12 ms·
The Media Industry and the “Make-Google-Pay” Fantasy
- ForHackernews 8y agoIf I were a policymaker and I had to choose between saving a free and independent press and saving a big advertising company, I know which side I'd be on.
- PakG1 8y agoIt's funny, at first, I misread that you wrote "I know which side I'd bet on." Which raises an interesting question. We know which side we'd probably be on, that's the rationalist speaking. Which side would we bet on though? Specifically, which side does the realist bet on winning in both the short and long run?
- ForHackernews 8y agoOh, I think it's pretty clear that Googbook has the legacy media at their mercy. The realist bet has been against responsible news media for almost long as that's even existed as a market segment.
- syn0byte 8y agoThe one making more "campaign contributions" of course.
- adrianN 8y agoGoogle provides a lot of traffic to the websites operated by the free and independent press. If they don't manage to monetize that traffic sufficiently then that's their problem. Google obeys robots.txt, if they don't want to be indexed it's easy to achieve this. I really don't understand why Google should pay for what they do.
- Nasrudith 8y agoIt is a permission culture mentality. It doesn't matter that you are making them money by say buying their hardware and painting it neon green to resell - you made more money from their work so they feel entitled to another cut.
- Nasrudith 8y agoExcept it does the exact opposite of that. It is like a mudslide - burrying the small and leaving the giants diminished but lacking competition. The point is that their childish fantasy of a policy will only hurt everyone except for those who long for a tightly controlled media oligarchy with moats protecting from competition.
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoProbably one of the most telling charts I saw was data extracted from a Google quarterly report[1], showing how much of their ad revenue has moved from ads embedded in pages (which they have to share with page owners), and ads in their own search engine and apps, which they get to keep 100% of. While Google used to be providing value to the sites it helped locate, more and more it's enriching itself at the cost of those sites. If we can't realign their incentives with revenue sharing with news sites, we need to shut them down, because the way things are going, Google is bleeding out the journalism industry. They were in a symbiotic relationship, but it has transitioned to a parasitic one. [1] https://twitter.com/jason_kint/status/1055606344559063040 https://twitter.com/jason_kint/status/1055606344559063040
- preinheimer 8y agoI think this is an interesting insight: Google is, in a way, competing with the pages it links to. If you can find the info you want, and click on an ad while still on a google owned domain: they make more money. We've seem some shots fired in this battle already. In the earlier days of google search for something with a clear cut answer, and you'd likely see the answer in the summary. Sites missed out on that traffic so they started moving the answer lower down in the page, with poorly written teaser summaries in the results. Now google is showing a large block at the top of the page with it's guess to the answer at the top.
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoI agree, but... First: Google doesn't need saving. They're doing just fine. Second: I fear that every proposal to save a free and independent press is going to destroy freedom in some very concrete ways.
- ForHackernews 8y agoI think is is a fair response. 1) Any time somebody suggests taxing, breaking up, or otherwise regulating the tech giants, there's a chorus of voices afraid we'll kill their golden goose. That's why I phrased it as a choice to "save" one or the other. If it ever did come down to a binary choice, I'd sooner our society sacrificed Google to save NYT/BBC/Der Spiegel. Others may disagree, of course. 2) There's a legitimate argument to be made that government intervention to shore up the press will result in unintended consequences and/or make the press beholden to their government benefactors.
- matt4077 8y agoCopyright has always been a government-backed scheme. Yet that has never stopped a publisher from being critical of the government.
- tsunamifury 8y agoI think the author has a good grasp of the situation that is more important than the average person understands. Murdoch knows his empire is waning and is attempting to ingratiate himself to government officials by becoming an unofficial mouthpiece of several conservative governments. His coup d'etat would be if he is able to turn that relationship official in some regions, pass laws to make his content mandatory to publish, them extract a link tax from the distributors. An irony of ironies considering he will build that on the back of ideogolgy that fundamentally criticizes this strategy. Note: An exceptionally well written analysis that shows the author has a good understanding of both product and business motivations. It is so rare to see writing like this in the era of outrage journalism.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> His coup d'etat would be if he is able to turn that relationship official in some regions “In Germany, a comparable anti-snippet law was rendered powerless by a group of publishers who did the math and offered their content for free in exchange for the usual stream of clicks sent back to them” [1]. In summary, this law has made having access to Google more valuable. [1] https://mondaynote.com/the-media-industry-and-the-make-google-pay-fantasy-1b4de36e3b04 https://mondaynote.com/the-media-industry-and-the-make-googl...
