25 ms·
'Dark fluid' with negative mass could dominate the universe
- 3327 8y agoThen we are definitely in a simulation. That is the fabric that holds the universe together.
- rjplatte 8y agoThat's a complete non-sequitur.
- lawlessone 8y ago>The gravity from the positive mass galaxy attracts negative masses from all directions, and as the negative mass fluid comes nearer to the galaxy it in turn exerts a stronger repulsive force onto the galaxy that allows it to spin at higher speeds without flying apart. I don't get this, seems contradictory.
- ams6110 8y agoI was just about to quote that same sentence. How can positive matter attract negative matter which at the same time is repelling positive matter? The author is described as an Astrophysicist at Oxford (a reputable place) so I assume I'm either just not getting it or this is poorly worded.
- jbay808 8y agoTo approximate with Newtonian laws: F=ma Meaning that positive and negative masses will accelerate in opposite directions in response to the same applied force. The effect is different, but it's a bit like how when you are in a car and hit the gas pedal, and your kid is in the back seat holding a helium balloon, the kid feels pushed backward into the seat but the balloon flies forward toward the windshield. F = GMm/r^2 Meaning that gravitational forces between opposite signed masses is the opposite direction from the force between masses of the same sign. Thus, the gravity force repels the normal mass away, but this repulsive force actually drags the negative mass along with it, because the negative mass accelerates the wrong way when "repelled".
- zamalek 8y agoWe have an intuitive ~~example~~ approximation of this in real-life: balloons in a car[1]. [1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uAJlg8MDAlU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uAJlg8MDAlU
- taeric 8y agoI'm intrigued. Isn't the reason a balloon moves forward more of buoyancy? If you do the same experiment with the window open, doesn't it do as expected by most people?
- wwarner 8y agoI didn't read that positive matter is attracting negative matter. What I gathered is that the presence of a cloud of negative matter in the right place would be held in place by mutual repulsion of the outer arms of the galaxy and the inner galaxy. And that the neg matter supplies enough repulsion to the diffuse outer galaxy that it can spin a bit slower than it would have to otherwise.
- sp332 8y agoMaybe it was modeled as a curvature of space? So positive masses curve space so that everything moves toward them - including light, massless particles, and negative mass. And negative mass repels everything, including other negative mass, by shaping space differently. [Edit: jbay808 has a better explanation below, and negative mass attracts negative mass.] That behavior is described here https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Negative_mass#Runaway_motion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Negative_mass#Runaway_motion but it's not what I was expecting either.
- smaddox 8y agoHuh, very interesting. Definitely not intuitive by comparison to electric charge.
- astrocat 8y agoYeah this helped me create a mental picture that kind of makes sense. It would clarify why negative mass is also concentrated in areas of high mass, and could also provide the mechanism for constant universe expansion, as the space between masses is constantly being pushed away by the diffuse negative mass. Heh, armchair physics is fun :)
- mklauber1 8y agoI think what they're saying is that positive mass galaxies attract the negative mass, even as the negative mass repels the positive mass (and all other negative mass). In a stationary system, eventually the two will reach an equilibrium. However, the effects of this in a system in which the positive mass galaxy is spinning is that the negative mass counteracts the forces of inertia, allowing the galaxy to spin at higher speeds without shattering like a cd spun too quickly. Now, whether the math of all that makes sense, I'm am not in a position to comment on.
- skykooler 8y agoWouldn't that allow for a "perpetual motion" setup where a blob of normal mass is in front of a blob of negative mass? The negative mass would push the positive mass forward, and then be attracted to it and follow. What am I misunderstanding?
- Nasrudith 8y agoScrewily to our intuitions negative mass goes in the opposite direction of its acceleration. It still goes away but the acceleration is in the same direction. It is weird and easy to be confused.
- FabHK 8y agoDamn, you're right, there goes the hoverboard.
- eutropia 8y agoI think you meant to say that the mass accelerates opposite to forces acting upon it. An idealized -M + M = 0 pair of particles (one normal, one negative mass) could experience runaway acceleration. Author touches on this in the paper as a potential source for the incredibly high-energy extra-galactic cosmic rays. Granted, the paper describes a model in which something that acts like a particle with negative mass exerts this force upon things, but has no claims as to what a physical manifestation of this would look like.
