7 ms·
New York's Low Apartment Turnover Hinders Affordability
- PLenz 8y agoMy family has had the same apartment in Queens since 1916. It'll go to my brother at some point in the future. An outlier for sure but plenty of the people I grew up with were in multi generational apartments and expected to be the next generation to take it over.
- koolba 8y agoHow much is the rent/size vs a market rate?
- asnyder 8y agoI can answer this based on my parents example. They've lived in the same building since I was born and the same now rent-stabilized (previously rent-controlled) apartment in Brooklyn for the last 26 or so years. They live in a 3 large bedroom, one gigantic living room, kitchen, dining area and front lobby. Over the years the rent has increased to the now $1050.00, if however they were to move out (not passing the apartment to any children) it's likely that apartment would rent for around $3000+ considering the neighborhood and area.
- alistairSH 8y agoWow. That's less than half the rate for a 500sqft one-bed in a nice part of DC. I hadn't realize the stabilized rent units were so out of whack with the market.
- busterarm 8y agoWhat mechanism brought your rent-controlled apartment to rent-stabilized? We've been a rent-controlled 1br apartment since 1969 (lucky...) and the rent is around $1500. Also that rent-stabilized apartment doesn't go to market rate just because they move out. Depending on how much of the building is rent stabilized, it would likely stay rent-stabilized until the rent threshold crossed ~$2700. A rent-controlled apartment would become rent-stabilized.
- timr 8y agoIt doesn't hinder affordability for the people living in the apartment. Do they not count? It's pretty sad that the HN thought police have downvoted this into the dirt. Why don't you try answering the question, instead?
- rdlecler1 8y agoA large portion of the market is paying way below market rates. In some cases it’s ridiculously affordable. Supply constrictions inflate the affordability of everything else.
- dajohnson89 8y agoThe term "ridiculously affordable" is really a rich one. Anyways I think you're implying that removing rent stabilization would have a net downward pressure on prices. While that may be true and it seems reasonable, I'd like to see some data to back that up. You do realize that a major reason rent stabilization exists is to protect people from being evicted out of their homes as the price of the surrounding area increases, right?
- dajohnson89 8y agoPeople want an easy scapegoat. Either that, or jealousy.
- hnaccy 8y agoDoes this also apply to criticism of income inequality?
- wan23 8y agoIt does hinder affordability for the people living in the apartment as well. It makes it look unreasonably expensive to move to anywhere else and incentivizes them to stay put, even if their heat doesn't work or if they are too old for their fifth floor walkup or any of the other reasons people move.
- 8y ago
- Aloha 8y agoThis is the nasty side effect of rent stabilization/control. If you're outside the system, you're kinda screwed.
- canadianwriter 8y agoWhich wouldn't be as much of an issue if their were a lot more rental units being built each year - we have the same problem here in Toronto - changing zoning laws to allow taller purpose built rental buildings would massively help but NIMBY's don't want to lose their view!
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- andrewla 8y agoI'm not sure this is an accurate summary of the situation in NYC. There are large amount of units being built in new high rise buildings throughout the city. Projects like Hudson yards in Manhattan are notable; and in downtown Brooklyn new high rise apartment buildings are constantly opening up, not to mention large amounts of development in Williamsburg and the surrounding areas, and even down in Sheepshead Bay. My understanding is that Long Island City is also seeing an explosion of new highrises, but these others I've seen with my own eyes. Notably almost none of these units are "affordable", except a certain number of lottery-dispensed rent stabilized units that the buildings allocate in exchange for certain tax abatements. Even so, growth continues to outstrip housing supply, but with the exception of certain historic preservation areas, developers are putting up units as fast as they can. Real estate is still expensive, and developers can't get the land to build on for free, or force people to sell in the face of skyrocketing housing prices.
- Kalium 8y agoNobody should ever use words like "large" in reference to housing construction where absolute numbers are meaningless. "Large" and "small" are useless without some agreed-upon baseline. What you're describing is a city where a large-in-absolute-numbers-by-some-arbitrary-standard amount of housing is being built while also not being enough. As sufficiency for demand is the operative question, I submit that a better set of words is "sufficient" and "insufficient". Given that it's less than the amount of population growth, I would characterize it as an insufficient amount of housing supply being built.
- troxwalt 8y agoIs it a case of chicken vs egg? Is it unaffordable for others because tenants do not move out of their affordable housing? Or is it unaffordable for others because tenants can't afford to move out of their affordable housing?
