16 ms·
Italy’s olive crisis intensifies as deadly tree disease spreads
- eecc 8y agoOlive groves from Puglia are about a couple centuries old, and were originally meant to produce low grade oil for lamps. Furthermore, at that time picking was a painstaking manual process but labor was cheap. So these trees were let to grow naturally, making it impossible to use mechanized picking today. Overall it would be better to setup a replantation program to allow for modern and cost-effective management. I have little hope it will ever happen.
- chmaynard 8y agoThis looks like an opinion piece disguised as objective reporting. There's just enough factual information to make it seem credible but the author is clearly taking sides. For example, the article characterizes people with environmental concerns as "anti-science" yet there's no evidence presented to support this point of view.
- paganel 8y agoIt does sound a little subjective but then the following seems like it really happened, which definitely looks like being anti-science: > In June, some parliamentarians formally deposited documents at the Senate, one of Italy’s two houses of parliament, which challenged the scientific evidence on which Xylella management plans have been based and called for a Senate inquiry into whether scientists have misled the public. These claims were repudiated the following month, in an independent analysis commissioned by the national science academy, the Accademia dei Lincei. The Senate has not yet acted on the call for an inquiry.
- beaconstudios 8y agothat action isn't intrinsically anti-science. It depends on the objection that the counterparty has raised - if their objections are legitimate or just based in conspiracy. If the results cannot be defended without resorting to an appeal to authority then that is more anti-science than challenging the work itself.
- frostburg 8y ago"These claims were repudiated the following month, in an independent analysis". It was anti-science populism (and it was actually worse than this retelling makes it look).
- beaconstudios 8y agothe claims being repudiated doesn't make it anti-science either. However, I'm not denying that it could be anti-science, and it sounds like you know more about this than is written in TFA.
- paganel 8y ago> If the results cannot be defended without resorting to an appeal to authority then that is more anti-science than challenging the work itself. I think trusting "an independent analysis commissioned by the national science academy" compared to a political action initiated by a few politicians is not "an appeal to authority", quite the contrary. At some point we do have to trust some people who are better prepared and informed than us on a particularly given subject. Especially in the Italian political and social context, where some other scientists have been recently prosecuted for "failing" to predict earthquakes.
- beaconstudios 8y agoto be clear, I was addressing the original complaint, not the response to the independent analysis. If your allegations are addressed by an independent third party and you continue to reject the outcome, then it's pretty clearly conspiracy-based.
- Nasrudith 8y agoWell not wanting to use /any/ insecticidal measures I think qualifies. One can rightfully argue about the specific chemicals while agreeing using something to contain outbreaks is needed.
- ataturk 8y agoWelcome to all journalism.
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y agoScientists were accused of having spread the bacterium delierately, or allowed to become endemic through neglect, that they have been subject to the corrupting influence of business (in particulary solar companies who might stand to profit from the clearing of olive groves), that they have a remedy but will not release it, that they are wrong about the cause of the disease which is instead a fungus that can be dealt with without having to cut down the infected trees, etc [1]. None of the above is a direct attack on "science" in general, as a process, or a concept, nor an attack on scientists in general. However, all these sound a great deal like the claims of various anti-science conspiracy theorists, like anti-vaxxers or HIV-denialists: scientists are in bed with big pharma, they spread HIV through infected needles, vaccines are what cause disease, etc. "I'm not saying that this proves anything- I'm just stating the facts". ___________ [1] https://www.nature.com/news/italian-scientists-vilified-in-wake-of-olive-tree-deaths-1.17651 https://www.nature.com/news/italian-scientists-vilified-in-w...
- coldcode 8y agoThe easiest way to ensure that people listen is to do nothing and let all the olive trees in Italy die. I presume at that point people will pay attention.
- amelius 8y ago> If found guilty, Italy could, for example, lose access to important agricultural subsidies. That will help ...
- xbryanx 8y agoItaly has a messy history listening to and even jailing its scientists, as they go about the normal process of empiricism. https://www.nature.com/news/italian-seismologists-cleared-of-manslaughter-1.16313 https://www.nature.com/news/italian-seismologists-cleared-of...