- tsunamifury 8y agoI don’t think you understand. He would make it mandatory to list his content and to pay.
- mailslot 8y agoLocal and major news sites alike, are cesspoools of intrusive advertising and tracking. They’re so poorly built, with so much advertising, that they hardly even function any longer. Even if Google links to a news site, I won’t click. It’s probably 30 secs for my new iPhone to partially fail loading, abruptly reload, and then auto play video I didn’t ask for... while covering the article with more ads that I have to click to dismiss. Reading about the latest headlines is like sitting in a timeshare presentation, only it drains my phone battery and crashes my browser. It’s a shame that the media is so bad at producing media. The quality is down, the delivery is terrible, and they want more money.
- Yetanfou 8y agoBrowsing the commercial web without a host of filtering is like having unprotected intercourse with random strangers. Ad blockers will take care of the advertising, auto-playing video won't auto-play if there is no auto-play to begin with, Javascript is blocked by uBlock in 'advanced user' mode or by using a browser like Privacy Browser which blocks it by default (and allows per-site exceptions to be made). Sometimes there's nothing left after that, true, but mostly it reduces the ad-infested misery to manageable proportions. This works on Android, it might work on iOS as well. Then again, it might not given the limited choice of browsers on that platform. To get the latest headlines I suggest using a RSS reader (e.g. 'News' on Nextcloud/Owncloud) and subscribing to those feeds which you deem interesting. This gives you headlines, sometimes with a snippet of content, often without but subscribe to a few different publications and you'll have the same news described using different headlines which often give enough insight into whether the item is worth your time.
- kkarakk 8y ago>To get the latest headlines I suggest using a RSS reader (e.g. 'News' on Nextcloud/Owncloud) and subscribing to those feeds which you deem interesting. This gives you headlines, sometimes with a snippet of content, often without but subscribe to a few different publications and you'll have the same news described using different headlines which often give enough insight into whether the item is worth your time. it also locks you into a bubble of your own creation with very little provocative or interesting content
- paol 8y agoI'm a lot less worried about the "link tax" clauses than the copyright liability clause. Not because the link tax is a good idea but because it's a spectacular own goal that is mainly going to hurt the idiots who lobbied for it. Giving companies direct liability for policing copyright in user-uploaded content is a much bigger disaster, on two separate fronts, both highly damaging: 1) Implementing youtube-style content id will be a huge burden for small companies. Youtube reportedly spent tens of millions on it over several years. This tilts the field in favor of large incumbents even more than it already is by nature. While the amount of content to screen is really small, human-driven filtering is a possibility, but as soon as you need to scale up you're screwed. Any startup in Europe that needs to do this is a no-go from now on, IMO. 2) Back to that multi-milion content ID system: it sucks. It sucks really badly. It over-reports infringement left right and center. Now imagine what it will be like when youtube is liable a priori for every false negative; any sane legal department is going to demand a minimal number of false negatives at any cost. Now imagine what that will do to the false positive rate. Now imagine what the false positive rate will be when every site has to bodge together a similar system, with neither google's money nor google's technical expertise. The second point has been missed by most criticism of the Copyright Directive, and to me it's the biggest problem of all. I fear the wasteland that will result. Are we going back to the point where only a handful of content producers exist and everybody else should be content just consuming it? Welcome to the 20th century, Europe.
- wbl 8y agoNo because you can publish it yourself. We don't need giant middlemen to use the Internet.
- kinkrtyavimoodh 8y agoWhile that is true, it is quite difficult to compete against ad-revenue-driven content creation.
- whatshisface 8y agoEventually, people will have to run ads on their own websites, the same as before Youtube. There will be a lot less video content because serving video is a tough thing.
- azurezyq 8y agoAnd article 13 is not only for Google... Copyright scanning is hard and there government requires 100% recall, which can only be achieved by shutting down the site. IMO the government receives the criticism and just redirects the fire towards big ones.
- Kurtz79 8y ago"Traffic of news sites depends heavily on Google." It seems counterintuitive to me, at least for my use case. I rarely search for "news", I have a handful of websites to which I usually go to for them. I might search the name in Google if for whatever reason it doesn't show on the top results when I start typing the name on the search bar, because I'm too lazy to use bookmarks. Do most other people use aggregators or "search" for news?
