13 ms·
I worked for financial traders for a few years before I wised up. It was at least refreshingly honest; during the hiring process, my boss explained that the com
by wpietri 8y ago
I worked for financial traders for a few years before I wised up. It was at least refreshingly honest; during the hiring process, my boss explained that the company had a pile of money and our goal was to turn it into a bigger pile. But what I didn't understand was that mostly we made money when other people lost it. We turned a profit by being smarter or faster or luckier than the people we traded with.
I ended up leaving mainly because it was an unhealthy, high-pressure environment where a lot of the most celebrated people were giant dicks. But I stayed away because I realized that we weren't making anything better. We just situated ourselves near a river of (other people's) money and tried to siphon off a bit of the flow. It was depressing.
I'm glad I never went back. I honestly think the finance industry could be half the size it is with no real harm to the rest of the economy. And given what a mess the 2008 crisis was, trimming the industry way back might be overall beneficial.
- gronne 8y agoSame reason(s) i stopped pursuing a career in finance. The percentage of the financial sector (mbe not including direct investors like vc’s) that is actually beneficial to markets and society can be counted on one hand.
- hacker_9 8y agoAs a counterpoint I work in finance and work with a group of smart people that all check their egos in at the door. It's a great place to work. We also try to turn money into more money, it's pretty much the game of life whether you play it or not. It pays really well so I can't complain. Is the job fulfilling? Depends on your goals - for me I've gained a huge knowledge of low level programming, and front line experience on how far one can go with both software and hardware to 'win' against other competitors in the space. That's invaluable stuff for me. Is the job moral? Anyone who puts their money on the line knows the risks, this isn't stealing from the poor. People who invest must understand risk, and risk is really the only way things move forward in the first place. But it also implies there can and will be people who lose out.
- sigi45 8y agoWin against whom? People with less knowledge. Less technology. There should not be an additional layer of risk involved only because people bet on other people. If I buy a share from company x, the success of that company should represent the share price. But that is partially true. And NO enough people have no idea what they are doing. In Germany we increased the requirements for trading. You have to read stuff and sign off otherwise the bank will not allow you to buy certain products. Is the job moral? No.
- quanticle 8y agoIn Germany we increased the requirements for trading. You have to read stuff and sign off otherwise the bank will not allow you to buy certain products. We have that in the US too. While ordinary "retail" investors can buy stocks and bonds (which they can do in Germany too, I presume), most of the "exotic" products that people complain about are restricted to "accredited" investors. In order to be an accredited investor in the US, you have to be one of the following: - a bank, insurance company, registered investment company, business development company, or small business investment company - an employee benefit plan, within the meaning of the Employee Retirement Income Security Act, if a bank, insurance company or registered investment adviser makes the investment decisions, or if the plan has total assets in excess of 5,000,000 dollars - a charitable organization, corporation, or partnership with assets exceeding 5,000,000 dollars - a director, general officer, or partner of the company selling the securities - a business in which all the equity owners are accredited investors - a natural person who has individual net worth or joint net worth with the person's spouse that exceeds 1,000,000 dollars at the time of purchase or has assets under management of 1,000,000 dollars or above, excluding the value of the individual's primary residence - a natural person with income exceeding 200,000 dollars per year in each of the two most recent years or joint income with a spouse exceeding 300,000 dollars per year in those years and a reasonable expectation of the same income level for the current year - a trust with assets in excess of 5,000,000 dollars not formed to acquire the securities offered whose purchases a sophisticated person makes So as you can see, there are already quite stringent requirements for trading most "exotic" derivatives in the US. You either have to be a millionaire, have the backing of an institution, have government certification or all of the above in order to trade things like mortgage-backed securities and government bonds. I have zero ethical qualms about winning when I know that the other people I'm competing against are millionaires, have institutional backing, have government approval or all of the above.
- beejiu 8y ago> I honestly think the finance industry could be half the size It is strange that an industry whose only purpose is to service the productive economy should be 20% of GDP. Here's an interesting take of the downsides to having such a large financial sector within an economy: https://www.theguardian.com/news/2018/oct/05/the-finance-curse-how-the-outsized-power-of-the-city-of-london-makes-britain-poorer https://www.theguardian.com/news/2018/oct/05/the-finance-cur...
- tonyedgecombe 8y agoTo be fair that's not all on the back of the UK, finance is an international business in the UK.
- taneq 8y agoThe human brain consumes 20% of our total energy budget in exchange for allocating our resources, so maybe it's not too out-of-whack?
- kochikame 8y agoNot really a good analogy. The brain does far, far more than marshal resources and distribute the where they are needed, which in essence is what the financial sector does for the economy.
- regularfry 8y agoI think it's a perfect analogy. From the point of view of a species as a whole, the majority of what we see as the brain's functions are only relevant because humans are amazingly inefficient compared to smaller organisms. We need our brains because our reproductive cycle produces "too big to fail" output.
