11 ms·
Quora pays thousands for posting questions
- Cyclone_ 8y agoWould be curious to know how much revenue for the company the top earner generated
- randomacct3847 8y agoI wonder what motivates Adam D’Angelo to keep on as founder and CEO after 10 years of running Quora. Here is someone who got rich off FB and could do anything. Maybe early on that “anything” was Quora but I really can’t believe that what Quora is now is anything close to what he envisioned when he first started the site. At this point it feels like a Zombie co that keeps chugging along because it has no other choice but to do so? Quora embodies what I fear most about the idea of ever starting a VC-backed co...that once you accept money it is very hard to return it and if your burn rate is low you could just “exist” for years without actually succeeding or accomplishing much at all.
- the_other_guy 8y agoBut what if this was his sole vision for Quora in the first place? It doesn't require a genius to know that everybody who worked in the new era of social media (mid to late 2000s) understood that you could create an empire from your users' free labor while doing literally nothing. Quora was built as such, Quora was made so that one website contains questions and answers about everything and exploit search engines and SEO to become one of the most popular websites for a long time.
- ttoinou 8y agoWell now you know the secret to get rich, go ahead ;)
- the_other_guy 8y ago2018 is too late already, Quora and many others came in a time when making a post viral on Facebook and Twitter was way much easier in late 2000s and early 2010s and almost for free, exploiting Google search engine was also much easier back then. Now the internet is popularity contest business, pay for exposure or see your products die.
- codezero 8y agoHave you thought about this a lot? Quora is Adam's baby. He owns most of it and has been involved as a primary investor for... I'm not sure how long. Before that he was CTO of Facebook and an early investor in Instagram. He's made immense returns on these investments. I don't have numbers, but I would bet money he could buy back Quora from investors with cash and still be a several-hundred-millionaire. With that said, why would he do anything but his pet project?
- manigandham 8y agoHaving so much success though can also mean that you don't have as much drive to make a great product because you're already set. Not that it must be the case here, but passion is hard to maintain when it doesn't really have much effect on your life. Also, if the site can be run completely independently (and it looks like operational costs are rather low) then why even take VC in the first place? Surely the effects of hundreds of millions requiring a return could easily be predicted as eventually causing problems?
- codezero 8y agoI agree with your first point, but Adam is also one of the sharpest people I’ve ever known. It’s hard for me to resolve the idea that he’d be complacent. As for funding, he wasn’t liquid when Quora started afaik, but also even smart wealthy people take loans and get VC.
- minimaxir 8y ago> The top earning partner has earned $26,897 and asked over 8,000 questions, averaging about 45 questions per day That average metric is more suspicious than an indicator of scale/impact.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- bilal4hmed 8y agoIm so glad I deleted my account on that site
- manigandham 8y ago$27k for 8000 questions, that's basically admitting they paid for spam. I don't see how this is a good product decision at all and the content quality has declined severely. Meanwhile being a Top Writer has done nothing for me other than getting the opportunity to buy quora branded swag from their store. Saying that this system is imbalanced and unfair seems to be an understatement.
- nikkwong 8y agoThe mind blowing fact is that they're advertising this metric as if it's a stat to be proud of. I think the average person browsing the internet would see this and instantly question the site's credibility. I would maybe understand this statistic being shared internally or in an email to partners--but published publicly on the internet? They're just looking to invite criticism and a loss of trust.
- fourthark 8y agoOr they just want more people in the partner program and don't care about their reputation.
- daveFNbuck 8y agoThey linked me to a similar document when I was asked to join the partner program. It's not a very encouraging stat.
- Havoc 8y agoWhat happened to Quora anyway? When it started I recall it being super hot with crazy high quality answers. Then they started with logins being required and it all seemed to go downhill at an amazing speed.
- smithesh 8y agoOne thing that has happened is that Quora is now dominated by users from India. That has resulted in much content that is not as relevant to audiences in the US. One would think that an answer is an answer but it turns out it’s not like that, there is a cultural element and something that works in one country doesn’t work in all others.
- brynjolf 8y agoYou know like Americans talk on the internet? Where you guys just presume everyone is from your state or even city.
- manigandham 8y agoVC demands for growth. It could've remained an independent high-quality site since it really doesn't take much to run, but raising $226 million requires a return. Since they've chosen the advertising model, that means increasing views at all costs to create the inventory to sell those ads. Unfortunately but inevitable.