- simias 8y agoThis particular story is embarrassing (although as your article points out, they were eventually cleared) but I don't think it's directly related to the problem at hand. Failing to heed the warnings of scientists is unfortunately not something we can stereotype on Italians alone...
- superflyguy 8y agoNo, but this is unprecedented for a developed country. Yes, they were eventually cleared. Great. Some doubts remain but it cannot be proved beyond all reasonable doubt that they were witches. Not guilty!
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y agoI'm pretty sure the US is considered a developed country and it routinely ignores scientists' warnings about the climate and the environment in general.
- arcticfox 8y agoIgnoring warnings != jailing scientists for failing to warn I'm embarrassed by the anti-science positions taken in the US but those are hardly the same magnitude
- superflyguy 8y agoI'm not sure how you didn't pick up on the fact that this was not about scientists being ignored.
- _eht 8y ago
- mlrtime 8y agoI was pretty shocked to learn that most (~80%) of the Italian extra virgin olive oil that comes into the US is neither Italian or olive oil. https://www.cbsnews.com/news/60-minutes-overtime-how-to-buy-olive-oil/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/60-minutes-overtime-how-to-buy-...
- endorphone 8y agoThat article certainly doesn't say that 80% isn't olive oil. Instead it argues that up to 80% doesn't meet the very stringent requirement to be classified as extra-virgin olive oil, often because it's partially mixing with lesser grades (or even simply differently sourced) of olive oil. That's a far cry from wholly substituting.
- 14 8y agoIn other cases, a bottle labeled "extra-virgin olive oil" may not be olive oil at all, just a seed oil like sunflower made to look and smell like olive oil with a few drops of chlorophyll and beta-carotene. This does not sound like a far cry that sounds like fraud.
- Kurtz79 8y agoYou are still selling an inferior product, claiming that is something it is not. In Italy or Spain, you can find "non extra-virgin" olive oil sold as well, although at a lower price.
- endorphone 8y agoI'm not disputing that. I'm disputing the completely unsubstantiated and simply ridiculous claim that 80% of olive oil isn't actually olive oil. That's a misreading akin to claiming that "80% of Halloween candy is pure sugar, and might even have a razor blade in it" means that 80% of Halloween candy has a razor blade in it.
- Phillips126 8y agoIts a sad state of today's food products. Honey in particular is often fraudulent containing syrups and sugars to add to volume while still being marketed as "Pure Honey". Worst of all, it is getting harder to detect the authenticity in modern labs as "honey factories" continue to develop new ways to throw the test results.
- choot 8y agoI wonder if such bacteria can be designed in a lab. And then used to attack developing countries massive agricultural production. Let's say, china and india are growing export regions. And if American or Russian companies design a specific bacteria to target their major agricultural exports then the prices will go up due to falling supply. So is this possible? Could this be happening somewhere in the world?
- folli 8y agoIt's probably easier to screen for existing bacterial strains that do such a job, instead of designing them.
- Bud 8y agoYes. About a billion times easier. Just send a few tourists in who are contaminated.
- sct202 8y agoIt'd probably be a bad idea since the disease would probably spread to the other growing areas eventually.
- ggm 8y agoAlthough it's possible, occams razor does not suggest it is the most likely reason
- andrenotgiant 8y agoOlive Wood is really beautiful and expensive, I wonder if this will drive a decrease in the price of it. In the US there is a special variety of pine killed by Mountain Pine Beetles that is relatively cheap but liked by woodworkers because the fungus that kills it leaves interesting blue streaks : https://www.sustainablelumberco.com/2015/03/beetle-kill-pine-qa/ https://www.sustainablelumberco.com/2015/03/beetle-kill-pine...
- AdmiralAsshat 8y agoReminds me of the burl: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Burl https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Burl It's basically a kind of cancer inside the tree, but it's highly prized because it looks pretty.
- hinkley 8y agoSpalted maple is a fungal decay, halted before the wood becomes too unstable to work.