- sova 8y agoYes this analogy would work if every brain became a cancerous growth that realigned laws and basic pathways to serve the survival and growth of the brain, but this is not the case, the brain in the body has a maximum size (proportionality) and also serves the rest of the body. Not only the brain's satisfaction, but the skin, the gut, the sense organs all rely on the brain however the brain serves them primarily before serving "itself"
- dmos62 8y agoIt's fairly obvious that speculation doesn't produce social value; and, if you take money to be a proxy for social value, which I think is a good idea, speculation is equivalent to printing money. It's a very pure the-rich-get-richer type of scheme. I dabble in retail trading fairly often, because I sometimes feel like if I have to produce capital, I might as well just "print it", so this is as much a criticisim of myself as of anyone else.
- brailsafe 8y agoI can think of a few arguments, albeit with gaping holes, as to how money is a good proxy for social value, but would you mind expanding on that a little? Also, I am curious as to what you mean when you refer to retail trading as printing money. Don't know anything about it (why I'm curious), but from what I have heard about trading in general, it seems to have some reasonable level of risk.
- dmos62 8y agoThe classic example of the divide between social value and monetary value is volunteering. Volunteers create social value, often to the detriment of their financial standing. I know some people who would dedicate all their time to volunteering (they already dedicate at least half) if they didn't have to do gigs from time to time to make ends meet. By retail trading, I meant that I'm not what you'd call a big-time trader. I use a broker that is available to retail clients (i.e. everyone). I didn't mean to imply that trading and speculation aren't risky. Trading is like printing money, because while you make money without producing any value, the guy next door makes money by actually producing something. Socially, it's freeloading, like stealing is freeloading. You get value, without providing value. A double-spend attack.
- nafey 8y agoOf course it does. Financing a revolutionary company by buying it's stock allows it to raise money and change our lives for the better.
- goobynight 8y ago
- CathyWest 8y ago> I honestly think the finance industry could be half the size it is with no real harm to the rest of the economy. With technology it should have shrunk by a couple of orders of magnitude. You don't need a room full of old men in green visors cranking away at adding machines to get anything done anymore. Instead technology has only made it bigger.
- Jedd 8y ago> But what I didn't understand was that mostly we made money when other people lost it. Where did / do you think money comes from?
- jrnvs 8y agoIt should come from adding value and thereby growing the economy, which is then reflected in an increase in the money supply.
- FakeComments 8y agoFor someone like Warren Buffet, the money comes from enabling corporations that serve consumer interests — that’s going to be the case for anyone doing value investing or similar. Other kinds of “finance” are more like playing poker where everyone is betting the public’s money. I can believe someone new to finance didn’t think very hard about which kind of firm they were at.
- wpietri 8y agoFrom the creation of value for other people. Most businesses are positive sum. E.g., the sandwich shop down the street buys ingredients at X, puts in labor valued at Y, and sells me a sandwich for Z > X+Y. They have created value. (As have the the people doing the labor, because they took time valued at zero and turned it into marketable labor.) Money is a representation of the value created by humans. That's why the government must continually increase the money supply [1]: if money's value is to stay stable relative to goods, the supply has to increase as society creates more value. Finance is sometimes value creating. E.g., the sandwich shop owner is willing to pay the bank for transferring money from my account to theirs. But it can also extract rents (e.g., arbitrary or hidden fees) and be parasitic (as when banks speculate with money insured by society, like during the S&L crisis). [1] E.g., https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/M2 https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/M2
- Jedd 8y agoI should possibly have qualified your original 'lost' phrasing, but my point stands. Yes, value is created, but money isn't, by the actions you describe. If I 'value add' the ingredients of a sandwich, and then sell it to you, you still have to surrender (or lose) money. Any sale of goods or services ideally involves both parties determining that the transaction is favourable to their interests -- but it's impossible to avoid the fact that the buyer will have less money as a result. This isn't a bad thing. Arguably a strong indicator of the health of an economy is the agility of money / wealth within it. But your original observation was: > But what I didn't understand was that mostly we made money when other people lost it. ... and that's an ineluctable outcome of any financial transaction.
- avip 8y ago>We just situated ourselves near a river of (other people's) money and tried to siphon off a bit of the flow Are you quoting God Bless You, Mr. Rosewater there?
- wpietri 8y agoNot consciously! I haven't read that since long before my time in finance. Clearly I need to read it again.
- throwawaymath 8y agoI respect your opinion about the industry, but I'd encourage you to consider that you may be wrong about the financial sector not making anything better. That may be true about specific firms or pockets of the industry, but valuation, price discovery, liquidity, de-risking and credit are all legitimate benefits facilitated through financial activity. I'm not arguing investment banks and hedge funds are an unmitigated good! But at minimum, finance (much like tech) is far too complex and mixed to be able to correctly say you're not making anything better if you work in it. That being said, I can absolutely understand why you'd regret working at a specific firm in the industry.