- halfjew22 8y agoCompletely agree here and this is just more evidence that advertising NECESSARILY depletes the quality of the online experience. This is the last time I'm going to spam this post, but I'm very excited about my new website knophy.com and believe it solves all these problems. It's open source, going to economically and behaviorally incentivize competence and evidence backed content, and is going to always be free of ads and paywalls. I'll be announcing more details here shortly. Here's a copy and paste from a different comment with some more details: -- BEGIN COPY PASTE -- Gonna copy and paste this below, but it's very exciting to see your feedback on Quora. I'm working on a prototype for my website, knophy.com, that is going to revolve completely around promoting those with competency. On the Internet, there is too much value and emphasis on QUICK bangs of interest, while the real value can lie much more comfortably in long for interaction, much like a conversation in person. I'm not going to give too many details now, but I look forward to hopefully having you guys give the prototype a trial once it's ready. I estimate that will be in about 3 - 4 weeks. knophy.com is currently live, but it's really just there because I'm developing all of this out in the open. I'm also working on radically changing how we think about business structures and actually incorporating the idea of demonstrated competencies into how the board is going to function. If you'd like to check out the repo, it's here: http://github.com/technoplato/knophy http://github.com/technoplato/knophy
- RickJWagner 8y agoQuora is a little addictive. I get an email daily with several questions (and links to the answers.) Some I like, some I don't. But it is interesting to read.
- anonytrary 8y agoI used to enjoy getting Quora digests. I remember seeing famous people and even some of my professors using Quora. Jimmy "your premise is flawed" Wales was famous on Quora for his shutdowns. The site slowly started turning into a platform for marketers to pump their self-help/motivational channels.
- the_other_guy 8y agoPathetic. You rarely see an authentic answer in Quora these days. It's all self-promotion, direct and indirect advertising, fake wisdom and "life hacks".
- atomical 8y agoI agree with you. Many of the popular writers seem interested in internet points. Many of the answers have the same storytime format. The writer takes us back in time, introduces a concept that on first inspection seems wrong, and eventually gives us an example of why it is correct by using an example of someone else's misfortune. It gets old fast.
- diN0bot 8y agocontent quality aside, at least this makes users customers. why shouldn't folks creating content on sites like this be part of the profit sharing?
- manigandham 8y agoThe only valuable content are the answers, some that have taken hours to write and kept up to date by passionate folks who are willing to share their expertise and knowledge. They don't pay for answers though, and this is making writers turn into unpaid workers generating money for spammers who just post questions all day. Many writers I know have stopped because there is no upside.
- vasilipupkin 8y agoI wish someone would make a for profit site that is a mashup of hacker news, quora and twitter and paid people for posting content, specifically for upvotes. I would invest in this personally
- manigandham 8y agoI think paying for content is the problem because it skews everything, unless there is very tight control over submissions.
- vasilipupkin 8y agoWhy ? What’s the difference between paying for upvotes in dopamine hits or money ?
- manigandham 8y agoBecause people will do anything for even trivial amounts of money while upvotes are controlled by users which is self-correcting when the community and controls are well managed.
- danso 8y agoI'd be interested in knowing the thought process/analytics that inspired the idea to pay for questions, and not (highly-upvoted) answers? My main reason for joining Quora was that it seemed to be the social network that Dave Baggett [0] (at the time) was actively using. [0] https://www.quora.com/profile/Dave-Baggett https://www.quora.com/profile/Dave-Baggett
- wetpaws 8y agoAt some point Quora become so metric driven, so focused at maintaining their growth and retention and hell knows what, that it turned into a very user unfriendly place, akin to Yelp. No, I don't need to login. No, I don't need 50 more notifications and an email digest, no, I don't need to install the damnt app.
- p1esk 8y agoI quit Quora after they deleted my account by mistake - in the process of merging my two accounts with different emails, they managed to delete both - and then said "sorry, we screwed up, but unfortunately we can't undo it". All my answers were gone. I put many hours into writing those answers and I still don't understand the policy of automatically deleting all content when the account is deleted.
- Aeolun 8y agoThat policy is actually good. If someone goes through the trouble to delete their account it makes sense that they’d want their content gone too (privacy).
- p1esk 8y agoNo it does not. When you decide to delete your account it should be up to you if you also want your content deleted. The company should not make that choice for you one way or another.
- tinyhouse 8y agoA few years ago I thought Quora was the biggest threat to Google. There were many questions I would go straight to Quora to find answers. I was wrong.
