10 ms·
Why don't we bring trolleybuses back? They rock! You don't need polluting batteries in order to run them, just some copper to put the wires up, and we've been m
by paganel 8y ago
Why don't we bring trolleybuses back? They rock! You don't need polluting batteries in order to run them, just some copper to put the wires up, and we've been master of this "technology" for almost a century now. Also, we should extend or re-introduce the tram network.
- stevefan1999 8y agoThey required overhead transmission wire planning as well, but I do agree we should overhaul trams that we use it to satisfy the need of short distance and constant location travel.
- masklinn 8y agoAlso recent trolley generations can be equipped with batteries which get charged while connected to the overhead transmission network (or opportunistically at bus stops), allowing some operations on non-wired segments.
- icebraining 8y agoSome places are bringing them back, e.g. Prague started using them again this year, after 46 years. The modern ones often come with a battery that allows them to run sections of the line without overhead wires.
- fiala__ 8y agoThey've been in continuous use in Bratislava since the 1940s, and they also have the hybrid ones. They're especially suitable for steep slopes where rail-based transport doesn't work. Absolutely iconic vehicles!
- iguy 8y agoDo the hybrid ones have any clever way to re-connect? All the busses I've seen have this system where the driver has to walk to the back and pull on some rubber bands to put the tentacles back on the wires. If this could be automated, then perhaps you could omit wires at big junctions where it's most messy, needs lots of points, etc. Building & maintaining wires with 90% coverage might cost half as much as 100% coverage, I would guess.
- kalleboo 8y agoIf you search YouTube for “trolleybus automatic” there are a couple of videos. Looks like there are special locations where the catenary has a little plastic guide on it. It also looks quite slow.
- iguy 8y agoThanks! Turns out there is a whole trolleybus youtube, amazing.
- pferde 8y agoYes, where the hybrid buses connect to the wires (usually at certain bus stops), the wires have sort of "tentacle catchers" on them, shaped as upside-down Vs. The driver just has to stop on the usual spot, press a button, and while passengers are boarding and exiting, the "tentacles" unfurl, and are guided by these "catchers" towards wires. The driver just watches for a light to go on on his dashboard. It works pretty well - in many years, I have only seen once that the tentacles did not end up where they should, and the driver had to get out and manually correct it.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoSeattle has this before for their downtown bus tunnel. Always annoying when the unfurling went wrong, but it was very workable. They got rid of it when light rail went in, and now run clean low emission buses in the tunnel instead (hybrid, natural gas) to avoid ventilation issues.
- JorgeGT 8y agoJust if anyone is curious, the technical term for the "tentacles" is pantograph. And if anyone is more curious about why it has "graph" in it, it's because the term refers to the old utensil for copying drawings which is similar in terms of aspect and principle.
- Steltek 8y agoPantographs are only the bar mounted on a scissor-like mechanism that you find on light rail. They only allow for one electrical connection so they don't work for trolley buses. The word I would use here are "trolley poles".
- friendly_chap 8y agoBudapest and a lot of parts of Hungary use trams and trolleys a lot, they never went away. I always thought about them as quirky archaic tech, but you have just changed my view! Cheers
- Lukas_Skywalker 8y agoThey have been and still are in use in most Swiss cities. They have a backup ICE for emergencies, but mostly run on electricity. Works really well, and makes for a rather silent ride.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoUS cities with lots of hills still have trolley bus routes (San Francisco, Seattle, even LA has a few routes). Switzerland has them because of the hills as well (eg Lausanne). Electric + rubber has really great torque for climbing hills. Even replacing trolley buses with a tram requires the use of rubber tires instead (eg Laussane’s newer metro).
- sschueller 8y agoMost electric buses in Zürich now have had their ICE backup engines replaced with batteries. They are also now able to disconnect and reconnect from the wires from inside the cabin via button press at specific locations.
- nolok 8y agoQuite a few cities in France have been developping trams line this past couple of decade. In "Ile de France" (Paris and its metropolitan area) the last tram line was closed in 1938 but it's coming back and there are now 14 lines planned, 10 of which are already opened (8 of those opened between 2006 and 2017), the oldest one opened in 1992 and the last one in the current plan should open in 2023. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tramways_in_%C3%8Ele-de-France https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tramways_in_%C3%8Ele-de-France
- maeln 8y agoNantes was the first city in France to have a tramway [0] :) ! It was very unsafe and thus got the nickname "Péril Jaune" (yellow peril) because of it's color. Today, Nantes still has a wide Tram network and I really enjoy it. I find it more enjoyable than metro. They tend to smell less and you can enjoy the scenery will traveling :) . [0] https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ancien_tramway_de_Nantes https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ancien_tramway_de_Nantes
- shaki-dora 8y ago> “Péril Jaune" (yellow peril) Seems to be a common theme in France
- mymythisisthis 8y agoToronto still has lots of trams left, and is building light rail. Unfortunately we got ride of hundreds of electric buses in the 1990s.