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoI'm pretty reliant on an RSS reader. I rarely use Bing News/Google News/etc. unless I'm curious about a breaking story that isn't covered in my subscribed feeds (which are mostly tech news.) The other place I end up picking up a lot of news is Twitter, and of course, here on HN.
- onion2k 8y agoNew traffic (aka growth) often comes from Google, and without growth every site will slowly die.
- Aunche 8y agoPeople Google the news when there's a major event going on that they want to know more about but don't usually read the news. For example, I did so to find out the 2018 US midterm results.
- buboard 8y agoif you re searching for (or something) someone public you re likely to encounter news articles about them, many of them, and you usually read multiple to find what u re looking for. That creates a lot of traffic.
- vorpalhex 8y agoYes, I use aggregators so I don't fall victim (as easily) to echochambers of my own design. All sources are biased, but at least you can hopefully get some idea of the truth by reading differently biased sources.
- 8y ago
- zzzcpan 8y ago> By pushing to the “link tax”, publishers are shooting themselves in the foot three times over. I don't think that's true at all. Beyond some short term traffic loss there are no negative consequences for the media industry if Google leaves this space. I suspect that's what big publishers actually aim for, they understand Google is not likely to pay and want to control how users discover news themselves.
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoThe challenge publishers are fighting is effectively scabs in a union strike. If news publishers block Google, the one (or few) publisher who chooses not to gets all the traffic. And the problem with news is it's easily copied and redistributed. So the real reporters and journalists could all block Google and Google may try to sustain itself on pushing blogspam instead. It's very possible that only government regulation which forces participation (such as the link tax) can actually work.
- vorpalhex 8y ago> It's very possible that only government regulation which forces participation (such as the link tax) can actually work. Why don't we just make Google give every news org a few million a year then? Why pretend it's anything else but Google directly paying for the news? Side point, if news subscriptions were reasonably priced (upfront pricing, and billed monthly instead of this odd weekly nonsense), they would probably not care at all about Google.
- Kalium 8y agoGoogle brings traffic, traffic brings views, and views bring ad revenue. The number of media outlets, today or historically, that subsist entirely on subscriber numbers is tiny next to the amount that use subscriptions as well as ads.
- ForHackernews 8y ago> Why don't we just make Google give every news org a few million a year then? That sounds sensible enough to me. As an example, Canada taxed blank CDs and CDR drives and distributed the revenue to their music industry.
- buboard 8y agoI think if pressure from "traditional" publishers keeps going, google is going to put plan B in action and go on to actually own the news as well. It's not hard for them to build an "uber for news" for journalists, editors and the common man, as in fact they have been subsidizing the open web with adsense for decades anyway. Maybe the next google reader will be about google's own news.
- bepotts 8y agoThe problem with that plan is that if Google were to release such a service in the EU, the EU would then fine Google for using their search monopoly to prop up a service in another industry (News). The EU did something similar when Google used their search monopoly to promote Google Shopping. EU is gonna EU.
- buboard 8y agoSure, but if google decides to pull out of european news, someone else might find it an attractive idea. And , considering that (if this passes) EU will have made it impossible for a european company to do that, it will be somewhere outside the EU.
- c16 8y agoWhat's stopping Google from refusing to pay the news sites, thus de-indexing them from Google entirely? If the relationship is "pay me for my content", then refusing to serve links to their media is absolutely within their rights. Only the publishers have something to lose here.
- buboard 8y agothat's what they did in spain
- nevez 8y agoThey didn't de-index the sites in Spain, they just closed Google News.
- PeterisP 8y agoAs the article states, this is the exact thing that happened in Spain and Germany, with the result being that the major publishers folded. Which is an argument that "make google pay" idea is futile and doomed from the beginning; the publishers can't make google pay simply because they need google far more than google needs them.
- nradov 8y agoWhat's stopping Google is that they would lose out on advertising revenue, and drive users to other search engines which do serve links to news media sites.
- scarejunba 8y agoIn practice, people trust Google more than hey trust the news site. Google News in Spain was shut down in 2014. Google dominates search engine market share in Spain today and for every period from 2014 to 2018. In fact, Spain’s news industry suffered for it.
- wmf 8y agoThe next step is probably a version of "must carry" for the Internet where Google is required by law to index news and required by law to pay for it.
