3 ms·
There has been a staggering amount of research over the decades on this topic. And there are countless real world examples in particular within business and pol
by threeseed 8y ago
There has been a staggering amount of research over the decades on this topic. And there are countless real world examples in particular within business and politics which support the conclusions of the research. Simply that quotas work and encouragement doesn't.
So thank you anonymous guy for trying to prove the opposite with no facts or evidence. And maybe in a century or so when we have eradicated systemic sexism and racism it might be a more interesting conversation to have. But for now I prefer to stick to the facts and methods that are proven to work.
- zimablue 8y ago"Works" according to what definition of working? Works to create a gender balance that you assume a priori is "correct" with any deviation being down to evil discrimination? Or do you have some more interesting definition?
- k___ 8y agoA cursory google search that took 30 seconds. FT: Diversity bring boost to profitability: https://www.ft.com/content/1bc22040-1302-11e7-80f4-13e067d5072c https://www.ft.com/content/1bc22040-1302-11e7-80f4-13e067d50... McKinsey: Why Diversity Matters https://www.mckinsey.com/business-functions/organization/our-insights/why-diversity-matters https://www.mckinsey.com/business-functions/organization/our... Academic paper based on multiple case studies: https://www.emeraldinsight.com/doi/full/10.1108/SHR-10-2017-0068 https://www.emeraldinsight.com/doi/full/10.1108/SHR-10-2017-... It is head-smackingly obvious that a wide variety of experiences at senior management level leads to broader market fit, which leads to better products, which leads to larger number of sales targets which leads to greater profitability and growth and has the side effect of reducing HR complaints, increasing inclusivity and making work more enjoyable for everyone.
- sheepmullet 8y ago> It is head-smackingly obvious that a wide variety of experiences at senior management level leads to Is it? Many of the companies with board level quotas aren’t particularly efficient.
- Sacho 8y agoThe first link is behind a paywall so I couldn't access it. The second link is some good research, demonstrating a correlation between diversity and profitability. I was hoping to find within it an analysis of possible confounding factors - for example, what if profitable companies can afford to initiate "diversity and inclusion" campaigns and institute quotas, which would turn the causality the other way around(higher profits -> more diversity), rather than the researchers' explanation(more diversity -> higher profits). Unfortunately there doesn't seem to be any such analysis in the paper. Is this the full text of the third link? https://www.emeraldinsight.com/doi/pdfplus/10.1108/SHR-10-2017-0068 https://www.emeraldinsight.com/doi/pdfplus/10.1108/SHR-10-20... The link is more of an article on what diversity and inclusion is, and how to measure its benefits, rather than research that shows those benefits.
- zimablue 8y agoSo you've picked a metric "profitability". First one paywall, third one no evidence, second one correlation causation. It's head smackingly obvious that the most profitable companies tend to be the largest/most publically visible, and the most vulnerable to lobbying for quotas, and with the most ability (since their profit is based on being a big boy who can extract rent) to implement whatever is socially desired at the time. Take tech, look at the most profitable companies, they're also the biggest, they're also the most lobbied. Per your final comment, the job of senior executives is not always, (or even normally?) focussed on market research/product. Old Apple being the famous exception. There's gap between your prose and how watertight the evidence you presented is.
- dr_teh 8y agoThe onus is on you to prove that quotas outperform skill-based hiring. Sorry, but d'uh.
- threeseed 8y agoThat's the beauty of having a large sample size. There are examples everywhere. Look at political parties which imposed forms of quotas e.g. UK and Australian Labour. They have extremely high levels of female MPs versus alternative parties. Or look at corporate boards and executives across many countries. Almost all have seen improvements in female participation: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gender_representation_on_corporate_boards_of_directors#Gender_quotas https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gender_representation_on_corpo...
- antientropic 8y agoIsn't that pretty much tautological? Yes, if you impose gender quota, then you're obviously going to get more women. The empirical question is whether the organization is better off as a result.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- sheepmullet 8y ago> They have extremely high levels of female MPs versus alternative parties. And having more women MPs instead of men has done what exactly for their countries? I don’t think anyone has particularly great things to say about either countries Labour parties.
- arethuza 8y agoMeanwhile in other threads we often discuss how the hiring process is broken for technical positions - what makes us think that hiring in other fields is any better?
- ElBarto 8y agoIf by 'work' you mean that quotas lead to more women in the targeted roles then that's obvious... But actually solving these issues (whether real or perceived) means not having quotas.
- throwawayXH3eol 8y ago> There has been a staggering amount of research over the decades on this topic I'm very much interested in reading about this. I'd be very thankful if you were to provide a few references :)
- raxxorrax 8y agoquotas don't really work and are injust. You don't even know the condition for success, so I doubt there could exists data that would support your assumption in any way.
- klohto 8y ago> trying to prove the opposite with no facts or evidence You're doing exactly the same. You have provided no evidence or facts. > There has been a staggering amount of research over the decades on this topic Great, so provide it.
- threeseed 8y ago> https://aicd.companydirectors.com.au/membership/the-boardroom-report/volume-15-issue-3/lets-talk-about-quotas https://aicd.companydirectors.com.au/membership/the-boardroo... Since introduction of quotas, Italy saw women's representation soar from 8% to 32%, France from 21% to 38% and on average the world saw a growth of 5% from 2012 to 2015. > https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Women_in_government#Quotas https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Women_in_government#Quotas Of the top-ranked 20 countries in terms of female representation in government, 17 of these countries utilize some sort of quota system to ensure female inclusion.
- kjjjzzzz7zg 8y agoObviously, if you implement a quota, the representation will rise. That says nothing about the side effects, or even the motivation of women to aim for higher careers in general. As for the research showing higher profitability for diverse teams: a lot if it is about diversity of thought, not diversity of genders. But even if you take gender into account, you have to also consider economic trends. Businesses that flourish might simply be more able to afford women (who are more costly employees than men, if only because of the sick days and higher likelihood to drop out because of pregnancy). So the correlation would actually be inverse (success would cause more female employees, not the other way round). Or think about oil industry vs tech industry. Fewer women work in mining, but the tech industry was exceptionally successful in recent years. It might just be a random artifact that more women work in tech than in mining, and tech happened to be more successful. If you look at such papers, always pay attention to the interval they use for claiming "more success". If they say "from 2009 to 2016 diverse companies were more successful", bet you ass that if you look at the data from 2000 to 2018, the correlation fades away.
- sheepmullet 8y ago
- dekken_ 8y agoQuotas are the definition of discrimination
- kjjjzzzz7zg 8y agoA lot of that research is just "research", or at the very least jumping to conclusions. Like finding that "women earn less than men on average", but then jumping to the erroneous conclusion that there must be discrimination against women at work. That kind of pattern is visible in almost every feminist paper. Even if the research is legitimate (for example it IS interesting that women earn less than men on average - clearly something is going on), they end up with jumping to some conclusion that they always wanted to prove to begin with.
- zinid 8y ago> Simply that quotas work and encouragement doesn't I wonder what other outcome one might expect from quotas.
- belorn 8y agoIf the research and conclusions are that clear, lets make it a law. To give that some perspective with Swedish data; 87.4% of men and 87.6% of women has a professions position that is gender segregated. Out of the top five worst offenders four is dominated by women. In higher education there one program that is currently fully dominated by a single gender and that one is 100% women. It would be interesting to see what would happen if a law demand gender quotas for those ~90% of work places. If we assume a linear distribution where the average work place has a gender ratio of 80:20, about 18% of every employed person in Sweden would then get their job through the gender quota law which is then about a half million women and men. That would make for a fascinating social experiment.