- chicob 8y agoI'm an olive and almond producer in Portugal. In preparation for this very serious issue, since that the only thing I can do is to minimize the risk of infection, I tell all personnel to spray bleach on trimming scissors for each tree, the case of high density orchards, and for every 10-15 trees (or each row) in super high density orchards. I also try to monitor for infection vectors like Cicadellidae, and for possible ill trees in the vicinities. I will report any suspect case to the authorities, be it my neighbours' or my own. I am also looking for affordable insurance that covers this kind of problem. Also related to new agricultural issues arising from globalisation and worthy of attention are the zebra mussel (Dreissena polymorpha), the water hyacinth (Eichhornia ssp.), and the Asian clam (Corbicula fluminea) that obstruct irrigation pipes.
- libertine 8y agoPortuguese (Alentejano) fellow with some olive trees (not aimed at production) - if this spreads do you think it will start in the south or it won't matter?
- chicob 8y agoOlá! I don't think it will matter, because many times the problem starts at the nursery. There are many nurseries, both inside the EU but also outside, like Morocco for example. When orchards are being installed across the country, it really could start anywhere. Weather does not seem to have any importance in the spreading of the disease. What happened with the palm weevil (Rhynchophorus ferrugineus) doesn't necessarily apply here: X. fastidiosa infects a wide range of plants including ornamental plants, so it is really a matter of 'when', not 'if' or 'where'.[1] As of February 2017, there were 132 confirmed cases in Balearic Islands that are now considered lost for the bacteria.[1] As far as I know, there are no confirmed cases in Morocco, which is why many farmers look there for safe nurseries. [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xylella_fastidiosa#Hosts https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xylella_fastidiosa#Hosts [2]https://www.elmundo.es/baleares/2017/02/28/58b5aec5e2704e06758b4588.html https://www.elmundo.es/baleares/2017/02/28/58b5aec5e2704e067... (Spanish)
- smackay 8y ago
- izietto 8y agoHey! The region where I live is on HN homepage. I wonder if this plague is somehow related to the fact that Puglia ecosystem has been subverted in the last 50 years by heavy pesticide usage and intensive agriculture.
- dt_rsp 8y agoI remember reading this some years back, about horizontal resistance rather than vertical resistance. http://sharebooks.com/system/files/Return-to-Resistance.pdf http://sharebooks.com/system/files/Return-to-Resistance.pdf I was unable to find a whole lot more information on the subject at the time.
- woliveirajr 8y agoIn Brazil, there is some interesting story about how Cacau trees were contaminated with a plague called "vassoura de bruxa" (Crinipellis perniciosa). Many trees were found with some contaminated branches tied to them. In portuguese there are some news (ex.: http://atarde.uol.com.br/bahia/salvador/noticias/1257586-entenda-o-caso-da-vassoura-de-bruxa http://atarde.uol.com.br/bahia/salvador/noticias/1257586-ent...) considering that it was some kind of bioterrorism.
- vanderZwan 8y agoPeople outside of Italy are probably not aware of how seriously they take the topic of olive oil over there. The label "extra vergine" increases the price so much that there is a huge economic incentive for fraud. To combat this they have a taste police (literally) that checks that olive oil samples are not secretly mixes of fresh and old oil together. They are... quite opinionated, as you can see this exchange from when a Dutch journalist came to visit them and asked their opinion on the (supposedly) extra virgin that was sold in the Netherlands[0]. Taster: "This eh... oil is eh... very particular (...) It's Spanish!" Journalist: "It's Spanish? I wouldn't know." T: "Hah, now you know! This smell is very characteristic of Spanish olive oil." J: "But this is not a defect, is it?" T: "Yes." J: "It's defective?" T: "Yes." J: "Because it's Spanish?" Other taster: "For Italian people, yes." A few minutes later[1], the boss comes with a more diplomatic answer: "That the olive oil is Spanish is not a defect per sé, but within our guidelines we do consider it a defective product, because our own oil has a very specific smell and flavour. It's a fine product for Spain, but not for us." EDIT: for the Europeans: the same program also revealed that Carbonell and Bertolli are the same Spanish company with a different label, with pretty much the same (mostly) Spanish olive oil. In case you care about that sort of thing. Personally I'm kind of curious how Greek olive oil fits in this picture. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jkO1dwx2_KA&t=16m https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jkO1dwx2_KA&t=16m [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jkO1dwx2_KA&t=19m26s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jkO1dwx2_KA&t=19m26s
- docbrown 8y agoIn addition to Italy, Europe as a whole is pretty picky when it comes to olive oil. As an anglo who was introduced to authentic olive oil imported from Greece.. there is a very serious distinct taste difference between cheap and legitimate olive oil.