- stuxnet79 8y agoArtificially set prices make the market more inefficient. The reality is that a lot of people want to live in NYC and there just isn't enough supply of housing for it be "affordable". By setting the price of a rental apartment too low in a hot real estate market like NYC, you are incentivizing people who would otherwise move out of the city or seek more efficient living arrangements (smaller apartment, rent a room) to stay put. Rent control constricts the supply in two ways: 1) It makes prices that much higher for units that aren't rent controlled and whose prices are set by the market. If the rent for these rent control units was allowed to fluctuate based on the market, the turnover would be higher and there would be more apartments available in total. 2) It incentivizes less units being put on the market because (a) A potential landlord (e.g. someone who wants to rent a room out in their 2 bedroom apartment or an owner of a townhome / brownstone who wants to rent their basement out) won't be able to make a profit or maintain their unit at the artificially low price set by regulation. (b) Real estate developers also won't want to build new apartments / condos if they know that they won't be able to get their money back by renting (because the govt is forcing them to rent at a super low price).
- busterarm 8y agoa) "Rent-controlled" apartments account for less than 24,000 units across all of NYC. b) "Rent-stabilized" apartments account for a significantly larger percentage but the majority of stabilized apartments in the more desirable areas (all of Manhattan, Astoria/LIC, Sunnyside, close parts of Brooklyn) are within 20% distance of market rate and lose their classification once they cross ~$2700/mo. c) On the whole, owners of buildings renting to rent-stabilized tenants are not losing money and can afford to make capital improvements (which increase rents) and hire management companies just like with any other building.
- njn 8y agoAn interesting article, but I don't agree with the author's conclusion that rent control is worse than the California-style alternative. Is San Francisco currently better off than New York? No rent control there, and prices are even higher than NYC. I wouldn't find my 1br NYC apt for $1500 in SF. Maybe 6 years ago, but not now. Rent stabilization alone isn't a solution the housing affordability, and maybe there's more to it than meets the eye. But New York's solution shouldn't just be to get rid of it. What model city would they be following? Rather, changes in zoning laws could be really great, following Tokyo's model. The author hints at this. https://www.vox.com/2016/8/8/12390048/san-francisco-housing-costs-tokyo https://www.vox.com/2016/8/8/12390048/san-francisco-housing-...
- kettlecorn 8y agoSan Francisco does have rent control: https://www.sftu.org/rentcontrol/ https://www.sftu.org/rentcontrol/
- jordonwii 8y ago> An interesting article, but I don't agree with the author's conclusion that rent control is worse than the California-style alternative. Is San Francisco currently better off than New York? No rent control there, and prices are even higher than NYC. We have rent control on units occupied before Costa-Hawkins went into effect (1995 I believe). SF builds very very few units per year, so this covers a very high percentage of the units in the city.
- bsimpson 8y agoIt also depends on the ownership model of the property. If the landlord only owns a single unit (e.g. an individual condo in a building, or a single-family home), the financial aspect of rent control doesn't apply.
- bsimpson 8y agoFWIW, I was paying $1900 for a studio in SF in 2010. You've got to go back quite a bit farther than 6 years for $1500 to be a typical price for a decent 1 bedroom.
- CodeSheikh 8y agoUnlike San Francisco, New Yorker cannot lock in to a rent when they first moved in. I wonder if this is something New Yorkers could have benefited from or adding to the problem that the article has pointed out.
- dwighttk 8y agoWouldn't that lower turnover even more? Is San Francisco known for its affordable rent?
- Apocryphon 8y agoSo how are Amazon and Google going to deal with this with their corporate expansions?
- megaman8 8y agoIt's not their problem because way too many people want to work for those companies.
- omegaworks 8y ago>Stable communities and households with deep roots in communities are, in many ways, desirable. One sentence ascribed to the intangible quality of life benefits of a stable community. A single sentence, with not even an attempt to quantify the positive effects of stability on living standards, even life expectancy. https://nypost.com/2017/06/04/new-yorkers-are-living-longer-happier-and-healthier-lives/ https://nypost.com/2017/06/04/new-yorkers-are-living-longer-...
- jlarocco 8y agoI'm surprised rent control doesn't take into account a person's dependents. It's not fair for an "empty nester" to keep living in a large apartment when their dependents leave, though I guess evicting them doesn't seem right either. That said, I'm not convinced there's such a big connection between churn and affordability. Moving is really inconvenient, and there are a lot of good reasons to stay put.