- wpietri 8y agoI can definitely say I wasn't personally making anything better. Any liquidity our little prop trading firm was adding was at best epsilon. I agree that the industry does produce some value. But ask yourself honestly: what percentage of any given person's time and energy is devoted to value creation? To what extent are they sure their day's work is value-creating rather than value-subtracting for the economy as a whole? Maybe things have changed, but at the time very few people even cared about those answers. Those that did thought about the question very little, and with none of their customary rigor. The reason I said the industry could be half its size (rather than eliminating it entirely) is that I know it produces some value to the rest of the economy. But if it could be half its size (or smaller) then it's perfectly plausible the average person in finance is a net drain on society.
- atq2119 8y agoIt's interesting to try to compare finance and tech on whether or not they are beneficial to society. epsilon improvements can be quite useful to society. Clearly some amount of both is useful, but I'd argue that finance has run its course in the sense that pretty much all incremental "improvements" made by finance are basically hurting society.[1] This is because while things like market making are obviously necessary, you've got to ask yourself: does making trades on a timescale of microseconds or even less as opposed to making trades on a timescale of minutes lead to better outcomes in the real economy? The answer is almost certainly "no", but at the same time, trading firms that are engaged in zero-sum games are still able to siphon a lot of money from the rest of the economy that goes into just that. So the net outcome for society of that is clearly negative. We shouldn't be kidding ourselves, though. A lot of the incremental improvements in tech these days are also net negatives to society. Mostly this is because so much of tech is driven by advertisement. However, there are large parts of tech, including some very traditional parts, in which improvements are clearly beneficial to society, e.g. when it comes to building more powerful and efficient hardware. [1] An exception might be entirely new sub-sectors of finance that explicitly target beneficial outcomes. Climate finance comes to mind.
- toyg 8y ago> I honestly think the finance industry could be half the size Me too; but then I think of all those unsavoury traders who would have to get other jobs, eventually inflicting hell on the innocent, and the prospect of keeping them where they are, flies to flypaper, becomes more appealing. (disclaimer: I work in the sector at large)
- wpietri 8y agoThe sad part for me is that I don't think they (all) start out unsavory. Our company had a lot of fresh-faced college grads flowing into it. They turned up just because they were bright and ambitious and finance looked like a promising career. I know some of them have gone on to do good things elsewhere. What if more of them did?
- tootie 8y agoWhile not every business is a zero-sum game, a lot of them are. If I open a coffee shop near another coffee shop and run them out of business by serving better coffee, that's not unethical, it's just capitalism working as intended. What you're probably referring to is what's called rent-seeking. Rents can be described as unproductive profits. Money made through obscure technical means, market position, abuse of trust, etc and not providing a valuable service. Big financial services firms are always a mix of productive services and rent-seeking. It's not really unethical, but it's ethically dubious and it's also considered mandatory in order to stay in business and please the shareholders.
- wpietri 8y agoI appreciate the comment, but that coffee shop is not zero sum in two important ways. One, if you're selling coffee every day to people, then you are creating value for all the people who say, "Hey, this was a good purchase. I'll come back tomorrow." So it's definitely not zero sum in the main economic sense. Value is created with every cup. Two, if you open up next near another coffee shop, that's still not zero sum. More people will get coffee. Your better coffee means that people will get more for their money. Maybe your competition will force neighboring businesses to up their game. And even if another business ends up closing and exactly no new customers get served, that's still not zero sum, in that you're providing a better product. I agree big financial firms are a mix of productive and rent-seeking behavior, although a lot of their nominally productive behavior is just helping other rent-seekers, so I think the truly positive-sum service is pretty small. I also disagree that rent-seeking is ethical. That some in the industry consider it "mandatory" is pure self-justification, a way of passing the moral buck.
- pmiller2 8y agoIn my most recent job search, I told exactly one company to (politely) fuck off and never contact me again. It was Goldman Sachs. I think what I actually told them was something to the effect of “GS represents everything that’s wrong with the economy today and should have gone out of business in 2008.” I don’t regret it.
- gammateam 8y agoMany trades are non-zero sum actually. It doesn't matter that you made money because someone lost SOME. Both market participants receive what they wanted to out of it. For example, you take linear bets - going short a stock - and you bought to cover at a profit to someone that was maybe long and selling at a loss. You say wow so zero sum. But little did you know, the person that was long was actually collecting premium from their covered call options trade, and is still getting what they wanted out of it. They may not have begun losing more money for their tolerance for another 2% or 10% drop in the stock. They would come out net positive until then, even though their MAXIMUM potential profit was still more. Both participants still got what they want, and you wouldn't be the wiser - unless of course you were trading products that had no derivatives market. But even then you wouldn't know, because they could be written OTC.