- 8y ago
- JamesCoyne 8y agoNegative mass inverts signs in ways that are not intuitive. Best explanation is a diagram from the author's twitter page [0][1]. When a positive and negative mass particle interact gravitationally the positive mass is repelled and the negative mass is attracted. [0] https://twitter.com/Astro_Jamie/status/1070303556266283008 https://twitter.com/Astro_Jamie/status/1070303556266283008 [1] https://i.redd.it/qt2tf2tbni221.jpg https://i.redd.it/qt2tf2tbni221.jpg
- castis 8y agoPositive matter creates a gravity well. This much most people are familiar with. Seems to me what they're saying is that this well will pull in negative matter until a balance is reached, this will, in turn exert force on the internal structure of the galaxy.
- tylerjwilk00 8y agoThink of it as one pushes while the other one pulls.
- cwp 8y agoThe galaxy is in the center, and with a large positive mass it attracts negatively-massed matter towards it. But the negatively-massed matter repulses rather than attracting, so it has the effect of "squeezing" the galaxy in on its self.
- InclinedPlane 8y agoNegative mass is like playing opposite day. Negative mass is attracted to other negative mass, but because of the inverse acceleration to force relationship of negative mass the end result is that it is pushed away from other negative mass. Negative mass would also repel positive mass, which is straightforward for the positive mass but for the negative mass (again, inverse acceleration) it would end up with an "attractive" motion toward the positive mass.
- darkWWWeb 8y agoEvery "dark" physics piece is essentially a science opinion piece, with "darkness" included in the title as the general prevailing clickbait advertising strategy, because the layperson interpretation is that it implies sinister mysteriousness. It's never news, it's just a refresher listing of unknowns.
- jetrink 8y agoThe word 'dark' is used in titles because the articles are about the nature of dark matter and dark energy, which are widely accepted terms. You would have to go out of your way not to use the word dark when talking about these subjects and it would make titles less descriptive.
- DiabloD3 8y agoA "dark fluid" with negative mass COULD dominate the Universe, sure. But so could galactic-scale electric currents and magnetic fields, and is more likely. No one ever talks about that.
- XorNot 8y agoBoth these are real things we measure with radiotelescopes. They are not strong enough to produce the necessary effects, they are however interesting phenomena - https://arxiv.org/pdf/1302.5663.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/1302.5663.pdf.
- jerf 8y agoThe biggest tell that the Electric Universe theory is bunk is that anybody who ever talks about it can't hardly get two sentences in before dropping in the "but nobody ever talks about magnetic fields or electric currents at this scale"... which is easily observed to be utterly false. Astrophysicists talk about it a lot, and you can find even more discussion if you add "plasma" to the search terms. If Electric Universe advocates are so wrong about something so easy to check, it doesn't give me much reason to check out anything else they say. (The fact that I have done so nevertheless and I've never managed to find them making an actual prediction is another. It seems to be one of those recursive handwave theories that never quite lands on anything concrete no matter where you search, but it sure does know that the standard theory is wrong.)
- jazzyjackson 8y agodon't EM fields require a persistent source?
- dekken_ 8y agothis is the correct answer. Gravity is a product of this also. Light is a circuit and black holes don't exist
- galadran 8y agoPaper: https://arxiv.org/pdf/1712.07962.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/1712.07962.pdf Not a physicist, but my summary of the author's point would be: If you allow for matter with a negative mass and plug it into a n-body simulation. You seem to get what looks like dark matter from first principles. Namely, a halo of non interacting matter around galaxies in just the right "non-cuspy" shape. Their conclusion is that this is worth considering, as almost all mainstream cosmology makes the assumption that mass >= 0, despite the fact mass <=0 doesn't seem to violate any physical invariants we know. The idea is persuasively simple. Every other force besides gravity is polarised, so why not also gravity? It seems interesting to me, but I'm nowhere near knowledgeable enough to know whether it can be easily refuted.
- aetherson 8y agoIs it true that every other forces besides gravity is polarised? There's a repulsive nuclear strong force and an attractive nuclear weak force? EDIT: Partial answer is that there is a three-"color" polarization for strong force. I feel like it somewhat weakens the argument of "everything else is polarized, why not gravity" if the other forces are polarized in unique ways.
- walrus1066 8y agoStrong nuclear force is always attractive.
- galadran 8y agoIt most definitely isn't. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_force https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_force
- walrus1066 8y agoApologies, you are correct, jumped the gun a bit there. It's repulsive at short distances, attractive at longer distances. And oddly, the longer the distance, the stronger the force, it doesn't follow the inverse square law!