- swebs 8y agoThey got rid of them in Philadelphia because people hated driving over the tracks and them ruining their tires. Some routes upgraded to to electric buses that still use the existing overhead power lines. I'd assume the driver has to be careful to stay within certain tolerances since he's no longer on a track.
- nothrabannosir 8y agoIf it has tracks, it's a tram. An electric bus which uses overhead powerlines is a trolleybus. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tram https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tram https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trolleybus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trolleybus
- swebs 8y agoAh, my mistake. We've always just called them "Trolleys"
- stplsd 8y agoMaybe I am missing something, but trolleybuses do not have tracks, they get power from overhead wires.
- catbird 8y agoPhiladelphia still has trolleys running on tracks, though maybe less routes than before. http://www.septa.org/maps/trolley/city.html http://www.septa.org/maps/trolley/city.html
- perfunctory 8y agoThey are live and kicking in some countries https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trolleybuses_in_Belarus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trolleybuses_in_Belarus
- masklinn 8y ago> Why don't we bring trolleybuses back? After decades of contraction, Lyon[0] re-started expanding its trolleybus network and converting ICE lines (sometimes back) to trolley a few years back. In the near future they're intending converting half a dozen ICE lines using IMC trolleys for more flexibility (able to run on batteries between overhead transmission segments, and to opportunistically recharge at bus stops). [0] the premier French city for trolleybuses and one of only 3 cities which still has a network
- gumby 8y agoThey never went away in US cities like SF and Boston, where they are referred to as “Trackless Trolley”.
- klohto 8y agoWe still have them in Czechia. I doubt they would go away now.
- plextoria 8y agoWe never got rid of them in Moldova! Trolley lines must still be running in most post soviet countries.
- D_Alex 8y agoSimply because electric buses are the superior technology right now. Metro bus services is actually an ideal application for electric vehicles: The needed range is short, charging facilities can be in one place (depot), stop-start driving suits the propulsion system, and low noise and no emissions are a bonus in the highly populated areas.
- Xylakant 8y agoTrolleybusses are electric, they just get their electricity from overhead wires, similar to a railway. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trolleybus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trolleybus
- ollie87 8y agoThey are but they need more infrastructure than battery vehicles.
- Reason077 8y agoExactly. The high cost, inflexibility, and maintenance requirements of overhead wires all make them unattractive for new installations. Battery electric buses, on the other hand, can operate anywhere that diesel buses can, and a fault with one bus or one section of wire will not break the whole route. Many cities also consider overhead wires to be visually unattractive. Birmingham's new tram network is being built to use overhead wires on suburban tracks, but switch to battery power in the city centre to avoid having to install overhead wires there.
- v_lisivka 8y agoHybrid electric+battery transport and sharing of wires with trucks makes them sexy again. See https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SJO4g_D4jow https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SJO4g_D4jow
- agsdfgsd 8y agoAre a few overhead wires actually more expensive than the massive batteries electric buses require? They are certainly less damaging to the environment.
- ThePhysicist 8y agoTrolleybuses still require infrastructure wherever they run, hence in many cities in Europe they got replaced by trams as they seem to be more efficient (because they're much longer than a bus). In Berlin there are already electric buses in operation on several lines (manufactured by Solaris, a Polish company and EVO bus, a Mercedes Benz subsidiary) and they will start experimenting with inductive charging soon. The idea is that you have a charging pad beneath each bus stop, where the short stops the bus makes would be sufficient to recharge the bus enough to keep it running all day. A single electric bus with charging station costs them about 600.000 € (https://www.morgenpost.de/berlin/article215300097/BVG-Busflotte-wird-bis-2030-unter-Strom-gesetzt.html https://www.morgenpost.de/berlin/article215300097/BVG-Busflo...) btw. So about 1000 times my annual subscription :D They ordered 30 more that will be in service next year and plan to have their whole fleet electrified before 2030.
- morsch 8y agoInductive charging is only 90% efficient at best. Doesn't really matter for portable devices with their tiny batteries, but it seems wasteful for vehicles.
- tasuki 8y agoIt could significantly reduce the required battery size though.
- hyperbovine 8y agoIt does matter if it means for don't have to drive 10000lbs of batteries around all day.
- davedx 8y agoYep electric buses running around Schiphol airport area since last year in the Netherlands. They are great!
