12 ms·
I find this development very sad. For a short number of years it looked like the Internet would enable me to legally watch any movie I want whenever I want it.
by adrianN 8y ago
I find this development very sad. For a short number of years it looked like the Internet would enable me to legally watch any movie I want whenever I want it. But Hollywood did not want it that way. Instead streaming services are slowly but surely becoming just another TV station. Everything is siloed again and unless I want to pay ten bucks a month per movie studio I'm again left choosing between movies I don't really want to see. Not long now and it'll become strictly worse than renting DVDs in all dimensions but the small inconvenience of having to go to a physical store.
- nradov 8y agoThe majority of movies from all major studios are available for rent on Apple iTunes and Google Play.
- fipple 8y agoAnd Amazon Video.
- chrisper 8y agoThis assumes you are in a region Hollywood approves of. And even then often not all languages are available. Some movies even become available much later than in the US for example. So far piracy is still more convenient and accessible even if I am willing to pay for movies and TV shows. Good thing it's legal in my country.
- Semaphor 8y agoI remember spending 2 hours trying to buy a new TV show in Germany but in English (so on Amazon.com and not .de). VPN, fake US address, virtual gift card sent from one account to another. Nothing worked. In the end, I pirated the show.
- chrisper 8y agoYes. That's exactly my issue. Often they also only have English in Stereo.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoLocalization issues are one of those things that cross the border of insanity. Yes, dear distributors, I understand that you want to make moniez by translating movies to local languages. But in every country, a good chunk of population can speak English, and many of us actually prefer to watch in English. That chunk of population usually also has money to spare, so why won't you let us pay you and watch the original material?
- Zekio 8y agoBaked in subtitles that you can't turn off, drives me damn near insane.
- MRD85 8y agoIt hasn't been an issue for me in the past couple of years but I recall, in the not-to-distant past, that I often had to pirate things that were unavailable to me. I'd attempt legal ways of purchasing but they would fail and I would have to resort to piracy. I feel that content creators have become a whole lot better at making content available than they were 5 years ago.
- Semaphor 8y agoRegarding buying, "The Gifted" is not available at Amazon.de but is at Amazon.com. And that's without the problem of often not available English subtitles even when English audio is available. On Netflix Germany (the only Netflix I can get since they banned VPNs) I can't watch most animes in Japanese with English subtitles. On Prime Video from Amazon.de, they often don't bother to even license the OV audio at all.
- IronBacon 8y agoThe Netflix web player can use external subtitles provided by the user, on the other hand, if you aren't using the right combination of browser and platform, you are restricted to 720p. So, yeah, not really a solution...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- BurningFrog 8y ago> Everything is siloed again Jeez. Extrapolate much? A few things are siloed. Almost everything is available at both Apple and Amazon.
- chime 8y agoCBS content is on CBS Access only. Disney is moving their content out of Netflix as they launch Disney+. HBO original content is only HBO only. Same with original content from Amazon, Netflix, and even YouTube Red. There is a lot of content out there now for almost every demographic on each of these platforms so finding something to watch is rarely a problem. But that doesn’t mean silos aren’t real. Hollywood movies are available on any rental service. But not all good movies are made/produced by the big studios now. So they remain unavailable unless you subscribe.
- oblio 8y agoSome of these streaming services will fail.
- threeseed 8y agoNetflix, Amazon and Apple are producing unique content which will ONLY be available on their respective platforms. Go look at the TV space where you can only watch Stranger Things, Black Mirror, 13 Reasons Why etc on Netflix. And they are talking about extending this to movies. Seems pretty reasonable to me to be alarmist.
- drb91 8y agoFor now, at expense. The only major pain I have from the iTunes library is no Miyazaki. Unfortunately they are also licensed by Disney in the US so I’d not expect Ghibli works to ever show up. Personally I’ve found the netflix mail service to be the best for scratching the itch of arbitrary movies, if you can be patient. EDIT: also, TV shows are clearly siloed, but I was under the impression you were referring to movie rentals.
