10 ms·
Does Australia's access and assistance law impact 1Password?
- danieltillett 8y agoWould an Australian employee of 1Password be forced to lie to us and do something that we would definitely object to? We do not, at this point, know whether it will be necessary or useful to place extra monitoring on people working for 1Password who may be subject to Australian laws. So not only does this idiotic law destroy the Australian software industry, it could prevent Australians from being hired outside Australia. Someone or some group in the Liberal/National Party (the current government here in Australia) really, really, really hates developers. Edit. Time for some Aussie geek civil disobedience I think. Edit 2. We have a huge number of Aussie developers here on HN. Let's use this to organise some sort of protest. Either that or we will all be off to Centrelink.
- berbec 8y agoI can imagine go-banning a country from GitHub repos. This is true insanity on Australia's part. Don't they know any backdoor will undoubtedly be found and spread? People find vine abilities in software designed to be secure. When there is an intentional backdoor, it will be abused even quicker.
- danieltillett 8y agoSeriously our current government is a thick as two planks of wood, but this law is so stupid that it must be deliberate. Maybe whoever wrote this law ex-girlfriend left him for a software developer, because it seems almost perfectly designed to punish developers.
- FuckOffNeemo 8y agoRead up on the article about how it's going to happen. Hide a third party in your group chat as a silent observer that you can't see. Terrifying. Wickr for all comms, here I go.
- Valmar 8y agoAs long as we can still clone and pull anonymously, I'll be half-happy, at least. :)
- ehnto 8y agoI hope they do. I hope the global tech industry ostracises us and our tech industry falls apart, and that the politicians wear every bit if it in some kind of political aftertmath, referendum, vote, protests, I don't care. My worst fear isn't this causing damage, my worst fear is that the tech community will be apathetic and impotent, like they have been all other erosions of privacy so far.
- BigJono 8y agoI'm far more worried that this bill will be forgotten than acted upon. What happens 2 decades down the track when a newly elected government suddenly realises that through 20 years of apathy they've been slowly handed every tool they need to turn themselves into the 4th Reich?
- aplummer 8y agoInsanely it is bipartisan, I think only the greens voted against it.
- danieltillett 8y agoI know :( I love Australia, but I despair at the politicians we elect.
- jay_kyburz 8y agoVote Green and we might see some changes.
- dwd 8y agoProblem is the Greens are unelectable in the lower house because they dilute their message across too many fringe issues that the majority of the public don't care enough about. If they focussed on climate change, renewables, health and education (issues that affect the majority) they would have a better chance of picking up some lower house seats. Otherwise we need a modern day Don Chipp to splinter a group off of either the LNP or ALP and form a new party that can hold key votes in both houses.
- jay_kyburz 8y agoPerhaps, but voting Green next year will send a clear message that we are looking for change.
- lurker72 8y agoWhat sort of change? I agree with the parent that they spread themselves across too many fringe issues. I.e I may vote the greens to help save the environment, but that doesn't mean I care about kids with gender dysphoria.
- icebraining 8y ago
- FuckOffNeemo 8y agoI guess I'm moving back to the UK. No wait, can't do that either. Perhaps I'll live in the US for a while, I haven't lived there yet. Or just become the digital nomad and move off to Budapest like many of my past colleagues and friends. I don't have the emotional depth at this point to articulate a well thought out perspective on what impact these laws will have one me, our industry or my own personal safety in Australia. But I can say for sure, that the entire thing is completely fucked.
- mav3rick 8y agoHow do they like living and working in Budapest ?
- FuckOffNeemo 8y agoThey fucking love it. The work is occasionally sparse, they've expressed it's not some where to raise their family but as couples/single income workers, they wouldn't trade it for the world. Edit: typo, spare=sparse.
- danieltillett 8y agoWell if you are Australian you are fcuked everywhere. What company is going to want to hire a Australian developer who can be pressured into secretly inserting a backdoor into your software?
- shard972 8y agoOr worse, what about Australian companies? I work at a company in Australia that works on systems that will get deployed into locked down enviroments for privacy reasons/laws. Could the Australian government force us to spy on our overseas customers? What about our indirect customers (Customers of Customers)? Can the Aus government strong arm us to spy on these people we in theory could spy on but don't deal with directly. All of this while lying to our clients, legally of course....