- vesinisa 8y agoThe very idea that the aggregator (Google) should pay the advertisers (news sites) for directing traffic to them is just patently absurd. By common sense, it should be the other way around. Sadly, the traditional media has a massive conflict of interest here, so the issue passed at least in my part of EU with little to no ado. But once the member states start enacting the directive to legislation, the manure will surely meet the propeller. No amount of regulation can change fundamental economic facts. Once Google News starts going black around EU, and the search engine traffic & revenue disappearing from the publishers, I am sure they will be soon very eager to license their content at zero cost, or less.
- reaperducer 8y agoIs Google News really that big a deal for publishers? Considering all the places where they voluntarily put their content (Facebook, Twitter, Apple News, etc...), is the loss of Google News really a problem? I don't see anything magic about Google News that isn't done better (Apple News), or more thoroughly (Twitter) elsewhere.
- wmf 8y agoPresumably the publishers intend to strong-arm all those sources into paying them.
- ma2rten 8y agoThey are referring to news snippets that show up in Google Search (not the Google News app on your phone). Those are one of the most significant sources of traffic for publishers.
- skybrian 8y agoEven for a web search, Google News doesn't show snippets at all anymore, just headlines and thumbnails. (This is in the "Top Stories" widget and on the "News" tab.) It looks like the snippet is still there for generic web results, but that's further down the page for a news search and probably not a big driver of traffic.
- JustSomeNobody 8y agoHow does this conversation go? I mean, seriously, were people sitting in a room thinking, ok, so Google gives us free advertisement, but what if we were to get them to pay us to advertise for us? And everyone just nods and agrees? What the heck? Greed. Everywhere. You just can't escape it. I'm so disappointed in people these days.
- ma2rten 8y agoMost news sites have comment sections. I am wondering if someone could post copyrighted material on purpose in the comment section and use the new EU law to sue publishers.
- nine_k 8y agoIIRC, according to the new regulations, anything that a user uploads must be pre-screened for copyright violations before being made public.
- deckar01 8y agoThis makes complete sense to me. There is no reason that posting content to a platform that millions of people could see should be free or instant. Other publishing platforms take responsibility for their content, and it costs them money that Google isn't spending, because it would rather spend it on legal on the back end. I wonder if any platform has ever created a moderation system that can acheive this scale. I imagine it would require captcha like screening process with multiple tiers of moderator specialization and appeals.
- cr0sh 8y ago> There is no reason that posting content to a platform that millions of people could see should be free or instant. So if someone is on a particular platform, such as the one we're currently using, and they post a base64 encoded image, or article, or whatever... ...you really want every possible comment screened, paid for, or be delayed in some manner so someone or something can check that the data is legit? That can't work; sure you could probably figure a way to work around the base64 encoding and automate things, but what happens if people start using other more difficult encoding systems to publish such content in text-only forums? Yes, this is reducto-ad-absurdum territory - but these kinds of directives would have to apply to every kind of user-generated and posted content system, including mostly or wholly text-only boards like this one.
- deckar01 8y ago
- lifeisstillgood 8y agoWhat are these "future tools" that Google is investing millions in for the industry? I am not sure what they could do to help? Putting back the search term in each click through?
- ummonk 8y agoYoutube will arbitrarily deprioritize, demonetize, or remove content from its platform, and as with all of Google, the appeals process is slow and questionable. Since it exercises so much curation power over the content on its platform, it should likewise be liable for said content. Protection from liability for content on your platform should only be extended to platforms that actually act as common carriers.
- Animats 8y agoOn the copyright front, arguably Google should be liable if they "monetize" pirated content with ads.
- megaman8 8y agoSeems it's much easier to get some legislation passed than actually fix your business model. Everytime I come across an interesting news article and want to make a 10c donation, there's never an easy micropayment way to do it. Furthermore places like the wall street journal block their content and ask you to pay hundreds of dollars. I'm not going to pay hundreds of dollars just so I can speed-read a single article for 60 seconds. Come on, media industry, get with the times and understand your target customer.
- scarejunba 8y agoThe WSJ has gotten with the times. They’re doing well with their approach. It’s what their customer wants. I like their model.
- throw2016 8y agoThis article is a one sided look at how publishers benefit from Google without considering the other side, at all. This is not helpful for informed discussion. If Google is 'helping' these publishers then the counterpoint is these publishers are also 'helping' Google by making the content at their cost in the first place. Without their content what will Google search? Wikipedia, blogs? Without news content google search users will not get news context about their search queries so the search engine will lack a critical perspective and become lower quality, which will take billions of dollars of value off Google, lower its value to users and make room for other options. Let's not pretend Google is not benefiting from news content. And since people clearly value news content producers can generate value outside of Google, and Google will need to pay to make money from that content or do without. Targeting a predatory model will make space for better models and ideas to emerge.