- BurningFrog 8y ago
- empath75 8y agoSo instead of watching thousands of movies for free you can watch thousands of movies for 20 or 30 dollars a month.
- bad_user 8y agoI think that viewpoint many of us had about the Internet was naive and it doesn’t take much to realize why. In order for commercial content to be produced, consumers have to pay money somehow. TV stations preferred an ads model. When you pay money as a consumer, you pay to a commercial entity. Therefore a single fee you’d pay for watching all the content you want has to go to a monopoly. Whether that’s a state agency that handles the collection and distribution, or whether it’s a natural monopoly that destroyed its competition, it really is the same thing. That we’ve got “silos” can only mean that we still have competition in this space. I would be more afraid of a future where there’s only one commercial entity left. Which sounds good in the same way that communism sounds good.
- r_c_a_d 8y agoIt doesn't have to be that way. You could have multiple providers like Netflix and traditional TV stations competing on quality of delivery, whilst licensing content from each other. Exclusives are by definition anti-competitive. Some sort of compulsory licensing might work. Or it might lead to no-one producing anything...
- bad_user 8y agoThere's not much to compete on. I don't see a difference between Netflix and HBO GO in terms of the actual distribution ... HBO GO's app and website are shittier, but that's irrelevant as long as it lets me watch their shows in HD. And I disagree that exclusives are anti-competitive. If Netflix can create value using its own money, they should be allowed to establish whatever licensing terms they want, including none other than streaming to its own subscribers. If that's anti-competitive, then the definition is broken.
- r_c_a_d 8y agoThere is a lot to compete on. Recommendations and reviews for example, customer service, price, outages, video quality. The problem is that those things are harder to build a marketing campaing on than "We are the only channel that has Game of Thrones". Exclusives serve only the producer. They are terrible for consumers, as the orignal commenter lamented. Perhaps "anti-competeitive" is the wrong word, since each channel can compete at having the best exclusives ... probably "anti-consumer" is what I meant.
- TulliusCicero 8y agoIf you're only paying $10-12/month per service, this was inevitable. There's no way you could fund all the TV and movies that people want with a small fraction of what people used to pay for cable/satellite TV.
- foolfoolz 8y agoYou’re really discounting how good things have gotten. Movies today are $12/movie. Netflix is selling you any movie for ~$10/month. Not just crap movies, Cuaron! If you’re not watching a movie alone, it’s a better deal. Cable would cost you $75-$100/month. Now that service included with your movies. You could buy 5 of these services and it would still be cheaper than it cost you 15 years ago to see similar content. Most people only buy 1 and share accounts with their friends. Renting movies is easier than ever and still a great option. You don’t even have to leave your house. Previously you would drive to the rental shop and pay $4. Or waited in line at redbox and pay $1. It’s true that you can’t always rent, a lot of times ive tried it’s for purchase only. The silo doesn’t make sense though when you compare to the price of buying movie tickets, or the cost of cable TV, or even the cost of renting. It’s way cheaper today than it used to be.
- nikofeyn 8y ago> Netflix is selling you any movie for ~$10/month. are you talking about their streaming options or dvd mail service? their streaming service has very limited options for good movies. and the good ones are ones i have usually already seen (and yet netflix's machine learning "experts" constantly recommend them to me, i.e., they have nothing else to offer or they aren't experts). netflix is pushing their own content more and more, which i personally find not good. they also tend to oversell their role in production. it's gotten to the point where i watch maybe a couple of good things on netflix a month, and so the price no longer makes sense. i'm personally thinking of going back to their dvd mail service or just canceling it all together. many of these services are now not worth the $10-15 a month. for example, for hbo go or now, or whichever is the streaming only option, i just pay when i am ready to watch some tv series for a month or two and then cancel it. it's akin to renting. it isn't worth it to pay year round, although i would say their movie options for streaming are probably better than netflix's, they're just less in number.