- mklauber1 8y agoI'm curious about the idea of "allow[ing] negative masses to not only exist, but to be created continuously." Given the law (in the scientific sense) that matter/energy cannot be created or destroyed, on a scale of 1 to FTL travel, how crazy is this idea?
- pavel_lishin 8y agoI thought it was less a law and more of an observation.
- Retra 8y agoScientific laws are just quantified observations.
- daxfohl 8y agoYup, that part seemed like a stretch to me too. Besides which, it doesn't seem to address any of the conflicts between QM and GR, so I'm not seeing it as a terribly interesting path. Not saying it's wrong, but it's not where I'd put my money.
- marcosdumay 8y agoThis is at the "would lead to FTL" level.
- SolarNet 8y agoHe points out that it's a mathematical tool and may not result in particles, e.g. matter or energy, as we currently think of it. It could be a property of space-time, as space is always expanding everywhere, space it self could have a negative mass. This could even be some sort of weird energy-neutral balancing mechanism (e.g. some sort of energy - my bet is on potential energy, like how gravity causes things to accelerate through the potential energy of the arrangement - is lost that accounts for the creation of negative mass particles or whatever; conservation is observational, but we don't really know what 95% of the stuff being conserved is in the first place). Hence it can be consistent with the conservation of mass and energy.
- 8y ago
- sulam 8y agoSounds a lot like phlogiston, especially since it apparently must be continuously created to matched observable behavior.
- autopoiesis 8y agoBut perhaps its continuous creation explains why the universe seems to contain so much of it?
- therein 8y agoBeware the Physical Chem, my son! The laws that arn’t, the constants that vary. Beware the phlogiston, my little one And of the molality be wary. He took his entropy in hand Long time the adiabatic foe he sought So rested he by the delta T And stood awhile in thought. And as in Newtonian Thought he stood The Physical Chem with Beer’s Law Plot, Came Bohring through the orbital wood And took quantum leaps when hot! PV! RT! And with fugacity, The entropy discharged his wrath. It reached a degenerate state, and being late, He returned by the mean free path I wonder if anyone will recognize this. :)
- deathanatos 8y agoIf by recognize you mean that it's a variation/remix of "Jabberwocky"[1], then yes. The second corresponding verse (so this corresponds to "He took his entropy in hand"), so others can see the resemblance (I chose the second since the first is a bit harder to see): He took his vorpal sword in hand: Long time the manxome foe he sought— So rested he by the Tumtum tree, And stood awhile in thought. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jabberwocky https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jabberwocky
- therein 8y agoVery cool. Today I learned something about a AXE (Alpha Chi Epsilon chemistry fraternity).
- hirundo 8y agoWhat's the relationship between negative mass and negative gravity and anti-gravity? Dark fluid is repulsive, so is it theoretically possible to collect a ball of it, put it between you and another positive mass, and fly apart?
- RootKitBeerCat 8y agoYes, that is essentially my understanding
- NedIsakoff 8y agoHere comes the Alcubierre Warp Drive!
- gradys 8y agoExactly where my mind went. Does the perspective described in the paper make the Alcubierre drive seem more plausible? Or is there something about the nature of the dark fluid hypothesized that would make it useless for something like that?
- krapp 8y ago>Or is there something about the nature of the dark fluid hypothesized that would make it useless for something like that? Assuming it was, literally, some kind of magical FTL juice... it all seems to be outside the galaxy, which means tens of thousands of years' travel just to get to it. If we're willing and able to do that, why bother with FTL at all?
- noetic_techy 8y agoHe is also implying that it spontaneously emerges from space on a continuous basis. If that's the case then it may be possible to setup a harvester of negative mass. The question is how much of it emerges in so many square km of empty space. It could be 1 particle per light year.
- krapp 8y agoI'm not a huge fan of the Fermi paradox but if it has any validity, it would seem to suggest the problem is difficult to say the least.
- noetic_techy 8y agoOr extremely easy if you believe the UFO reports... the only incorrect assumption is that they would initiate contact. Even Dawkings knew that this would be a stupid assumption: https://www.richarddawkins.net/2017/11/we-just-sent-a-message-to-try-to-talk-to-aliens-on-another-world/ https://www.richarddawkins.net/2017/11/we-just-sent-a-messag... If they show up every couple thousand years and don't say anything, would we even notice?
- bitwize 8y agoEezo?
