4 ms·
From the bit I've read from https://pimbook.org/pdf/pim_first_pages.pdf https://pimbook.org/pdf/pim_first_pages.pdf it seems to be very very poor. * 19 pages o
by andrepd 8y ago
From the bit I've read from https://pimbook.org/pdf/pim_first_pages.pdf https://pimbook.org/pdf/pim_first_pages.pdf it seems to be very very poor.
* 19 pages of droning before you start with something concrete. Much talk talk talk about your experiences before you get to the point. I can't put into words how much it frustrates me when I'm expecting to read something interesting and the author takes 3 paragraphs talking about nothing (usually with lots of overexcited exclamation marks).
[sorry if I am being blunt, but it's how I feel]
* Imprecise definitions. This defeats the purpose of learning mathematics. Like Leslie Lamport says, rigour in mathematics is not a hurdle or a chore one must endure, it's the whole point of learning the damn thing. You give imprecise definitions, and then obscure it even further with neverending paragraphs of confusing explanations. This to me kills the whole pedagogical value the book might have. Here is a rule of thumb that in my experience applies well to almost everything in mathematics: the simpler your explanation is, the better. Your goal is to explain a concept as succintly and beautifully as possible. This exposes the idea behind it. A long and meandering explanation only serves to obscure the idea behind. Less is more.
* Attempting to shoe-horn programming "lingo" into mathematics. Sometimes, the best way to explain something, even to programmers themselves, is not to force an awkward analogy with Java programming. EDIT: 5 pages later: "The best way to think about this is like testing software." oh boy...
* The graph in e.g. page 8 (20 of the pdf) is terribly typeset. The axes text is way too small to read and in a font that doesn't match the rest of the content.
- dustycat 8y agoI am curious how many people the author has taught mathematics to. It doesn't seem a good idea to jump into writing a textbook teaching mathematics unless one has experience of teaching mathematics. But the author makes the very point about early failures of programming, due to lack of experience, so perhaps he can supply information about what his pedagogical experience consists of. Teaching other people is a craft, similar to programming or mathematics, with its own necessities.
- jacobolus 8y agoApparently he was a TA as a math PhD student at UIC. Now is a programmer working at Google. He wrote a bunch of posts on his website over the years, https://jeremykun.com/main-content/ https://jeremykun.com/main-content/
- mcguire 8y agoHis blog has appeared here before and I've found it well written.
- j2kun 8y agoIt's a good question, and sort of hard to balance. I don't have any formal training as a teacher, or really a _pedagogy_ per se. I did teach five years of discussion sections among calculus, python programming, and differential equations. I do guest lectures for high school math classes, volunteered with groups like Black Girls Code and Hour of Code. I also did years of tutoring-center style tutoring, which meant I worked with students from the entire math curriculum. One time I even did an impromptu linear algebra course for a group of co-interns when I worked at MIT Lincoln Lab. So in terms of number of people face to face, somewhere in the low thousands seems right. In terms of writing, my blog has on the order of millions of all-time page views. I think it's a stretch to call the book a textbook. I think of it as an O'Reilly-type general technical book, but for math. If someone uses it to teach a course, that would be pretty wild, and I'd feel honored. Hope you enjoy it :)
- jbasrai 8y agoI enjoyed reading this opinion, do you have any recommendations for math textbooks that reach the standards you've described?
- andrepd 8y agoNot exactly math, but physics, since that was my background. Perhaps my favourite textbooks are Landau and Lifschitz[1]. They pretty much exemplify what I mean. They are concise, lucid, entirely self-contained. All the relevant information is there and not one bit more. The material is reduced to its key ideas, therefore making their exposition as clear as it can possibly be. Many people I've spoken to, however, don't like it precisely for being "too terse", so there you have it as well: ymmv. Another book that fits this is Cohen-Tannoudji's Quantum Mechanics[2]. The first two chapters explain quantum mechanics from absolute scratch. It starts as all physics does: with an experiment. Then everything else follows from looking carefully at the consequences of that observation, and the concepts are truly explained for what they are, because they are presented in the simplest way possible. "Idea" is more understandable than "Idea+Cruft". This is remarkable to me: much fuss is made about how quantum mechanics is strange and confusing and difficult to grasp, and it is indeed so. In that first chapter, however, I've found the most illuminating explanation of quantum mechanics I've ever read. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Course_of_Theoretical_Physics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Course_of_Theoretical_Physics [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Claude_Cohen-Tannoudji#Selected_works https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Claude_Cohen-Tannoudji#Selecte... EDIT: I just opened Landau's Mechanics Vol I, and here's what his colleague had to say about his writing and teaching style: "[These are] all the features of his characteristic scientific style: clarity and lucidity of physical statement of problems, the shortest and most elegant path towards their solution, no superfluities.". Indeed.
