7 ms·
It's not just Japan but also China, India, Russia, and the EU that each have ambitious space programs and have had them for quite some time. The US has historic
by jillesvangurp 8y ago
It's not just Japan but also China, India, Russia, and the EU that each have ambitious space programs and have had them for quite some time. The US has historically been leading the pack as space programs have been very expensive. However, what we are seeing now is commoditization of technology and vast decreases in cost. SpaceX has quite effectively shown that you can out compete bigger players with a combination of modest availability of capital, talent and out of the box thinking. The level of their capital expenses is quite a lot more reasonable than what it took Nasa to get to the Moon or running the space shuttle program. It gets it down to the level where aspiring billionaires can get things done in reasonable time frames on reasonable budgets (Bezos, Musk, Branson, etc.). Likewise, any multinational or country with access to similar resources can hope to achieve similar results.
So, there is going to be a wave of countries, companies, and people trying to get to emulate SpaceX. Of course the military angle here is scary. Several of these countries are also nuclear powers and the nature of space rockets is that once you can get them to space, delivering payloads back anywhere on earth is relatively straightforward. That used to be the exclusive domain of the US and Russia. That's no longer true.
- baybal2 8y ago> SpaceX has quite effectively shown that you can out compete bigger players with a combination of modest availability of capital, talent and out of the box thinking. But did that employing hordes of ex NASA, Lougheed, Raytheon, MDA engineers, and best and brightest at that. SpaceX is as far from a ordinary SV startup as it can be.
- jillesvangurp 8y agoI agree, they achieved a lot and they stood on the shoulders of giants. The point is that they proved it is possible to achieve these things now. Other companies are emulating what they do and are also getting results. I'm not trivializing their achievements at all.
- nine_k 8y agoNASA, Raytheon, etc did employ these same engineers, and had access to much thicker wads of cash. They did not produce a returnable, reusable rocket, though. They've produced the Space Shuttle.
- ghaff 8y agoWith technology that is now about 40 years old. With the benefit of hindsight, the shuttle probably wasn't the ideal design--if only because it wasn't reusable as the designers hoped--but I think it's fair to say that the "right" design wouldn't be what can be built with a clean sheet of paper today. (Arguably, existing heavy launch vehicles should just have been upgraded for man rating given that ULA's launch vehicles are pretty reliable today. But I'm not enough of an expert to know what the best alternatives to the Shuttle would have been.)
- nine_k 8y agoI don't reproach Shuttle designers. I just try to point at their different incentives. SpaceX has rather different goals than Raytheon or NASA, afaict. This is natural.
- smaddox 8y agoYeah, it's not clear if a self-landing retrobooster would have been possible given the components available at the time of the space shuttle's design, not to mention the vast improvements in computer modeling and simulation that we're available to SpaceX. But, of course, that's only part of the story. The space shuttle had additional political constraints, i.e. spreading the wealth to many congressional districts, that greatly increased the cost and complexity.
- Xixi 8y ago> That used to be the exclusive domain of the US and Russia. France detonated its first nuke in 1960, and put its first satellite (called Asterix) in space in 1965. So it has not been the exclusive domain of the US and Russia for more than half a century. Of course North Korea joining the club is a tad more scary...
- doombolt 8y agoFrance has a long history of invading all kinds of countries, including European ones (think Napoleonic 1812). They're not hesitating to do that today when we consider Africa. Neither South nor North Korea has either commitment or capacity or historical precedent. North Korea is a "fake it till you make it" media scarecrow. They would not go to agressive war and they never actually claimed they want to. If you try to do "five whys" on "Why you should fear North Korea more than France" the topic will evaporate around the third "why".
- walkingolof 8y agoNapolean did not have access to ICBM, thats why I also think NK is a tad scarier that France anon 1800...
- doombolt 8y agoYou are thinking that Napoleon is a phenomenon on NK instead of being a phenomenon of France. This is based on some loud noises coming from the direction of NK and relative silence from French side. This is baseless. France have access to ICBM, aaaand we know they are Napoleon-capable. I'm not saying they're in for a global conflict, just telling that political-military opinions are built upon sand.
- baud147258 8y agoWell, Napoleon was born on a Mediterranean island (Corsica), which wasn't part of France the year he was born. Edit: it was sold (? or given) to France this year, from the Republic of Genoa.
- readhn 8y agoRussia cant really compete on a mass scale. They can create maybe one-off things but nothing on a scale that can threaten other nations.