- foolfoolz 8y agoyour hbo story is really good. i think a lot of services fall in that category of “only when i want it”. which is exactly the shift from old world cable. just the fact that you have the option to do that with hbo go, all for less than $50 and without a single phone call, is incredibly improved over 10 years ago
- conanthe 8y agoThis is amazing. TV is a second best thief of time. You should be happy you have time to do other stuff.
- mac01021 8y agoWhat's the first best?
- lotsofpulp 8y agoFor me, online forums.
- AzMoo_ 8y agoChildren.
- majewsky 8y agoMinecraft.
- DrBazza 8y agoI hoped the same - it was unfortunate that bandwidth lagged CPU speed, otherwise a video Napster if it had existed and rampant mp4 piracy would have forced the movie industry down the same route as music: one or two major services with everything on it. Instead we have Amazon Prime, Netflix, Hulu, BBC iPlayer, the coming Disney service, and so on.
- Mindwipe 8y agoIt wouldn't. Music was always collectively licensed, for decades, in order to provide radio. The industry developed around that model as half it's income. That was never the case for TV, and never will be.
- harryh 8y agoThe differences between how music and movies are paid for is not driven by bandwidth, but by the fact that an average movie is 2 hours long and an average song is 4 minutes long. Taking 2 minutes to switch from Netflix to Amazon to watch a 2 hour movie is no big deal. Taking 2 minutes to switch from Apple Music to Spotify to listen to a 4 minute song completely recks the experience.
- shrimpx 8y agoWhat do you think about Amazon? They have a large collection of movies to rent. In that sense it's like the classic rental store. (I concur that the internet hasn't done much to upgrade business models in a way that favor consumers more, besides adding digital delivery.)
- paxys 8y agoDid you honestly think you would get all content ever created, old and new, for $10/month without ads for the rest of your life?
- adrianN 8y agoRenting DVDs costs about one or two Euros per DVD and they have to have physical stores and employees and can only rent a movie to one person at a time. The cost of streaming a movie to a customer is close to zero. I think it's reasonable to expect being able to stream a movie for at most one Euro. I don't watch a movie every day, so ten to twenty Euros a month sounds realistic.
- paxys 8y agoRenting movies or TV episodes for a dollar or two is possible even online. People want a lot more than 10 movies a month though.
- adventured 8y agoYou're only talking about the infrastructure cost in that equation of distribution. The issue is that the movie owners want to be paid for their content availability even if few people watch it. There isn't much Netflix can do about that. You're not just paying for how many movies you watch per month (eg 10), or how much bandwidth you consume, you're paying for access to all of the content Netflix offers. It's a communal distribution of cost across the entire customer base to enable an artificially large library for the masses with all their variety of taste. Why? Because they have to pay all the content owners, or they walk. Those content owners effectively get a little sliver of your monthly fee. If Netflix increases its catalog of movies from external owners by 4x, the sliver gets smaller per movie on average (or they have to raise prices a lot). They'd have to convince content owners to give them most movies for free. Consider the model of monetary distribution based on actual watching of content. If you're a movie library owner, with a catalog of 1,000 mediocre quality studio movies to offer up to a streaming service, are you going to take close to $0 from Netflix based on few people watching the content there, or will you take a lot more from a competitor that needs filler content to take on Netflix? Due to this effect it's impossible to distribute the majority of movies on streaming services based on how often they're actually watched (the demand for them). There will always be some other service willing to bid the bottom quality 3/4 of movies up. If all of their customers globally were actually willing & able to pay ~$22 per month for Netflix streaming, they could probably technically afford to give you access to nearly all movies ever made at today's licensing rates. Hollywood won't comply with that however, not under any circumstances. Netflix can realistically never afford to pay Disney enough to not launch its own competing service.
- lambdadmitry 8y agoThey're just utilizing the rent-enabling framework that was put in place by Hollywood lobbyists (and forced on the rest of the world by US power). In a sense, it's inevitable unless people of US get their shit together and fight copyright laws that are a huge economic drain at this point (from multiple subscriptions because exclusives to DRMs of all sorts to zillions of hours of art removed from YouTube because it "violates copyright"). True, there were a few years when lobbyists were lagging behind, but without political pressure there is nothing preventing them from coming back in force, which they did.