- diffeomorphism 8y agoLandau-Lifschitz as a reference is also very polarizing. There are people that really like the style (myself included), but I have also met many people that really dislike it, think it is too hard, too brief, too dry, too little description of intuition... . Similarly, the Feynman lectures are loved by some and disliked by others.
- marktangotango 8y agoAttempting to shoe-horn programming "lingo" into mathematics. This statement is particularly amusing and highlights to me the fact that mathematics are a natural language, and not a programming language. Sussman had a really great presentation on this point; anyone who’d argue this please watch! https://www.infoq.com/presentations/Expression-of-Ideas https://www.infoq.com/presentations/Expression-of-Ideas
- throwawaymath 8y agoDo you mind summarizing Sussman's presentation? I can't view it on the link you provided without making an account. I can't tell from your comment whether you agree or disagree with the parent's point.
- espeed 8y agoHere's a YouTube link of the presentation... https://youtu.be/iqlxsSrd-M4 https://youtu.be/iqlxsSrd-M4 NB: The slides aren't visible in the video, but here's the corresponding AI Memo by Gerald Jay Sussman and Jack Wisdom from November 2012... AI Memo 2002-018: The Role of Programming in the Formulation of Ideas (November 2012) [pdf] https://dspace.mit.edu/bitstream/handle/1721.1/6707/AIM-2002-018.pdf?sequence=2 https://dspace.mit.edu/bitstream/handle/1721.1/6707/AIM-2002...
- andrepd 8y agoThat was very interesting! Certainly a different perspective.
- adrianmonk 8y agoRegarding the first point, if you are the type of person who just wants it to get to the equations with a minimum of talk, you're probably not the intended audience of this book. The culture of mathematics (including its lingo) has always been a big barrier for me. Thus far, I've only skimmed it, but that part looks promising to me. It seems reasonable to guess that if someone has learned a good bit about programming but managed to avoid learning about math, reasons like culture, terminology, accessibility, and motivation might be a big part of why. So including that sort of material in this book makes sense to me.
- andrepd 8y agoRegarding the first point, if you are the type of person who just wants it to get to the equations with a minimum of talk I don't want "no talk" and "just equations, I want the "minimum of talk possible" that communicates the ideas and nothing more. I find the more stuff you write the more there is to confuse people. The best way is to strip everything that is superfluous. You are left with the essential, in the clearest form there can be.
- sn9 8y agoMath books already exist for that audience. Indeed, most of the canonical texts for undergrads would likely fit the bill.
- mlevental 8y agowtf is wrong with hn. >[sorry if I am being blunt, but it's how I feel] you should learn to keep your feelings to yourself when the only function they serve is to denigrate others and derive cruel satisfaction for yourself. >Here is a rule of thumb that in my experience applies well to almost everything in mathematics this is aspirational pretension - everyone claims to appreciate formal purity /after/ they've learned something but when you're /learning/ none of that matters because you're just trying to develop intuition. to be one of those people that understands after their own stumblings/ruminations and then begrudge the next person the same is despicable. shame on you and i hope you're never in a position where someone depends on you to teach them absolutely anything. >Imprecise definitions. This defeats the purpose of learning mathematics. Like Leslie Lamport says, rigour in mathematics is not a hurdle or a chore one must endure, but that's just like your opinion man (or leslie lamport's). there are shelves and shelves of books for people like you - go read bourbaki or rudin or mochizuki or whomever you'd like. this book is not for /you/ - it's stated purpose is to excite and entice people that don't have formal mathematical training to learn mathematics and those sorts of people decidedly don't enjoy austere definitions and succinct theorems and terse proofs. hence the only purpose your comment serves is to hurt the author's feelings, an author whom i might add has done infinitely more for the math community than you have with your pedantry and vitriol by maintaining a blog https://jeremykun.com/ https://jeremykun.com/ with literally reams of interesting mathematical content that is simultaneously exciting /and/ rigorous. and furthermore iirc jeremy was originally a math ed phd student so i trust his opinion of the right way to teach math infinitely more than i do yours mr random internet physics guy. next time think twice before posting this kind of lowbrow mean shit.
- hyeomans 8y agoI'm grateful for OP opinion and your opinion. I agree with you except in "next time think twice...", I think that opinion trigger your response which was great! Enjoy your weekend, both of you!
- theoh 8y ago"wtf is wrong with hn" One thing that's wrong with HN is that perceived "negativity" often gets condemned in exactly the way you have done here. It seems as if a significant number of HN readers have never really participated in a spirited discussion with arguments made from multiple different perspectives. Maybe any kind of apparent conflict scares them, maybe they project their own aggression onto a comment that seems to go against the grain of the discussion. It will never change.
- Brakenshire 8y agoI personally think this is exactly wrong. Most people struggle with Maths because they don’t have the implicit understanding that books like you’re talking about rely on. It’s like telling a novice programmer to read the documentation. I’m not sure how successful this book is but it seems a worthy attempt.