- jillesvangurp 8y agoI agree that their economy is a mess. However, they do enjoy a monopoly on transport to the ISS currently and that is due to them having better and cheaper rockets than Nasa. This is being fixed of course but that is after a rather embarrassingly long decade of being dependent on the Russians and their Soviet era rockets still being quite awesome. My understanding is that their engines are still quite competitive, even when compared to SpaceX and Blue Origin. So, I wouldn't discount them outright. If through some uncharacteristic set of events manage to pull their heads out of their asses, they are still well positioned to do awesome stuff going forward. Of course, the current kleptocracy is hopelessly inept and unlikely to get much done on this front. That seems to be the tragedy of Russia.
- umichguy 8y agoThe Russian RD-180 engine is a masterpiece.
- readhn 8y agoIts not about their economy. Poor economy is the result of wide spread corruption and incompetence at all levels. Sure they still enjoy the benefits of soviet era advances but that is slowly going away as well. Also Brain drain is real, anyone capable and who is not brainwashed left the country. THAT alone will continue to hit the country hard in the future on all fronts (and already is).
- duxup 8y agoIs Russia really competitive anymore? It seems like they've fallen behind and outside of putting humans on the space station, and riding out the life of their existing rocket system (granted a highly reliable one) they're potentially doomed to keep lagging under the current kleptocracy.
- Hoefner 8y agoAs far as I know there are at least 3 private space companies in Russia with some ongoing projects. But state owned Roscomos definitely have some problems lately.
- soperj 8y agoThey're the only ones putting people on the space station. I'd say yes. Not to mention they supply the engines for a few different american rockets.
- azernik 8y agoThat is, again, riding on the coattails of Soviet designs; they're only providing one engine model abroad (the RD-180 for the American Atlas V), and that one is a two-decade-old relatively-slight modification (two-chamber instead of four-chamber) of a late-Soviet design. In terms of actual new technology, there's just the Soyuz-2 (just coming into service now, and the first in the Soyuz family to use digital instead of analog control systems) and the new Angara rocket family. Angara will be the real test of new Russian technology development. Payload and cost of the 1.2/A5 are in theory about the same as reusable Falcon 9/Heavy; operational launches are expected to start next year. If it manages to get good reliability and cadence, that will be the real proof that Russia is still competitive.
- coldtea 8y ago>SpaceX has quite effectively shown that you can out compete bigger players with a combination of modest availability of capital, talent and out of the box thinking. Well, it's not like NASA (or the USSR equivalent) couldn't "think out of the box". In fact they had to, several times, to get to space/moon. All those newer challengers (no pun intended) also benefit from a long list of technologies and problems they've already solved for them.
- paulsutter 8y agoBiggest problem at NASA, contractors are paid a percentage of cost “We’ve got to change the way contracting is done,” Musk told the governors. “You can’t do these cost-plus, sole-source contracts because then the incentive structure is all messed up. As soon as you don’t have any competition, the sense of urgency goes away. And as soon as you make something a cost-plus contract, you’re incenting the contractor to maximize the cost of the program, because they get a percentage.” From https://arstechnica.com/science/2017/07/elon-musk-knows-whats-ailing-nasa-costly-contracting/ https://arstechnica.com/science/2017/07/elon-musk-knows-what...
- yourapostasy 8y ago> ...are paid a percentage of cost Principal agent problem comes to bite us in the ass really hard in many industries where percentage of cost embedded somewhere within the incentive structure raises its head. Real estate, finance, insurance, the list of industries is long.
- nradov 8y agoNASA only uses cost-plus on a small fraction of contracts. It's sometimes unavoidable for high risk work; if they insisted on fixed price contracts then suppliers just wouldn't bid at all.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- umichguy 8y ago
- azernik 8y agoSpace launch and ICBM technology has actually drifted apart over time. The early ICBMs that were suitable for space launch were liquid-fueled, and this is actually a really bad choice for missiles; it can take hours to fuel a rocket and ready it for launch. Modern missiles are almost all solid-fueled, which lowers performance (bad for commercial launch) but lets you store the missiles fueled and ready for launch. The only example I know of an operational launch vehicle with a lot of ICBM commonality is the Israeli Shavit, and that one is not commercially competitive; Israeli payloads (even military) are only launched on Shavit if they require a particular level of secrecy.
- robdachshund 8y agoWell the us and Soviet space programs were more about building advanced ICBMs than going to the moon. The latter was a nice side effect for patriotic ends. If you can get a rocket into space without issues, you can slap a warhead on it and hit any target you please. The space race was a pissing contest over nuclear launch capability.