9 ms·
New York’s Wealthiest Cut Losses as Manhattan Real Estate Falters
- code4tee 8y agoThe high end of the NYC real estate market was always just effectively made up big numbers. $15 million home, $25 million home. It’s hard to objectively assign real values to such places. Frankly though if you can’t afford to blow a few million on the speculative ultra high end market then you have no business owning such properties. While all NYC area real estate is pricy, outside the ultra high end stuff the market isn’t seeing such fluctuations.
- ChuckMcM 8y agoExcept that in the article it said that even the sub-million dollar homes were being pushed down by the same forces. Tax law changes, higher interest rates, and currency controls on foreign buyers means it costs more in real wealth to buy a home, so the prices shrink to match. (or they don't shrink and the houses just stay on the market)
- projectramo 8y agoI thought the article said the sub-million market was pushed down by different forces. Below million market was pushed down by interest rates. The over million market was pushed down by capital controls on foreign buyers and tax law changes. This seems to support what the OP was saying.
- gist 8y ago> While all NYC area real estate is pricy A good way to see how atypical NYC pricing is is to take a look at what a house right next to the road that leads to JFK airport will cost you. I think spot checking 4 bedrooms was like $600k (when I checked years ago). The same amount will get you a super nice suburban house (with a lawn in a nice neighborhood and school district) in many other places. Not next to a heavily traveled freeway.
- ummonk 8y agoI mean, that seems like a steal by Bay Area standards.
- neom 8y agoI moved to Manhattan 10 years ago and it's been really sad to watch the decline, both in commercial and residential, more and more full city blocks of store fronts sit empty, and friends who have bought homes are experiencing a depreciation in their investments. Wealthy folks from outside the US have or had a "cottage" in Manhattan, but people are trying to sell their 2nd or 3rd houses, and people are not buying a 2rd or 3rd house. My biggest concern, however, is if the changes in weather and environment are going to impact this Island.
- usaphp 8y ago> more and more full city blocks of store fronts sit empty Hmm, which part of manhattan are you talking about? Living in the upper east side I don’t notice any change at all
- neom 8y agoFrom what I've seen if you walk up Broadway from Houston it is getting worse and worse, I think generally between 1st and 6th above Houston but lower than 14th is thinning (I realize that's a fairly large area)
- notyourday 8y agoThat's just historic leases and options to extend running out. Lets presume the commercial leases on storefronts are 10 years with an option for another 10. The holdouts that you are seeing signed leases in 1998-1999. They are still paying 1998-1999 rents with a slight YOY escalation. That's how Pearl River Mart was able to afford its place. 1999 that section of Manhattan was a dump. Here's a walk down the memory lane: * In 1997 my girlfriend at the time bought a two floor condo in Park Slope (2,400 sq feet) for $220,000. Her friends told her that she overpaid. * In 1999 a friend of mine had her generation skipping trust buy two buildings in Soho next to each other for $1.27M. They had to modify trust documents because with that buy trust was over exposed to real estate. * In 1999 apartments on Broome St in Soho were lofts with the kind of showers one would expect in the third world countries. 5-6 artists would live in one because they split 3000 sq foot one floor apartment 5 ways for a grand total of $1200/mo. Residential leases are simply too short which is why we do not see the massive spikes in rents as the lease is being re-negotiated the way we see them in commercial real estate.
- baybal2 8y agoI think Manhattan real estate is overpriced. The price should be lowered. And about "high-end dominated markets." I think it's true that there is simply not enough of billionaires and Saudi sheikhs to fill 10 million bucks apartment buildings, and there are simply too many places in the world competing for billionaire level clientele. People developing such projects are too optimistic, and omit that they will never make money on them because there are too many ifs in their plans. Simple demand/supply math is not on their side, and they lack any unique advantages to lure away wealthy buyers from other places. From all above, I conclude that high-end real estate is a very, very, very risky business. News coverage, and popular public stereotypes also play a role there. In case of Shenzhen for example, the press is happy to report that average price continues its surreal non-stop growth, while completely forgetting to mention that the median price was going down for at least 5 years. The high-end of the market is being dominated by big name speculators, and low-end with "moms and pops investors."
- CydeWeys 8y ago> I think Manhattan real estate is overpriced. The price should be lowered. NYC isn't a centrally managed economy. Things are worth precisely what people are willing to pay for them. There's no way to force prices down. And you thinking it's overpriced doesn't matter when others are willing to pay those prices. Clearly that means that price is accurate, you're just not willing to pay it.
- defterGoose 8y agoI think you may be confusing what people are "willing" to pay and what people are "forced" to pay. We do not operate in "free market"
- cultus 8y agoThis is good news for the vast majority of people in NYC. The same thing is happening in Seattle where I live, and I'm thrilled.
- TomVDB 8y agoStarting to happen here as well. My South Bay neighborhood: 8 months ago, a 1300 sqft 3 bed/2 bath sold for a staggering $2.4M. It’s still being renovated. They almost tore the whole place down with only outer walls and roof standing. Last week, a 1500 sqft 4 bed/2 bath just a few houses down the road went under contract for $2M, after multiple price reductions.
