10 ms·
The US saw similar efforts in Detroit and other Rust Belt cities. That mostly just resulted in asset flippers hoarding houses and letting them fall into further
by bobthepanda 8y ago
The US saw similar efforts in Detroit and other Rust Belt cities. That mostly just resulted in asset flippers hoarding houses and letting them fall into further disrepair. I wonder what steps Japan is taking to mitigate that possibility.
- dev_dull 8y agoSource? When I looked into buying an “abandoned” house, the city used a bizarre tax calculation that used historical values to value the house (and it’s tax liabilties) in a bizarre and costly way.
- bobthepanda 8y agohttps://www.reuters.com/article/usa-detroit-housing/cheap-detroit-homes-are-costly-for-communities-unwary-buyers-idUSL2N0DV2RE20130703 https://www.reuters.com/article/usa-detroit-housing/cheap-de... I was never talking about the taxes, just the sticker price for the house. Japan doesn't seem to be waiving property tax for these houses, either, so the comparison is still valid.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- coldtea 8y agoOnly a property in Detroit in the deserted areas could mean frequent meetings with muggings, violence, etc. In Japan it will just be a regular house.
- rmason 8y agoActually if you look at what happened to the majority of homes that were rehabbed that's not the case. Most of them were in the downtown area and crime actually went down. Grant you there were urban pioneers that chose less than desirable areas but they were the exception. In Detroit the formal program run by the city that gave away houses mandated that they be rehabbed and inhabited by the person receiving them for a minimum of five years. Then there's the Land Bank that buys the houses, then rehabs them and sells them at auction. Know some people who've gotten really good buys, some houses sell below the Land Bank's cost. https://buildingdetroit.org/?SID=kqj4u36nhvgh8e54pm6v434ai5 https://buildingdetroit.org/?SID=kqj4u36nhvgh8e54pm6v434ai5
- samstave 8y agoSo, what if you purchased these with the express intent to tear them down and install pre-built tiny-homes on them. So you effectively get a plot of land, with service-hookups and low property taxes. but you can install beautiful, yet-tiny home on it. http://windrivertinyhomes.com http://windrivertinyhomes.com has amazing units.
- rmason 8y agoNo need, there are thousands of acres of vacant land in Detroit. Complete with city water, sewer and brand new led powered street lamps. There are lots of experiments including a proposed hotel made entirely from shipping containers. Last I checked you can buy a vacant lot for $100 and they'd probably give you a discount if you bought an entire city block.
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoI have lived in crappy neighborhoods[1][2]. Violence is not likely to be an issue as long as you don't inject yourselves into your neighbors' business it's really not the big deal the upper classes make it out to be with all their hand wringing. Violent crime doesn't really happen that often per capita (i.e. odds are it will never happen to you). Not getting involved with drugs is like 90% of the battle. If you do get unlucky and encounter crime it's probably going to take the form of someone stealing something from your yard. I think you either need to already be comfortable living somewhere like that in order to do so stress free. [1] https://www.neighborhoodscout.com/ma/fitchburg/crime https://www.neighborhoodscout.com/ma/fitchburg/crime [2] https://www.neighborhoodscout.com/ma/new-bedford/crime https://www.neighborhoodscout.com/ma/new-bedford/crime Edit: This reminds me of every time crappy minimum wage jobs come up. I have first hand experience with and offer my opinion but then get told that I have no idea what I'm talking about. The filter bubble is real.
- pitt1980 8y agoThis is a single person thing (especially a single male thing) as a single male, I can reliable predict that I can mind my own business and probably be fine as a parent, I can't reliably predict that my kids will mind their own business and probably be fine
- fromthestart 8y agoYou've clearly never lived in a shitty neighborhood.
