6 ms·
Why are you comparing Elementary OS with a version of Linux Mint that's at least 5 years old? Especially when they had such a big design shift in the last year
by andrepd 8y ago
Why are you comparing Elementary OS with a version of Linux Mint that's at least 5 years old? Especially when they had such a big design shift in the last year or two.
Up-to-date screenshot (still with the "old" theme Mint-X, but actually Mint-Y (based on arc) is the default as of the latest version): https://linuxmint.com/pictures/screenshots/serena/gallery/5.jpg https://linuxmint.com/pictures/screenshots/serena/gallery/5....
The choice isn't between ugly and Elementary. It's a false dillema. E.g. Cinnamon, which is pretty and functional.
- adar 8y agoWith all due respect, that screenshot you linked looks straight out of 2008.
- andrepd 8y agoI genuinely take that as a compliment. I wouldn't be caught dead using a monstrosity like, I don't know, windows 10 (or even the hideous interfaces of Google products) just because it's ""modern"".
- Koshkin 8y agoVista, whose look Mint (in the screenshot) is trying to emulate, was a monstrosity.
- virtualritz 8y agoIt's almost as bad 5 years later then. - icons on task bar too low - icons on task bar vertically not aligned - task icons different size than pinned icons on task bar - task text vertically aligned too high - icons stylistically not matched - system icons unreadable (badly designed, all look the same, don't convey purpose adequately) - task bar icons on right are vertically all over the place - task bar mini icons sizing on right is not consistent - file manager icon sizes all over the place - file manager bottom bar icons are too low and lack 'breathing room' at bottom compared to top bar with buttons - file manager top/bottom bar size is mismatched - horizontal alignment/margin of icons on file manager's top and bottom bars is inconsistent I could go on and on. People who don't care about these things don't see them. Their vision is not trained for it. But for a polished experience, even to UI laypersons, they make all the difference.
- black-tea 8y agoI think it's more that you are trying to see these things while other people use computers to do work.
- solarmist 8y agoSo everyone with an eye for design doesn't do work? Anyways anyone that has trained their eyes (which allows extremely technical visual skills to be developed, not just "art") to actually see what their eye is transmitting to them and not just interpreting it will immediately notice these kinds of things. It's like saying to them stop looking at letters if you're trying to read. If this sounds like gibberish try this exercise. https://www.allaboutdrawings.com/upside-down-drawing.html https://www.allaboutdrawings.com/upside-down-drawing.html
- black-tea 8y agoI'm a trained musician but I'm not going to complain when my plumber doesn't quite sing in tune. It just doesn't matter. I have a pretty well-trained eye for typography too, but when the choice is between systems that are free, fast, privacy-respecting, and functional and systems that are pretty but completely out of my control I'm never going to choose the latter. I'm not sure what posts like yours are trying to achieve. Are you just complaining about how nobody has managed to make something that is free and perfectly well "designed"? If so, why not try to do something about it rather than complain? You'd probably make a lot of people happy if you did. To me it seems more like you are saying that your priorities are with superficial design rather than anything actually relating to work, hence my original comment.
- thekelvinliu 8y agoi agree with you about the plumber. it doesn't matter. but imo that example is not really an analogous situation. what if your instrument was always out of tune? or if a member of your ensemble couldn't keep time? i bet that would prevent you from making a record or being productive otherwise as a musician. as a full time developer and someone who does notice these little things, i care a lot about good design and visual polish. in order to get my work done, i have to use these interfaces for hours on end, after all. if it doesn't particularly bother you, hey that's great. even if not intentional, this and your original comment come off as a bit disparaging, so that reply isn't terribly off base.