- imtringued 8y agoBraunschweig has inductive charging for buses in active use for 4 years already. [0] [0] https://www.verkehr-bs.de/fileadmin/user_upload/downloads/Emil/A5_emil_Flyer_ENG.pdf https://www.verkehr-bs.de/fileadmin/user_upload/downloads/Em...
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoSeattle still has trolley buses, but has been getting rid of them as NG and EV buses are more flexible. Getting off track with overhead lines is annoying, and they got rid of bus overhead lines in the downtown tunnel when light rail went in (electric being previously necessary for ventilation).
- village-idiot 8y agoThis is easy. Diesel buses were more cost effective than electric trolleys, which is why they replaced all the trolleys with diesel buses. Electric (battery) buses are expected to be more cost effective than the diesel buses they’re replacing. Thanks to the transitive property of inequality, we would expect electric buses to be more cost effective than electric trolleys.
- rsynnott 8y agoIf the cost of everything has stayed the same for the last century, that's correct. In real life, however, the economics have changed; a number of cities are actually bringing back tram lines and/or trambuses. This is partially because (tracked) tram lines can support far greater line capacity than buses, though.
- village-idiot 8y agoMixed overhead and battery usage seems to be a very wise idea. The flexibility of a bus and the cheap charging of a trolley. In general a lot of this has to do with the infrastructure of your city, and the local costs of retrofitting streets to include overhead wires.
- 0db532a0 8y agoInequality is not transitive.
- modzu 8y agowe have them in Toronto!
- segmondy 8y agoWhy don't we figure out this remote business? If more people, just 10% of the population work remote full time, can you imagine the difference?
- Theodores 8y agoBecause the roads then fill up with commuters that come in from even further away. Imagine your typical city - jobs in the centre, housing on the outskirts, everyone doing the rush hour thing. People might be prepared to give up three hours of their day for the required commute. Now if a magic wand is waved and people start to work at home then those desks in the city centre will still be there. If the roads are that bit - 10% - faster/clearer then that tempts people from neighbouring towns to commute into the big city as they can now afford the time to do so due to the roads being quicker. Rather than work remote the far better idea is to have people work local. Imagine you have a programming gig on the other side of town and commute across town taking an hour or so each way. Coming the opposite way is someone else who lives near where you work and they are trying to get to an office down the road from where you live. They are a programmer too. Now what if you could swap jobs with them? In that way you might have a ten minute commute and they might too. In that way a far bigger difference can be made. But the thing is that we don't have a means of matching these job swap opportunities up. Time for a YC job swap for lazy commute startup?
- FooHentai 8y agoI dunno, you're pinning your dismissal of the initial idea on 'those desks in the city centre will still be there' when it's entirely feasible they'll just reduce over time in-line with demand. In fact, we see that right now with the trend towards unallocated desking and flexible working, where desk numbers within the same floor space is being reduced in favour of deploying more collaboration spaces and allowing more staff to work away from the office in a manner than suits them. That's what that reduction in office density downtown looks like in practice. Then your counter proposal depends on people being able to 'swap jobs' while handwaving away the complexity that would involve. Most knowledge worker roles aren't that fungible.
- Spooky23 8y agoThe capital costs are really high, and you lose flexibility. If you look at the challenges that entities like Google Fiber and municipal wifi initiatives have, one of the major ones is that pole infrastructure is really expensive. In my city, streetlights cost something like $800/yr each. Battery and associated infrastructure is cheap and effective.
- mtgx 8y agoMost likely because you need a whole railway to go with it, and it seems modern societies tend to hate railways and don't have any interested in investing in new ones or even maintaining the old ones anymore.
- gok 8y agoOn-street trolleys are the worst of all worlds. They require the infrastructure construction of a metro system, but can get stuck in traffic and can't be rerouted. Just use buses or build a real train system.
- dmix 8y agoPlus the countless cables criss-crossing every major street intersection like a spider's web are quite ugly: https://www.flickr.com/photos/drum118/26380513184 https://www.flickr.com/photos/drum118/26380513184
- rsynnott 8y agoThey're good for high-traffic lines, but the cost of infrastructure makes them impractical for lower frequency lines.
- FooHentai 8y agoYou do still use (some) batteries for trolley buses, as they have to bridge gaps where the overhead wires are unavailable (roadworks etc). The overhead wires are the biggest reason to avoid trolley buses. They're expensive to deploy and maintain, a visual eyesore, and constrain the bus network to predefined routes. Electric buses are a great improvement - At the expense of more batteries per bus and deployment of charging stations at depots/terminus, you avoid the wiring hassle entirely and have far more flexibility to change routes as required.