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoYes I have[1][2]. It's really not bad unless you drive yourself nuts worrying about things that will probably never happen to you. Yes, you see and hear the effects of crime everywhere but as long as your not know by your neighbors to be an ass, your house is harder to rob than most of the nearby ones and you don't associate with the wrong people you'll be fine. It's not like there's stray bullets coming through your walls once a week (if there are odds are it will be the police who fired them, not that it makes it any better). If you're the person who freaks out over some people in the street getting in a fight or a gunshot a few blocks over then yeah, it's gonna be bad. [1] https://www.neighborhoodscout.com/ma/fitchburg/crime https://www.neighborhoodscout.com/ma/fitchburg/crime (this one is the "nicer" of the two by a long ways, has come a long way since the recession. I would have no problem raising a family here) [2] https://www.neighborhoodscout.com/ma/new-bedford/crime https://www.neighborhoodscout.com/ma/new-bedford/crime (this one won the "award" of #1 crime rate in the state a few years back)
- ransom1538 8y agoDetroit: If you have a credit card and a want to own an apartment building, it is the place to be. Just needs some elbow grease. There MUST BE opportunity at $5 USD per square foot -- but it is hard to visualize. https://www.point2homes.com/US/Multi-Family-For-Sale/MI/Detroit/Durfee/3707-WAGER-Street/51690101.html https://www.point2homes.com/US/Multi-Family-For-Sale/MI/Detr... [I think you can talk this guy down to $10k].
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- discordianfish 8y agoIf they’d throw in a working visa I’d be intrigued
- mywittyname 8y agoStarting a construction / rehab company might work.
- toomuchtodo 8y agoThis is how you build "new cities" [1]; pair startups with working visas and tie it together with funding and resource commitments (cough cough PlanGrid et el) to bring dilapidated housing back into inventory. Inexpensive corporate housing with you bootstrapping the culture and the community core. [1] https://cities.ycr.org/ https://cities.ycr.org/
- dahdum 8y agoIf you could pull that off, sounds like an incredible program to me. I don't think anything could revitalize Detroit like large amounts of immigrants would.
- monocasa 8y agoAnd Detroit already has a large immigrant population, so it's not that much of a culture shock.
- agumonkey 8y agoJapan is a peculiar country, I'd bet a few dollars that they won't abuse the system that much.
- masklinn 8y agoHouses depreciate quickly and I don't know that land appreciates at a very high rate, so there isn't much to abuse in the first place. And because japan's zoning is not completely stupid, redevelopment can be done piecemeal. So if you buy to flip, either you flip very quickly for little to no gain or you don't and the neighbourhood gets redeveloped around and without caring about your property, which will likely be too small for anyone to be much bothered. The exceptions could likely be significant plot of lands like old temple grounds and the like which could sustain an entire development on its own.
- yardie 8y agoIt's a lot more complex than that. Usually these deals have tax liabilities and liens that aren't chargeable unless the city agrees to it. Anyone can tell you, there is nothing more expensive than a free house/boat/car.
- rzzzt 8y agoWhy don't they sell it at a discount, then?
- yardie 8y agoThese are usually handled through city property auctions. Bidding usually starts at a few dollars. But you have to read the fine print. They will usually have city, county, state, federal, and private liens on them. For example a federal treasury auction will discharge IRS tax liens but not state, county, and city charges. I've seen $1mm beach-side homes auctioned for <$100k. But then have $500k+ in state liens on them. A savvy buyer will get the titles and try to get the liens discharged by negotiating with the other agencies or pay them off. This is factored into the offer they will make on the property. If you think you've stumbled into a method to get rich quick you're sadly mistaken.
- seansmccullough 8y agoThey do, but you still have to pay the back taxes, which in a lot of cases are more than what you paid for the property.
- dionidium 8y agoSt. Louis is the market I’m most familiar with, but I’m sure it’s the same everywhere: it’s not just taxes and liens; it’s that most of the properties are worth less than the cost of making them habitable. Every municipality has occupancy requirements and building codes. Any house you can buy for $100 in Detroit is going to cost roughly the same (or more) as new construction to meet these codes. In St. Louis, for example, you’re required to present construction plans and hard timelines as a condition for purchasing abandoned property. They aren’t going to accept your optimistic DIY dreams. They have to be real plans at market rates. And if you don’t meet the agreed-to dates, you lose the property. A lot of these properties literally have a negative value; it would cost more to renovate them and complete environmental mitigations on them than is profitable. When you see a property for $100, you almost certainly wouldn’t want it unless you were paid to take it. Use common sense; there’s a reason these properties were completely abandoned by their previous owners.
- rb808 8y agoI've seen programs like these where you have to live in the house, which is a good solution.
- natalyarostova 8y agoAs an object level fact, Japan has a homogeneous culture centered around honor, which is much different from Detroit.
- Pica_soO 8y agoWhere the culture is all centered around respect.