- chicob 8y agoThe possibilities for Star Wars puns are endless. There are alternative explanations that theorized that the 2nd law is not linear for extremely weak forces.[1] Thus, two masses that were sufficiently far apart would experience an attraction larger than that predicted by an inverse square law. I think some particular applications of these theories were proved wrong some years ago, but I can't find those results. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Modified_Newtonian_dynamics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Modified_Newtonian_dynamics
- abruzzi 8y agoActually, Star Trek had an episode where a giant space amoeba pulls the Enterprise into a "zone of darkness" where thrust towards the amoeba pushes the enterprise away from the amoeba. Sounds similar. Of course they destroyed the creature with some antimatter. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Immunity_Syndrome_(Star_Trek:_The_Original_Series) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Immunity_Syndrome_(Star_Tr...
- Pxtl 8y agoWould this be only gravitational mass that's negative or would it be both gravitational mass and inertial mass? Because negative inertial mass is zany and wierds me out. Negative gravitational mass behaves in a way that makes sense to me.
- jperras 8y agoIt's explained in the paper.
- contravariant 8y agoSurely its inertial mass is going to remain the same? In the same way that positive and negatively charged objects behave more or less the same way.
- walrus1066 8y agoHas to be gravitational only. Otherwise positive mass is repelled from negative mass, but the negative mass accelerates towards it. So both masses accelerate in the same direction, until they have infinite kinetic energy! Conservation of energy & momentum would still hold, because negative mass would have negative energy & momentum, cancelling out that of the positive mass. But the above surely would be an 'unphysical' situation.
- jon_richards 8y ago>Negative masses are a hypothetical form of matter that would have a type of negative gravity – repelling all other material around them. Unlike familiar positive mass matter, if a negative mass was pushed, it would accelerate towards you rather than away from you. Pretty sure the author means both. A continuously accelerating system seems "unphysical", but we have an example already: the accelerating expansion of the universe.
- OscarCunningham 8y agoThe paper uses the version where both gravitational and inertial mass is negative. This means that everything wants to accelerate towards positive mass and away from negative mass. So positive mass naturally forms clusters (galaxies) and negative mass naturally spreads out evenly but concentrates around the galaxies (forming the dark-matter halos).
- swamp40 8y agoCould be made into a nice Landspeeder!
- ars 8y ago> Negative masses are a hypothetical form of matter that would have a type of negative gravity – repelling all other material around them. Unlike familiar positive mass matter, if a negative mass was pushed, it would accelerate towards you rather than away from you. That assumes that inertial mass = gravitational mass, which is assumed to be true, not not proven.
- privong 8y ago> That assumes that inertial mass = gravitational mass, which is assumed to be true, not not proven. The assertion has been tested experimentally. Inertial and gravitational mass are seen to be equivalent within the bounds of experimental accuracy. The wikipedia article on the "Equivalence Principle" has lists of tests for various versions of the principle: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Equivalence_principle#Modern_usage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Equivalence_principle#Modern_u...
- ars 8y agoAnd the negative mass postulated here? We don't know if it's still equivalent there because we have never tested it. It would be a lot simpler if inertial mass was negative gravitational mass in this theory. Then you have repulsive gravity with normal behavior under force.
- privong 8y agoI see I misunderstood that you were specifically questioning the equivalence for this postulated negative mass. I thought your statement was a more general one.
- scott_s 8y agoI found the author's Twitter summary of the paper useful as well: https://twitter.com/Astro_Jamie/status/1070302359325151233 https://twitter.com/Astro_Jamie/status/1070302359325151233
- jobigoud 8y agoThreadified: https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1070302359325151233.html https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1070302359325151233.html
- russdill 8y agoSounds a lot like the concept of the Dirac sea to me. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dirac_sea https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dirac_sea Rather than have dark matter particles, have negative mass dark matter particles in every other location instead.
- sixo 8y agoThis is explicitly very different from that. There's no claim of "negative mass dark matter particles" in _ever_ location, rather, they have a specific distribution.
- tylerjwilk00 8y agoThat distribution being all the places that aren't normal matter particles. So primarily outside of galaxies.
- jon_richards 8y agoNo. The negative mass matter clusters around galaxies because it accelerates towards positive mass and away from other negative mass. The area between galaxies becomes largely empty in the simulations.
- RobertoG 8y agoI'm confused. From the article: "This is explained by the Hubble-Lemaître Law, the observation that more distant galaxies are moving away at a faster rate." If we observe an accelerating universe how can be that galaxies in the past move away at a faster rate?
