10 ms·
A while back I noticed that my HN karma was rising at a rate that would put me on the leaderboard, so I decided to make an effort to submit content and post qua
by lisper 8y ago
A while back I noticed that my HN karma was rising at a rate that would put me on the leaderboard, so I decided to make an effort to submit content and post quality comments just to see if I could crack the top 100. After a few months I did it, and kept rising up to a high of 85 (today I'm #88). Then I realized I was spending way too much time on HN, and how easy it was to fall into this trap of thinking I was doing something worthwhile just because people were upvoting me. There is something visceral about looking at a number that you have somehow convinced yourself is a measure of your value as a human being, and seeing that number get bigger, even if at the end of the day that number is utterly meaningless. And, of course, when it comes to money the number is not meaningless, which makes the effect that much more powerful.
BTW, money is not just good for buying material things. You can spend arbitrary amounts of money on philanthropy and political donations. Once you start to do that, a lot of people start to want to be your friend. That kind of attention and deference can also be a very powerful drug.
- cyberferret 8y agoDid not even realise there was a leaderboard for HN karma. I stopped tracking my own karma score a while back. I was getting upset by even a handful of downvotes, and as soon as I decided to just publish my thoughts without caring about down (or up) votes, my happiness went up quite a few notches.
- lisper 8y ago> Did not even realise there was a leaderboard for HN karma. It's a well kept secret. And I've been much happier since I stopped looking at it, but every now and then I fall off the wagon and sneak a peek.
- cyberferret 8y agoWell, I implore you to do us all a favour and NOT publish the link to the leaderboard... :)
- lisper 8y agoWouldn't dream of it.
- catacombs 8y agoFor the curious: https://news.ycombinator.com/leaders https://news.ycombinator.com/leaders
- nostrademons 8y agoIt actually used to be one of the top tabs but was removed when PG realized that people trying to score points off each other hurt the quality of discussion. IIRC it was the same time that point totals for each comment were hidden from everyone but the author.
- jacquesm 8y agoCredit to user jackowayed: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=460631 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=460631
- mcv 8y agoMaybe it would be a good idea to hide your own total karma too. It's always right there on the top right, and I can't help looking at it. And I feel happy and proud when that number has gone up, and upset when it has gone down. Much more useful would be notifications of people responding to my comments, or maybe even people continuing discussions that I'm interested in. It's easy to lose track of those if I haven't posted in them.
- purple_ducks 8y agotampermonkey script to do just that (would be nicer if HN could pop the karma into a span with an id :-) ) // ==UserScript== // @name hide HN karma // @namespace http://tampermonkey.net/ http://tampermonkey.net/ // @version 0.1 // @description hide HN karma // @author You // @match https://news.ycombinator.com/* https://news.ycombinator.com/* // @grant none // ==/UserScript== (function() { 'use strict'; if(document.getElementById('me') !== null){ //hide karma Array.from(document.getElementById('me').parentElement.childNodes) .filter(x => x.nodeType == Node.TEXT_NODE) .forEach(y => {y.textContent=' '}) //remove link to profile page let me = document.getElementById('me'); let newme = document.createElement('span'); newme.textContent = me.textContent; me.parentElement.replaceChild(newme,me) ; } })();
- eigenvector 8y agoI agree. We have been conditioned to use wealth - which is neatly expressed as a 1-dimensional value - as a proxy for merit. If we are asked to do something that in abstract we would consider stupid or pointless, but is now accompanied by a large amount of money, we accept with the presumption that no one would offer so much money if it weren't very important. Money provides a very simple, neat way of valuing every item or service on Earth. Deceptively simple.
- tasty_freeze 8y ago> We have been conditioned to use wealth ... as a proxy for merit. I imagine this is especially true for people who have a high score on this metric. It appeals to ego and vanity.
- marmaduke 8y ago> we accept with the presumption that no one would offer so much money if it weren't very important oh boy I'd take a higher paying job to pay my mortgage or ease vacation with kids. No need to have a higher value than that.
- eklavya 8y ago> neat way of valuing every item or service on Earth Isn't that the very concept of money? :) Edit: newlines
- EADGBE 8y agoYes, the problem is that people associate what you have with what you are. Which are not the same thing. And therefor, make money the root of all evil today. If we traded in goats, it'd be how many goats you have. It doesn't matter at all the medium, as long as the value is tenable.
- Firadeoclus 8y agoTo be pedantic it's pricing not valuing. Price and value (and cost) are related but different concepts.
- 8y ago
- baroffoos 8y agoI fell in to the karma trap on reddit years ago and I ended up trying to conform to trends to maximize my karma. Its a really boring way to use a website and I found myself not saying a lot of things because I know they will be downvoted and I will lose my internet points. These days I don't give a shit about karma and I say whatever I want. I feel better about sharing opinions and I say what I really think.
