12 ms·
> suddenly we get very "every person for themselves" the second homelessness has a price tag. A confounding factor involved here is that many government strate
by crooked-v 8y ago
> suddenly we get very "every person for themselves" the second homelessness has a price tag.
A confounding factor involved here is that many government strategies for dealing with the homeless are endless money pits without noticeable results. I think a lot of people would be more comfortable with their tax dollars going to that purpose if they didn't feel like nothing was actually happening from it.
- dan_quixote 8y ago> endless money pits without noticeable results Homelessness budgets are money pits because our first line of defense is so often the ER where the patients can cost tens of thousands of dollars per day. The patients with serious mental health or substance abuse problems also have nowhere to go after the ER...so they get stuck there for many extra days/weeks because no one will take them. Do the math and each hospital visit can easily extend past $1 million and typically are at least in the hundreds of thousands of dollars.
- Retric 8y agoActually spending targeting homelessness is fairly minimal. So, IMO it’s hard to call it a money pit.
- ddingus 8y agoIs that not due to simply not spending?
- Retric 8y agoIf you estimate ~20k per homeless person per year * 550,000 homes in the US you get on the order of 11 Billion dollars per year out of something like 7,150 Billion of total government spending. On the other hand if you look at social security as one way to reduce homelessness it’s vastly more expensive.
- ddingus 8y agoNeither one of those actually speaks to our spend.
- Retric 8y agoI was more acknowledging it's not that easy to put a single number on that spend. The low number is a little over half that 11 billion I mentioned, but you can easily come up with other metrics which provide vastly larger figures.
- ddingus 8y agoOkay got it. :D That's totally fair. Honestly, I don't think we are spending, or the problem wouldn't be where it is right now. Two things are needed. One, attack the root cause. To remedial spending to beat back this problem that we're now faced with. We need those things, because Downstream effects from all of this will be very very expensive.
- xienze 8y agoWell in SF and Seattle the spending continually increases and the homelessness problem manages to get worse every year. Sounds like a money pit.
- omegaworks 8y agoThe money pit is the cost of housing. Homelessness and artificial housing scarcity go hand-in-hand.
- Retric 8y agoDumping this on Local government and homeless people move around based on what’s best for them. Solve it nationally and you don’t have that problem.
- hn_throwaway_99 8y agoI think the other problem is that the more one city spends to "fix" its homeless problems, the more other areas ship their homeless to these cities with more resources. It's certainly the case in Texas, where many smaller cities and rural areas give homeless people a one-way bus ticket to Austin, Dallas or San Antonio.
- omegaworks 8y agoThis is a common enough misrepresentation of the sources of homelessness that it's imperative that you stop spreading it. 71% of San Francisco's homeless used to have homes in the city, it is likely a similar proportion elsewhere. http://sfist.com/2016/02/11/71_of_sf_homeless_once_had_homes_in.php http://sfist.com/2016/02/11/71_of_sf_homeless_once_had_homes...
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoThese studies always sound dubious, just like the misrepresentations that you are pointing out. First, they are just surveying a population that is incredibly difficult to survey. Second, they don't look into what they meant by having a home, was it just crashing at a friend's house? Were they ever employed at all in the city? Where were they born, where did they grow up? Cities act as a catchment for the rural areas around them: you can't really be homeless in Ellensburg or Aberdeen or Walla Walla (with no social services), but you can be homeless in Seattle or Spokane. A lot of kids on the street near UW in Seattle (aka ave rats) hail as far away as Montana. When I was working in downtown Seattle, many of the homeless that came around were Native Americans from various regions in the PNW. And ya, people do wind up homeless after they move to the big city, but often for reasons back home (they lost their support network and couldn't stay solvent). Anyways, you can't fix the homeless problem in individual cities without also fixing it in the surrounding regions, or even the nation. People are mobile, they will be attracted to the best deal.
- omegaworks 8y ago>These studies always sound dubious, just like the misrepresentations that you are pointing out. So are you suggesting we base our understanding of this problem on anecdotes? The problem I have with that is that the anecdotes that you present are constructed to support the idea that there is nothing to be done, that we must simply accept that homelessness is too big a problem to be solved or even quantified. I refuse to accept that conclusion, and support efforts to understand the problem rationally. http://hsh.sfgov.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/San-Francisco-PIT-Executive-Summary-FINAL-6.21.17.pdf http://hsh.sfgov.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/San-Francisc...
- coryrc 8y agoLike documented here: https://roominate.com/blog/2016/anatomy-of-a-swindle/ https://roominate.com/blog/2016/anatomy-of-a-swindle/
- spookthesunset 8y ago> endless money pits The reason they are money pits is because they aren't something that will be solved by a city or even a state. Any attempt to solve the problem locally in a "humane" way has a high risk of just attracting more folks in the same circumstance to the area. The most effective way for a city or state to "solve" the local homeless problem is to simply pay for one-way bus tickets to somewhere else. But that doesn't solve the actual problem. Homelessness is a systemic problem that can only be meaningly addressed in a humane way by the federal government.
- CryptoPunk 8y agoIt's an endless money pit because if you subsidize something, you get more of it. The massive increase in subsidies for low-income single parents has resulted in a massive increase in children born into single parent families over the last 50 years.
- tuesdayrain 8y agoSo that means if we want to solve homelessness, we need to start taxing homeless people.
- CryptoPunk 8y agoOr just stop subsidizing them. In the short term, it's more suffering for the poor, but in the long run, it's fewer people born into multi-generational poverty traps and into communities where they learn to become dependent and game government programs, because the dominant source of income is unconditional social assistance programs provided at the taxpayer's expense.
- fjsolwmv 8y agoYou think homeless people were predominantly born on the street to homeless parents?
- 8y ago
- vkou 8y ago> without noticeable results. To make an analogy, consider that hospitals dump millions of dollars, and physician hours into their trauma wards. Yet, so many of the patients in them keep dying! Clearly, the rational thing to do is to declare that trauma treatment is a waste of time and money, and is not achieving meaningful results. We should cut physician hours, and re-allocate them to some other area of the hospital, that has a better survival rate. /s Or, alternatively, consider all the efforts you put into testing and code reviewing your code - yet bugs still slip through to release. If all you do is count the number of bugs that make it to release, with no baseline, you may conclude that all that testing effort is not having noticeable results. We should shut down the Jenkins server, and just let any dev submit whatever we want, without any review. The problem is that as long as you see homeless people in your city, you will think that there are no noticeable results to these programs. That the situation might be twice as bad if those programs weren't in place... Doesn't really cross the mind.
- tomrod 8y agoWhy can't something like this work? https://www.npr.org/2015/12/10/459100751/utah-reduced-chronic-homelessness-by-91-percent-heres-how https://www.npr.org/2015/12/10/459100751/utah-reduced-chroni...