- brokenmachine 8y agoYes. But don't you feel safer over Christmas? /s
- jay_kyburz 8y agoMy understanding is that this is the whole point of the five eyes program. It's illegal for the US to spy on its citizens, so they ask Australia to do it and report the findings. According to Wikipedia, Snowden revealed that the five eyes countries "have been spying on one another's citizens and sharing the collected information with each other in order to circumvent restrictive domestic regulations on surveillance of citizens."
- Jerry2 8y agoI can already see it on HN in a few days/weeks from now: Hiring Australians considered harmful
- mirimir 8y agoWell, under the current circumstances, how can it not be? I mean, who pays well enough for employees to risk prosecution and huge fines? The honest ones will just quit. But now that I think of it, does that in itself violate the law, or at least the nondisclosure aspect?
- boyter 8y agoI don’t know if quitting is a valid way out. More likely need to get fired.
- mirimir 8y agoSo what, just be clueless about it, and get caught? This is just so stupid and sad.
- DEADBEEFC0FFEE 8y agoPossible canary quitting. "I'm resigning for patriotic reasons."
- mr_toad 8y agoForcing someone to do a job is slavery. And I’d argue that forcing someone to spy on others, to engage in sabotage, and to lie is a violation of basic human dignity.
- Radle 8y agoBeing a citizen awards you with rights and responsibilities. Whether we think that implementing backdoors is morally right, that does not mean that Australian citizens do not have responsibilities to their country. And neither does it mean that the Australian government cannot force their citizen to fulfill their legal responsibilities. A lawful order by your government is not slavery.
- mickael-kerjean 8y agoCan someone share if there's any protest or event one could participate to maybe change things or at least gain public attention? I'm one of those sole trader based in Sydney extremely worried by this law and very willing to protest
- ajdlinux 8y agoOr, alternatively, maybe it's just not true that you need to do this, because maybe the law doesn't work how most software engineers automatically assume it does, and maybe it doesn't apply based on citizenship... (It's still a really bad law, but for different reasons, and the ridiculous rhetoric from all sides is ridiculous. There's been a few good people like Stilgherrian writing decent commentary.)
- askmike 8y agoThe article states that the law is too vague to know how it will be used: > There is a great deal of vagueness in the law in its current form, and we do not know how it will be interpreted and used when it goes into effect in March. When dealing with security issues, you are dealing with worst case scenarios. If a law can be abused I am happy my password manager has thought about how to best protect me from this scenario. Same as with software vulnerabilities: if 1password detects one that doesn't mean that someone read my passwords, but I expect them to work on it nonetheless for the slight change someone might.
- ajdlinux 8y agoYes, it's a bad law. Yes, in large part that's because it's vague. No, it's not so vague that it's impossible to figure out any limits to the implications for service providers. The worst vagueness is in specific areas (e.g. what does the prohibition on "systemic weaknesses" in mandated technical capabilities actually mean - lots of expert opinion says that the definition of that particular safeguard doesn't actually protect us against very much). The final section of their post discusses a common idea that interception agencies can request individual employees to do things without their employers' knowledge. I'm pretty confident this is bogus, and appears to be based on a misunderstanding of statutory interpretation that some organisations have encouraged (see the thread at https://twitter.com/stilgherrian/status/1072666031963979777 https://twitter.com/stilgherrian/status/1072666031963979777, which includes at least one actual lawyer), and at least one representative of the Australian Government who was involved in drafting the legislation has explicitly denied this (towards the end of the recording at https://www.lawfareblog.com/lawfare-podcast-global-developments-encryption-and-surveillance-law https://www.lawfareblog.com/lawfare-podcast-global-developme..., there may be better and more formal written sources for this). Also, they're wrong about the start date of this legislation - it's already commenced. So, yes, the law is very bad and vague (in parts), and yes, you need to think about worst case scenarios, but that doesn't excuse poor analysis. edit: I should also add that apart from the badness of the law itself, the Government primarily has itself to blame for not communicating with industry and community and allowing wild speculation to go around unchecked - they have really lost control of the narrative here, and that's bad for their own desired outcomes more than anything else.
- lurker72 8y agoIt's not just the liberals at fault here, the labour party also supported this bill. Both sides of the same corrupt coin, beholden to their five eyes masters.