- tzakrajs 8y agoBecause more and more negative mass fills in the space left behind by the expansion creating further expansion?
- mirceal 8y agoIf anyone is interested in dark matter and dark energy I recommend this book: https://www.amazon.com/Our-Mathematical-Universe-Ultimate-Reality/dp/0307599809 https://www.amazon.com/Our-Mathematical-Universe-Ultimate-Re... Written by this guy http://web.mit.edu/physics/people/faculty/tegmark_max.html http://web.mit.edu/physics/people/faculty/tegmark_max.html is does a fantastic job of going from really simple concepts/experiments to blowing your mind.
- british_india 8y agoI invite you to plug in negative mass to Einstein's famous equation. Negative mass is what is required for faster-than-light travel. What is needed is a craft that has a normal, positive mass shell that contains and holds an equivalent amount of negative mass, thereby giving the entire craft a net mass of zero, allowing unlimited acceleration.
- hirundo 8y agoHere's an article describing the theory that sound waves have negative mass. It also describes it in terms of the behavior of fluids. https://www.realclearscience.com/articles/2018/08/11/could_phonons_have_a_negative_mass_110719.html https://www.realclearscience.com/articles/2018/08/11/could_p... Maybe these phenomena are linked, and it's more immediate than cosmology. via: https://twitter.com/robinhanson https://twitter.com/robinhanson
- dragonbonheur 8y agoLooks like the rest of the world is about to catch up with Jean-Pierre Petit's theories about negative masses surrounding positive mass objects like galaxies and holding them together... Even the proposal for the modification of Einstein's theories... Times are a'changin. It took almost ten years (2007-2017) from JPP being shunned by the scientific community (and the highly politicised French Wikipedia) to others "discovering" the same things he had been saying all along. https://arxiv.org/abs/0712.0067 https://arxiv.org/abs/0712.0067 http://jp-petit.org/papers/cosmo/2018-AstrophysSpaceSci.pdf http://jp-petit.org/papers/cosmo/2018-AstrophysSpaceSci.pdf You may give yourselves the smallest pat on the back in the universes.
- DoctorOetker 8y agofigure 1 of that paper is virtually identical to the galaxy rotation curve of the current paper! both were N body simulations thanks for pointing out this earlier work
- scottmsul 8y agoIf you put a negative mass and positive mass side by side and release from rest, they will accelerate indefinitely and break conservation of energy. Of course science should be open to any possibility, no matter how strange. But I feel the author understates its strangeness. And requiring negative mass to be continually created makes this theory not all that much "simpler" than the standard dark matter+dark energy.
- snowwrestler 8y agoI'm not sure I think infinite repulsion is any stranger than infinite attraction, which is how we think gravity works now.
- YaxelPerez 8y agoThey would accelerate indefinitely, but it wouldn't break conservation of energy. Gravitational force is inversely proportional to distance^2, so potential energy (integral from 0 to infinity of Force dx) still converges to a finite number. Same with normal gravity, but backwards.
- walrus1066 8y agoI think the weirdness is, the distance between masses wouldn't change, they'd just accelerate together, in the same direction, indefinitely. Both mass would experience negative repulsive force: F=Gm(-m)/r^2 =-Gm^2/r^2 The positive mass accelerates away from the negative mass, because F=ma => ma=-Gm^2/r^2 => a=-Gm/r^2 Now here's the kicker. If inertial mass (the m in F=ma), is the same thing as gravitational mass. Then, the negative mass accelerates towards the positive mass. Because F=(-m)a => F=-ma => -ma=-Gm^2/r^2 => a=Gm/r^2 So accelerates in same direction as positive mass. Technically, conservation of energy & momentum is maintained, because the negative kinetic energy of negative mass would cancel out positive energy of positive mass. But I think the above can't be natural, because the magnitude of kinetic energy would grow to infinity, leading to even more impossibilities. So you'd need to 'hack' the theory of gravity and make inertial mass different to gravitational mass. So the particle has negative gravitational mass, but positive inertial mass, to make laws of physics stay sane :)
- garmaine 8y agoWould this also explain galactic voids as regions of large negative mass? It would seem that deviations in the Hubble constant bear a void would confirm this theory.
- Olsi 8y agoHi for Everyone! I"ve got an interesting news. Would you like to have an interesting pastime in internet. http://VO1U8.TK http://VO1U8.TK Click here.