- vanderZwan 8y agoI think that in the northern parts of Europe we still seem to be pretty oblivious, so I would limit that to the Mediterranean area. And having tasted proper local food during my trips there, I can't exactly blame the people from there for being picky. Like you said, the taste difference is huge, and there also is a large romantic component to it: most recipes are quite simple, but rely on using fresh ingredients. It's very anti-industrial by nature.
- amelius 8y agoQ: are olive trees a monoculture like bananas?
- Arnt 8y agoThat word does not mean what you think it does ;) No, they're not. They can be grown in a monoculture (a large area occupied by the same plant), but they're not clones like bananas. They are, however, slow. What you plant today doesn't give you olives any time soon.
- usrusr 8y ago> They are, however, slow. What you plant today doesn't give you olives any time soon. That's why news like this terrify me so much. Even deadly human diseases seem depressingly harmless by comparison, given the relative ease with which we can be replaced, relative to a very old tree. Thinking of humans as replaceable feels awful.
- commentor10 8y agoIs it time to hoard good olive oil?
- cataphract 8y agoOlive oil is a fresh product that needs to be consumed within a relatively short time span (preferably within a year or so) — after that it starts getting rancid. So this is not really an option.
- pvaldes 8y agoIt seems that Italy has a problem checking imported alive plants. Is not exclusive from Italy, Spain also has issues, and France, but it seem that it happens a lot there for some reason. Is the Olive, and the Chestnut also, and other crops...
- mark-r 8y agoAggressive destruction of plants that are believed to be infected without actual signs of infection is a bad idea. You may destroy plants that have a natural immunity. Keeping those plants may be the only hope for a long-term solution.
- josario 8y agoI'm Italian and I come from Puglia. It strikes me directly. It's a hard punch in the stomach, problem is that people don't want to remove this old trees, they are even centuries old and so they make the disease spread more and more as time progress and as a matter of fact the olive oil selling is their only income. The state failed, they had no direct order to remove the trees nor economical help. As an example in my father field where we grow olive oil trees, there are few that has this disease, but my father hasn't removed them, it's a cost we can't afford. Now put a lot of ignorant agriculturist old men without money that have has the only source of income selling olive oil in front of this disease and you get the results.
- inferiorhuman 8y agoWhile at the grocery store yesterday I noticed that the store had a few shelves of cutting boards and bowls made of olive wood. They're made from non-producing olive trees in Tunisia. The little blurb on the cutting board suggested that the Tunisians cut down the trees once they stop producing. I wonder if there's enough of a market that producing wood would incentivize cutting down infected trees. The grain is visually very distinctive and appealing and the items themselves weren't particularly cheap.
- josario 8y agoNo, because the infected trees wood is crap and falls apart, it can't be used to make wood items or wooden stuff sadly :( And yes, the tree wood of healthy plants is amazing.
- inferiorhuman 8y agoOh that's a shame. On the other hand it's likely that olive growers can adapt (although this means that traditions will change). We've done it with bananas, and, to some extent, citrus.
- koliber 8y agoWhen I was staying in southern Spain in February, the home had a fireplace. The local gas station sold olive tree firewood. This points to the conclusion that some pruning of olive trees is going on on a regular basis. At the same time we saw plenty of gnarly old trees and wondered what the different philosophies of olive tree pruning/cycling are.
- notacode 8y agoim italian, and the problem it's not disease but bad weather
- scalio 8y agoI recently read Biodiversos by Stefano Mancuso and Carlo Petrini, the founder of the slow food movement. It's basically a discussion between the two where they lay out the big problems with our production and consumption of food. For instance, concentrating on making single kinds as productive as possible instead of cultivating variety is extremely dangerous, as shown by this event. The great Irish famine is maybe the most striking example. Humanity does exactly that with wheat, cows, almost everything. The very basis of most of the globe's food comes from a handful of species. In my mind, this is one of the great ticking bombs of our close future.