- BigJono 8y agoIs there anything we can do that will have an actual impact? I don't really rate standing in the streets with signs as an effective tactic in this country. Remember only one of the submissions on this bill was in favour of it, the politicians here don't listen to words from the citizens.
- xf86alsa 8y agoAsked a Swedish security firm this exact question the other day. They said they would not hire anyone from Australia anymore, which is a shame.
- Cub3 8y agoAs an Australian front end developer currently sitting in the UK, my plan has always been to go home in 5 or so years. Am now deeply concerned with what the industry will look like in that time, not only are there major bandwidth issues due to the NBN mess but laws like this that carelessly punch holes in security make a bunch of startups non starters onshore.
- gammateam 8y agoFire your Australian employees. This isnt about “Jobs for the sake of Jobs” this is about a secure product. But you already knew that.
- aplummer 8y agoConsider than any employee could be threatened physically and capitulate to a demand, and this is just another, not necessarily greater application of force.
- mirimir 8y agoTrue. But then they go to the police about it. Except that doesn't work for this. Even if you're overseas, I doubt that authorities will come between you and your lawful government. And OK, maybe they would, if it were North Korea, or even China. But Australia? That seems unlikely. Especially with the 5/13/whatever Eyes aspect.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 8y agoAnd in particular: State so clearly, in written form, so that the people you fire have something to show their representatives. Those idiots obviously can't think in hypotheticals, but they might well understand "I got fired because of this law".
- diebeforei485 8y agoOr, help them relocate to another country.
- timClicks 8y agoI feel like this provides almost no assurance. > ... will not introduce back doors into our products, .... Surely 1Password can't actually make that promise in good faith. They're the perfect target for the kind of intervention that the AU gov wants to carry out.
- FuckOffNeemo 8y agoThey could just stop doing business in Australia entirely unless they were then strong armed by the 5 eyes? All my other favourite services in Australia are geo-blocked, let's geo-block my preferred password manager next.
- gumby 8y ago> Would an Australian employee of 1Password be forced to lie to us and do something that we would definitely object to? This law is a disaster for Australia's software industry (sorry Atlassian) but as an Australian living and working outside Australia I can't see that I would be subject to it. Australia is notoriously punitive to Aussies overseas (quite different from, say, India) so it would hardly make sense for such a stupid law to apply to us -- unless the US demanded it I suppose (this whole law is clearly a 5 eyes effort).
- phs318u 8y ago> this whole law is clearly a 5 eyes effort Bingo.
- chc4 8y agoThe fear would be that software engineers who are Australian citizens would want to travel to Australia again to visit family, and then be forced to comply. You can be living and working in the United States, but if you're an Australian citizen traveling with an Australian passport they can simply not allow you to leave unless you implement a backdoor, never mind the fines and jail time.
- pepr 8y agoHow about simply visiting Australia without your corporate laptop? Or take the laptop but without the means to connect to the corporate network/accounts?
- phoe-krk 8y agoVisit Australia, get the notice, go back to wherever you live and work, and either implement the backdoor or get kicked whenever you return to Australia one more time.
- DavidNielsen 8y agoPeople tend to be deeply attached to seeing their family and friends, so the mere hint that the reality of such laws could be purposely weaponizing those emotions is nothing shy of vicious. As a Dane who lives in Brazil I’d be devastated if I had to choose between the ability to see my family once a year or my ideals. It would tear me apart. To not be 100% sure I could go to my parents should one of them fall gravely ill e.g. would be heartbreaking. I mean I love you people and I believe you are entitled to freedom, privacy and security but that is not a choice I’d make lightly. I do not envy Australian developers right now, not only is their marketability severely reduced, the emotional cost of taking a stand can be downright crushing to the spirit. This is just.. evil. There is no other word for it.
- steve19 8y agoHypothetically could they force BitBucket to inject code into repos or binary releases? I know git is signed, but how many consumers (who just download and compile) check the git log in the cloned repo actually match the the website?
- jjcm 8y agoIt's one of the questions we're asking ourselves internally at atlassian. The only upside to the law is it was written without any idea of how modern software development works - any backdoor or explicit code injection should be caught at the pull request stage.
- rorykoehler 8y agoYou have to move your company abroad or risk losing all your customers.