- kochikame 8y agoI went through the exact same arc with Reddit. Once you reach a point where you have say 100,000+ karma, no downvote can ever really touch you anymore and you can start being honest again. If in addition to that you don't care about being banned from certain subs, well, congratulations, you're once a again a free man!
- baroffoos 8y agoMy original account has been banned from hundreds of subs. The vast majority of them I had never even been on before and was bot banned because I commented on a competing sub or something. These days I just make up a random account every month.
- kkarakk 8y agosome subs like offmychest ban anyone with a submission history to political subs like kotakuinaction as they perceive that someone with links to that subreddit cannot possibly contribute in a constructive manner. whether they are right or not is something only they as mods can perceive. it is actually against reddit rules to auto ban users like that but it is part of the increasing number of rarely enforced rules on reddit
- gammateam 8y agoHN will shadowban your account if you dont conform to popular opinion enough Aside from saying unpopular things, a net negative karma will also do it, which is a reflection of the same outcome Always check your post history from an incognito browser to see if others can see it
- stretchwithme 8y agoSocial animals value status. But better to earn it achieving meaningful goals you'll be proud of years from now. HN will be forgotten soon enough.
- rv-de 8y agoIn terms of machine learning money is the opposite of regularization. The more money the less regularization the more over-fitting to your specific self-chosen environment. A not rich person will have to learn to cope with obstacles. A rich person can remove obstacles. But it is impossible to remove all obstacles which will lead to increased hostility towards those remaining annoyances - like for example with SUVs in traffic. Calling a nice comfy SUV your owns means you removed obstacles like hot and cold weather (thanks to elaborate climate control), people literally look up to you in your SUV (big ego gains - less obstacles in terms of having to deal with disrespect), both due to direct in indirect conditions you won't have to deal with car problems. But when you are in traffic you'll also feel aloof and drive accordingly - like you own the street. But you cannot enforce it. End every so often there will be a conflict with a guy driving a ridiculous, old, little Toyota who won't give you way or won't let you zip into his lane. Now you are heated because this puny peasant isn't acknowledging your ego. And that's just one example.
- TheOtherHobbes 8y agoMoney is an insanely toxic mental, political, and social poison, for exactly these kinds of reasons. It's also a social reward function that privileges egotism and narcissism over empathy; exploitation, scamming, and rent-seeking over creativity, curiosity and invention; and short-term gain over long-term damage. Like the hardest of hard addictive drugs, it's an almost irresistible modifier of behaviour and attitude.
- charlesdm 8y agoThere's plenty of creativity in tax avoidance and financial engineering. Now, I'm not saying that is the kind of creativity you want to promote, but it certainly is there. There are many people who have fun doing this kind of work.
- rv-de 8y agoThen again few rich people will engage in this creative task on their own - most will probably just hire an accountant.
- belorn 8y agoThis might sound odd, but there is some real health benefits in perceiving oneself as having high social status. A few of those are better immune system, successful aging, lower stress hormones, lower risk for illness and depression, faster recovery, and just general higher energy and confidence. It can have a very strong positive effect on ones social network. It is a very powerful and deeply biological aspect of life. Looking at research and listening to experts in this fields, it is really fascinating how anything can be made into a value system for social status. Not only that but we can participate simultaneously in multiple social circles with completely different value systems, and as one researcher put it, we tend to channel most of our self worth based on the system where we are ranked highest. Strangely, money seems like one of the hardest method but also one of the most effective method to achieve this.
- osrec 8y agoI think it's generally assumed that more money equals better physical health, but the psychological aspects are very underrated. Money equals certainty for a lot of people. It lets them count on certain things always being there. Having your own home, respect, clout totally builds your confidence and lets you face life with positivity. You can afford to be wrong more often, so you don't mind sticking your neck out - sometimes you lose, but often times you win big. In short, money removes a lot of anxieties. A poor person simply doesn't have these luxuries, and the anxiety of poverty is a killer in its own right. Our flavor of capitalism is also such that all the wealth ends up in a small number of hands. The winner takes all. I wished we could somehow enforce equality without negatively impacting innovation. Probably wishful thinking, but I wonder if society can be optimised so everyone can feel prosperous at the same time?!
- tonyedgecombe 8y agoI wouldn't be surprised if the levels of inequality are negatively impacting innovation. There has to be an optimum level but I don't think we are anywhere near it in the Anglo-sphere.
- Applejinx 8y ago
- abc-xyz 8y agoAssuming link karma counts, then it seems like you could spend a couple of hours writing a Selenium script that would check the XX most upvoted HN websites for new content every minute, and then copy the title field and URL for HN submission. I suspect running that for a few hours every day would see you climb to the top very fast, and it would require very little maintenance.