- hagzor 8y agoChongo longo
- debatem1 8y agoStupid non-physicist question here: we know the universe is expanding, but where does it expand at? Are there physical areas which we can observe growing? And if so, shouldn't that mean that we observe distant objects as lighter than their interactions with closer objects would imply?
- YaxelPerez 8y agoThe explanation I've heard is that it's just space being created everywhere at once. There's no center from which everything expands. This VSauce video explains it better than I can (later in the video): https://youtu.be/3pAnRKD4raY https://youtu.be/3pAnRKD4raY
- andrewshadura 8y agoImagine a flat ‘universe’ on the surface of a balloon which is being inflated. There would be no centre of expansion on the surface of the balloon, the space would appear everywhere equally.
- danbruc 8y agoSpace expands everywhere, also right in front of you, it is just a very small effect over short distances. Two points one meter apart expand away from each other with a speed of 0.07 nanometers per year. For short distances electromagnetic and strong forces just pull everything immediately back together as things want do move apart. Over larger distances, think the scale of galaxies, gravitational forces keep the stars, the gas, and all the other stuff together and prevent galaxies from expanding. But once you move beyond the scale of galaxies and galaxy clusters there are no longer any forces strong enough to counter the expansion of all that space between galaxies and so in general the distances between galaxies are increasing. There are still exceptions, in clusters of nearby galaxies gravitational forces can still bind those galaxies together but with increasing distances between galaxies the expansion finally overpowers gravitational attraction. It is important to remember that not only are all forces becoming weaker as distances increase but also that points are expanding faster away from each other as their distance increases. As said, two points one meter apart move away from each other with 0.07 nanometers per year but two points one kilometer apart move away with 70 nanometers per year because there are a thousand meters in between them, all of them simultaneously expanding at 0.07 nanometers per year.
- sadness2 8y agoI love the choice of the word "could" for this title. Makes it sound like the plot for a science fiction book X-D
- starbeast 8y agoPresumably you could describe this as a theory of levity. For happy spacetimes.
- SubiculumCode 8y agoNot a physicist. If negative mass exists, is it featureless, or is it composed of units which can combine to form analogous negative mass atoms, negative mass molecules, etc?
- OscarCunningham 8y agoIt would presumably be composed of units which could well join together into larger structures. But these would have to be small scale (the size of atoms or molecules) because gravity causes negative masses to move away from each other. So it wouldn't clump together into planets and galaxies.
- here2day 8y agoTotal crap made up to suit a failing theory of relativity and Big Bang.
- jasonhansel 8y agoReminds me of this (very old) theory of gravity: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Le_Sage's_theory_of_gravitation https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Le_Sage's_theory_of_gravitat...
- _xgw 8y agoNon mobile link: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Le_Sage's_theory_of_gravitation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Le_Sage's_theory_of_gravitatio...
- radarsat1 8y ago> Air bubbles in water can be modelled as having a negative mass. Forgive the naive take on this, but it's a weird point to me... if air bubbles in water can be modelled as having negative mass, but clearly do not (they are made of particles with positive mass), then they are only "negative" in relation to the material surrounding them. So even if they can be modelled this way successfully, clearly the model doesn't imply for certain that they do have negative mass. So by analogy, just because a negative-mass model can explain the observations of dark matter, doesn't it still leave the question of whether anything "real" is implied by it? Perhaps it's just a reflection of a negative relative to some unknown bias (field), like the Higgs field, but in "absolute" terms is not actually negative. (Not sure "absolute" has any meaning here..)
- archibaldJ 8y agoThe concept of whether something is "real" is a metaphysical amusement. And it is never meant to be answered in modern physics. Physics has come a long way into what it is today from natural philosophy. I believe all physicists in this day and age subscribe to the notion of model-dependent realism in one way or another. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Model-dependent_realism https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Model-dependent_realism Perhaps someday in the distant future we will discover that many assumptions in physics are simply wrong since we really do indeed live in a computer simulation and it is one where the Von Neumann architecture holds so it is always possible to alter "physics laws" like the Pauli exclusion principle and "physics constants" like the speed of light. And these "physics laws and constants" do get altered under certain if-statements or else there will be bugs and the simulation will crash, rebooting itself as a result. Or perhaps this simulation does crash and reboot itself very often. It's like elixir. We simply are not aware of it. Maybe that could be why we have things like the Heisenberg uncertainty principle and quantum tunnelling.
- Filligree 8y agoOkay, but does this stuff break the weak energy condition? Could we build Krasnikov tubes with it?