- rayiner 8y ago“All you can eat” movies for $10-20 per month is unrealistic. These movies cost tens of millions to hundreds of millions of dollars to make. I’ve got 3-4 subscriptions for $10 per month or so, and that covers pretty much everything. Occasionally, we’ll rent or purchase something on iTunes, where the prices are completely fair. As an industry development Netflix and Amazon Prime have been great. The problem with Hollywood was not the price, but the fact that it was releasing total crap. The streaming services have created real competition on that front.
- KozmoNau7 8y agoThey should make less expensive movies, than. Hundreds of millions of dollars for less than 2 hours of content is absolutely ridiculous, as are the wages paid to these so-called "celebrities" in them. Big movie business needs to die, and fast.
- rayiner 8y agoPeople want the big, expensive movies with big-name actors. How do we know that? Because that's what they pay for. That's the competitive market at work. With modern technology, digital cameras, digital editing, and digital distribution, you can make movies for a fraction of the price of Hollywood blockbusters. There's no barriers to entry stopping you from distributing your low-budget movies to hundreds of millions of people via Youtube, etc. But nobody wants to watch that indie crap. They want $250 million MCU blockbusters. Indeed, you're seeing the push towards higher production values in TV too. Low-budget weekly shows are being replaced by high-budget "prestige TV." Back in the day, "Lost" was expensive (for a new show with an unknown cast) at $3-4 million per episode. Today, Netflix and Amazon are blowing $50-150 million to pre-shoot an entire season of shows like House of Cards, the Crown, Altered Carbon, etc. And at the end of the day, it's all just entertainment. The market is structured to give people what they want, what's wrong with that?
- yodon 8y agoEntertainment is a hit driven industry where the returns are highly nonlinear and the increase in return (whether measured in viewership, popularity, or dollars) goes up dramatically as you move up the success curve. Audiences have demonstrated without question that they prefer bigger movies (yes, I know, my big fat Greek wedding and Clerks, these are six sigma outliers that are fun to talk about precisely because they are outliers). The people who make films make them (gasp) to make money, because if their films don't make money they can't raise the money to make another one and they want to make more than one. They need to raise money because no one wants to see a film shot on a $6 budget, and no one wants to invest all that time and creative energy in a film no one will want to watch.
- jshaqaw 8y agoThe entire streaming paradigm is a step backwards. Paying ala carts for the content you want would make it much easier for the end customer and enable greater diversity of content. There is no reason for the streaming service middleman when quality content can be independently financed/produced/marketed and then sold point-to-point as in the Apple ITunes model. I am involved with financing and producing independent TV content. The existing distribution model of cable channels and streaming services is nothing but an obstacle. But so long as this is the dominant industry model I have to live with it. Netflix “beat” the iTunes ala carte purchase model the old fashion Silicon Valley way - by subsidizing an unsustainable provision of services with very foriving capital markets. No it was never realistic to fund all the content you wanted to see for $12 a month. Now everyone wants their own streaming service which just means we end up replicating the old bundled cable model. It’s funny that this is happening without the actual technological reasons that original cable model existed in the first place. I do think this (unfortunately) ultimately leads to greater piracy. I don’t see streaming services 6-20 getting a place on the average consumer’s monthly spend.
- rchaud 8y agoBe careful what you wish for. The Internet made it easier for vendors to provide that "anytime, anywhere" service to you. It didn't however give them an an economic incentive to do so. Right now you can still buy a physical DVD/Blu Ray which can be ripped into a digital format of your choice. You still have control. You still only have to pay once. You even have the ability to re-sell it as a used product. That's going to change once studios decide physical media isn't worth it anymore, and so if you want to re-watch something, you need to have a subscription, or need to re-join the service to watch.