- beokop 8y agoMove the company abroad and fire all their Australian staff, no less.
- justinclift 8y agoThey have Australian founders too. That makes things even more tricky. ;)
- rorykoehler 8y agoProbably time for them to call it quits.
- woolvalley 8y agoWhat happens when the entire Australian staff get the order? Usually to sneak something in, you just need a clique of about 2-5 staff to write it, approve the change and get it deployed. If the company is large enough, most won't notice the rogue commit, and if %90 of the company gets the order, well good luck!
- jedberg 8y agoThis law honestly makes me reluctant to hire anyone in Australia or any AU citizens abroad. Which is a shame, because the ones I know are good developers. I hope the law is negated by another one before it goes into effect. If not, at least it will force everyone to have good software practices such that no one person can put a backdoor into a piece of software.
- brokenmachine 8y agoAs I understand it, the law is already in effect.
- jedberg 8y agoAccording to the article it doesn't go into effect until March of 2019.
- ajdlinux 8y agoMost parts of the Amendment Act have come into effect as of the day after assent (9 December 2018). The fact that they get this wrong is probably a good indication of how much you should trust the rest of their analysis on how this may affect them.
- stephen_g 8y agoThe law is in effect. It passed both houses on December 6th and received royal ascent on December 8th.
- npunt 8y agoFrom what info is available on LinkedIn, it looks like 1Password does not employ anyone in Australia currently: https://www.linkedin.com/company/1password/people/ https://www.linkedin.com/company/1password/people/ However, Agile Bits (parent company) does have a customer service person in Australia: https://www.linkedin.com/company/agilebits-inc/people/ https://www.linkedin.com/company/agilebits-inc/people/ It's weird and depressing to have to do this search. Having a diverse international team should be something we celebrate.
- chopin 8y agoWhat I am missing in the article: Which are the measures taken making it hard to insert backdoors into the product? I've expected a link to their security practices and development process at least. And even then how can I vet this as a customer?
- Niksko 8y agoAlthough concerning and moronic, I'm comforted by the fact that this bill is so fantastically infeasible that I'll never personally have to worry about it as a developer. Any organization where you could be secretly compelled to introduce a back door in such a way that it wouldn't be detected is not a company I will work for.
- danenania 8y agoRealistically, I think there are always people at any organization who could do this—anyone with access to monitoring, alerts, and logs, for example, will be able to make undetected changes. Sure, you can put alerts on your alerts and monitor your monitoring, but you need people to manage that second layer too. And no matter how tightly you restrict access, you’ll need people to manage access control.
- endominus 8y agoAs I understand it, this law also applies to solo developers, so if you create a tool that many people decide to use as an Australian, you might be compelled to betray your users. Not many checks and balances there.
- diebeforei485 8y ago1Password has recently been pushing a subscription model where your passwords are stored on their cloud. It's still end-to-end encrypted across devices, but the Australian (or other) government could be silently added as a "device". For now, they still support storing on Dropbox and iCloud, which is what I use - because I don't want to hand over too many keys to any one company regardless of how trustworthy they are. I hope they continue supporting as many options as possible.
- medecau 8y ago> It's still end-to-end encrypted across devices, but the Australian (or other) government could be silently added as a "device". You can add any amount of "devices" as you want to my account. Hell, go ahead and just copy the db without adding *Agency as a "device". You are still out of luck until you get the Master Key AND my One Password. [XKCD 538](https://www.xkcd.com/538/ https://www.xkcd.com/538/) say's it won't be too hard but still not trivial.
- Svoka 8y agoHonestly, you can post your password vault publicly if you dare. It is random bits useless you can decrypt it with your master password. For quite some time this was one of the way to access your passwords from alternative OS's, with html page doing decrypting.
- bespoken 8y agoThis should not be a discussion about Australia or any government in particular. The discussion should be about the importance of not supporting closed source. I believe in open-source. This just proves once again that closed source cannot be trusted. I would never use 1Password or any of it's variants. It still amazes me that so many people are sending their most precious secrets to a commercial companies' cloud server. I only use Keepass open source password manager, every day for over 9 years now, and I'm really thankful to the devs that build and maintain this nice piece of software.
- justsee 8y agoWhy would moderators intervene on an important, popular discussion like this? https://twitter.com/justsee/status/1072766976194301952 https://twitter.com/justsee/status/1072766976194301952 Calling dang?