- have_faith 8y agoI've downvoted you, but only because it's what you would have wanted
- feiss 8y agoSomething similar happens with school grades . You get labeled as an A kid, a B kid, you define yourself like that, and a good part of your life is spent fulfilling the spectations of that grade.
- philpem 8y agoNot to be too cynical, but the people who start schmoozing after you become rich probably just want a bit of the gold...
- tromp 8y agoI spent years and years playing a MUD (Multi User Dungeon) trying to top the leaderboard. Once there, I couldn't stop. I kept going and going, until one day I overflowed the signed 32 bit int experience, and then promptly disappeared from the rankings. That turned out to be a good thing. I lost most interest in advancing the counter...
- SnaKeZ 8y agoWhen a bug can save a life :D
- camelNotation 8y agoI believe it's possible to achieve the same level of life satisfaction by translating your experience of the world through a lens of gratitude and purpose. I've had opportunities to meet and get to know people with high net worth (mostly successful entrepreneurs) and people that willingly chose to live below the poverty line (religious devotees, teachers in poor communities, public advocates in poorly-funded non-profits, etc). I can't say one is happier than the other. Both require you to sacrifice things you might otherwise want. For the rich, that sacrifice usually takes the form of unstable family life (if any family at all) and alienated relationships with children because they work too much. For the poor, that takes the form of more immediate, material sacrifices like worrying about food, healthcare, and housing. But something both share in common is that they can be happy if they are grateful for what they have. Gratitude is a powerful thing. Curiously enough, the least happy people I've met are the ones that fall into neither category. Enough money to feel safe, fed, and warm, but no direction or meaning in their life. They aren't sure what to do with themselves. Should they try for more money? Should they choose a less vapid career path? They can't give up the middle-class salary or the middle-class experience. It's very sad.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- michaelcampbell 8y agoI've installed browser extensions to turn off karma/points on as many sites as I can find. For me this has worked well. I still kid my wife about "internet points" when I take a photo for Google Maps and the like, and I totally empathise with you on the feeling of seeing that number, but for my own peace of mind I've had to restrict myself from it.
- tokyodude 8y agoI'm not trying to be #1 but I do feel iike scores on various sites have a negative influence on me. Added this to my `userContent.css` in firefox to hide my scores and votes @-moz-document domain(news.ycombinator.com) { .score { display: none; } body>center>table>tbody>tr:first-child>td>table>tbody>tr:first-child>td:nth-child(3) { visibility: hidden; } body>center>table>tbody>tr:first-child>td>table>tbody>tr:first-child>td:nth-child(3) a { visibility: visible; } html[op=user]>body>center>table>tbody>tr:nth-child(0n+3)>td:first-child form>table>tbody>tr:nth-child(3) { display: none; } } which HN would just let me check a box "no score"
- digianarchist 8y ago"Why Aren’t Hacker News Leaders Happy With the Karma They Have?"
- Stryder 8y agoMoney can’t purchase genuine human connection, and that’s pretty much the root of it. Anything that can be purchased is that much more enjoyable when real human connection is involved, otherwise it honestly doesn’t matter how lavish the thing is, it just becomes kind of boring. It’s possible to purchase fake connection, but again it’s pretty boring because it’s fake. Even the money making process is more boring without genuine connections to others.
- perfunctory 8y ago> There is something visceral about looking at a number that you have somehow convinced yourself is a measure of your value as a human being If only we could somehow get the rich to look at the CO2 ppm and be excited about that number getting smaller.
- rafiki6 8y agoInteresting. I've noticed that the upvoting/downvoting system isn't very objective and tends to favor one side of an opinion over another. Meaning people will upvote you on HN if what you post resonates with them, and HN readership is skewed towards one end of the political/social spectrum. This means that the reward mechanism of HN (upvoting for karma), rewards those with content that conforms rather than challenges some of the assumptions and opinions that run prevalent here. It's very analogous to the real world and money. It's quite rare to be rewarded monetarily for challenging status quo or established trends/opinions. If I was to open a business to challenge an incumbent in an industry, the obstacles I'd face make the risk daunting. That's why the failure rate for start-ups is so high. I'd love to see a study of HN and Reddit and their voting system to see if we can find any strong correlations between that and the real world.
- supercanuck 8y agoMy accounting professor use to always say, "You get what you measure." It didn't seem as so insightful then, but as I navigate this world, I get it.
- karanchawla 8y agoYes there's a similar quote I read somewhere which is now a part of my internal monologue: "You can't improve what you can't measure." So, I'm always trying to measure everything about my life and improving and optimizing things.