- Kalium 8y ago> If Google is 'helping' these publishers then the counterpoint is these publishers are also 'helping' Google by making the content at their cost in the first place. Without their content what will Google search? Wikipedia, one person blogs? The whole rest of the internet, which among other things contains a sizable number of media outlets that are not subject to these protections? Frankly, Google is better-equipped to walk away from news providers than the news providers are to walk away from google. Google has done this before, even. You are, of course, absolutely right that there is room for another business model here. In fact, one might posit that there has been room for decades! Surely it's possible that there could be a business model whereby consumers get access to the news they value for a reasonable price, producers of news get paid fairly, and profit-extracting aggregators are kept to the slimmest of financial margins. Surely it would be better for consumers (who doesn't like supporting journalism, so critical to a free society?) and journalistic outlets (who obviously would love to be free of Google's iron yoke)! It's curious that no good replacement has arisen when the opportunity and incentives are so clear! Perhaps in Spain, where Google News does not operate on domestic newspapers and has not for years? But I'm sure that's merely my failure to understand how Google sucked all the oxygen out of the room and prevented those incentivized to do so from creating something better. Can you help me understand what I've missed?
- 8y ago
- HissingMachine 8y agoAfter numerous sites will have to block access to them for users coming from Europe, even if it is for a short while to implement tools to comply with these regulations, people will not start to hate them, they won't start hating Google, Youtube or whatever site they are barred from accessing, they will start to hate the EU. Anti-EU sentiment will get a big boost and they can't blame anyone else than themselves, good job and good luck bureaucrats.
- sarcasmic 8y agoAs usual with upcoming legislation, FUD predominates in the conversation. A reasonable person may be used to parties with vested interests to exaggerate or misrepresent facts, but it's unfortunate when parties from whom you may not expect a clear bias continue to perpetuate uncertainty and doubt. Article 13 states that the measures to seek rightholder approval for user-submitted content "shall be effective and proportionate, taking into account, among other factors" the nature and size of services, whether they're a small and medium business, the sheer volume of material uploaded, and the cost burden of such an effort. Furthermore, it refers to a precise definition of the sort of enterprise that is to be impacted by this regime -- those that provide "public access to a large amount of works or other subject-matter uploaded by its users which it organises and promotes for profit-making purposes", exempting a variety of others. This leaves ample leeway to require a more rigorous scheme from hosts as big as YouTube while being more lenient with a hobbyist forum. Article 11 states that the copyright protection of journalistic articles from aggregators will expire at the end of the following year from the article's publication. It reaffirms the right of publishers to decide how they wish to profit from their work -- if they choose to make it available for the aggregator at no cost, that is their right as well.
- qaq 8y agoOK could you point to anything that outlines actual criteria for classification because the language you included from Article 13 in your comment is not restrictive in any manner.
- sarcasmic 8y agoOriginal text [1], changed by amendments [2]. Relevant definition: Amendment 150, Proposal for a directive, Article 2 – paragraph 1 – point 4b (new): > 'online content sharing service provider' means a provider of an information society service one of the main purposes of which is to store and give access to the public to a significant amount of copyright protected works or other protected subject-matter uploaded by its users, which the service optimises and promotes for profit making purposes. Microenterprises and small-sized enterprises within the meaning of Title I of the Annex to Commission Recommendation 2003/361/EC and services acting in a non-commercial purpose capacity such as online encyclopaedia, and providers of online services where the content is uploaded with the authorisation of all right holders concerned, such as educational or scientific repositories, shall not be considered online content sharing service providers within the meaning of this Directive. Providers of cloud services for individual use which do not provide direct access to the public, open source software developing platforms, and online market places whose main activity is online retail of physical goods, should not be considered online content sharing service providers within the meaning of this Directive; [1] https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX%3A52016PC0593 https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX%3A... [2] http://www.europarl.europa.eu/sides/getDoc.do?type=TA&language=EN&reference=P8-TA-2018-0337 http://www.europarl.europa.eu/sides/getDoc.do?type=TA&langua...
- stevespang 8y agoI think YouTube has a angle here, just cut off You Tube from the entire European community in order not to suffer fines. I mean Google already had to leave China and Russia, is Europe next ? Of course, Europeans will all find "backdoors" to get access, but then it's not You Tubes problem. This issue is really all about revenue and who get's to keep what$$$.