- andrepd 8y agoThat's not at all the point I was trying to make. Indeed, if you check my other comment, both the books I give as an example have precisely the feature of being self-contained. Landau's Mechanics starts with the basic concept of a particle. Cohen-Tannoudji's Quantum Mechanics starts with the simplest possible description of the double-slit experiment. Again, they assume no prior knowledge about what they are trying to teach (wouldn't be much of a textbook about the subject if it did require previous knowledge about the subject, now would it? :))
- pcein 8y agoThe counterparts of these books in the mathematical domain may be self-contained with respect to the subject matter, but you fail to consider the fact that most of them require a high degree of mathematical sophistication and are really targeted at people who have already acquired the required level of intuition. The "self-contained" nature of these books is deceptive - they might start with some innocent looking stuff about counting, integers etc and very soon drill deep into abstract stuff through complex chains of reasoning which a beginner will find extremely dry, bewildering and unfathomable. When you are a total beginner and trying to learn a subject through self-study, you are more likely to appreciate a book in which the author tries to recreate the experience of sitting in a classroom and listening to a professor holding your hand and showing you stuff from various angles.
- westoncb 8y agoThere is a common category of misguided book review that the parent comment falls under: the reviewer has some particular things they are looking for from a book and fails to see that there are more uses for it than their own; so they generalize, reading the book's failures to meet their personal criteria as a failure intrinsic in the book's content, and mistakenly lambaste the work. > 19 pages of droning before you start with something concrete. One person's "droning" may be another person's "rare, illuminating presentation"; we are not all interested in the same things. I can offer another perspective that what the author wrote on polynomials within the first 19 pages there is in fact pretty unique and interesting. > Imprecise definitions. This defeats the purpose of learning mathematics. The commenter is again taking a minority viewpoint and baselessly extending it. There is a special kind of paranoia that often manifests in discussions of mathematical pedagogy that any departure from perfect rigor will weaken the minds of students. This is a blatantly shallow and one-sided view of things: the fact that rigor has value does not imply that the most effective method of teaching—which is a matter of both mathematics and human psychology—is to offer nothing but the most rigorous presentation possible. This particular book is explicitly targeted at helping to transition programmers into mathematics. Given that goal, do you really think the pedagogically superior approach would be to offer a more rigorous definition of polynomial than: "A single variable polynomial with real coefficients is a function f that takes a real number as input, produces a real number as output, and has the form: f(x) = a0 + a1x + a2x^2 + ... + anx^n" —in the introductory chapter of the book? I would urge potential readers to take the parent comment with a grain of salt. And also, if you're among this book's target audience and trying to teach yourself mathematics, be aware of such personalities preaching this particular dogma of mathematical instruction: it's fairly common on the internet. But it basically represents the same corner of the mathematics world as that of the programming world where folks insist on using nothing but VI/Emacs on Linux with C++ and/or Haskell, and are all too ready to belittle any alternatives perceived as softer/weaker. These aren't necessarily the most impressive programmers—they just project the most intimidating auras. Don't let their counterparts in mathematics scare you off.
- andrepd 8y ago>One person's "droning" may be another person's "rare, illuminating presentation"; we are not all interested in the same things. You are absolutely correct in that regard. I've talked to many people who hated the textbooks I most liked, and preferred ones that I found unreadable. Just goes to show that what works for you may not work for me. You are very wrong on the other point: none of what I said is borne out of a view that mathematics should be difficult and "hard" an impenetrable (rather than soft and approachable). Indeed I view this sort of overlong prose as impenetrable and confusing, and the succinct style of e.g. Landau textbooks much clearer (see my other comment). >The commenter is again taking a minority viewpoint and baselessly extending it. This is not a minority viewpoint. I'd daresay is the majority opinion among mathematicians. It is also the opinion of prominent computer scientists: Dijkstra, Leslie Lamport, Donald Knuth, to name a few off the top of my head. It is also plainly true: mathematics is about rigour. It is not an obstacle, nor is it an end in itself, but it is a fundamental part of mathematical study and reasoning. If you aren't being rigorous, you're not doing mathematics, it's just a waste of time. I'll let Michael Spivak speak for me: "In addition to developing the students’ intuition [...], it is important to persuade them that precision and rigor are neither deterrents to intuition, nor ends in themselves, but the natural medium in which to formulate and think about mathematical questions." >be aware of such personalities preaching this particular dogma of mathematical instruction: it's fairly common on the internet. But it basically represents the same corner of the mathematics world as that of the programming world where folks insist on using nothing but VI/Emacs on Linux with C++ and/or Haskell Completely nonsensical comparison (C++ and Haskell?? two languages who could not be further apart), and again, not in the least bit what I mean with my criticism.
- ReidZB 8y agoI'd recommend reading Tao's blog post "There’s more to mathematics than rigour and proofs": https://terrytao.wordpress.com/career-advice/theres-more-to-mathematics-than-rigour-and-proofs/ https://terrytao.wordpress.com/career-advice/theres-more-to-...