- innocentoldguy 8y agoIt's much less so today than it was when I first went to Japan back in the 80s. Still, the culture supports vending machines lining the streets and not a single little shit vandalizing them in sight.
- natalyarostova 8y agoIn Kyoto the free, public bathroom, in the middle of the city, was cleaner than my own bathroom. Whereas in Seattle I won't use one for fear of syringes.
- innocentoldguy 8y agoI agree! I lived in Bellevue for a while back in the 1990s. One day, I was taking my family to Snoqualmie Falls and my three-year-old had to go to the bathroom. We stopped at a gas station in Issaquah and when I opened the door, it looked like people had just pulled down their pants in the doorway and splatter-shot into the room. It was so disgusting. I don't know what it is about American culture that makes that OK. I've never seen anything like that in Japan.
- OpenBSD-reich2 8y agoIt's America's lax immigration policy toward third worlders, and leftover cultural enrichment from the slave trades.
- wavefunction 8y agoI doubt that, I guess. I checked into the program in Detroit and you had to live in the property for a year. Now maybe people got around that somehow but that's not how the program was structured.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- pastor_elm 8y agoThe layouts of those suburbs are terrible. State should have just tried at least to make some greenbelts of those areas.
- golemiprague 8y agoIn Japan it is very common to destroy a house and build a new one on the land, construction is fast and zoning is very lax. A lot of old houses are sold for destruction and when I say old I mean 50 years, it is the normal way in Japan. The problem with those houses that the government offer is their location, it is usually remote places where there is no chance for gentrification like in Detroit which is still almost a million people city. There is also a cultural difference, Japanese just keep their environment neat and clean, you need to see Japanese homeless tents to understand. In Japan mostly everybody are from the same culture and adhere to those unwritten rules. Homogenous society has certain advantages over diversity in contrast to what is hammered into our head continuously in the west for certain political reasons.
- mikekchar 8y agoIt's not easy to asset flip in Japan. I have no idea about this program. I live in Japan and I haven't heard about it, so I'm not sure what the deal is. However, people in Japan don't buy used houses. Due to the large number of earthquakes, etc, older houses are felt to be unsafe. A house on a property is actually a liability because the new owner will have to knock down the house in order to build a new one. I'm absolutely certain that the abandoned houses are abandoned because they are literally not saleable. Even perfectly good houses that were built in the last 20 or 30 years sit on the housing market in my area for years before they even get a single offer. Houses that cost $300K end up selling for around half that price, even after waiting for years to sell it. That's how non-existent the used housing market is in Japan. And this is not to say that housing is flat. Empty lots sell relatively quickly. Nobody wants a used house. That's the reality of the market. I don't know exactly what this programme is, but I would venture to guess that they will give you the house/land as long as you knock down the existing house and build a new one. This will cost you the aforementioned $300K, at which point you can flip it for $150K. That's how they mitigate that possibility :-)
- neic 8y agoWhat reasons do people have for not wanting a perfectly good 20-30 year old house for half the price of a new one?
- zik 8y agoEarthquakes are commonplace in Japan. You don't want an older house which may be structurally compromised.
- mikekchar 8y agoI think that is the main reason. But also, people buy houses at different times of life in Japan. Often it's people nearing retirement, buying the "dream house". They want exactly what they want. It's a bit of a vicious circle, but people don't/can't do "starter homes" because you can't sell them. Another common practice is to inherit your parent's or grandparent's house, knock it down and build a new one. So the same family will live in the same location for many generations, but they will rebuild the house in order to adapt to changing needs. I think this reflects the rapid rise in wealth in Japanese society. Before WWII, Japan was quite a poor country. From WWII onwards, Japan went from absolute poverty (where everything was flattened by the war) to the second largest economy on the planet (now, edged out by China for that honour). So every 20-30 years represented a major upgrade in housing. I'm finding that in my area in the last 10 years used houses are getting slightly more popular. Certainly for me, when I eventually stop jetting back and forth between the UK and Japan I will buy a used house. A 20 year old house is still rated for a level 7 earthquake and I think they are perfectly good. I would say that at least 30% of my neighbours are over 60, so housing is going to be extremely easy to acquire (though still not a good investment).
- ben_netanyahu 8y agothe detroit situation happened because of immigration of blacks to the north. It's actually a great predictor of what will happen in Europe instead of in Japan.