- lachdoug 8y ago> Would an Australian employee of 1Password be forced to lie to us Any employee could be forced to lie to you. Section 317C of the Act outlines what sorts of products and services come under its jurisdiction. The primary test is whether you have one or more Australian users. You do not need to be an Australian resident or company to be affected by this law. If you have Australian users, you are subject to the Act. https://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;db=LEGISLATION;id=legislation%2Fbills%2Fr6195_aspassed%2F0001;query=Id%3A%22legislation%2Fbills%2Fr6195_aspassed%2F0000%22 https://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display....
- cesarb 8y ago> Any employee could be forced to lie to you. [...] If you have Australian users, you are subject to the Act. Suppose I am a Brazilian working in Brazil for a Brazilian company with Australian users. What authority would this Act have to prevent me from immediately showing the demand to my boss, the company's legal counsel, my coworkers, or even publishing it on the Internet? Sure, they could forbid me from ever visiting Australia, and perhaps demand my extradition if I ever visit a few other countries, but I don't see what they could do to me in my country. In fact, I could even argue that obeying their demand would be illegal under my country's laws.
- lachdoug 8y agoYou are correct. The practical reality is that the Australian government doesn't have much authority in Brazil. It's more of an issue for people from the other 5 eyes countries. If you are a UK citizen working in the UK, and a UK agency wants access to encrypted data, successful extradition would be more likely. The 5 eyes governments won't rush into this. They will be tactical in establishing a legal precedent. The game plan is to wait for a case where there would be little public sympathy for a developer, perhaps where the developer has committed other crimes too. They will seek extradition then. Once they have done it once, it will be much easier for them to do it again.
- sweetp 8y agoI am happy I recently left Australia, and that my company is incorporated in the states with European servers. I can't imagine the govt would want any data on any users of my software (not that I have any other than what any standard mailing list would have). But this law still gives me pause before thinking about ever moving back... such a shame, as it's a great country. But out of principle, im not sure I could move back knowing that the govt could ask me to spy for them whenever they feel like it.
- zmmmmm 8y agoI'm glad companies like this are speaking up in this way. Politicians need to understand that this is really happening: the destruction of the Australian software industry is now underway. Even if they still think they voted for a perfectly good law, they must understand that perception is everything and the outcome of what they have done is going to have horrific consequences. As an Australian, please help us and speak up like this.
- stock_toaster 8y agoWonder how long until a Fastmail employee is compelled to hack the company. I have really liked Fastmail over the years. What a sucky situation. Any good Fastmail alternatives (not google, outside AUS)?
- newscracker 8y agoThere are quite a few. Posteo.de, Mailbox.org, Mailfence, Runbox.
- praneshp 8y agoI reached out to Fastmail, who referred me to https://fastmail.blog/2018/09/10/access-and-assistance-bill/ https://fastmail.blog/2018/09/10/access-and-assistance-bill/
- mshirlaw 8y agoGuess I’m off to gaol soon because I’m certainly not implementing a software backdoor for the Australian Government. Nor will I approve any pull request that does so. I expect I should do well in prison, definitely got the skills & personality to succeed in there (hint: mild sarcasm).
- heavymark 8y agoWould back doors only be an issue if you use their online site to store and access your logins vs just keeping it local?
- anotherevan 8y ago“Because iocane comes from Australia, as everyone knows, and Australia is entirely peopled with criminals, and criminals are used to having people not trust them, as you are not trusted by me…” — The Princess Bride
- rmbeard 8y agoAn Australian passport is now a liability.
- rmbeard 8y agoPresumably the law also applies not just to devs but to anyone who updates software, e.g. a password protected word file or any file on a password protected system, i.e. all computers/phones, etc. The problematic wording is here, which defines a "provider": the person develops, supplies or updates software used, for use, or likely to be used, in connection with: (a) a listed carriage service; or (b) an electronic service that has one (a) the development by the person of any such software; or (b) the supply by the person of any such software; or (c) the updating by the person of any such software It is far broader than just software entering into production, but can include ancillary software.
- rmbeard 8y agoAlso for those thinking of leaving, it is illegal for Australians to give up their citizenship, i.e. Australian law excludes this possibility.