- TangoTrotFox 8y ago
- DonHopkins 8y agoCould this repulsive 'Dark Fluid' be what they use on the Enterprise to generate artificial gravity? They could pipe the stuff through the ceiling to press you down against the floor. But that would make the gravity point the wrong way in the decks above and below. But if they alternated the direction of "up" on each deck, maybe they would cancel each other out.
- matte_black 8y agoNegative mass... holy shit with this we could break the speed of light
- point78 8y agoHow?
- matte_black 8y agoBy offsetting the mass of a system, to produce a zero mass vehicle.
- point78 8y agoVery cool stuff
- EthanHeilman 8y agoTake a net negative mass vehicle, and accelerate it by having it collide with its propellant. Would this be an anti-rocket?
- matte_black 8y agoHow does it come to a stop, the vehicle gains too much mass?
- EthanHeilman 8y agoThe mass part of the vehicle could either detach from the negative mass component. Or the vehicle could eject mass to reduce velocity.
- FabHK 8y agoI've personally verified this part of the paper: > Observations clearly indicate that the Universe is not empty. EDIT to add: Another nice, slightly Douglas-Adams-y quote: > This implies that our Universe is just one of those things that happen on occasion, and we can simply think of its existence as being illustrated by a 1 billion-σ statistical event.
- pmontra 8y agoNo problem with negative masses, but where does this continuously generated fluid come from?
- RootKitBeerCat 8y agoCompletely a layperson who’s only read science for the masses type physics and astrophysics, but now imagine that there are all sorts of undiscovered phenomena that are actually just the inverse of existing properties of nature we know. Does that make sense, or resonate with more rigorous scientists, Reade archers, students?
- vtesucks 8y agoAlright question for all you genius physicists- what makes you visit this forum which is primarily a discussion board for news and startups (primarily)in the field of Information Technology? I'm curious because I don't know you're your domain intersects with this forum's.
- exabrial 8y agoNegative mass is required to produce warp drive... We might not be stuck here forever
- jxcole 8y agoOne of the most interesting properties of matter with negative mass is that if something collides with it it accelerates in the opposite direction of the incoming object. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exotic_matter#Negative_mass https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exotic_matter#Negative_mass
- bmh100 8y agoDoes his theory explain the Bullet Cluster and baryon acoustic oscillations?
- hliyan 8y agoTitles that describe poorly understood scientific phenomena as "bizarre", "mysterious" etc., hurts science, IMO. I would expect this from a journalist (though not excuse it), but an academic? Why not something like "Negative mass dark 'fluid' halos around galaxies as an alternative to dark matter"?
- time-domain0 8y agoNeither an experimental physicist nor cosmologist, but another possibility is that our universe shares very slight space-time interactions with other universe(s) in a multiverse where its mass-energy casts negative mass "shadows" in ours. Blackholes in one creates areas of repulsion and expansion in the other. Maybe this is where the missing mass-energy is? It's there, but it's not in our universe.
- agapon 8y agoI recall reading article in a popular science magazine about hypothetical negative mass with exactly these properties. It was about 25 years ago and the magazine was Russian language. Unfortunately, I can't recall its name now.
- agapon 8y agoOh, thanks to the power of the internet search, I found a scan of that article: http://epizodsspace.airbase.ru/bibl/tm/1990/10/otrits-massa.html http://epizodsspace.airbase.ru/bibl/tm/1990/10/otrits-massa.... The journal is "Техника-молодежи" (a Soviet style name that I am incapable of translating to English) and the article is from 1990. And that article refers to a publication by Robert Forward in a journal with a name like Aerospace Technology or Aerospace Engineering. But I found an article in on the same topic in NewScientist: https://www.newscientist.com/article/mg12517084-200-the-power-of-negative-matter/ https://www.newscientist.com/article/mg12517084-200-the-powe... Wikipedia, of course, has an article on Negative mass as well.
- FiatLuxDave 8y agoThank you! The first thing I did when coming to this thread was search for posts containing "Robert Forward", as any discussion of negative inertial mass is incomplete without mentioning his work. So, kudos. Anyone interested in the implications of negative mass should probably check out Timemaster, a sci-fi novel by Forward. Negative mass can hypothetically do some interesting things. Things such as allowing lightspeed travel by matching negative mass to positive mass in equal amounts, leaving a non-photon object with rest mass = 0, or producing energy by accelerating negative mass to high velocities. Unfortunately, Forward is much better as an idea guy than he is as an author. The scene where the hero travels back in time and has a threesome with himself and his wife is a bit awkward...
