of the life experiences of the social groups for whom equality has remained out of reach. Also note that I’m not trying to target straight white men (I’m a straight white man too). I think this has more to do with power dynamics. I’m sure countries like India and China have their own particular historical class of power that is the target of their own social movements.
- colemickens 8y ago>If we want to have honest, good faith discussions on the topic of social equality, the only solution is for people to earnestly and honestly inform themselves of the life experiences of the social groups for whom equality has remained out of reach. While I agree with every word you wrote, I don't know how you can maintain hope in this. Just weeks ago, there was an HN thread, where between the article and comments there were dozens of stories of women suffering harassment. And yet still, multiple people here commented to the effect, "No real women in my life tell me about this stuff, the rest must be hysterical." I'm paraphrasing, but it's not an unfair characterization. I see it in the same light as folks that have a completely 100% incorrect understanding of "[institutional] privilege" and are already at a weird level of anger by time they enter any conversation about it. They seem to be unable or unwilling to entertain, let alone accept, evidence contrary to their closely held beliefs (and there's evidence to back it up). Meanwhile, the groups that get frustrated at continual, constant marginalization from those with their heads in the clouds, or try to advocate for causes and less ignorance, are given three-letter acronym labels which are used to deride and derail. And within 5 minutes this reply is swinging +/-4 votes with no replies. How absolutely utterly depressing.
- Liron 8y agoHere's a smart, honest, careful intellectual who is always striving to elevate our discourse, and the mob just tries to drag him into the mud with the same blunt emotional attacks they use on everyone. Short attention spans, fake outrage, and lazy arguments are the fundamental problems of contemporary discourse. But Robin Hanson has consistently been one of the best role models of what high-quality discourse should look like.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoI was a full time mom for a lot of years. I absolutely would not have tolerated one of my kids triumphantly humming louder to intentionally aggravate the other one. The fact that he thinks there is something wrong with the other child protesting this makes me think the answer to his question -- Do I Offend? -- is probably "yes." He probably is pretty offensive at times. He doesn't really get basic human respect. Having said that, I have come to the conclusion that we all offend, we all exclude, we all decide what kind of people we want to associate with and what kind we want nothing to do with. Then we argue about who is right and where those boundaries "should" be drawn. Some people draw those boundaries along racial lines or religious lines or other fairly arbitrary categories for deciding who is the "right" kind of person and who is the "wrong" kind of person. Boundaries drawn that way tend to have a lot of downside to them. But it's simpler and easier than trying to figure out who is actually respectful, honorable, kind and decent. That's a much harder question to answer in a meaningful way and we often need to decide if we trust someone to some degree under circumstances where, no, we can't reasonably determine the answers to such questions. So it's really common for people to come up with some shorthand method for sorting the presumed good apples from the presumed bad apples so we can try to get through the damn day without wondering if the guy bagging our groceries is really a serial killer. I don't think it's actually good policy to use such rubrics. I think the world needs to sort out some better methodology for coping with social realities in a world of 7 billion people when our brains evolved to cope with little tribes and villages of about 150 people. But I have come to believe that we all, to some degree or another, tend to promote rules with our own self interest in mind. So I no longer feel like, clearly, X is morally superior to Y! Just because I'm a big believer in X and I spent years thinking about it doesn't mean it really is morally superior in some big picture sense. Those folks who believe in Y may have spent just as much time thinking about it and may feel just as strongly as I do and we may both be wrong. We may both simply be promoting something that happens to work for us as individuals while dressing it up in moral language because that works better for getting buy-in than admitting "It works for me, so I want it that way to enhance my life." I'm a woman. Hacker News was perhaps as much as 98 percent male when I joined under a different handle more than nine years ago. I feel like it has become more welcoming of women over the years. I feel like I have played some role in that change. I think the guys here tolerate me as well as they do because I don't take some sort of strident moral ("Feminazi") position that I have some kind of right to be here. I am mindful of the fact that there is something of value here and that thing was mostly built by men. I'm aware that change is a potential threat to the value that exists and accommodating my presence -- what with me being some loud-mouthed brassy broad who never managed to learn my "place" in the world and who, for whatever reason, grew up with the idea that my voice was as acceptable as any guy's voice, never mind that this is apparently not what most people on the planet seem to learn -- de facto involves change. I've worked at trying hard to figure out how to make that work in a way that doesn't kill the goose that lays the golden eggs, so to speak. When I first joined HN, I was more inclined than I am these days to feel self-righteous about trying to stand up for myself. I still am willing to take a stand, but I am much less inclined to feel self-righteous about it. I'm just a human trying to make my life work. I'm angry, as most anyone would be, about the ways in which I feel that arbitrary categories, such as my gender, have undermined and seem to continue to undermine those efforts. I am a big believer in win-win solutions. If other people help me make my life work, then that's one less person who needs food stamps and other forms of welfare. We pay for those people who don't succeed. Whether they are in prison or standing in line at a soup kitchen, someone else is paying for them because they can't manage to support themselves. But I'm also aware that not all solutions are win-win solutions. Plenty of them are just redefining the split without growing the proverbial pie. So it is generally reasonable to be somewhat leery of people advocating for changes that would lead to them having more pie, because it is possible that they are just trying to change the rules to get a bigger slice for themselves at the expense of other people. The things that have happened to me really stick in my craw precisely because I'm not looking for a handout. I've consistently tried to figure out how to develop an earned income of my own. Perhaps people have trouble seeing the distinction there. Perhaps all they hear is that I want a better life and they assume I'm asking for a larger slice of the pie rather than asking for the means to bake more pie for myself. I'm not very good at writing in some kind of "professional" detached third-person fashion. I've gotten a lot of feedback over the years that I'm doing it wrong to speak from firsthand experience and to speak from a first person point of view based on my life experience. For a long time, I worked at improving on that. At this point, I'm sort of inclined to feel like such accusations are really just intended to silence me, not to tell me "There are better methods for communicating than what you are doing and please get a clue, you silly person, you." So the above is testimony as to the problem space as I best understand it, not me whining about my life and asking for advice. If you give me advice about how I'm just doing it wrong or you want to tell me that talking about my life is inherently bad and wrong and unwelcome when it seems fine for other people to talk about their lives, I'm planning to just ignore such replies. Happy to engage people about anything of actual substance concerning, say, how the world draws various boundaries, etc.
- grigjd3 8y agoAnyone who goes so far out of their way to state that they don't push values is clearly trying (feebly) to mask their own motivations, perhaps even from themselves. Perhaps more incriminating is how thuroughly self-referencial this person's writing it. This person is so engrossed by his perception of himself as neutral that he doesn't recognize the validity of other people's experiences.
- didibus 8y agoAm I the only one who can't find a single argument for why he isn't biased in the whole article? He just goes: "Some people say I'm an offensive bad person, which is pushing a political and moral agenda, with my own biases, but I swear, I am pure facts and logic, and my reasoning is always neutral, and so I hope we can all move along and allow me to continue my logical rhetoric." I was hoping for some facts, counterfacts, examples, logical reasoning, I don't know, some more concrete demonstration of his good faith, neutrality, and display of unbiased methodology. Instead I just got a plea to believe his words. Did I miss something?