- codinghorror 8y agoyou and many, many other venture capitalists
- dec0dedab0de 8y agoIm still wondering why Quora is allowed in google results. They're like the new expertsexchange. Plus it completely baffles me that anyone would use it for a topic that has a stack exchange.
- GCA10 8y agoOlder Quora has excellent answers on NASA topics (thanks Robert Frost) and linguistics and police procedure, as well as many other niche topics. Google is right to recognize these standouts. Not sure about the rest.
- theossuary 8y agoMore than anything I want a search engine I can blacklist domains in.
- abraae 8y agoYep, and a quick way to search with/without blacklisted sites included. I'd pay for that.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- SparkleBunny 8y agohttps://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/personal-blocklist/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/personal-bloc... For me, it's "Pinterest, what's that?"
- grecy 8y agoJust putting "-quora.com" (no quotes) on the end of a search seems to do it just fine.. you could have a long list of them you copy/paste in every time, or I imagine you could write a grease monkey script to do it for you automatically every time you click "search"
- 8y ago
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- arduinomancer 8y agoTwo comments: 1) Why wouldn’t the people answering the questions get that money? Aren’t they the ones adding value to the site? 2) I’ve noticed a ton of spam answers recently where the answer is just a link to another site, didn’t used to happen like 2 years ago
- julienreszka 8y agoTurns out good questions are sometimes more valuable than good answers
- rurban 8y agoBut in fact the quality of the new questions go down, while the quality of answers is still better than elsewhere. For sure good answers are more valuable than good questions.
- julienreszka 8y agoWhat do you mean
- jiveturkey 8y agopeople like to demonstrate their expertise, and/or be helpful to others. the answers are going to come regardless. asking questions can be done anywhere. the point of paying is to attract them to quora vs the competition.
- outsidetheparty 8y ago> The top earning partner has earned $26,897 and asked over 8,000 questions, averaging about 45 questions per day > The top 10 earning partners earned an average of $9,189 and asked 11,256 questions each, averaging 61 questions per day This explains quite a bit about the quality of the content on that site....
- perlgeek 8y agoThat's $0.82 per question for the top 10 earning partners, in case somebody is too lazy to do the math :) And yes, advertising this fact seems misguided to me.
- ada1981 8y agoI just got invited to the partner program. I opted in but didn’t pay much attention. What is the best way to maximize the revenue / opportunity here?
- yumario 8y agoWith Quora I learned how real filter bubbles are. During the 2016 elections I used to click on a lot of anti-trump questions. The site painted me a picture that trump was a "joke" and that he no one seriously believe he had a "chance". I was genuinely chock he started winning the primaries.. and then the elections. Looking back I still can't believe that I was so out of touch with reality. I haven't use Quora since them. Nowadays I actively try to ignore Quora when it shows up in search result. But when don't the answers are often short and wrong, or blatant self promotion.
- codezero 8y agoFor what it's worth, despite the very strong liberal bias on Quora, (I worked for Quora 2012-2014), they tried very hard to reduce bias from their feed algorithms and tried to remain very neutral in rankings and distribution. I think there was a conservative chilling effect that went above and beyond what they could have done to help.
- Proven 8y agoJFC.... Awful idea. What is this, early 2000? Does StackOverflow and those guys pay anything? IIRC you don't even get paid to answer. Quora's investors' money is goin' down the toilet. Haha, paying for questions: the dumbest idea I've heard in 2018!
- faitswulff 8y agoAside, but I get all my Q&A jollies from https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/ https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/ these days. The moderation is unparalleled and the questions as well as the answers are interesting. There will be unanswered questions, which is frustrating, but the quality remains high.
- NoblePublius 8y agoStill No API, right? So no care.
- vishnu_ks 8y agoReminds me of the site Mahalo.com which used to pay users for posting answers. Anyone heard of them lately?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- SergeAx 8y agoIf we look at Quora as a marketplace connecting users in need of information and experts, then paying for questions means oversupply of experts. This is a bad sign: if a lot of people are ready to work for free, there is another incentive behind. I believe it is either marketing or vain. If so, it seems irrational to me to seek any kind of information anything on Quora.
- sigi45 8y agoNo one thinks that's unethical?
- techsin101 8y agoWhen you ask question you get zero answers and it get flagged as "badly worded"? And when you search a question you get 50 questions asking the same thing and each has 90 answers each but most are complete bs, or spam or like 20 people saying the same thing or copy paste from top Google search results.... You can't scroll long enough.. Also 20 paragraph stories from Indian person.