- tigerlily 8y agoAnyone read up on David Wiltshire's timescape model? After reading it, I became more skeptical of dark matter and dark energy theories as the cause of the Universe's apparent accelerating expansion.
- mrhappyunhappy 8y ago“Negative masses are not a new idea in cosmology. Just like normal matter, negative mass particles would become more spread out as the universe expands – meaning that their repulsive force would become weaker over time. However, studies have shown that the force driving the accelerating expansion of the universe is relentlessly constant. ” Is it though? How can you measure a universe-size force that takes billions of years to “move” on a human lifetime scale?
- throwaway487550 8y agoHow abstract concepts, introduced to establish artificial symmetry, could be used to describe aspects of reality which does not rely on any abstract notions whatsoever? Some processes are symmetrical to an outside observer, which does not imply that anything must be or should be symmetrical. It is an observer's preference to see symmetry everywhere. There is no such fucking things as "dark" liquids or negative "masses" merely because a model superimposed on reality have nothing to do with reality itself. The impossibility is the same as the principal impossibility of revealing the CPU's actual wiring from the level of code it runs. There is not a single fucking way to do it in principle, no mater what fancy guesswork one would use or what kind of a wrongly simulated model one will superimpose on what one is able to "see" and examine. This is not even science, but some sort of contest of abstract theology, crafted to please fellow reviewers and sectarians.
- 3chelon 8y agoDark fluid, negative mass? Rubbish, it's turtles all the way down!
- domparise 8y agoIf we can prove that dark matter exists with negative mass, this may pave the way for fundamental research on other phenomena with negative mass, like anti-gravity effects.
- kjeetgill 8y agoMy favorite bit from the author on Twitter: https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1070302359325151233.html https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1070302359325151233.html > The next-generation radio telescope - the Square Kilometre Array @SKA_telescope will be able to test this theory, and directly confirm or invalidate its predictions. 13/17 It is rather surprising that the model predicts the properties of a LambdaCDM universe. As a casual observer this is is what gets me excited! We'll get our answers one way or another.
- anentropic 8y agoTwo passages from the article: > Negative masses are a hypothetical form of matter that would have a type of negative gravity – repelling all other material around them. Unlike familiar positive mass matter, if a negative mass was pushed, it would accelerate towards you rather than away from you. > The gravity from the positive mass galaxy attracts negative masses from all directions ...why aren't these contradictory? intuitively... wouldn't a negative mass be repelled by positive gravity? (I am not a physicist of any kind, obviously) In the author's Twitter thread https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1070302359325151233.html https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1070302359325151233.html there is this image: https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Dtp7YjWW4AEIvSp.jpg https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Dtp7YjWW4AEIvSp.jpg ..which seems to answer my question If I understood the picture: - positive mass gravities attract each other and result in acceleration towards each other - negative mass gravities attract each other, but the negative mass means this attractive force results in an opposite acceleration (they behave as if repelled) - a positive mass and a negative mass have gravities which repel each other so the positive mass accelerates away from the negative, but the negative mass inverts its gravitation repulsion into an acceleration towards the positive (I find it hard to imagine how this interaction actually plays out, it's a bit counter-intuitive.. I guess they must cancel out rather than chasing each other faster and faster?)
- planck01 8y agoInteresting rebuttal from someone in the field (who is actually quoted in the paper): http://backreaction.blogspot.com/2018/12/no-negative-masses-have-not.html http://backreaction.blogspot.com/2018/12/no-negative-masses-...
- noetic_techy 8y agoThis then leads to the inevitable questions, is an Alcubierre Warp Drive possible, since one of its pre-requisites was particles of negative mass?: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alcubierre_drive https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alcubierre_drive >>a spacecraft could achieve apparent faster-than-light travel if a configurable energy-density field lower than that of vacuum (that is, negative mass) could be created If this matter is popping into space continuously as the author describes, it could be possible to harvest it. The question is, how much of it is popping into existence in lets say a square km of space (something we could feasibly cover with our current tech), and how do we detect and capture it. The author does readily admit that his theory may be wrong, but useful as a mathematical tool. It's like saying "My theory may be the Newtonian Mechanical model of dark matter + dark energy, but not the quantum (read: real) theory." I sure as hell hope he is correct and its a real particle we could capture. It could open up technology we have yet to realize and get us off this rock.