- Retric 8y agoI don’t know about dangerous. We have a wide range of crops and the loss of a single one is only ever a regional problem. The loss of any one crop be that something minor like strawberries or major like corn is just not that big a deal globally. Now locally yea it can be a huge issue, but the tradeoff of lower productivity every year vs the low odds in any one year of a problem make this fairly complex balancing act.
- scalio 8y agoThe problem is that the same crops are grown globally, so once a disease grabs hold, it can spread very quickly, eradicating yields globally.
- Moru 8y agoGoogle Banana fungus. We don't have a wide range of crops. We have monoculture and a very small set of GMO crops that is used all over the world. For example there is a lot of different rice species but we eat mabe five of them in western countries.
- Retric 8y agoLet’s assume the worldwide Banana outpdrops to zero in one day. That’s bad, but not what I would call dangerous. In terms of the food supply, their are several major food crops that are important wheat, corn, rice, soy etc so the loss of a major one would be very bad, but the worldwide food surplus is so mind blowingly vast it would not nessisarily result in starvation for anyone beyond possibly the farmers directly affected in the 3rd world. And frankly next year you can generally plant something else.
- adreamingsoul 8y agoI also see a third option, let nature run its course. Yes, that means we will reduce the supply of Olive oil. But, if they follow through with the quarantine practices, it will destroy hundreds of years of root growth, diversity, and soil health. Why do humans think they can stop the force of nature? We only make it worse for ourselves when we attempt to "control" nature. /endrant
- nicodds 8y agoHello people! A voice from the field here. As in most of the cases in Italy, we can say that the approach is: "the situation is hopeless, but not serious". Apart from the joke, it is a sad period and the Xylella case is just part of a bigger whole. But let's stay focused. Actually, the problem has a long history and Nature wrote about it several times over the last 5 years. I'm not an expert, nor a practitioner of the field. Nevertheless, it seems a growing evidence show that the bacterium is responsible for the problem together with a state of abandon, spread over many areas of the region, uncultivated from several decades. The local court started an investigation to understand how Xylella reached the Salento area. Due to a poor scientific approach and an uneffective communication, such investigations gave rise to very large protests among public opinion. These protests blocked de facto any political decision to stop the spreading of the bacterium: politicians are more interested in their consensus. This lead to a paralysis status in which Xylella prospered and the infection spread over, towards southern areas of Brindisi province. Meanwhile, the investigations did not find a clear responsible. There are two main voices in this side. The first says that Xylella infection was the result of an out of hand scientific experiment aimed at testing some plant protection products. The second says that Xylella comes from massive and uncontrolled import-export activities in a big plants trading facility. Both stories have a similar geographical origin, near the city of Gallipoli. HTH, Nico
- sifoobar 8y agoFrom my understanding there are two ways this happens. 1) We mess with plant genetics, which creates weak mono cultures. Bananas being the biggest offender I'm familiar with. And 2) We play God and release our lovely designer creatures into the environment to marvel at the unintended consequences. This one hits me where it hurts though, I wouldn't get through a day without good olive oil.
- anon2775 8y agoAlso, Europe is desertifying like crazy due to climate change. Spanish farmers can't get the irrigation water they need, and have to go out of business or move in order to open greehouse farms in other actual desert areas. It's horrible because the planet is becoming so inhospitable that a nearly global desert is what we have to look forward to, if not Venus.
- igivanov 8y agoIt's sad for producers of genuine olive oil but as a rather indifferent consumer I always remember that olive oil, honey and I forget what else are the most falsified food products in the world. I would guess that the market of "extra virgin olive oil" will remain, cough, healthy.
- b1r6 8y agoIt's quite unfortunate, but the eventual solution is resistance. Plants have immune responses too? If they are all extremely similar genetically, that is the actual problem.
- pif 8y ago> Italy declared a state of emergency over the crisis in 2015. But quarantine efforts — which can involve uprooting beloved, ancient trees — have been opposed by environmentalists and some farmers, That's always the problem with stupid environmentalists (as opposed to smart environmentalists): they can only say no, but they never propose an alternative solutions to the actual issue.
- PHGamer 8y agohah sometimes environmentalists really are too crazy.