- jonknee 8y agoIt's a poor headline as it's not just the wealthiest: > But agents said the slowdown extends beyond new condos, hitting every segment of the market. While the cooling is more significant at the high-end, smaller units also are affected. In the third quarter, the median price for a one-bedroom Manhattan home was $815,000, down 4% from the same period in 2017. The volume of sales fell 12.7%. > “What’s most significant about 2018 is that even the sub-$1 million market is slowing because of rising mortgage rates,” said appraiser Jonathan Miller. Rates for a 30-year mortgage averaged 4.81% in late November, up nearly a full percentage point from the beginning of the year, according to Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. Higher interest rates and lack of SALT deduction are a big double whammy for the non uber-wealthy (who can afford to move to optimize taxes).
- hendersoon 8y agoHigher interest rates are fine if you're looking to buy, more expensive money means cheaper housing. That's what's happening here. People forget that interest rates aren't _normally_ 0% as they've been for most of the past decade. Losing the SALT deduction really burns, though. That's new.
- hackeraccount 8y agoFor all the talk of wanting to stick it to the rich SALT is what the Democrats are going after. When the Democrats are in a position to write their own tax bill, there will be 3 times as many brackets, the top bracket will be 90% and - as a "compromise" they'll bring back SALT.
- ummonk 8y agoAny way to get around the paywall?
- badrequest 8y agoPaying.
- hasperdi 8y agoOr not paying... https://outline.com/v4EbyE https://outline.com/v4EbyE
- jonknee 8y agoYou can redirect through Facebook and read it: https://www.facebook.com/flx/warn/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.wsj.com%2Farticles%2Fnew-yorks-wealthiest-cut-losses-as-manhattan-real-estate-falters-1543508960 https://www.facebook.com/flx/warn/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.wsj.c...
- projectramo 8y agoAs far as I can remember -- my entire adult life -- I've heard about this great real estate bubble in the big cities. Every year I hear NYC and SF are about to crash because the growth is not sustainable. I assume this myth has been around much longer. Perhaps people know what was being said or written in 90s, 80s, 70s and 60s. But in spite of all this, in spite of temporary slow downs and slight blips, the broader market just becomes more and more expensive. Numbers that seem to make no sense, or seemed absurd even 5 years ago get blown past. I don't know what the reason is, but I would love to read a truly satisfactory explanation for this.
- acct1771 8y agoMoney laundering and export of funds from stricter home countries. Chinese and Saudi Arabians own a very large portion of our country.
- projectramo 8y agoI should add that I find data quite convincing. I hear arguments like the one you state but I don't find them convincing. This is for several reasons: 1. Saudis feel quite unwelcome in the US, and prefer to buy homes in London. 2. New York is so far that a Chinese billionaire would prefer something on the other coast. Especially in Canada where they don't have to pay taxes on worldwide income if they establish residence. And without data, this is just an impression based on fragments of articles. I still haven't seen data for the Chinese buyers in Vancouver, and that is a far easier case to make.
- acct1771 8y ago...who'd be collating that race data on homebuyers? Good luck. Link it if you find it.
- ghobs91 8y agoThe demand side of it is that with every decade, the midwest's manufacturing economy shrinks, and more of their population empties out into the coastal cities. The supply side of the problem is detailed here: https://i.redd.it/ibo81s465yy11.png https://i.redd.it/ibo81s465yy11.png
- ep103 8y agoThere's been a predicted glut of luxury apartment condos for years now, as all the new luxury buildings on the 50s start coming online. Add in increased Chinese export vigilence, tariff wars, slowing economy, and the tax overhaul that targeted blue states, and of course the multi-multi-millionaire apartments and condos are taking a hit. The thing is, and this article leaves out, is that that luxury apartment glut was originally expected to last 3-5 years. Then rising population rates and etc were supposed to take over again. So your sub-million dollar condos might take a hit for the next few years, but barring another economic recession or crash, its probably just temporary (read, possibly a good time to buy). For truly high $ places, where all the other things on the list of causes above will have much more effect, it might be worth sitting out for a while.
- JimboOmega 8y agoI don't know about NYC, but in SF, $1M is a very reasonable price for a condo for a non-1%er. If you and your partner are both in tech and want to get a two bedroom, for instance. I definitely wouldn't put the threshold for uber-rich money parking or buying a pied a terre at $1M
- neonate 8y agohttps://outline.com/v4EbyE https://outline.com/v4EbyE
- NTDF9 8y agoI don't see why this is not obvious to most people. The rich get outsized benefit of compounding, outsized benefit of money managers saving their losses in every bust, outsized benefit of buying assets at rock bottom prices and then outsized benefit of compounding again. Every single cycle, the rich get richer because of their resources. How is this not obvious? The problem is not wages. The problem is richness from speculation.