5 ms·
What does the above problem have to do with the pigeon hole principle? I’m all for CS foundations, I learned the pigeon hole principle as an undergrad, I never
by seanmcdirmid 8y ago
What does the above problem have to do with the pigeon hole principle? I’m all for CS foundations, I learned the pigeon hole principle as an undergrad, I never used it (in work or during my phd) and have since forgotten it, but I’m glad I did that. But the above problem....just feels like a Googly interview question, whether it is just diff or not.
What really gets me riled up is that these companies don’t care about my specialty or actual experience at all during the interview even if this is why they want to hire me at all in the first place. Nope, it’s all brain teaser coding questions that have nothing to do with what they would actually want me to do if hired. I get why they do it (one size fit all interview process), but I don’t think it is at all better.
There are now whole undergrad courses at universities like Stanford devoted to gaming the interview process at google and Facebook and other big techs. I don't think this is desirable or sustainable.
- nradov 8y agoThis seems related to Goodhart's law: "When a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure." If the hiring process for some tech companies has become so dysfunctional that they actually consider brain teaser coding questions to be meaningful then we should expect that competitors with more results oriented hiring processes will eventually beat them in the market.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoPerhaps the tenacity and work ethic needed to study a couple of months for an interview selects for people who would do the job well anyways? Maybe that is what it means to be Googly as a culture fit? Anyways, practicing solving clever small programming problems at least isn’t boring (though I’m beginning to burn out on it), it reminds me of prepping for a high school or ACM programming contest. As long as it eliminates enough false positives, they’ll keep up with it. It isn’t just if you can solve these problems, but can you also write straight lines of text on a white board? Also, do it while talking and and standing on one foot at the same time.
- SmirkingRevenge 8y agoI love to hate on these interview practices, but I have to admit, the brain teaser problems have actually improved my programming, I think.
- Apocryphon 8y ago> As long as it eliminates enough false positives, they’ll keep up with it. So Google is relying on a brute force approach to hiring?
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoYa, but everyone is. Too many fakers in this industry.
- raverbashing 8y agoAnd too many people that can't be bothered to think of easy ways of filtering them without something stupid like fizzbuzz Who's the faker again?
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoIf you have a better way, propose a startup, you’ll make bank.
- TeMPOraL 8y ago> work ethic I sometimes wish people explain what they mean by that, because I'm confused by the phrase. I assume it's some Americanism that has a broad range of meanings. Cramming trivia for interviews doesn't sound like the "work ethics" I see when I google the term, but then again, I recently had a German student explain to me that they understand hard (but dumb) work as what this phrase means.
- mkohlmyr 8y agoI agree it can be hard to put your finger exactly on what it is. My best sense of it is that it is something approximating your ability to follow through on some task that a) was never, or has seized to be interesting or otherwise stimulating or b) is sufficiently difficult that many people would allow themselves to quit. Often related to the idea that there is some form of delayed gratification to be had.
- anonymous_fun 8y agofangs a vs g approach