- a_c_s 8y agoAgreed: if we supplemented & replaced some aspects of rent control with mechanisms like long leases (eg. 5 year lease with only inflationary price increases) and long notification periods for lease renewal denial (eg. 1 year notice that your lease won't be renewed for the next year) would allow for physical & financial stability without locking apartments up semi-permanently.
- gdgtfiend 8y agoHoward Husock, who wrote this article, is a VP for policy research at the Manhattan Institute. The Manhattan Institute is a conservative think tank with an agenda, so please take this column with a grain of salt. Howard stated his opinion but did not provide any evidence that reducing rent stabilization in New York would effect housing prices positively. Please keep this context in mind while reading this article, and stay informed.
- helen___keller 8y agoOn one hand, it's kind of the point of rent control/stabilization that it's supposed to protect residents (particularly ones that aren't rich) from the risks of major changes in the overall market (like rent increases far outpacing inflation / wages). Cities exist to serve their citizens, after all, and citizens at risk of being displaced are part of this population. When you see people paying a third the market rate on rent, that's the system working as intended by any measure. On the other hand, there are obvious inefficiencies in the system (like empty nesters holding onto units larger than what they need because they can't afford to lose them). Regardless of issues with New York's rent controlled housing, there's a wider national issue that there's an undeniable trend towards migration to a few top "innovation hubs", and these hubs are all simultaneously failing to urbanize as needed to satisfy the demand. What this country needs are federal subsidies and incentives to encourage/assist top hubs in developing good urbanism (which notably supports lower income people as well as just the wealthy). What is good urbanism you ask? 1. Density to support affordable commercial activity in or near hubs of existing commercial activity (ie, building skyscrapers downtown, most cities have this one down) 2. Expansion of transit that goes to said commercial hubs, particularly any transit that does not compete in traffic with private motor vehicles (subways, light rail, BRT, commuter trains, etc). The goal is to maximize the amount of land that can viably and reliably commute to the commercial hub within 1 hour without use of a private motor vehicle. 3. Densification of all land that can viably commute to the commercial hub within 1 hour. In particular, any neighborhood covered by the transit mentioned in (2) should (by some mechanism) be allowed to increase in density naturally in accordance to supply and demand (You can't let existing homeowners veto that new apartment building just because it's ugly). These three rules were pretty much common sense prior to the spread of the private motor vehicle, but with cars we kind of just decided you can commute from anywhere now so it's a free for all. Hence the dispersal in our housing patterns this past half a century. Problem is, the free market has shown that top 21st century companies have no interest in placing well-paying jobs dispersed throughout many cities and many suburbs, but rather concentrated in a small number of innovation hubs, so we need to adapt our housing patterns accordingly.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> These three rules were pretty much common sense prior to the spread of the private motor vehicle And late 19th and early 20th century urban utopias were the result? There are certainly problems with car culture (especially environmental impacts), but the idea that pre-car common patterns of urbanization were “good urbanism” is something which needs some support.
- busterarm 8y agoYet another post on HN about NYC rent-control. Just sit back while HNers make wild unsubstantiated claims about everyone paying 1/3 the market rate for apartments and how they're they primary reason why rent is so high in NYC. I'll make the popcorn.
- parrot_11 8y agoWhat I've seen in many big cities happening with regularity: 1. City has a good mojo, not too big, not too small. 2. Not too unequal neighborhoods. 3. #1 and #2 attract startups, big companies. 4. Rents rise in the city. 5. Slowly there will be calls to increase housing density. 6. More houses get built, housing density increases, rents go down by $100-$200/month for maybe 1-2 years. 7. Rents bounce back in about 1-2 years and then continue on. 8. Calls to increase density further, eventually the city loses its desirable properties and poor people are still relatvely just as worse off as they were before. 9. The rich tech worker is still in the same position, relatively. Important thing being, even after doing all these things, the median poor person in the name of which all this densification happened is still stuck in the same relative bad standing as he/she was before, only difference being the city lost its charm in the process as well. Obviously, this doesn't apply in the case of NYC since it's been a big city for a long long time but the above story is worth keeping in mind for small cities in many states. It might be a better idea to have companies distributed more uniformly than pushing for high densification of few cities. It spreads economic benefits around as well.